HD’s review of Shiver (The Wolves of Mercy Falls, #1) > Likes and Comments

Comments (showing 1-22 of 22) (22 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Loni (new)

Loni Flowers bout time you're reading this!! lol

message 2: by Kimberly ☕ (new)

Kimberly ☕ my daughter keeps telling me i need to read this!

message 3: by Erin (new)


message 4: by Nayab (new)

Nayab haha! now i remember why i hated that book so much.

message 5: by Aleixie (new)

Aleixie lol

This is killing me!!!


message 6: by nick (new)

nick Laughed my butt off when I read that :P
I, also, didn't like this book so much.

message 7: by Sasha (new)


Kristin (Blood,Sweat and Books) I actually own this but haven't read it. I keep hearing it is like the wolf version of Twilight and that just doesn't appeal to me. Maybe someday I'll try to read it but for now I'll just look at the pretty cover on my shelf and be happy with that.

message 9: by Aleeeeeza (new)

Aleeeeeza this is one of the most brilliantly well-written critical reviews i've ever read! awesome job, H.D.! love how you so eloquently captured my exact thoughts on it :)

message 10: by Thalia (new)

Thalia I totally forgot about the leaking womb line until just now. Shows how much I didn't want to read it and was mostly just skimming the book. I wanted to give it one star, but gave it two because I liked the switching points of view. x)

You basically captured everything that was wrong with this book. *appluads*

message 11: by Kathy (new)

Kathy Am now unliking shiver.

message 12: by hayden (new)

hayden This is pretty ironic, considering you posted an update saying "I'm in love!" :) Is this your first one-star review ever?

message 13: by HD (new)

HD Tolson Hayden wrote: "This is pretty ironic, considering you posted an update saying "I'm in love!" :) Is this your first one-star review ever?"

Isn't it? I was in love. At first.

And haha, I think so!!

message 14: by hayden (new)

hayden I gasped when I saw that you gave it one star. "HD? ONE STAR?" Haha it was so surprising!

message 15: by Dawn Teresa (new)

Dawn Teresa If you loved the first 100 pages, I think a one-star review is a little misleading. Maybe you have to be a girl to like this book, but I gave it 5 stars.

message 16: by Dawn Teresa (new)

Dawn Teresa You didn't say whether or not you finished the book this time around.

message 17: by hayden (new)

hayden Dawn wrote: "You didn't say whether or not you finished the book this time around."

The shelf says did-not-finish. :)

message 18: by Loni (new)

Loni Flowers Shocked. I'm so sad you didn't like this. Oh well. :(

message 19: by Claudia (new)

Claudia Patrício Didn't like it either. Too cliché and confusing for me. Didn't get their relationship at all

message 20: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Hahahaha, I have to say, even though I loved Shiver, this review is hilarious. I don't know how I missed that leaking womb part... You do bring up a lot of good points, I guess I'm just a sucker for unrealistically sweet guys in my books. Great review!

message 21: by Thalia (last edited Mar 31, 2012 11:39PM) (new)

Thalia Dawn wrote: "Maybe you have to be a girl to like this book."

I'm a girl and I all but hated it. XD A total, hopeless romantic at that, and even I thought it was a little much.

message 22: by Jen (new)

Jen Halligan Oh, HD. Thank you for this fantastic review. You know that I love Shiver, and Maggie's writing so when I first saw the 2 stars I started getting defensive... but you explain your opinion brilliantly. Personally, I love ambiguous prose, so to each their own. Honestly, I don't remember the leaking womb line, but yeah, that's is gross!

Kudos for the honest review!

back to top