Scarlet’s review of Vampire Academy (Vampire Academy, #1) > Likes and Comments

119 likes · like
Comments (showing 1-50 of 140) (140 new)    post a comment »

message 1: by Adela (new)

Adela Clancy I didn't like this first book very much either when I read it, but for some strange reason I stuck with it and now it's actually one of my favorite series'. I think you should atleast read one more book before dumping the series, if that's what you're gonna do. IMHO the series gets better, though Rose is still kind of annoying at times lol


message 2: by Sayaka (new)

Sayaka Miki I'm 14, and I could handle this book. I read books much worse! Well, they were adult fiction, but I thought it was just medium, the content in this book.


message 3: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Musi wrote: "I'm 14, and I could handle this book. I read books much worse! Well, they were adult fiction, but I thought it was just medium, the content in this book."

I'm not saying people can't "handle" it. Though just because someone can handle it doesnt mean they should read it at a younger age. I guess it all depends on how you were raised. Some parents let their kids have more freedom at a younger age. I was taught what was appropriate and inappropriate for my age all throughout my life, so I guess my opinions are a bit different. But given how fast kids seem to be "growing up" these days, I cant say I'm surprised by how many younger kids read books with inappropriate material.


message 4: by Kaethe (new)

Kaethe I cant say I'm surprised by how many younger kids read books with inappropriate material.

You'd have been horrified when I was growing up, back before there were any YA books and kids went straight from Nancy Drew to Jacqueline Susann and other books intended for an adult audience. Usually by age 12. I don't think kids are growing up any faster in their reading habits. On the contrary, I think the rise of YA has given them many more options for appropriate works.

(Consider this: Lord of the Flies and The Catcher in the Rye were the only two books I read with teen protagonists from 6th grade until...well, a while after college, probably)


message 5: by Nan (new)

Nan Hi Scarlet. I'm not trying to be a troll and pile on here, but I do have at least a small disagreement with what you've written here.

You say that Rose was being rebellious just "to be bad." (That's from one of your comments, above.) I don't agree with that. At the start of the book, she and Lissa are returned to the Academy after having run away in order to keep Lissa safe. She had a reason to rebel at that point. Her later rebellions also have reasons. Rose does not want the destiny her culture has planned for her. She wants to be a guardian, yes, and enjoys the hard work that goes into training. But she only sees two options in her life: guardian or blood whore. When she's rebelling and breaking the rules, part of the reason for it is because she cannot stand that she only has the two choices. (A blood whore is someone that allows herself to be bitten during intimate acts. Since dhampirs are sterile with one another and only have children if one of the parents is a Moroi, her only two options are guardian or parent--and dhampir mothers are considered blood whores by the Moroi community.) That sort of social confinement sounds like a darn good reason to rebel in my mind.


message 6: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Please note that I said "in most cases." I recognize that some of her rebellious acts had good intentions behind them as you mentioned above, but I was mainly talking about where she acts out for her own selfish reasons, not the ones where she's doing what she thinks is right for herself and Lissa.


message 7: by Sarah (new)

Sarah I agree that Rose is a very abrasive protagonist & difficult to read. Even now, after three books, have I learned to like Rose? ....Not particularly. :P I stuck it out because I liked the world-building & was interested in the supporting cast -- Lissa & Christian, especially, but also Adrian (who doesn't appear until book 2) & Dmitri & Mia (who is also a b**ch, but for some reason I like her anyway).

