172nd out of 802 books
—
2,126 voters
The Truth-Teller's Tale (Safe-Keepers #2)
by
Sharon Shinn
Innkeeper's daughters Adele and Eleda are mirror twins - identical twins whose looks are reflections of each other's, and their special talents are like mirrors, too. Adele is a Safe-Keeper, entrusted with hearing and never revealing others' secrets; Eleda is a Truth-Teller, who cannot tell a lie when asked a direct question. The town of Merendon relies on the twins, no on...more
Paperback, 276 pages
Published
April 5th 2007
by Firebird
(first published January 28th 2005)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Sep 26, 2010
Mariel
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
liars and honest Abes
Recommended to Mariel by:
me doing the right thing by me
Talk is cheap. Especially when it comes to telling someone what is what. People lie. I've come to feel as I've gotten older that it's not good for all that much. Is it more important to be honest with everyone, or just honest with yourself (you'll learn more doing the latter)? I think honesty is overrated. There are too many layers, too many almosts to say for certain. The certainty is lying, to me. The intent behind the lie is what matters and the intent behind the truth, right? Because either...more
I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I couldn't believe I didn't see the ending coming, and yet I didn't! I think perhaps that's because the plot sort of creeps up on you, most of the book I kept asking myself, "What is this book even about?" because it seemed like nothing was happening, but then before you know it it's all exploding all over the place and there's crisis and drama and oh my! I did guess most of it before it happened, but only like a page or two prior, so that was fun. And ag...more
Adele is a secret-keeper, physiologically incapable of sharing a secret. Her twin sister Eleda is a Truth Teller, incapable of telling a lie. From the young age of 12, these sisters assume positions of responsibility in their town, but what happens when they get dragged into royal intrigue and the indiscretions of the most powerful family in town?
As an adult reader of a young adult novel, you always have to keep in mind that the intended audience is younger and assumed to be less sophisticated a...more
As an adult reader of a young adult novel, you always have to keep in mind that the intended audience is younger and assumed to be less sophisticated a...more
I'm going to give this book a solid B. The characters are reasonably likable. The premise is interesting: mirror twin girls, one destined to always tell the truth, the other destined to always keep secrets. And, the plot threads for the most part tie up neatly (if a tad predictably) at the end. However I say predictable for someone who knows fairytale and mystery formula very well...there's a bread
crumb trail of clues that I would call good writing. Keep in mind this is a YA book (and apparentl...more
crumb trail of clues that I would call good writing. Keep in mind this is a YA book (and apparentl...more
"The Truth-Teller's Tale" is a young adult or middle-grade fantasy novel which will appeal most to girls. It's the second novel in a series, but you don't need to read the first book to understand this one. This one may spoil events in the first novel, though.
It's a charming novel, though I found it predictable. But it probably won't be predictable to a middle-grader. I was expecting a more complex story based on the "a Safe-Keeper told a secret, a Truth-Teller told a lie" beginning promise, but...more
It's a charming novel, though I found it predictable. But it probably won't be predictable to a middle-grader. I was expecting a more complex story based on the "a Safe-Keeper told a secret, a Truth-Teller told a lie" beginning promise, but...more
I thought this started off a bit slowly, but by part two the action had kicked in and it kept going for the rest of the book. I could really relate to Eleda because I too find secrets infuriating and often wanted to smack Adele, even though I did understand why her role as a safe-keeper was important and why Eleda still loved her (she had her moments). Nothing in this book came as a surprise: I guessed that Adele had put the herbs in Eleda's food the minute she got sick, suspected Alexander and...more
Jul 24, 2011
Kiersten
added it
Very enjoyable. I have always wanted to write a story with a character who was physically unable to lie, but it wouldn't have occurred to me to write her a twin sister with exactly the opposite gift - to be unable to reveal a secret, no matter what she has to say to avoid it. I liked how the first half of the book was spent developing the world and the characters, before throwing the reader into the nonstop action: romance, mystery, and intrigue - of the second half. The characters were well-don...more
This is the second book in the Safe-Keepers series. I picked it up, since I wanted a book to read between some new books I was waiting to come out. I'm a Sharon Shinn fan. So, thought I'd give it a try. Glad I did.
It's about two twins that are complete opposites. Adele and Eleda have opposite names, wear their hair parted on opposite sides, and even write with opposite hands. They are also opposite in deeds, one keeps all secrets while the other has to always tell the truth. They're called Safe...more
It's about two twins that are complete opposites. Adele and Eleda have opposite names, wear their hair parted on opposite sides, and even write with opposite hands. They are also opposite in deeds, one keeps all secrets while the other has to always tell the truth. They're called Safe...more
I love Sharon Shinn, but I think she should stick to writing adult novels. This is a solid story, with amazing characters, and a great setting, but just like the first book in the series, The Safe-Keeper's Secret, the ending was incredibly predictable.
