Love Over Scotland (44 Scotland Street Series #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Love Over Scotland (44 Scotland Street #3)

3.93 of 5 stars 3.93  ·  rating details  ·  4,947 ratings  ·  414 reviews
Once again confounding expectations, Alexander McCall Smith has written a mystery novel unlike any other. Inspired by a chance encounter with Tales of the City novelist Armistead Maupin, the author of the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency decided to write a novel under the pressure of daily serialization. Originally published in 110 installments in The Scotsman, 44 Scotland S...more
MP3 Book, 0 pages
Published April 17th 2009 by Recorded Books, LLC (first published 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Persephone
Another gentle offering from Edinburgh. And it's rather nice, what with death, disease, global warming, and possible financial disaster in the headlines, to escape into the more manageable problems of those living in and around 44 Scotland Street.

The last "44 Scotland Street novel" I read was The World According to Bertie, which takes place after this one, but it doesn't matter. The characters in these novels lead busy lives with plenty of time for reflection. Here's an example I particularly li...more
Zen Cho
I find it difficult to understand why people dislike Alexander McCall Smith. I can kinda see them not getting the point (I can't get the point of Henry James, which is much more literarily embarrassing), but I'm not sure why you'd dislike him. I guess you might find him twee?

Anyway, I love his books. The Two and a Half Pillars of Wisdom is still my favourite, because it is the perfect example of the kind of gentle absurdity I think he is best at, and because I read it at a time when I badly nee...more
Gemma
I hate to say it, but this book bored me witless.
This is the first in the series I have read, and I picked it up from a hotel reception as there was nothing else.
The book does give a description of what happened in the last installment at the beginning, so felt that it would be fine to pick up half way through, and it was. The story was easy to follow, it was just very very boring.
I was expecting a soap opera type theme, but there was no scandal, no excitement with any of the characters, they...more
Yooperprof
This is the third in a series of Edinburgh-based novels, and I think I've had about enough. I still enjoyed reading about the sufferings of poor Bertie, the victim of an overbearing and controlling mother. And Angus Lordie's dog Cyril has an interesting adventure that unfornately is cut short much too soon. But the "twee" factor seems to be greater in this book than in the others, as many of the characters revel in what appears to be the boring and bland provincialism of the Scottish capital. Mo...more
Donna Radcliff
I'm going to hang this series up for now. To be honest, I don't care about most of the characters; not Pat and Matthew, or Big Lou, certainly not Antonia Collie, or Domenica and Angus (though the world seen through Clive's canine eyes was pretty good). It got to the point that I was just reading the chapters about Bertie. Those were great. However, I keep waiting for Bertie to dissociate and his evil side would exact a terrible revenge on his mother that includes much pain and blood. Even better...more
Katie
I think I have learned enough about these characters in the first two books. Upon picking this book up I found myself bored with the characters. Pat is no longer living at 44 Scotland St and lost my interest when her immaturity began to show in the second book. Bruce, who I loved to be annoyed by is in London and Domenica is off chasing pirates. I am bored. The only one I wanted to see more about is little Bertie, but I just could not get myself to push through to see his parts. Maybe one day I...more
Louise Culmer
I was very disappointed in this one. At the end of Espresso Tales, Bertie's wimpy father finally atarted standing up for Bertie,and I thought he was going to get liberated from his stupid mother, and be able to give up the silly pi k dungarees, doing yoga etc. But instead, it is as if the events of the last book never happened, and Bertie is as much trapped by his mother as before. And his father has dwindled into being practically non-existent.

There are somd funny bits, especially Domenica's ad...more
Ken Deshaies
I can't help myself. I start one of Smith's novels thinking something like, "Well, this will just be more of the same." Forgetting, of course, how much I enjoyed the last one. Before you know it, I'm laughing out loud and find I have a hard time putting the book down to, say, sleep. His sense of humor is consistent, and Bertie continues to be an absolute kick. Bertie's adventures are both amazingly unbelievable and believable. Sounds ridiculous, I know, but for a kid who has an interest in readi...more
June Louise
"Matthew thought for a moment. Were there any funky people in Moray Place? He thought not. He was not at all sure if there were any funky people in Edinburgh at all. Some towns were distinctly funky - San Francisco was an example - but Edinburgh was not one of them, he thought."

This third volume in the Scotland Street series requires a literary passport as we follow our well-loved characters in their adventures in places as diverse as Edinburgh, Indonesia, Paris and a short trip to Glasgow. As w...more
Christia
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Sue
Lately I’ve had a few too many pieces of downbeat news, I needed some escapist fiction, and so it was time again for Alexander McCall Smith. Luckily he’s written a lot of books, and I have plenty more waiting for me.

