32nd out of 127 books
—
33 voters
General Winston's Daughter
by
Sharon Shinn
When eighteen-year-old heiress Averie Winston travels to faraway Chiarrin, she looks forward to the reunion with her father and her handsome fiancé, Morgan. What she finds is entirely different from what she expected. She realizes that Morgan is not the man she thought he was; and she finds herself inexplicably drawn to another. Handsome Lieutenant Ket Du'kai is like no on...more
Hardcover, 342 pages
Published
October 18th 2007
by Viking Juvenile
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,563)
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Sharon Shinn amazes me. Her worldbuilding is always intriguing; her imagery and her plot hooks are often well-worn to the point of being a little hokey, but the things she does with them are just incredible. General Winston's Daughter really surprised me. All the way through, it feels like just another spunky-heroine-comes-of-age book -- the kind of book I really enjoy, but not a standout in that class -- and then, right near the end, the plot twists in a way that actually changed how I think ab...more
"General Winston's Daughter" is a young adult fantasy. It's a look at how imperialism affects the conquered with Averie being a member of a British-like society that has taken over several "more primitive" societies for economic gain. Averie has an increasingly sympathetic view of the conquered peoples.
I enjoyed the world-building as Averie learned about the new culture. I liked Averie even though she was head-strong because she tended to be willful about neutral or good things, like wanting to...more
I enjoyed the world-building as Averie learned about the new culture. I liked Averie even though she was head-strong because she tended to be willful about neutral or good things, like wanting to...more
I generally like Sharon Shinn books, but I can't recommend this one.
I found the central character, Averie, very annoying. Her adventures in the borderlands reminded me of the beginning of Robin McKinley's far superior, The Blue Sword. Averie comes to a colonial outpost to visit her father and her fiance. There are tensions between the newcomers and the native folk, whom she learns about in much the way a British colonial might learn about Indians a hundred years ago.
Her disenchantment with her...more
I found the central character, Averie, very annoying. Her adventures in the borderlands reminded me of the beginning of Robin McKinley's far superior, The Blue Sword. Averie comes to a colonial outpost to visit her father and her fiance. There are tensions between the newcomers and the native folk, whom she learns about in much the way a British colonial might learn about Indians a hundred years ago.
Her disenchantment with her...more
(3.5) This was pretty good. It's a little younger than I expected, but Averie's voice is fairly strong and her story (and the stories of those around her) compelling.
I mean, it's a pretty thinly disguised treatise on imperialism - but then, I'm anti-imperialist, so I buy it. Averie's home country is essentially Great Britain expanding its empire, Weskolia is France, and the countries they're mentioned as colonizing are African and Asian. It's not subtle.
But it's also not as simple (and potential...more
I mean, it's a pretty thinly disguised treatise on imperialism - but then, I'm anti-imperialist, so I buy it. Averie's home country is essentially Great Britain expanding its empire, Weskolia is France, and the countries they're mentioned as colonizing are African and Asian. It's not subtle.
But it's also not as simple (and potential...more
This book was written a few years after The Dream-Maker's magic, and it felt like Shinn had had a chance to refine her writing a little. The story was pretty complex and interesting, although the end broke my heart and I don't know if I'll get over it.
I really like the worlds Shinn creates. They are fictional, of course, but in this book it didn't seem like the countries were very thinly-veiled versions of real countries, like in some books I've read (*cough* Princess of the Midnight Ball *cough...more
I really like the worlds Shinn creates. They are fictional, of course, but in this book it didn't seem like the countries were very thinly-veiled versions of real countries, like in some books I've read (*cough* Princess of the Midnight Ball *cough...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I want to give it 3.5 stars :)
When we meet Averie, she's on a voyage to a new land, where her father and fiance are currently stationed in the military and where they are in the process of trying to occupy said country. As the daughter of a general, Averie has always had assumptions about the purpose and consequences of her father's work, but finding herself among a people in the process of being conquered has made her begin to question what it means to become a colony.
As she becomes familiar wi...more
When we meet Averie, she's on a voyage to a new land, where her father and fiance are currently stationed in the military and where they are in the process of trying to occupy said country. As the daughter of a general, Averie has always had assumptions about the purpose and consequences of her father's work, but finding herself among a people in the process of being conquered has made her begin to question what it means to become a colony.
As she becomes familiar wi...more
I'm definitely a fan of Sharon Shinn, but for some reason it's taken me forever to get around to this book. Well...actually if I'm honest I have to admit had a terrible case of cover snob with this book (Angie has a great discussion about this phenomena in this post at her blog, Angieville).
