The Victory of Reason: How Christianity Led to Freedom, Capitalism, and Western Success
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Victory of Reason: How Christianity Led to Freedom, Capitalism, and Western Success

3.89 of 5 stars 3.89  ·  rating details  ·  296 ratings  ·  63 reviews
Many books have been written about the success of the West, analyzing why Europe was able to pull ahead of the rest of the world by the end of the Middle Ages. The most common explanations cite the West’s superior geography, commerce, and technology. Completely overlooked is the fact that faith in reason, rooted in Christianity’s commitment to rational theology, made all t...more
Hardcover, 304 pages
Published December 18th 2007 by Random House (first published December 6th 2005)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Mere Christianity by C.S. LewisThe Screwtape Letters by C.S. LewisThe Reason for God by Timothy KellerThe Great Divorce by C.S. LewisConfessions by Augustine of Hippo
The Christian Intellect
91st out of 450 books — 412 voters
The Constitution of the United States of America by Founding FathersThe Declaration of Independence and The Constitution of the U... by Thomas JeffersonThe Federalist Papers by Alexander HamiltonGreen Illusions by Ozzie ZehnerThe Revolution by Ron Paul
Best Books to Become an Informed Voter
309th out of 662 books — 826 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 764)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Douglas Wilson
This is one of the most satisfying books I have read in a long time. It is one thing to reject, as I have for many years, the idea of the "Dark Ages," but Stark demonstrates just how "undark" they were. Leave it to secular thinkers to tag the most advanced human society to date as a period of blind superstition. And this book is potent evidence against those who want to represent free markets as an Enlightenment concept, one that Christians should leave behind. What we now call capitalism was al...more
Patrick
Given the title of this book, I expected an expert but narrowly-focused argument. Rodney Stark delivers far more than that. He may be the best researcher writing nonfiction today, and his prose is never dry or needlessly academic. The result is a gripping one-volume history of Christendom from an economic point of view. Stark addresses (and demolishes) the myths of the "Dark Ages," while also regaling the reader with tales about the Italian city-states, not to mention France, Spain, England, the...more
Jason
Professor Stark, a Baylor University social sciences professor, has written a book that should complement recent works by men like Jared Diamond or Victor Davis Hanson, in explaining why the West, and especially why particular forms of Christianity have led to unique successes for its adherents around the present world. Stark has written to especially critique ideas in the famous book, the Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. Instead he argues that Christianity in general has led to fo...more
Athens
Sep 09, 2012 Athens added it
Shelves: hist, e-books
About 15% of the way in, it became clear that this book would be controversial in a public way.

Without being an apologist for Stark, and certainly not so only this far in, he is making me consider some things that I had not considered before.

In specific, in the Christian model the individual makes free-will choices and is responsible for those choices. This assertion is then coupled with the duty of that individual to understand and use the formal process of ~reason~ to come to conclusions abo...more
David
Rodney Stark argues here, as he has in other places, that it was Christian faith that motivated the West to pursue capitalism. From this pursuit came western success. Stark argues that those who dissociate Christian faith from western achievements such as science and capitalism are rewriting history.

Stark argues in chapter one that Christian faith was unique in believing that progress was God-given. This allowed later theologians to reinterpret scripture when necessary. Therefore, while the Bibl...more
Socraticgadfly
When Stark can make broad-sweeping, but not very accurate statements such as "Capitalism was developed by the great monastic estates," you know to buckle your seat belts, you're in for a historically bumpy ride.

Here, as in "For the Glory of God," Stark claims to be rehabilitating Christian religious history from people labeled as militant atheists and others who are always implied to be inaccurate rewriters of history.

Well, if you read my more in-depth review of that book, you'll see that, while...more
Ron
It is commonplace to think of Christianity and rationalism as opposite historical and philosophical forces. In this study, Stark demonstrates that elements within Christianity actually gave rise not only to visions of reason and progress but also to the evolution of capitalism."Rodney Stark may be the most influential religious researcher of the past hundred years. He has revolutionized contemporary thought about religion and economics, and in this book - his most provocative yet - he makes a co...more
Robert
I learned more about world history and the rise of the West by reading this book than in all of my history classes through high-school and college. The Victory of Reason opened my eyes to the development of capitalism in the West as an out-springing of monotheism and the belief that God wants man to use his reason. Stark dispels many myths about the "dark ages" and sheds some very practical light on the disparity between North and South America. He is able to present and support his ideas withou...more
Diana
I was willing to read this book because Stark is not a theologian, nor is he Christian; he's a sociologist and therefore his perpsective is a little different. I am not religious but I do love history, the social sciences and I have a slight fascination with the origins of ritual behaviors.

The development of western civilization is so intertwined with religion it seems this book helps fills in some of the gaps where other history books end or fail to give a clear picture.

