Out of the Vinyl Deeps: Ellen Willis on Rock Music
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Out of the Vinyl Deeps: Ellen Willis on Rock Music

3.96 of 5 stars 3.96  ·  rating details  ·  340 ratings  ·  59 reviews
In 1968, the New Yorker hired Ellen Willis as its first popular music critic. Her column, Rock, Etc., ran for seven years and established Willis as a leader in cultural commentary and a pioneer in the nascent and otherwise male-dominated field of rock criticism. As a writer for a magazine with a circulation of nearly half a million, Willis was also the country’s most widel...more
Paperback, 234 pages
Published May 1st 2011 by Univ Of Minnesota Press (first published April 6th 2011)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,529)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Distress Strauss
Before reading this book, I was fairly certain Ellen Willis was my favorite music critic, and now, having experienced her work in the genre in concentrated form, I'm can say that, groundbreaking as it may be, she isn't. For one thing, she isn't a music critic at all -- she's a rock critic (which she would surely cop to). Her tastes, filtered through the folk precociousness of her adolescence, with its emphasis on MEANING, is as status quo as her politics were radical -- her Bible is Stones, Dyla...more
Jan 16, 2012 Bruce rated it 3 of 5 stars Recommends it for: WC magazine readers
Recommended to Bruce by: NPR Music (and shame on them)
I have strong ambivalence about this book... attract/repel, really. Attract, because most of these collected essays are so short (about 2-3 pages on average) that the book was easy enough to grab whenever I had a few minutes to kill. Repel, because so many of the essays sounded full of, in Willis’ words, “the worst kind of pretentious nonsense,” a baleful reminder of my own bloviating tendencies.

Vinyl Deeps largely consists of Willis’ New Yorker articles on rock from the late ‘60s to mid-’70s. A...more
blue-collar mind
Having been conversely born too late and too early (1964), I sometimes seek out music or literary criticism of earlier ages to learn about unheralded artists that I missed, or to view from afar some seminal moment in the culture that has passed into legend and therefore is not reported truthfully any longer. I have been reading 1970s criticism and essays and learning a great deal, just as I did when I delved deeply into the Algonquin Circle as a teenager and learned about writers and events not...more
Leah W
This book took a little while to hook me, but once I got into it, it was SO GOOD. LET ME SAY "SO GOOD" IN CAPS ONCE MORE FOR EMPHASIS.

This is a collection of Ellen Willis's essays about rock & pop music, mostly from the New Yorker (where she was the first Rock & Pop columnist). Later in her career, she wrote less about music and more about gender studies, freedom, and radical leftist topics, but there was a nice dose of this in a lot of her music writing, as well (for example, her dissec...more
the review was first published in maximum rock-n-roll may 2012

Ellen Willis was a feminist and a rock critic back when rock-n-roll and feminism were generally thought to be opposed to one another. Growing up in the 70's and 80's, I remember this dichotomy well. As a teenage punk rocker I went through a heavy rock-n-roll stage in the mid-80's -- Black Flag had long hair, Red Kross and The Melvins covered Kiss, Saint Vitus were ripping off Black Sabbath and I was learning to play drums -- pretty so...more

Bob Dylan "went electric" in July of 1965. Now, I had once heard that Dylan went electric, I'd heard neighbors and family mention this fact off-hand once or twice in my youth, and, frankly, I probably also heard it on a Behind the Music. I didn't care that Dylan went electric. Why would anyone?

