Best Books of the 19th Century
The best books published during the 19th century (January 1st, 1801 through December 31st 1900).
386 books ·
2,163 voters ·
list created June 12th, 2008
by deleted user.
Comments (showing 1-40 of 40) (40 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Wealhtheow
(new)
Jun 26, 2008 11:13am
Wuthering Heights is just SO histrionic. I refuse to vote for it!
reply
|
flag
*
Vilette needs to be voted up there over Jane Eyre! What's going on with this, people?PS- I appreciate your principled stand, Wealhtheow. :)
I like the character of Lucy Snowe (of Villette) better than Jane Eyre, but I think JE is a better novel. But I still voted for both. :)
Oh, I voted for them both too, I just think Vilette is the more powerful book. but that's what these lists are for, I guess. :)
I tried adding The Brothers Karamazov and Huckleberry Finn to the list, but it said they were not published in the 19th century. What gives?
Huck Finn is already on the list (currently #9), and Brothers Karamazov had the wrong pub. date listed, so you should be able to add it now.
Elective Affinities (a/k/a Die Wahlverwandtschaften) published 1809 is listed as not published in the 19th century.
My list is kind of a joke since half of them are in the database as not published in the 19th Century ... like Herman Melville's The Confidence Man or Thomas Carlyle's Sartor Resartus.
Crap books that don't deserve to be in here: Wuthering heights, Frankenstein, Heart of Darkness, Moby Dick.Great books which weren't here and i had to add: The hunchback of notre dame, Fathers and sons, Dr. Jekyll and Mr hyde, Pere Goriot, The Idiot
Elective Affinities and Sartor Resartus have addable dates now. As do The Confidence Man and The Brothers Karamazov.Anything else that needs a new original publication date, just mention it and I'll see if I can fix it.
What kind of retarded list is this? In a website where the userbase is dominated by females I can see why Austen and Bronte are at the top.
Villette is a good book but better than Jane Eyre would be a hard sell. LOL! Yep it is a woman's list. ;)
Capsguy wrote: "What kind of retarded list is this? In a website where the userbase is dominated by females I can see why Austen and Bronte are at the top."Since your mind is clearly dominated by sexism I can see why you're so unpleasant.
Wow, there are some harsh comments on here. Wuthering Heights isn't my favorite book by the Brontes, but it's not crap. My favorites are Jane Eyre and The Tenant of Wildfield Hall.
I can't believe Frankenstein is so high up...it's a terrible book...but what's with all the Wuthering Heights hate? WH is way better than a lot of books on here. And also, isn't A Little Princess 1900s? Not sure. (Oh, just checked. Looks like an earlier version was published in 1888.)
For some reason, a lot of people seem to have very strong opinions about Wuthering Heights, either for or against.
I love that Pride and Prejudice has top place. Such an amazing book and I can't imagine my life without it.Though Tess of the D'Urbervilles should be higher!
I agree that Frankenstein is terrible. It's painful to watch the main character run from place to place whining out his troubles to every passerby, who then tells him how wonderful he is. Ugh.Lots of good stuff here.
What you just said about Frankenstein is how I feel about Tess of the D'Urbervilles... I LOATHE that book.
The Count of Monte Cristo is the best book on the list...the people that didn't vote for it are the ones that were intimidated by the length and therefore didn't read it.As for Pride and Prejudice, my wife and I couldn't even sit through the horrible play.
I counted 23 on the first page - but American writing was very much in its youth in the 19th century.
i like this list! i just added a dutch classic from this time period: Eline Vere, written by Louis Couperus. good reads says it's published in 2007, but looks like that is about a new translated version, the original is from 1888 so very much fits the list!
Ugh, I cannot believe Wuthering Heights inched its stupidity so high up the list!I like a lot of the books on the list, though I wish Jane Eyre was first.
Nat wrote: "Ugh, I cannot believe Wuthering Heights inched its stupidity so high up the list!I like a lot of the books on the list, though I wish Jane Eyre was first."
I agree... I like my stories with SOME redeeming points and WH is horrible. Jane Eyre, on the otherhand, is a gothic masterpiece.
James wrote: "The Count of Monte Cristo is the best book on the list...the people that didn't vote for it are the ones that were intimidated by the length and therefore didn't read it.As for Pride and Prejudic..."
I totally agree with you! The Count of Monte Cristo was by far my favorite book ever. Pride and Prejudice was ok. Once I read the Count I have trouble reading rather boring books by Jane Austin. They're all the same.
flag as offensive (?)