I really didn't understand the cover, especially with a title like General Winston's Daugher, I thought it was about the Civil War (forget actually reading the synopsis, pshaw! ;-P). Once again I can kick mys...more
I really didn't understand the cover, especially with a title like General Winston's Daugher, I thought it was about the Civil War (forget actually reading the synopsis, pshaw! ;-P). Once again I can kick mys...more
Seventeen year old Averie Winston is the daughter and heiress of General Winston of the Aeberelle army. She embarks on a journey to the far off, exotic land of Chiarrin to join her fiancé and her father who are currently involved in a campaign to take over the country. Averie finds herself completely taken in by the culture and customs of Chiarrin, eagerly embracing them. Although the country of Chiarrin appears to have accepted the presence of the Aeberelle army, rebels have begun to launch sma...more
This is fantasy that is almost historical fiction. No magic to speak of, but it's not our own world - rather, a very Earth-like place with different countries and cultures. There are strong parallels to England's invasion and colonization of so-called "primitive" countries, with events that may even remind young readers more of the U.S.'s invasion of Iraq than England's conquering of India and other countries. The main focus is a young woman, engaged to be married, whose irrepresible energy, joy...more
This book is something that I wish I had left on the shelf. Allured by the cover and the author I picked this book up. I soon found it to be annoying, tedious, and unorigional.
This is the story of Averie Winston, the brash and undistructible daughter of General Winston. When she goes to visit her father, in the foreign land of Chiarrin were her father and her her fiance are stationed to help "protect" Chairrin locals from they're own rebels. As Averie flirts, goofs around, and becomes iindiffere...more
This is the story of Averie Winston, the brash and undistructible daughter of General Winston. When she goes to visit her father, in the foreign land of Chiarrin were her father and her her fiance are stationed to help "protect" Chairrin locals from they're own rebels. As Averie flirts, goofs around, and becomes iindiffere...more
Eighteen year old Averie is a very lovable heroine, rebellious and charming, who is traveling with her father and fiancee's army to a colony they are attempting to conquer. The adventurous heiress is quickly charmed by the foreign country but is naively surprised to find out the imperial army is not exactly welcomed by the local inhabitants. As Averie discovers the intricate cruelties of imperialism and tries to decide how she stands the world changes around her in this coming of age novel. I re...more
Averie, daughter of Aeberelle's military leader, goes by ship with her chaperone, Lady Selkirk, to dry, dusty Chiarrin, the latest conquest of Aeberelle's empire, to be with her father and her fiancé, Colonel Morgan Stode. She's a happy, enthusiastic, curious eighteen-year-old, and her travelling companion, the Xantish lieutenant Ket Du'kai, intrigues her with his stories of his homeland, Xan'tai, long since invaded by Aeberelle and absorbed into its empire. At the same time, he unsettles her by...more
I didn't enjoy this book as much as I thought I would.
The world that the author had created was strange. The names of things were hard to read/pronounce thus, interuppted the flow of reading.
The story seemed to drag on for me. I wanted more interaction with Lieutenant Du'kai, but came up lacking.
The main character, Averie, didn't evolve or progress evenly. Her character would progress some then regress.
The ending was disapointing, becuase not many scenes happened between Averie and Ket Du'kai. T...more
The world that the author had created was strange. The names of things were hard to read/pronounce thus, interuppted the flow of reading.
The story seemed to drag on for me. I wanted more interaction with Lieutenant Du'kai, but came up lacking.
The main character, Averie, didn't evolve or progress evenly. Her character would progress some then regress.
The ending was disapointing, becuase not many scenes happened between Averie and Ket Du'kai. T...more
This is not my favourite Sharon Shinn book, but it's a great read for teen girls looking for depth to a story with a little bit of romance. I appreciate that the main character's opinions and attitudes towards other cultures are transformed throughout the novel. I think it's a very interesting depiction of war based on cultural differences, colonialism, etc., but the story is not set in our own time and place. The descriptions of the people are far enough removed that the reader won't feel like...more
What threw me about General Winston’s Daughter was that I had no idea it was a young adult until after I picked it up. That might sound unusual, but when I need a new book to read, and have no certain book in mind, I’ll simply look for an author I like and pick up whichever book of theirs I haven’t read yet. As this wasn’t shelved in the YA section I figured it was of a similar vein as her Twelve Houses series. In that respect, at least, I wasn’t disappointed. Much like her Twelve Houses books,...more
Oct 12, 2012
Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Snail in Danger (Sid) by:
http://www.tor.com/blogs/2009/01/colonial-fantasy-robin-mckinleys-the-blue-sword comment thread
Shelves:
children-ya,
cover-pretty-white-girl
For the first, oh, 3/4 of this book I was enjoying this book and tearing through it, and being a little sad when I had to put it down to go to dinner. Then ... I'm not quite sure what happened. I mean, what happened is great for the country that got invaded. But as a critique of colonialism and imperialism (the clear authorial intent) it kind of failed. Probably because, at the end, the plan of the young white heiress is to (view spoiler)...more
As usually, Shinn did not disappoint. This fantasy novel follows the story of Averie as she travels to another country that her government invaded and now occupies. She is curious and open about her new home, eager to learn about a new culture and traditions. She also finds herself torn between her fiance and another intriguing young man, who is of a different race and culture, yet she finds true understanding with.