This week’s merriment came from “Love Over Scotland.” Smith is not deep, but he is witty, and he has a huge capacity for droll characters and diverting episodes. Pat, supposedly bright and sensible, still has a weakness for handsome cads. Domenica pursues her anthropological studies...more
Carol
I was very disappointed in this one. At the end of Espresso Tales, Bertie's wimpy father finally started standing up for Bertie, and I thought he was going to get liberated from his stupid mother, and be able to give up the silly pink dungarees, doing yoga and all the stupid stuff his mother wrapped him up in. etc. But instead, it is as if the events of the last book never happened, and Bertie is as much trapped by his mother as before. And his father has dwindled into being practically not arou...more
Heather
As an avid AMS fan, I have to say that I was a little disappointed with this book. I have loved all his novels I've read to date but for some reason this one just didn't get going for me. I love Edinburgh and so the location of the setting appealed to me, but I just didn't really warm to any of the characters (other than Bertie but I didn't think we saw enough of him). I found the Dominica storyline in the Malacca Straits a little far fetched. The reintroduction of Lard O'Connor could have been...more
Gina
Like a number of other reviews, I think I have hit my limit with the Scotland Street series. Perhaps reading/listening to them back-to-back is not the best way to "consume" them.

I know that some were bothered by the lack of plot, but I read so much non-fiction that simple character studies and descriptions of slices of life suited me fine. Of course, I listened to the first three of this series while drive and at work, so the simplicity was not an issue for me.

As for the character studies, I am...more
Tiger
In his third entry in the series, McCall Smith continues to enchant his readers with the lives of the inhabitants of 44 Scotland Street.

My favourite is 6-year old Bertie whose constant battles with mother Irene and father Stuart come to a head when he goes to the police station confesses his parents' questionable business engagement with Lard O'Connor (think Tony Soprano with a Scottish accent). Bertie is charming and engaging, but so are the other characters.

Domenica actually goes out to see he...more
Linda
This is the third book in the Scotland Street series by the well-known author of the No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency stories. I am enjoying each book in the series more than the previous one as the characters grow on me. There's no real plot, just character studies of people who interact with each other and their particular stories and conflicts. I must admit that it's totally addicting. This book and it's predecessors are like a continuing soap opera in print, but MUCH more fun. The author's hum...more
Suzanne
I begin with this entry in the series because it was the oldest work that the library had on its shelves. I put all of the earlier and later works on hold well before I finished this one. I can't decide whether McCall Smith is the new Jane Austen or the new Anthony Trollope. OK, maybe he isn't quite that good, but maybe he is. His characters are lovingly-drawn and fully-developed, with all the quirks and foibles of real people. He shifts among men, women, and children with ease. The setting, atm...more
Nancy
A nice, comforting, enjoyable read. Here's a quote that sums it up:

Says a writer of her characters: ". . . I want their vision of justice and good to prevail."

"And is that the only possible ending?" asked Angus.

"No," said Antonia. "Things can end badly, as they sometimes do in life. but if they do, then we know that something is wrong, just as we know it when a piece of music doesn't resolve itself properly at the end. We know that. We just do. And so we prefer harmony."

"And everybody lives happ...more
Monica Edinger
Have to admit I'm more mixed about this series as I read more. I really like parts of it, but not the way McCall Smith channels his own opinions, that of a person of a certain age, through his characters; he gets awfully cantankerous at times. And often it seems as if we are in an earlier era. Especially when it comes to the twenty-somethings: Matthew buys handkerchiefs, Pat never uses a cell phone, Bruce seems more like a cad from twenty years back than today, another young character talks abou...more
Jane
What I learned: Don't be fooled by having like an author's previous books that the next one will be good, too.

I picked this up at the library to have a small "purse" book to take along to a doctor appointment.

Yow! What a let down. This book isn't worth your time. He has a series of characters and rotates between them - you know that technique. But the end of the book I was skipping through all but one of the story lines, and I didn't care much about that one.

