Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Zona Aman Gorazde: Perang di Bosnia Timur 1992-1995” as Want to Read:
Zona Aman Gorazde: Perang di Bosnia Timur 1992-1995
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Zona Aman Gorazde: Perang di Bosnia Timur 1992-1995

by
4.27 of 5 stars 4.27  ·  rating details  ·  5,044 ratings  ·  274 reviews
Pada akhir 1995 dan awal 1996, kartunis sekaligus reporter, Joe Sacco, melakukan empat kali perjalanan ke Goradze, sebuah kota yang ditunjuk PBB sebagai daerah aman semasa Perang Bosnia. Selama tiga setengah tahun, kota tersebut terombang-ambing di ambang kemusnahan. Dikepung oleh pasukan Bosnia Serbia, penduduk Goradze yang sebagaian besar Muslim mengalami serangan dahsya ...more
Paperback, 244 pages
Published October 2010 by DAR! Mizan (first published 2000)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Zona Aman Gorazde, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Zona Aman Gorazde

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Michael
Really bad things happened in Bosnia and dumb-asses like me read about it in a comic book. I shrink in shame.

-m


WEF GN
Malbadeen
Jan 06, 2010 Malbadeen rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: not the faint of heart!
Ee-gads!
If you asked me to summarize this book with one word I would say...
INTENSE!

If you gave me two worlds, I would say...
SUPER INTENSE!

If you gave me three, I would say...
TOTALLY SUPER INTENSE!

Occasionally I feel remiss when it comes to world history/politics/current events. Occasionally it occurs to my knowledge of wars goes something like this:

-people in North America didn't like taxes so they threw tea around and then there was a war and now we have 4th of July.

-People were mean and stupid
...more
Kirsten
I think this may be one of the most moving and gut-wrenching books about war that I've ever read. I'm not sure why it made so much more of an impact on me than all of the other books of war journalism I've read over the years. There's something about it that just really gets under your skin. Maybe it's that Sacco can show us these people -- not just tell us what they looked like, but actually draw them as they look when they are most vulnerable or most ugly and violent. The plight of the denizen ...more
Ikra Amesta
Kejayaan Nazi memang sudah lama berlalu, namun filosofi fasis-nya masih terus diusung pada setiap perang dimanapun setelahnya. Tengoklah prahara di Gorazde. Sebuah daerah kantong di Bosnia Timur yang dikepung oleh pasukan separatis Serbia (Chetnik) sejak awal perang Bosnia. Sebagian dari populasinya adalah Muslim dan telah lama sebelumnya hidup berdampingan dengan orang-orang Serbia sampai akhirnya perang mengguratkan garis pemisah yang sangat jelas di antara keduanya.

Perang Bosnia adalah sebua
...more
Melki
Ethnic cleansing, torture, and rape seem like strange subjects for a graphic novel, yet somehow...this book works. Seeing the faces of the victims, not just reading about them, only serves to make the story all the more horrifying.

Sacco uses his black and white drawings as photo journalism, telling the tale of a safe zone that proved to be anything but safe for its residents. He offers up a history of the war through interviews with survivors, many living in bombed out shells that used to be ho
...more
Schuyler
Devasting is the first word that comes to mind. The story of the Bosnian War is a bit complicated (like most wars) but here is a radically condensed summary: Yugoslavia was made up of mostly Croatians, Serbians, and Muslims. And after WWII, the then president Josip Broz, commonly known as Tito, looked to down play ethnic nationalism and have each group live side by side peacefully. Then Tito died and Serbian nationalism took hold through the new Serbian president, Slobodan Milosevic, who became ...more
Jeff
Safe Area Gorazde is a stunning work, combining the best traits of journalism, comics, and historical non-fiction. What really makes this book exceptional is the fact that Joe Sacco has mastered all of the elements of his craft - the writing and the art hold up equally well despite the high standards that Sacco has evidently set for himself.[return][return]The tale told herein is alternately thrilling, horrifying, and redeeming, but manages to hit all of those high points without an excess of au ...more
Christopher Roth
Not just one of the best things I've ever seen about the Yugoslav Wars of Succession, but one of the best arguments for non-fiction comics. Very powerful book. It gets deep into the inexplicable phenomenon of how Serbs turned on their Muslim neighbors almost overnight when war erupted in Bosnia. Puts a human face on the Bosnian war more than anything I've read.
molly
To me, Sacco came off as kinda creepy but I did like that the majority of the book wasn't about his experiences or opinions (I didn't care for those parts). I appreciated that he presented the stories of a few of those you lived it.
Shannon (Giraffe Days)
This is a book I would probably have never known about if it hadn't been for a little workshop I attended during my teaching degree. Which would have been a sad loss for me, because this is an excellent book, vivid and educational, emotional and honest, a book that brings a complex and confusing war into your lap, at the same time beautiful in its artistic skill, and heart-wrenching in the agony of its story.