That said, I can totally understand why it's not for everyone. By all accounts I shouldn't like it; normally I avoid violent, chip-on-their-shoulder narrators with strong Mary Sue tendencies. I guess it's become a soap opera on my YA shelf. *shrug* But you might try FROSTBITE before giving up. Book 2 is my favorite of the series (though I'm only half done with VA, so take that rec with a grain of salt).


message 8: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Thank you Sarah, I'm glad someone understands my distaste for Rose XD A lot of people have told me to try and read at least one more book, so perhaps I will, but it will only be if I can find it at the library. I liked the world-building part of VA as well, and I think that if certain plot and character elements had been different, I would have enjoyed this book much more.


message 9: by Sarah (new)

Sarah YA & urban fantasy seem to breed abrasive heroines. I enjoy a chick that kicks butt, but surely there's a happy medium between wishy-washy & abrasive-like-woah. Rose is especially frustrating because I understand her frustrations about Lissa & dhampir choices, but she seems to enjoy making herself as unlikable as possible. Would it really be so hard to admit that your life isn't THAT bad? C'mon, Rose, you can do it. :P

I bet you can find FROSTBITE at the library. :) We sell that series pretty regularly at the bookstore where I work, so they must keep them on hand for loan.


message 10: by Ellen (new)

Ellen The first book is full of foreshadowing on her behaviour and actions and views as such for the rest of the series :) I understand that she does come off as a not very nice person, but she has her redeeming qualities (her protectiveness of Lissa as an example) and like the others have said, you're better of trying Frostbite before giving up completely XD


message 11: by Amanda (new)

Amanda I'd have to recommend you try the next book too. :) The first is my least favorite in the series, and Rose probably doesn't get any less violent, but I think she does mature.


message 12: by Redsketch (new)

Redsketch Have you read the entire series, or just this one book?
Personally, I like that Rose wasn't perfect. There's waaaaay too many heroines out there that are always noble, always do the right thing, are always 100% sure of their feelings, and never kiss a single boy before they find the one "they can't live without." I like Rose because she's realistic, and the mistakes she makes are just part of her personality, part of growing up.
That being said, this is the first book in a series that gets A LOT better as it goes on, making room for some really good character development, plot twists, and growth. :) I have to recommend that you read the rest of the series, since it redeems many of the annoying qualities of the first book. :)


message 13: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Oh I agree that I like heroines that aren't perfect, it's just I thought Rose was way too agressive, manipulative, and vain, among other things.


message 14: by Pao (new)

Pao I think Redsketch is right, the first book took a long time to hook me but the whole series are awesome, I also like that Rose is not the same as any main character, she makes mistakes and she's reckles which along the story makes her more interesting and impressive on her choices, she grows and she gets in more trouble but that's what makes this books really good, the best way to read this series is just reading it without expectations, if you had read it without expectations you would have found more pros, you can't read a book because of its reputation,then you would be dissapointed, also you should give a try to the second book.


message 15: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Honestly, even without my high expectations I still think I would have been disappointed. But like I said before, I will perhaps give Frostbite a chance in the future.


message 16: by iamjenai (new)

iamjenai I did not like the first book either and if you ask me, I always tell my friends to read Frostbite first because reading the first book will definitely make them hate the series ;) So try Frostbite like you said ;)


message 17: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Alright, thanks :)


message 18: by .·:*¨ × Shannon♥Loving Tomas Vrbada Like Woe × ¨*: (last edited Jan 13, 2014 06:20AM) (new)

.·:*¨ × Shannon♥Loving Tomas Vrbada Like Woe × ¨*: Personally i felt she tried way too hard to make Rose rebellious, Seriously who (in kindergarden, no less.) calls their teacher a fascist b*st*rd? O.o

Not trying to offend anyone or anything, i'm just mentioning what Rose said herself in the book.


message 19: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Haha, I know. At times Rose just got way over the top.


message 20: by Ali (new)

Ali The same thing happens in her Dark Swan series, its more adult, but it has a better story line. I think you'd like it, just by looking at some of your books. But young adults pertains to the ages 14- 21, roughly. So its targeted at older teenagers and younger 20s. xD


message 21: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Yes, but sadly the target range isnt always the actual range. There are some young kids out there that read young adult books. This is why I really wish books had content warnings (like with movies and some manga/comic books). Like hey, there's references to sex and drugs in here! Maybe you shouldnt let your 12 year old read it!