This book still gets a high rating, because despite the predictability, I did enjoy it very much. I like the world Shinn has created, with people being born with a gift that makes them tell the truth at all times or keep secrets. However, these uni...more
This book still gets a high rating, because despite the predictability, I did enjoy it very much. I like the world Shinn has created, with people being born with a gift that makes them tell the truth at all times or keep secrets. However, these uni...more
After Summers at Castle Auburn, I couldn’t wait long to track down another Shinn novel. This one, recommended by George (thanks, George), came with so many fascinating concepts that I was hooked from a glance at the back cover.
The fascinating concepts include the idea of mirror-twins, who reflect each other in perfect reverse—in this case, from the palindromic names, Adele and Eleda, on down. What each sees when she looks at the other is her own mirror image and the inverse of her magical gift....more
The fascinating concepts include the idea of mirror-twins, who reflect each other in perfect reverse—in this case, from the palindromic names, Adele and Eleda, on down. What each sees when she looks at the other is her own mirror image and the inverse of her magical gift....more
This is the second book in this series, but it can stand on its own. It is the tale of mirror twins who have opposite, innate, extraordinary abilities. One is a Truth-teller from whom people seek advice, because she must always tell the truth. The other is a Safe-keeper to whom people go to relieve themselves of the secrets that weigh on their souls, because she will never reveal them. The idea of the two roles is a fantasy characterization dream come true. What an idea for a book! Unfortunately...more
Eleda and Adele, mirror twins, are respectively a Truth-Teller and a Safe-Keeper. As such, they are summoned to the palace when a baby princess is born. Eleda predicts that the princess will be a docile child, not like her brother the prince. The sisters are daughters of an innkeeper and too poor for their friend Roelynn’s father to find them best suitable companions. And Roelynn is not happy with his plan to marry her to the prince. Very light but you can be sure that things will turn out happi...more
Sep 25, 2008
Erin
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
those who like quiet, thoughtful coming of age stories as well as fantasy
Recommended to Erin by:
Mom
So many of Sharon Shinn's books just make me feel warm inside.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The middle book of Shinn’s trilogy. The solution was kind of easy to spot, but I suppose that there are reasons for the main character not seeing it herself. By the way, all three of these books have gorgeous covers that are paintings. I’m rapidly growing to hate pretty much any and all photo covers–that’s a huge exaggeration, actually, but I’m so tired of models looking nothing like the characters, standing in a modern teenage posture. It’s especially awful with fantasy and historical books. [M...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I know some have been disappointed that the "twists" were fairly obvious. I, however, didn't feel this to be a story about twists, but rather one where the reader has all the pieces and gets to slowly, joyfully come together into a pretty pattern. We never needed to fear there wouldn't be happy endings - the question was how it would all come about.
As per usual, I love the worlds that Shinn creates. They're well thought out and interesting and, for this particular novel, I really loved the inter...more
As per usual, I love the worlds that Shinn creates. They're well thought out and interesting and, for this particular novel, I really loved the inter...more
Adele and Eleda are mirror image twins. When they look at each other it gives them the image of looking in a mirror. They part their hair on different sides, they both have one green and one blue eye, but it is the opposite for each. One is right handed and the other left. Their personalities are also opposite. One is a truth teller and the other is a safe keeper. They are two halves of a whole.
Eleda is the truth teller and this story is written from her viewpoint. She describes the life of bein...more
Eleda is the truth teller and this story is written from her viewpoint. She describes the life of bein...more
This is a worthy sequel to The Safe-Keeper's Secret. As in that book, the main characters are a safe-keeper, who can keep any confidence, and a truth-teller, who cannot tell a lie. The twist is that the two are mirror-image twins. The plot is interesting, if somewhat predictable (I had guessed the surprise ending 100 pages before the end).
However, I've rarely read a book that posed so many intriguing ethical questions. Potential group discussion questions! Are there people that you feel that you...more
However, I've rarely read a book that posed so many intriguing ethical questions. Potential group discussion questions! Are there people that you feel that you...more
I was a bit reluctant to start this, since I had loved The Safe-Keeper's Secret so much when I first read it that I just didn't believe there was really something that could follow that up in a satisfying way. While I didn't absolutely love this novel, it was a very enjoyable read and I had a lot of fun with the story and characters. The idea of two twins that are mirror opposites in appearance and personalities was interesting, and one thing I really enjoyed was how the longer I read the more I...more
I really enjoy Shinn's writing, but I didn't like this quite as much as the previous book in this series, "The Safe-Keeper's Secret."
It's a stand-alone story, although reading the first one first would help, a little bit, as far as understanding the premise behind this 'world.'