Goražde (pronounced "go-RAJH-duh") is a town in Bosnia, which used to be part of Yugosla
...more
Ryan Mishap
Like with Palestine, his previous graphic account of life in the occupied territories, I didn’t like Sacco. Here, though, he’s less evident while recounting his experiences in the title town during the Bosnian war. As the Serbs aggressively attacked their Bosnian neighbors, took territory and lives while the world community stood by, “safe areas” were supposed to be fire-free zones under UN protection. The reality on the ground is illustrated brilliantly as Sacco draws out people’s stories while ...more
Ruth
How do I put what I've just read into words? A picture is worth a thousand words and Sacco grabs ahold of this concept in this profound and enormously well-captured work on the Bosnian War. Serbians and Muslims, who were literally living next door as neighbors, somehow managed to hate and kill each other in a way that eerily parallels the horrors during WWII. Although strictly from the POV's of Bosnians and never from the side of the enemy, I still believe it's a great piece of journalistic work ...more
David Schaafsma
I recently read Terrorist about the assassination that triggered WWI, and was nudged to reread Sacco's wonderful text, set in the same region, beset by some of the same ethnic politics/history, of course, and discovered this special edition, issued in 2011. I think the original came out in 2001, and it was based, like his also classic Palestine, on Sacco's first person comics journalism in the region. He isn't ever trying to pretend he is just some fly on the wall. He's there, and often self dep ...more
Thomas Harr
I read this book shortly after doing a spring break tour of the Balkans. It's a good thing I visited Belgrade, Serbia first before getting this book because after reading it my sentiment is "Fuck the Serbs."

It's important to remember that this book is written from a specific point of view, and Sacco acknowledges in his book that this is not supposed to be an authoritative narrative of the breakup of Yugoslavia or the entire conflict. It's also really important to say that Serbia like any other p
...more
Nuno Ribeiro
When I was first reading this (and did not imagine that there was more graphic journalism of this kind - I only knew MAUS as graphic non fiction) it was so hard for me, at first, to think of Joe Sacco explaining what he was doing, in Gorazde. It all felt so groundbreaking, and fragile and absolutelly brave. There was a journalist, in a very unstable area, doing a story about war. He goes there so he can listen and take notes, talk to people, hear their stories, so he can produce a comic book. In ...more
Miles
A powerful graphic novel about the war in Eastern Bosnia between 1992 and 1995. When the events were taking place, it was easy to tune them out, thinking "it's just more ethnic fighting in the Balkans." Sacco does a brilliant job of humanizing the conflict, though, by introducing us to the very human characters the populate this city under siege. The book's power comes from the little moments - the request by a local man that Sacco teach him the lyrics to rock songs, the flirtations and material ...more
Tyler Hill
Joe Sacco's a crazy man. By that, I don't mean to say his behavior or attitude are wild or outrageous (actually, the reverse seems to be true); but instead, I say it because it just boggles my mind that he does what he does: Go to conflict areas around the world, and then write comics about his experiences there. First, you have the reality to traveling to an area where and armed conflict is happening (or, at least recently happened). Then you have the reality of creating comics: A massively lab ...more
Erin
War correspondent Joe Sacco’s graphic novel, Gorazde, is difficult to read. It reports on the experiences of Edin, a Bosnian Muslim, during the siege of Gorazde and describes in text and image the atrocities committed during the siege of the city and of neighboring towns, and of the violence of diplomatic decisions that favoured political expediency over human life and well-being.

As I read the book (in a single sitting, it’s entirely captivating) I asked myself what made the graphic form so effe
...more
Nicholas Whyte
http://nhw.livejournal.com/520565.html[return][return]Sacco has a superb portrait here of a community under siege, not actually sure if there is a future, yet alone what it might hold (there were persistent rumours that Gora~de might be traded to the Serbs in return for concessions elsewhere). He shows himself as an outsider, both slightly sinister (with his eyes never visible behind his glasses) and slightly absurd (with his lips grotesquely enlarged, giving him literally a big mouth). The inha ...more
Amanda
Apr 08, 2008 Amanda rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Amanda by: syllabus from a history class I didn't take
More accurately 3.7 stars. So I changed it to four. But not quite four. 7/10.

