Dan's review of Boneshaker (The Clockwork Century, #1) > Likes and Comments
42 likes · like
I had to work a little to get over the expectation of a different type of book that the cover gave me.
Miriam wrote: "I had to work a little to get over the expectation of a different type of book that the cover gave me."
I agree. The cover was very misleading. A more appropriate cover would have been Briar and the Doornails running from rotters with the image of Dr. Minnericht looming over the whole scene. The existing cover makes it look like there will be a lot of airship action.
I was expecting it to be about a girl who drove/piloted some sort of steampunk vehicle. But it was kind of cool to have a main character who was a poor, hard-working mom instead of a hot young thing.
Briar being a mother looking for her son is one of the few motivations that make entering a city of zombies make sense.
Indeed. Given that it didn't seem too hard to get in or out, I really wanted a stronger explanation for why anyone lived there.
I had some mixed feeling about this story, mostly pacing issues earlier in the book. Briar was such a well-drawn character, though. I liked her guts and determination and the fact she had a hard life. I also liked that her kid wasn't a spoiled and whiny brat.
I liked this enough to read another of her books (Fathom). I would say it had similar strengths and weaknesses.
"A steampunk book with zombies and airships shouldn't have so many dull spots."
This is a good way of putting it. Some of the running and hiding and chasing and searching got a bit dull because it didn't feel like it was advancing the plot much. I'd have preferred more character development instead.
I felt like some of the pacing would have worked better in a movie, but that's a common reaction for me when it comes to zombie related fiction.
Nah. I'd probably go with The Bookman, although Perdido Street Station, which I notice you're reading, has enough steampunk elements to give you a good taste.
Dan wrote: "Nah. I'd probably go with The Bookman, although Perdido Street Station, which I notice you're reading, has enough steampunk elements to give you a good taste."
Yeah, I'm starting to pick up on that. Really liking it so far so it may be a genre I should start exploring more.
I really struggled with this book for the very reasons you outlined in your review. I was BORED! too much. It was way over hyped I had a half a dozen people tell me I needed to read it. I loved the concept it just had too many issues.
Whew! You made me glad I left this one on the shelf at the library.
If you want to NOT READ another book that manages to screw up the almost surefire combination of zombies and airships, be sure to ignore The Affinity Bridge.
Melki wrote: "Whew! You made me glad I left this one on the shelf at the library.
If you want to NOT READ another book that manages to screw up the almost surefire combination of zombies and airships, be sure ..."
Too late. I already wish I hadn't read Affinity Bridge.
Faint hearted praise for a 3 star rating Dan. I picked this up and read the first chapter or so in the store and then put it back on the shelf. Slow and possibly going to be annoyingly so was my estimation. You've confirmed it for me. I also wasn't mad for the Affinity Bridge either.
Gary wrote: "Faint hearted praise for a 3 star rating Dan. I picked this up and read the first chapter or so in the store and then put it back on the shelf. Slow and possibly going to be annoyingly so was my es..."
It was right on the 2-3 border. It had its moments. If someone gives it to you, it's probably still worth a read.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Miriam
(new)
Feb 14, 2010 10:54am
I had to work a little to get over the expectation of a different type of book that the cover gave me.
reply
|
flag
*
Miriam wrote: "I had to work a little to get over the expectation of a different type of book that the cover gave me."I agree. The cover was very misleading. A more appropriate cover would have been Briar and the Doornails running from rotters with the image of Dr. Minnericht looming over the whole scene. The existing cover makes it look like there will be a lot of airship action.
I was expecting it to be about a girl who drove/piloted some sort of steampunk vehicle. But it was kind of cool to have a main character who was a poor, hard-working mom instead of a hot young thing.
Briar being a mother looking for her son is one of the few motivations that make entering a city of zombies make sense.
Indeed. Given that it didn't seem too hard to get in or out, I really wanted a stronger explanation for why anyone lived there.
I had some mixed feeling about this story, mostly pacing issues earlier in the book. Briar was such a well-drawn character, though. I liked her guts and determination and the fact she had a hard life. I also liked that her kid wasn't a spoiled and whiny brat.
I liked this enough to read another of her books (Fathom). I would say it had similar strengths and weaknesses.
"A steampunk book with zombies and airships shouldn't have so many dull spots."This is a good way of putting it. Some of the running and hiding and chasing and searching got a bit dull because it didn't feel like it was advancing the plot much. I'd have preferred more character development instead.
I felt like some of the pacing would have worked better in a movie, but that's a common reaction for me when it comes to zombie related fiction.
Nah. I'd probably go with The Bookman, although Perdido Street Station, which I notice you're reading, has enough steampunk elements to give you a good taste.
Dan wrote: "Nah. I'd probably go with The Bookman, although Perdido Street Station, which I notice you're reading, has enough steampunk elements to give you a good taste."Yeah, I'm starting to pick up on that. Really liking it so far so it may be a genre I should start exploring more.
I really struggled with this book for the very reasons you outlined in your review. I was BORED! too much. It was way over hyped I had a half a dozen people tell me I needed to read it. I loved the concept it just had too many issues.
Whew! You made me glad I left this one on the shelf at the library.If you want to NOT READ another book that manages to screw up the almost surefire combination of zombies and airships, be sure to ignore The Affinity Bridge.
Melki wrote: "Whew! You made me glad I left this one on the shelf at the library.If you want to NOT READ another book that manages to screw up the almost surefire combination of zombies and airships, be sure ..."
Too late. I already wish I hadn't read Affinity Bridge.
Faint hearted praise for a 3 star rating Dan. I picked this up and read the first chapter or so in the store and then put it back on the shelf. Slow and possibly going to be annoyingly so was my estimation. You've confirmed it for me. I also wasn't mad for the Affinity Bridge either.
Gary wrote: "Faint hearted praise for a 3 star rating Dan. I picked this up and read the first chapter or so in the store and then put it back on the shelf. Slow and possibly going to be annoyingly so was my es..."It was right on the 2-3 border. It had its moments. If someone gives it to you, it's probably still worth a read.