I have two complaints;...more
Laurie
May 02, 2008 Laurie rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: christians, sociologists, people who like interesting books
Recommended to Laurie by: Relevant magazine
When I took this book off the shelf in the Sociology section of the New York Public Library, I immediately wondered if this book would read like a college textbook. I will say that you should not attempt this book if you are feeling at all tired because it will only make your eyelids droop. However, when I was full of life, this book by Rodney Stark was very interesting. Stark basically defends the idea that Christianity lead to technological innovations and new ways of running society (capitali...more
Andy
Sep 24, 2010 Andy rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Anyone who enjoys history, wants their mind stretched, Christian libertarians
A fascinating thesis, well reasoned and documented. Great history, covering eras and items that are frequently neglected. Could barely put it down. And yes, he documents not just HOW but WHY and what about Christianity it is that leads to Freedom, Capitalism, and Western success. He shows that the Rationality and Reason that informs Christianity, as well as the belief in an ordered universe that makes sense and can be understood, the belief in equality before God, and many more fundamental tenet...more
Christopher
Reading Stark is always an adventure. A great deal of unique, stellar material, and just enough bad to keep you on your toes. Easily the best thing about the book is how he completely rejects the notion of the Dark Ages as a myth perpetuated by sour people, and then subverts it completely.

His first section on Christianity promotes economic and political freedom was good overall, though his grasp of good Christian theology left something to be desired. On a related note, his material on pre-enlig...more
Andrew
Fantastic. On the whole, very, very good. This book is for anyone who has ever been told that Christianity has been bad for civilization/progress. My main beef with the book is how much regard Stark hold democracy in as far as establishing free societies. Biblical law establishes free society, not allowing people to choose their despots, I mean, rulers, but I digress. A book for anyone who wants to have an insight into the implications of Post-Millenial Christianity.
Michael Gerald Dealino
Dear Richard Dawkins, the late Christopher Hitchens, and all other militant atheists out there:

You should have conducted more research before attacking other people's freedom of religion. If you did so, then you would have realized that religion, specifically Christianity, and science do complement each other. But you were so close-minded that you didn't even notice that.

Anyway, who really cares about your rants?
Phil
Genuinely outstanding historical analysis of European history from the Middle Ages to the Enlightenment. Emphasizes the economic and intellectual activity of the Middle Ages. If you have any notion that the Middle Ages were dark, backward, or stagnant, read this book right now.
Zach Hedges
I must say that I was quite disappointed when I finished this book, whose title and summary seemed so intriguing to me. Unfortunately, Stark's main thesis--that the principle of "reason", as unique to Christianity, was the primary factor in the rise of capitalism and indeed all of Western civilization--is largely confined to his introduction and conclusion. The chapters in between are dedicated to unnecessarily detailed descriptions (through the use of "case studies") of capitalism's evolution t...more
Greg Coates
Infuriatingly ideological, poorly researched, and filled to the brim with triumphalistic racism, this book is the epitome of religious right hagiographical hubris. Just a few notes for Rodney Stark:

- for the love of all things good in this world, cease equivocating your modernist, Lockean, post-Enlightenment language of "rights," "freedom," and "liberty" with the biblical concepts (which are ENTIRELY different). As a historian, you should know better. You commit the foul of anachronism to the nt...more
Justin Tapp
Stark sets out to challenge anthropologists like Jared Diamond who contend that Europeans rose to prominence mainly out of geographic factors in their favor. Stark's hypothesis is that Christian thinking-- forward looking thought towards progress and in favor of basic equality and property rights-- led to European development. That while the decline of the Roman Empire is something historians have lamented in centuries past, it was precisely the catalyst that freed up individuals to become entre...more
Jerry
Stark makes the case that medieval monks, during those slandered dark ages, birthed capitalism that would develop Western culture. He defines capitalism as "an economic system wherein privately owned, relatively well organized, and stable firms pursue complex commercial activities within a relatively free (unregulated) market, taking a systematic, long-term approach to investing an reinvesting wealth (directly or indirectly) in productive activities involving a hired workforce, and guided by ant...more
Rogers
Stark attempts to explain that capitalism has roots far deeper than the Reformation, and attempts to debunk long held notions about Greek logic, the Roman Empire, and how capitalism took hold in areas where rights of property and freedom were respected.

He is at his best when he cites empirical data. His explanations why England took off, why Latin and South America lagged behind North America, and why prosperous city-states like Venice declined are well argued.

I have only two complaints. One, th...more
Timothy Bertolet
The thesis of the book is simple: Christianity encouraged the use of reason which lead the rise of freedom and capitalism. In this book Stark takes on the sort of post-enlightenment lore that Christianity led to the dark ages and reason did not spring forth until post-Renaissance and even later until the dawning of "enlightenment".

In fact, Stark shows the the "dark ages" were hardly dark. This is not a new thesis to historians of the middle ages, as a number of recent studies have shown--yet thi...more
W. Bradford Littlejohn
If I had come across this book in a vacuum, no doubt I would’ve thought it mediocre and occasionally annoying, but nothing to get worked up about. But, knowing as I did (from word of mouth and from the enthusiastic blurbs on the cover) that many in conservative evangelical circles loved this book, I spent the entire time I was reading vexed by the question “Why?” And unable to satisfactorily answer that question, I found myself in a very ill temper throughout. Now, because this book received suc...more
Bob
The reigning perception of Christianity in the academy is of a faith that is the enemy of reason from which enlightenment humanism liberated us. Rodney Stark would contend that this is a characterization without basis in fact. In The Victory of Reason he argues that the distinctive progress of the west in science, technology, commerce, human rights, and democratic institutions can be traced back to the distinctive character of Christian belief.