message 22: by Ali (new)

Ali But most 12 year olds ARE coming into this in their every day lives. But reading about it can be desensitizing them to it so I agree with your Content Warning for books. But right now their parents should be on their case about it. Really, its up to them how their kid should be raised and that includes what books they read. :P


message 23: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Kids are around this at that age BECAUSE of things like this. Books, movies, magazines, tv shows....a lot of it is telling them that it's normal at a younger age when it shouldnt be.


message 24: by Ali (new)

Ali They're also around it because of their peers, family members, and "just trying to fit in". Kids learn things from their older siblings and think "Oh, I can do that" So they tell it to their friends and that's how things get started, especially in the middle school years. I'm not saying that the media and books aren't apart of the problem. But most magazines like Seventeen, CosmoGIRL, and US Weekly aren't targeted at 12 and younger. Are you saying that tv programs and magazines and books should stop producing what they're making for the age group they're targeting because of some kids' parents who aren't keeping a better eye on them?


message 25: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet No, I'm not saying that. In the end I can't be a parent to every child in the world, and I can't tell tv networks or movie producers to stop making shows and films. Not that I'd want to, but even if I did I wouldn't get very far. I guess the point I'm trying to make is I find it sad that younger kids are getting exposed to some of these things too early. Childhood should be a time of fun and innocence, not sex and getting high and using physical abuse because they think it makes you seem cool or tough. Like I said, I would love to see them at least put content warnings on books. There are many good parents out there who might see VA and say "Oh look, it's a cool vampire book. My child loves vampires, and this one is popular, I should get this for her!" All the while they dont know it contains material they might not deem appropriate for their daughter to read at her age.


message 26: by Ali (new)

Ali That's true. I still think that someone should make a person fill out an application before they can have a kid. xD
But I think a parent should read the book before giving it to their child. That's what my mother did when I wanted to read one of her books. But she's always given me freedom in trusting that I'll pick an age appropriate book.


message 27: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Haha yeah, some parents really shouldn't be parents.

My mom was the same way, but now that I'm almost a legal adult she does give me more freedom with what I choose to read. She still likes looking at my books before we buy them though, mainly out of curiousity and to see the price tag XD But she's for the most part always trusted my judgement.


message 28: by Ali (new)

Ali My moms the same way! She'll flip through it and then decide. But usually she just looks at the cover, reads the back, and then checks out the price tag. xD


message 29: by Kaethe (new)

Kaethe As a mother, my only question is "Will you loan it to me when you're done?"


message 30: by Ali (new)

Ali Lol, My madre usually just asks me to get a book for her. And then once I get it she's like so. You want to read? The only book she's ever really asked me to read is Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man by Steve Harvey xD


message 31: by Kaethe (new)

Kaethe Ha! My daughters and I swap books and recommendations all the time. So do my mother (and -in law). Mockingjay had us all fighting it out to be the first reader.


message 32: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet I read passages I really like out loud to my mom sometimes, but she prefers the action/espionage/spy thriller type books over my fantasy/paranormal/dystopia books, so we dont usually fight over who reads what first. The only books we've both read are some of the Princess Diaries series, and I've looked at a lot of the stuff on her shelf, like the Lost Symbol and the Gift of Fear.


message 33: by Kaethe (new)

Kaethe I love Meg Cabot! I think The Gift of Fear: Survival Signals That Protect Us from Violence is a really useful book.


message 34: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Me as well! And I agree. I think more people should read The Gift of Fear. The statistics in that book alone are shocking.


message 35: by Kaethe (new)

Kaethe Mmmhmm.


message 36: by Tane (new)