In this story, the romance is front and center, and the 'fantasy' aspects take a (very) background role. Adele and Eleda are 'mirror twins' - seeingly identical, but with very different personalities. One becomes a 'safe-k...more
It's a stand-alone story, although reading the first one first would help, a little bit, as far as understanding the premise behind this 'world.'
In this story, the romance is front and center, and the 'fantasy' aspects take a (very) background role. Adele and Eleda are 'mirror twins' - seeingly identical, but with very different personalities. One becomes a 'safe-k...more
I have several of these books waiting to be read, and I'm honestly not sorry that I do!
Sharon Shinn's writing is very readable and I've enjoyed everything written by her so far. This book is no exception. While it's not quite as good as her Twelve Houses series (which is written more for adults) this book carries definite appeal - I can see my 16 year old sister absolutely devouring it and the others similar to it.
Fun, light reads - a touch of fantasy, romance and a good story.
Sharon Shinn's writing is very readable and I've enjoyed everything written by her so far. This book is no exception. While it's not quite as good as her Twelve Houses series (which is written more for adults) this book carries definite appeal - I can see my 16 year old sister absolutely devouring it and the others similar to it.
Fun, light reads - a touch of fantasy, romance and a good story.
This was really a companion book, not a sequel, to "The Safe-Keeper's Secret" - only two of the characters from the first book were in this one, and they were extremely minor. It was really a standalone novel. This one had a little more mild "content" in it (not actual sex, but a few small allusions to it). It also had a lovely and satisfying romantic plot line - much more than the first - which I, of course, loved. On the whole, it was a nice, gentle, well-written summer read.
The Truth-Tellers Tale was about two mirror twins named Eleda and Adele. Adele is a safe-keeper and eleda is a Truth-teller. Their friend Rolynn always is crushing on a boy unworthy to her father.
Before Summermoon, the dance master Gregory comes along with his apprentice Alexander. Rolynn falls for Alexander who is a different person than she thinks he is.
It wasnt as good as Safe-keepers secret
I would recommend this book to anyone who likes very romantic fairytales (UGH!!)
Before Summermoon, the dance master Gregory comes along with his apprentice Alexander. Rolynn falls for Alexander who is a different person than she thinks he is.
It wasnt as good as Safe-keepers secret
I would recommend this book to anyone who likes very romantic fairytales (UGH!!)
Elada and Adele are twins and mirror images of each other in both personality and appearance. Elada is a truth-teller, unable to speak an untruth and compelled to always tell the truth. Adele, on the other hand, is a secret-keeper, as closed-lipped and good-naturedly duplicitous as her sister is outspoken. As the twins grow up and into their roles, their abilities help them provide the functions of confidant and advice-giver for the entire town. Occasionally the townsfolk mix up the twins, to so...more
Sharon Shinn is a new author (for me, anyway) I'm finding myself consistently going back to - I read three of her books in one weekend - two YA and one Adult and liked them all equally well - she's a rather nice mix of Robert Jordan (fantasy) and a less than sap-filled romance author that creates a romance that's even more romantic for it's lack of gushy wushy smexyness. You know - the everyday kind that we lowly realists exist for.
Happily surprised by this book. Loved the concept of the mirror twins and their special abililties. One sister unable to tell a lie and the other unable to share a secret. The story-line really pulled me in and kept me interested. I also liked that it was a clean book free of profanity. I didn't realize it was part of a series so I will have to go back and read the first and the next one as well. I really enjoyed this.
I totally love these books. The twins are fun, I like how Shinn can make a short book cover several years in order to bring you to a fully contextual climax (though based on the teaser on the flap the climax is more personal and less political/"important" than I felt led to believe), and I like the cast of supporting characters. Eleda is pretty stupid about her sister and Micah, though. On to The Dream-Maker's Magic!
So far, I’ve enjoyed all of Shinn’s novels, including The Truth-Teller’s Tale. She has a fairy tale-esque feel to her writing, complete with handsome strangers and happy endings. Somewhat predictable, but far from a generic fantasy read. She keeps the mood light, but still touches on some slightly grown-up themes, like sex and the nature of relationships, individual vs. societal expectations. A quick, enjoyable read.
I really just love the concept of the Truth Teller, it's so simple but has so many opportunities for awesome, I wish she would expand on it a little more. Awesome sibling relationship which gave this book bonus points, and a romance that was not filled with heart pounding staring at one another. You can see exactly where the plot is headed, but I didn't mind. It was just one of those nice little stories.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
I’ve been writing stories and poems since I was eight years old. My first poem was about Halloween: "What is tonight? What is tonight?/Try to guess and you’ll guess right." Perhaps this inauspicious beginning explains why it took me till I was in my thirties to sell a novel. It occurred to me early on that it might take some time and a lot of tries before I was able to publish any of my creative w...more
More about Sharon Shinn...
Share This Book
11 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...










view all 4 comments
