What is more intriguing is that he argues that this...more
Dennis
I love well-researched books that correct the false impressions left to us from historians who write with an anti-Christian agenda. Authors such as Edward Gibbons (The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire,) Jared Diamond (Guns, Gems and Steel), Carl Sagan (The Demon Haunted World) and Daniel Boorstin (The Discoverers) either through innuendo, ambivalence, or outright animosity, leave their readers with the impression that Christianity was either irrelevant, or else a great impediment to progress...more
Max Evans
Rodney Stark is becoming my hero. I first heard of him when he wrote the article about how Mormons were going to become a new world religion. That got me to start looking for things that he wrote. I was surprised when I found out that he'd written a number of books as well. One was a trilogy about monotheism and this is the end of that series. The things that he writes are fascinating to me.

One of his books opened my eyes to the third great monotheism, Islam. He wrote about Islam in a way that I...more
Adam T Calvert
Now this is a history lesson you hardly ever hear: its precisely because Western Europe (and then America) was Christianized that it became the world leader in everything (education, innovation, technology, economics, politics), since its conversion to Christianity; and only if it retains its belief in Christianity will it retain its leading role.

Starks, who at the time of writing this book was not by any sense a "born again Christian," writes with a very accessible style, a thorough background...more
Радостин Марчев
Завършвам книгата (след едно дълго прекъсване) със смесени мисли. От една страна никак не съм убеден в някои основни тези, които авторът поставя в самото начало. От друга книгата съдържа някои много интересни и правдиви според мен момента - например анализа и критиката на тезата на Макс Вебер за "протестантската етика и капитализма." Средната част донякъде ме отегчи, но за сметка на това последните 2 глави са чудесни - добре подкрепеното с цифри сравнение на икономическото развитие на северна и...more
Frank Roberts
No, it was not guns, germs, steel, geography, or luck that made Europe the leader of the world in technology, in economy, or in power. It was Christianity, with its ideas of progress, of individual human worth, and of a rational God whose universe could be understood, which made Europe great.

An excellent book, partly because it is an excellent economic history. Why capitalism works, and why it was born in a Christian milieu. Why and how Science came from a Christian milieu, and no other. Requir...more
Mathias Seiwert
"Extremely interesting book written when the author was not a Christian. Of course I could not understand everything in this book--some of it was decidedly over my head! But it does help us understand a little more thoroughly/clearly some of the reasons why different continents/nations/hemispheres have developed as they have over the last 1,000 years."
John
This is a great book. Stark demonstrates that it is Christianity that established the West as the dominant cultural force in the world. He contrasts Christianity, Islam, Confucianism, and others early on in the book to show that it was Christianity alone that gave man a rational, ordered understanding of the world. Christianity is centered upon a God that acts in a logical, consistent manner, giving man reason to study and understand the world--to pursue scientific endeavor. This then led to phi...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 25 26 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Money, Greed, and God: Why Capitalism Is the Solution and Not the Problem
  • God's Philosophers: How the Medieval World Laid the Foundations of Modern Science
  • Christianity's Dangerous Idea: The Protestant Revolution: A History from the Sixteenth Century to the Twenty-First
  • How The Catholic Church Built Western Civilization
  • New Testament History
  • How Capitalism Saved America: The Untold History of Our Country, from the Pilgrims to the Present
  • Defending Constantine: The Twilight of an Empire and the Dawn of Christendom
  • The Rise of Western Christendom: Triumph & Diversity 200-1000
  • Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies
  • What's So Great About Christianity
  • The Great Siege: Malta 1565
  • Triumph: The Power and the Glory of the Catholic Church
  • The Lost History of Christianity: The Thousand-Year Golden Age of the Church in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia--and How It Died
  • The Civil War as a Theological Crisis
  • The History of the Church: From Christ to Constantine
  • Carnage and Culture: Landmark Battles in the Rise of Western Power
  • Saint Thomas Aquinas
  • Fundamentalism and American Culture
15511
Rodney Stark grew up in Jamestown, North Dakota, and began his career as a newspaper reporter. Following a tour of duty in the U.S. Army, he received his PhD from the University of California, Berkeley, where he held appointments as a research sociologist at the Survey Research Center and at the Center for the Study of Law and Society. He left Berkeley to become Professor of Sociology and of Compa...more
More about Rodney Stark...
The Rise of Christianity: How the Obscure, Marginal Jesus Movement Became the Dominant Religious Force in the Western World in a Few Centuries God's Battalions: The Case for the Crusades The Triumph of Christianity: How the Jesus Movement Became the World's Largest Religion Cities of God: The Real Story of How Christianity Became an Urban Movement and Conquered Rome For the Glory of God: How Monotheism Led to Reformations, Science, Witch-Hunts, and the End of Slavery

Share This Book