Tane this book is amazing ... first off, rose is strong, shes strong willed, shes not like all those other girls in books im sick of, weak willed, always shy in front of boys, so girly when hot guys come near them, gosh im just sick of all the little weak willed girls i read about in books, man this book is amazing, rose strong girl, never falls for hot boys, meaning she doesnt get all speaky shy in front of boys, she has a snarky attitude which i love and i rate the book 5 stars


message 37: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Well that's great that you think that. Perhaps you should write that in your own review? And I said that I liked that Rose wasnt as wimpy as other characters I've seen, but sometimes she's way too over the top. She DOES fall for hot guys. She only likes Dimitri because she thinks he's a hot badass, and she always talks about hot guys that "girls just want to get naked with."


message 38: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer On the matter of this book being too inappropriate for young adults, take into consideration what most 'young adults' do now-a-days. Kids see worse stuff just walking down the street or going to school. Please keep in mind that Rose IS a teen-aged girl with good looks and lots of 'friends'. Most teenagers smoke, cuse, and 'almost loose their virginity' ALL THE TIME. That's what teenagers DO.
I think if you ever read the rest of the series, you'd see just how much Rose CHANGES over that timespan. THAT is what everyone is so excited over. You watch Rose, Lissa, and everyone else grow up from TEENAGERS into mature ADULTS. Yes, she's dramatic, yes, she's a bit 'slutty' but she is JUST like every other teen-aged girl before they start to grow up.
As for her liking Dimitri only because he's hot and mysterious, that's what made her look, but if she didn't develop REAL feelings for him, she might as well have ended up with someone like Eddy or Adrian. She loves Dimitri because he's strong, smart, witty, and caring. His being a super HOTTY is only a perk. Can you BLAME her for falling in love with a hot guy who has GOOD characteristics?


message 39: by Scarlet (last edited Apr 21, 2012 11:00PM) (new)

Scarlet Well first off, not ALL teenagers act like this. I know plenty of them who dont like drinking, smoking, or having sex at their age. But I am aware that a lot of them do. If you read my entire review, you would know where I stand on those matters. I never said it was all bad, but a lot of it isnt ok, either.

Again, you're wrong about all teenage girls being "just" like that before they grow up. Not all teens are jealous, abusive, slutty jerks with an ego.

From what I hear, Rose gets worse, but it would be nice if she grew up a little. Or A LOT. I've stated that I will consider reading Frostbite, but I still have no connection to Rose and honestly dont care about her as a character, because she makes herself so unlikable throughout the whole book.

And finally, yes, Dimitri being cute is definitely a perk, but that aside, I didnt feel like there was any real chemistry or development of their relationship. And honestly I found it rather weird.

This book just wasnt for me, but if you like it, then I'm happy for you.


message 40: by Carolyn (new)

Carolyn This review is amazing. I hated the book with a passion and will not be buying anymore from this series.


message 41: by Chinemerem (new)

Chinemerem OMG, I felt like I was the only who hated Rose. This book sums up my feelings toward the book greatly.


message 42: by Tane (new)

Tane Chinemerem wrote: "OMG, I felt like I was the only who hated Rose. This book sums up my feelings toward the book greatly."

What a rediculous thing to say. I guess your the kind of person who likes the week willed, dreamy eyed girl who gets all shy and nervous by hot guys.


message 43: by Chinemerem (new)

Chinemerem Tane wrote: "Chinemerem wrote: "OMG, I felt like I was the only who hated Rose. This book sums up my feelings toward the book greatly."

What a rediculous thing to say. I guess your the kind of person who likes..."


You don't know me so don't make assumptions on the type of protagonists I like. Yes, I get bored with the same weak, shy girls but rude, bad-tampered, and boy-crazy girls are not a good alternative for me. It's MY OPINION so I can think whatever I like. Sure I can't relate to all the reviews stating they loved Rose but I can definitely RESPECT THEIR OPINION.I suggest you do the same for me.


message 44: by Tane (new)

Tane Was just saying, my opinion on your post, get over it :)


message 45: by Scarlet (new)

Scarlet Chinemerem wrote: "OMG, I felt like I was the only who hated Rose. This book sums up my feelings toward the book greatly."