Read a better book! Or clean house....more
Terri
Wow! After reading all the other reviews, almost all 5 star for this book, I better tread lightly! I guess I better begin by stating that my family thoroughly enjoyed listening to No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series on tape and I was ready to love another McCall Smith read. That said, I found Love Over Scotland very easy reading, great for light, mindless, relaxing reading- and the chapters are really short making it possible to read a snatch here and there and come to a good stopping point ev...more
Varsha
McCall Smith strikes again. Enjoyed this as much the first two. This is not really a novel in the conventional sense: the plot is getting more and more skeins and not really going anywhere. But who cares. Life is like that too.
Anna
I love these wee books. McCall Smith's novels are like vanilla wafers - I don't notice when I've finished one and started another, but I enjoy myself all the while.
Stephen
One of the things that I like to do before going to sleep is to read a few pages of a pretty light, easy to read, book. Alexander McCall Smith is one of my favourite authors in this genre. This book is the third in the series. It contains a set of characters who, on the whole, I like. Their antics in their day-to-day lives are a bit like a soap opera, but I find that help helps me to wind down just right before going to sleep. I also like the format - a series of short, journalistic, pieces that...more
Readstoomuch
I am crazy about this series!!!
Joanne
This was another interesting segment of the 44 Scotland Street series as many of our favorite characters return and we are even introduced to a few new ones. I have always enjoyed Alexander McCall Smith's novels as they are full of delightful elements that never fail to put a smile on my face. The narration of Robert Ian MacKenzie only enhanced my experience that much more.

In the last novel it seemed to me that Bertie's father was actually stepping up to his wife to loosen the controlling grip o...more
Susanhayeshotmail.com
I continue to be captivated by the residents of 44 Scotland Street(and nearby environs). Not in the staying up all night because I simply must know what happens next way. No, not that at all, just in a gentle how're they doing now sort of captivation. Whenever I think of these books the words charming, witty and droll beg to be used and that continues to be the case.

This time around the odious Bruce is absent, though I cannot help but fear a return. Bertie is forced into yet more productive and...more
Michel
44 Scotland Street is my favorite series of McCall Smith, better even than the Nr. 1 Ladies Detective Agency or the Sunday Philosophy Club (note: start with the first in the series, entitled, you guessed it, 44 Scotland Steet).
In this style of his, simple, precise, lovely and loving, he tells the intertwined stories of the inhabitants of an apartment building in Edinburgh, and its neighbourhood: in this instalment, we learn how Bertie, the child prodigy with the hands-on mom, becomes an accident...more
Anne Hawn Smith
This book is another visit with the characters in and around 44 Scotland Street in Edinburgh and are introduced to two new and very promising characters; a very shady character from Glasgow who is a special friend of Bertie's and anthropologist Domenica Macdonald's friend who has come to stay in her flat while she is studying pirates. In this book we find Bertie managing to rebel against his horrid mother a little more with the help of his father. He also manages to get loose in Paris to his int...more
Ginny
book 3. The story continues: Bertie goes to Paris with the teenage orchestra that his mother has pushed him into and he's left behind. Pat moves in with Matthew temporarily when she is treatened by her flatmate (all about the boyfriend Wolf) At the end of the book she has to move out because she has romantic feelings for Matthew. He gives her a necklace. Ramsey D. dies while Angus Lordie is painting his portrait. Domenica leaves to do research and Antonia uses her place, meets with Angus, not re...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Trouble for Lucia (Lucia, #6)
  • Anarchy And Old Dogs (Dr. Siri Paiboun, #4)
  • Friends at Thrush Green (Thrush Green, #10)
  • Set in Darkness (Inspector Rebus, #11)
  • A Rather Charming Invitation (Penny Nichols, #3)
  • Large Print (Unshelved, #8)
  • Miss Julia Rocks the Cradle (Miss Julia #12)
  • Miss Buncle's Book
  • Hotel Pastis: A Novel of Provence
  • Wednesday the Rabbi Got Wet
  • The Young Wan
  • Notwithstanding
  • The Luck of the Bodkins
  • More Than You Can Say
4738
Alexander McCall Smith is the author of the international phenomenon The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, the Isabel Dalhousie Series, the Portuguese Irregular Verbs series, and the 44 Scotland Street series. He is professor emeritus of medical law at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland and has served on many national and international bodies concerned with bioethics. He was born in what...more
More about Alexander McCall Smith...
The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency  (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency #1) Tears of the Giraffe (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency, #2) Morality for Beautiful Girls (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency #3) The Kalahari Typing School for Men (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency #4) The Full Cupboard of Life (No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency #5)

Share This Book

“Gracious acceptance is an art - an art which most never bother to cultivate. We think that we have to learn how to give, but we forget about accepting things, which can be much harder than giving.... Accepting another person's gift is allowing him to express his feelings for you.” 52 likes
“Regular maps have few surprises: their contour lines reveal where the Andes are, and are reasonably clear. More precious, though, are the unpublished maps we make ourselves, of our city, our place, our daily world, our life; those maps of our private world we use every day; here I was happy, in that place I left my coat behind after a party, that is where I met my love; I cried there once, I was heartsore; but felt better round the corner once I saw the hills of Fife across the Forth, things of that sort, our personal memories, that make the private tapestry of our lives.” 39 likes
More quotes…