This book like other books such as Oshin is very interesting because it describes the character of Japanese women eager to live a life even bitter. The story in it teaches us about the meaning of the struggle for life, never give up and thank God. told us not to despair.

Unfortunately as a person holding a degree in writing, I have to totally disagree with this review. This book has a depth that doesn't focus so much on Japanese culture/history, but on the individual's feelings and character development. I also have to say that while this reviewer may be able to easily forget such a book, most people I know who have read it say it will be one of the stories that will stay with them forever.

I do think the idea of the story seeming superficial to resemble a geisha is interested, but probably not accurate.

Liz, I agree completely with your assessment. I read this book around the time of the movie's release and was at a loss to understand what people found so life altering.

Michelle, I completely agree with you. For one; it is very well written, no one is claiming that's not the case, at least that I have seen. I also think the characters were very well developed. For two; I'm not really sure how a person could not be affected at least somewhat by this girl's story, unless you are just disinterested with the genre or subject matter. Then that I could understand. Though, if that were the case, then why read it in the first place..? I am just surprised when I see people have a negative opinion of this book. I know many people who have read it, some very literate as well (more than I for sure), and I don't know a single one who hasn't recommended it or loved it.

"There's a way in which the book, written by a man and a westerner, is slightly fetishistic" - AGREE!!! Oh man, I can't believe I forgot to write that in my own review. This aspect really bothered me as I was reading the book, and is one of the prime reasons I preferred the film, which allowed the women to maintain their dignity.

Read it some years back. Strongest memory is that Hatsumomo is one of the best villains I've met.

I too cannot agree with this reviewer and having read this book several years ago still remember it well and consider it one of the most atmospheric books that I have read the author captures the essence of the geisha any the writing is beautiful

I disagree that the book is superficial in any way though I do think that in many ways the pace and tone of the book resemble the mystery and intrigue surrounding the life of a Geisha.