Bonnie Gayle’s review of The Arrival > Likes and Comments

1 like · like
Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)    post a comment »
dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Deb (new)

Deb I just read this book this morning! Your reviews are beautiful.


message 2: by Bonnie Gayle (new)

Bonnie Gayle Thank you:)

Could you figure out what the little creatures were about? I would be interested in your take on them.


message 3: by Deb (new)

Deb First thought: the little creatures were a rip-off of the spirit daemons from Philip Pullman's trilogy.

I dislike his writing immensely, though, so I thought harder.

The animal that latched on to the father reminded me of a cat that had been left behind by a former owner, especially since that room looked like it still had objects from a former occupant, collecting dust on the table. The overabundant number of animal pets in the drawings may be the hopeful avenue that Tan uses to depict a technology-driven yet socialable society, where animals remind people to live outside their boxes.

They puzzled me too, and I still don't think that I entirely understood them.


message 4: by Susan (new)

Susan I too thought of Philip Pullman's Daemons. I think I would prefer to think of Tan's creatures as organically arrived-at hommages rather than ripoffs as I admire the work of both writers. One thing that does make these beasties different is that they aren't explained - this forces the reader's mind into a place where he/she must accept without understanding, again bringing the reader to place of identification with the protagonist.


back to top