So, my recent graphic narrative reads have sort of jumped to either end of the genre: very literary graphic novel in Fun Home, and true comic book with Ex Machina. Fittingly, as a graphic narrative, Safe Area Gorazde lies somewhere else on the spectrum. Most accurately "illustrated journalism," it shares with Maus a startling effectiveness at conveying horrific atrocities using black and white drawings (although no anim
...more
Mejix
I have to begin by saying that I intensely dislike Sacco's drawing style. Most of it is tacky, cheesy, gooey, sticky. It feels like bad illustration from the 70's. The way he does background shadow lines using a ruler is god-awful. I also have reservations about the motivations behind these reportage comics. Many times they feel interested in the entertainment value of tragedy. As another reviewer here commented Sacco comes across as kinda creepy. He is nevertheless a good narrator, tells the st ...more
Erika Schoeps
A great, absorbing work of graphic novel journalism. Sacco is a master of balancing historical fact with human connection, creating a work of non-fiction that is both readable and educational. The use of black and white keeps things respectful and somber, preventing this from becoming about Sacco's artistic skills or merit, and more about the content. Another masterful thing Sacco does is expose the reader to the horror of the situation without making it too depressing to read. In all aspects of ...more
Alden Weer
Estoy bastante de acuerdo con este formato de comic documental. Joe Sacco pasó un tiempo en Gorazde (Bosnia) después de las guerras yugoslavas y plasmó en comic cuanto personaje, anécdota e historia de guerra encontró, brindando contexto político y social (hay bastante texto). Y es duro de leer. Es bastante duro. Por la pérdida de fe en la humanidad que experimenté leyéndolo, capaz me recordó a Maus, que transcurría en los campos de concentración nazis. Y buueno, la actitud genocida de los serbi ...more
Nabila Anwar
Buku yang mengisahkan tentang peperangan yang pertama saya baca adalah The Pianist. Saat sampai pada adegan seorang laki-laki tua dilempar dari lantai atas sebua bangunan hingga, saya berjanji itu buku perang-perangan terakhir yang saya baca. Nyatanya, saya maish tergelitik membaca kisah-kisah dari balik asap perang.
Gazorde Safe Zone adalah laporan jurnalisme intim yang divisualisasikan dengan cantik –secara grafis saja.- oleh jurnalis Joe Sacco. Dipandu oleh Edin, seorang warga setempat, Sacco
...more
Ms. Knapp
The winner of the 2001 Eisner Award for Best New Graphic Album. Sacco spent five months in Bosnia in 1996, immersing himself in the human side of life during wartime, researching stories that are rarely found in conventional news coverage, emerging with this astonishing first-person account.

Praised by The New York Times, Brill's Content and Publishers Weekly, Safe Area Gorazde is the long-awaited and highly sought after 240-page look at war in the former Yugoslavia. Sacco (the critically-acclai
...more
Jenny
My best friend is a Croatian émigré. Her Roman Catholic family escaped their village with help from their Muslim neighbors. I read this book to gain a better understanding of the war my dear friend and her family endured. Joe Sacco was there. He does a fantastic job in this graphic novel relating the harsh realities of war, the ugliness, the horror, the humor, and the humanity. If you have children, work with children, or simply have a heart for kids, sections of this book will be difficult to s ...more
Karyl
Safe Area Gorazde is probably the most powerful book I have read in a really long time. It's moving and horrifying, and the thought that all of this happened just twenty years ago is downright insane.

In the mid 1990s, I was a teen living in northern Virginia, worried mostly about my friends, my grades, getting into the right college. My father had always insisted that I watch the nightly news (with Peter Jennings, and I cried so much when he died a few years ago), so the events of the war in Bo
...more
Orion
A friend of mine loaned Safe Area Goražde to me. When I started reading it, I discovered that it has to do with the same region of Bosnia as Ivo Andric's Nobel Prize winning 1945 novel Bridge on the Drina. In fact, on page 110 of Safe Area Goražde, Sacco tells how on June 17, 1992 Serbian Chetniks killed 300 Bosnian Muslims on this bridge and threw the corpses into the Drina River. Andric used the historic Mehmed Paša Sokolović Bridge in Višegrad (the next town down the river from Goražde) as th ...more
Josh
Very rarely does a graphic novel move me to major emotion. But in this collection of Joe Sacco's writings and illustrations from Eastern Bosnia in the early 1990's, the accounts are so specifically direct, and illustrations are as moving as some of the best war photography from the past 150 years, any reader would be hard pressed to not feel some visceral emotion. The madness of the entire conflict along ethnic lines is clearly drawn, as neighbors and playmates are suddenly cast as enemies by fo ...more
Dimitri
perang di bekas negara Yugoslavia adalah perang terburuk dalam sejarah daratan Eropa setelah PD 2. kekejaman tanpa batas terjadi dimana-mana dan dunia diam membiarkan ini semua terjadi karena tidak ada kepentingan politik / SDA di area tersebut.

sebuah grafik novel yg sangat membantu melihat kondisi perang di sana pada waktu itu dan dampaknya pada masyarakat mereka. semoga buku2 Joe Sacco makin banyak yg dialihbahasakan.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Berlin, Vol. 1: City of Stones
  • The Photographer
  • Louis Riel
  • It Was the War of the Trenches
  • Chroniques de Jérusalem
  • Palomar: The Heartbreak Soup Stories
  • Barefoot Gen, Volume One: A Cartoon Story of Hiroshima
  • Hicksville
  • Fax from Sarajevo
  • I Killed Adolf Hitler
  • Quimby The Mouse
  • Stuck Rubber Baby
  • The Push Man and Other Stories
  • Paul Goes Fishing
  • Epileptic
  • Kafka
32468
Joe Sacco was born in Malta on October 2, 1960. At the age of one, he moved with his family to Australia, where he spent his childhood until 1972, when they moved to Los Angeles. He began his journalism career working on the Sunset High School newspaper in Beaverton, Oregon. While journalism was his primary focus, this was also the period of time in which he developed his penchant for humor and sa ...more
More about Joe Sacco...
Palestine Footnotes in Gaza The Fixer: A Story from Sarajevo Palestine, Vol. 1: A Nation Occupied Journalism

Share This Book