John’s review of Empire of Liberty: A History of the Early Republic, 1789-1815 > Likes and Comments

like
Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)    post a comment »
dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by John (new)

John So far, I'm struck by the disparity of ideals between Federalists and Republicans, and the unselfesh level of commitment both Hamilton and Jefferson display in framing their versions of an enduring republic, to the point where the former supported the latter for president in the face of a prospective Burr administration, knowing that Jefferson held public interest close to his heart, despite Ham & Jeffs deeply polemical positions in governing and managing the economy. The cultural washout of aristocratic pretention in the Age of Jefferson is brought to light in ways that resemble the current Occupy Movement, making the current political rivalry tame in comparison (so far).


message 2: by John (new)

John There are several descriptive chapters that precede the next to the last (War of 1812) that blend cultural outcomes in the republic during most of Jefferson's presidency and some of Madison's that after reading cued me to take a breath-taking pause before proceeding with his coverage of the war. Whereas my interest in specific battle coverage is typically overshadowed by my preference for causes and results, Professor Wood's engagement of war development is consistent with that of his political and cultural formulations, which credit victors in the successful campaigns without dramatizing winning or losing fronts. I was especially struck by the privateers' assistance to the American Navy, wondering how this sea-faring militia contrasts with contemporary private armed forces contractors; and fascinated by how the trade disputes leading to the war remained unresolved, yet established our country on equal footing with European powers to eventually become a beacon of hope for those who emigrated here for the economic opportunities exclusively provided by a democratic republic form of government. Moreover,this book demonstrates the mercurial turn of political events. Given that the union was nearly compromised by the threat of secession among northern Federalists who were justifiably angered by President Madison's self-imposed trade sanctions,the political turnabout resulting in Republican dominance and Federalist's demise can be compared to Bush 41's successful Gulf War and Obama's decimation of al-qaeda.


message 3: by John (new)

John There are several descriptive chapters that precede the next to the last (War of 1812) that blend cultural outcomes in the republic during most of Jefferson's presidency and some of Madison's that after reading cued me to take a breath-taking pause before proceeding with his coverage of the war. Whereas my interest in specific battle coverage is typically overshadowed by my preference for causes and results, Professor Wood's engagement of war development is consistent with that of his political and cultural formulations, which credit victors in the successful campaigns without dramatizing winning or losing fronts. I was especially struck by the privateers' assistance to the American Navy, wondering how this sea-faring militia contrasts with contemporary private armed forces contractors; and fascinated by how the trade disputes leading to the war remained unresolved, yet established our country on equal footing with European powers to eventually become a beacon of hope for those who emigrated here for the economic opportunities exclusively provided by a democratic republic form of government.


back to top