The story reminds me of tales I read of the English occupation of India and other...more
The story reminds me of tales I read of the English occupation of India and other...more
I think this book was interesting- a girl in a different country and learning different customs. A girl with a lively personality, someone who does what she wants and believes. She sees a different perspective, living in another country and has great empathy for the native people. I think I related to Averie slightly, in that when I went to another country, I was able to meet many natives and understand and learn their culture and I loved it, just like Averie loved the Chiarrin people. Fortunate...more
I actually really liked this one - there was a lot of politics but in an unheard of step for me I actually *didn't find them heinously boring* and in fact thought the Chiarrin culture in general was really quite interesting. Averie was a little too naive and frivolous for an 18 year old but I found her enthusiasm rather endearing, and Jalessa's betrayal at the end came as a total shock, which was nice for a change - I like being surprised by plot twists instead of seeing them coming a mile off....more
If this hadn't been by Sharon Shinn, I don't think I would have been as disappointed as I was. I expect better from her, not preachy, shallow, silly, easily manipulated characters who learn almost nothing over the course of the book.
I need to go re-read Archangel or Summers at Castle Auburn to recall the beautiful stories that she's capable of writing...
I need to go re-read Archangel or Summers at Castle Auburn to recall the beautiful stories that she's capable of writing...
EXCELLENT book! I greatly enjoyed it. (Though I could see the end coming before being halfway through the book.)
General Winston's Daughter is charming, enigmatic, confused, quick-witted, big-hearted, and sometimes a little dense, but that makes her a character easy to relate to and enjoy. Her name is Averie and she's bound and determined to enjoy herself even if she is in the middle of a war - her people trying to colonize a people who do not want to be colonized.
LOVED it. Would recommend for Y...more
General Winston's Daughter is charming, enigmatic, confused, quick-witted, big-hearted, and sometimes a little dense, but that makes her a character easy to relate to and enjoy. Her name is Averie and she's bound and determined to enjoy herself even if she is in the middle of a war - her people trying to colonize a people who do not want to be colonized.
LOVED it. Would recommend for Y...more
This was a pretty decent read. It is basically a British colonial story but with all the places and cultures changed so that the author didn't have to be historically or culturally accurate. It is a young adult book, but I thought that the writing (in terms of word choice, etc.) was still a bit juvenile for the actual story.
*slight spolier*
The protagonist would have to be the heiress of a not-so-small country to actually be successful in her financial venture at the end of the book. That was th...more
*slight spolier*
The protagonist would have to be the heiress of a not-so-small country to actually be successful in her financial venture at the end of the book. That was th...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
It's been a long time since I've done a simple pros and cons list. Think I'll do that here.
But some important things to mention beforehand- this is a third person-perspective book. YA with a pinch of romance. If you go into it wanting a sprawling romance you'll be disappointed. This book was poorly marketed and its biggest qualities are not well-clarified in the blurbs and promotion.
I enjoyed this book a lot but there is more that could have been. The ending however impressed me enough that I a...more
But some important things to mention beforehand- this is a third person-perspective book. YA with a pinch of romance. If you go into it wanting a sprawling romance you'll be disappointed. This book was poorly marketed and its biggest qualities are not well-clarified in the blurbs and promotion.
I enjoyed this book a lot but there is more that could have been. The ending however impressed me enough that I a...more
Swoon is a dark and twisted tale about a girl with powers that she can’t quite control. These powers get her, and the rest of the town, into quite a bit of trouble when she gives life to a ghost who was determined to get revenge on those who wronged him centuries ago. In the chaos and insanity that ensues, Dice finds herself dangerously drawn to her all-too handsome accidental creation.
This was one of those books that will only have two extremes of reactions: total love, or utter hate. With a bo...more
This was one of those books that will only have two extremes of reactions: total love, or utter hate. With a bo...more
Randomly picked this up at the library because the cover was cute and it sounded halfway decent - a girl travels to a faraway (fictional) territory, newly under her empire's control, to be with her father and her fiance, then falls in love with someone else and starts thinking about life in general as well.
When I opened the book, I was amazed by the long list of books the author has penned. Then I started reading and discovered how she'd found enough time to do so - there wasn't much to the boo...more
When I opened the book, I was amazed by the long list of books the author has penned. Then I started reading and discovered how she'd found enough time to do so - there wasn't much to the boo...more
Eighteen-year-old Averie Winston travels to Chiarrian (a distant country) to visit her father, who is a commanding General, and her fiancée Morgan. Her father has invaded the country and is working to overthrow local government and rebel forces. As she learns more about the situation and herself she realizes that Morgan is not the man that she thought he was; and slowly falls in love with Lt. Ket Du’Kai, who himself comes from a conquered society. Averie delves into the culture, wanting to learn...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
I’ve been writing stories and poems since I was eight years old. My first poem was about Halloween: "What is tonight? What is tonight?/Try to guess and you’ll guess right." Perhaps this inauspicious beginning explains why it took me till I was in my thirties to sell a novel. It occurred to me early on that it might take some time and a lot of tries before I was able to publish any of my creative w...more
More about Sharon Shinn...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...
































Aug 05, 2009 08:28pm