Glad you liked the review!


message 46: by Scarlet (last edited Jul 07, 2012 01:00PM) (new)

Scarlet @Tane

No need to be rude. And yes, you were assuming things by saying Chinemerem must only like weak girls. Since Chinemerem and I share the same opinion of Rose, you must assume the same about me. But you'd be wrong. I dont like bitchy protagonists, and I also dont like mary-sue protagonists. I like complex characters that arent one extreme or the other, but rather a balance.

Hermione, like I mentioned, is perfect. She is kind, loyal, tough, smart as hell, funny, independent, and has real emotions. Perfect character.


message 47: by Velvia (new)

Velvia Keithley Scarlet,

I have really enjoyed reading your review and all of these comments. I have written YA fiction and I often wonder how far to go with things like sex, drugs, etc. I know I cannot assume every teenager is the same, or even have 50% of the same experiences. You seem extremely intelligent and well-read for 16, making wonderful points.

I do think Rose's character goes to extremes, but there is a reason for it (kind of) that gets explained in later books.

Young adult is a strange genre. What the average 13 year old and the average 17 year old can read may be two entirely different things. I think Mead wrestles with that, but then again, I met her and she said she was used to writing more racy stuff for adults. Maybe she had a hard time toning down her YA stuff.

Thanks for your review.


message 48: by Scarlet (last edited Jul 03, 2014 12:06AM) (new)

Scarlet Velvia wrote: "Scarlet,

I have really enjoyed reading your review and all of these comments. I have written YA fiction and I often wonder how far to go with things like sex, drugs, etc. I know I cannot assume ..."


I'm glad you enjoyed my review and thank you for your lovely comments!

Yeah, I can understand how compared to her racy novels, Mead would think VA was very toned down, which is true in that sense. But when you don't set them against anything else, they still are very racy for the YA genre, in my opinion.

Like I said, I dont mind sex so much as I mind how frequently and quickly it seems to come up in YA. I dont mind if the two characters decide to do the deed (in a non-graphic/non-explicit way - this IS for young adults, after all.), but what really bothers me is that there is no growth in the relationship most of the time, the cliche "insta-love." Having the two main- characters feel "mysteriously drawn to each other" is NOT an excuse for a lack of romantic development. I want to know why they like each other (for reasons other than beauty), I want to see them get to know each other over time, and perhaps later, perhaps a few books later, they can take their relationship to the next level.

But frankly I think books like this are just more fuel to the fire that makes teens think sex early in the relationship (or before there really is one) is ok, and that shallow "love" is normal. Pff.


message 49: by Raven (new)

Raven I just find it funny that you think Katniss is a "better" Heroine... Katniss who through three books allows herself to be used as a pawn. Who does not decide which man to go with because of love or greater good, but who is better in each situation. Who does not make decision based on what would be best for the people that are around her or working with her. She is very much a Mary Sue, she seems to feel or display so little emotion, and yet she is the better hero?
Rose is hard to like but comes from a unique situation, and much like Faith from BtVS, we like her because she is such a badass especially when she pulls her head out of her butt and bucks up and acts responsibily. Her loyalty and care for Lissa is love in its purest form. She would die for Lissa and that is so uncommon in most books like there. Most youth oriented books have the catty friends that would stab you in the back as easy as blinking.


message 50: by Mei (new)

Mei Raven wrote: "I just find it funny that you think Katniss is a "better" Heroine... Katniss who through three books allows herself to be used as a pawn. Who does not decide which man to go with because of love or..."

Yes, Because Mary Sue's are dirt poor, average looking, have to take care of their sibling because their mother is depressed, and to top it all off, thrown in an area to fight to the death.

I'm not that big of a fan of Katniss, but I still have to give props to her. If I were in her situation I'd probably be dead.


« previous 1 3
back to top