Jamie’s review of The Brothers Karamazov > Likes and Comments

13 likes · like
Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)    post a comment »
dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Asif (new)

Asif I want to read this book, I really do, but when Nabokov describes it as "simply unreadable" I am not so sure anymore.

I guess I really should read it for myself instead of kowtowing to the Master's opinion...


message 2: by Jamie (new)

Jamie There’s a lot of ways I’d describe the Brothers K, and unreadable wouldn’t be one. I know the essay you’re citing, though, and Nabokov has a few great points while missing widely on others. In my humble opinion.

So yeah, I’d say give it a shot on its own terms, and see what you think.


message 3: by Asif (new)

Asif You are right, of course. I shall do as soon as I get round to it.


message 4: by Gerhard (new)

Gerhard Its one of my favourites as well. I cant recommend this book enough. You HAVE to read it.


message 5: by Theodor (new)

Theodor "It's a shockingly joyful book" - this perfectly describes my impression of this book (my favourite). I can't help thinking people who describe this book as merely dark and depressing have misunderstood it completely. I've noticed they tend to be people without any kind of belief/faith. This probably makes sense since without that, the way Dostoyevsky would have it, there is no hope. Only the despair and madness of Ivan. I've rarely felt more full or joy and hope than when I finished the last pages of this book and laid it down. Thanks for the review!


back to top