Ellen Willis set me straight on the subject of Dylan's electrification, as she set me straight on several other subjects. I now care, and have an opinion. Willis, the afterword notes, had an interest in...more
Tim Niland
The career of Ellen Willis as a rock music critic was comparatively brief, spanning the late 1960’s to the early 1970’s, but during that time she wrote some of the most insightful and thought provoking essays on rock and roll to date. As a radical feminist writing about a male dominated music for male dominated media, it took strong will and opinions to get her ideas out there, and she never wavered in her convictions. Beginning with the essay about Bob Dylan which brought her to the attention o...more
Collection of brilliant essays from Willis's tenure as a rock music critic through an important era of American & British popular music -- the late 60s through the early 80s, with a lot of 70s in the middle. Notable not just because Willis's prose is so very quotable, or because she writes about the not-always-comfortable intersection between culture and ideology as anyone I've ever read -- but also because she works so much of the personal experience of concert-going & record-listening...more
Ellen Willis's writing is the perfect time machine antidote for our skewed and over-saturated impression of the sixties and seventies. Her honest analysis of records and artists and live shows and "The Time" made me understand that decade in a way I never had before. Her review of the Beatles' White Album had me seeing the world of rock and roll in a whole new light, pre-reverence and commercialization, as did her take on live Lou Reed/New York Dolls/Grand Funk and Woodstock, an honest fan's rea...more
Why have I not heard of Ellen Willis before? Her lengthy essay on Bob Dylan is outstanding; it anticipates the film I'm Not There with her understanding of how Dylan used fame and publicity to cultivate mystique and to create privacy out of multiple personas. It's all the more extraordinary for her clear-sightedness without the benefit hindsight.

Most of her judgments have stood the test of time though the kind of music journalism Willis writes is out of fashion today. Her reviews are full of del...more
Bob Mcconnaughey
A musical flashback to reviews i read decades ago in my parents' New Yorkers. And still some of the most thoughtful set of reviews on a decade (more or less)..68-78..of pop music. Miscellaneous point...Under my Thumb by the Stones is far less sexist that Cat Stevens execrable "Wild World."
Aug 20, 2011 Annie rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2011
I like music, all kinds of music, but it's more in the vein of saying, "Oh, I really like this song," when it comes on the radio, but then five minutes later I can't remember what the song is called or who sung it. I only remember what it was I liked about the song.

So, I don't read a lot about music, a topic that produces endless amounts of material for the fanatics. Willis was obviously one of those fanatics, but I think what she was more interested in were the parts of music that stick with us...more
Jun 03, 2011 Jonathan marked it as to-read

Ellen Willis was one of the first rock critics — at a time starting in the late 1960s — when serious writing about rock, pop and R&B was rare. She was the first pop-music critic for The New Yorker, starting in 1968. She combined a love of pop culture and an active engagement with feminist theory to create a unique body of writing, which finally gets a proper showcase in a new anthology titled Out of the Vinyl Deeps: Ellen Willis on Rock Music, edited b...more
Ettore Pasquini
It was cool to read historic reviews of records of the 60s, 70s, and a little of 80s and hear what people thought of those records when they came out. Willis talks a lot about Dylan, Janis Joplin, and Creedence. Other artists discussed here include the New York Dolls, Beatles, Bowie, who all get a generous treatment, and then Clapton, the Who, the Doors (just 1 essay I think), Black Sabbath (1 article, at least it's about Vol 4), Patti Smith, Elvis and a few others. My favorite chapters were by...more
Willis is a sharp writer and this book is a lot of fun. And it's not just rock criticism as we today understand it; since this is the 60's, that magical time when music, art, drugs, culture and politics were all swirled together into one confusing, thrilling, heady mix, it's more like a devastatingly lucid, moment by moment, on-the-scene chronicle of the times. I particularly like the Bob Dylan piece that kicks things off, and it's hard to find any rock criticism better than her tough minded tak...more
I read a few glowing reviews about this book so I decided to give it a go. I don't read a lot of music criticism so I was curious about the first female rock critic and I was curious about rock writing in general. It wasn't a badly written book, it just didn't interest me as much as I thought it would.

The essays are from the 1970's so they focus on 70's rock bands - Bob Dyaln, Velvet Underground, Mot the Hoople, etc. Well, I was born in the late 70's but grew up in the 80's and 90's. Willis was...more
This book shouldn't have taken me almost a month to read, but I've been a little busy. And maybe if I'd read it more purposefully I would've loved it. Who knows? I'll surely read it again, since it's clearly of historical import and it's definitely very good from beginning to end, but I wasn't nearly as wowed by it as I expected to be.

I think the aspect of Willis' writing that most disappointed me was her style. She was brilliant and thoughtful, and almost always very clear and readable, but the...more
This is a collection of Ms. Willis’s articles she wrote for The New Yorker in the late ’60s and ’70s while she was the pop music critic. The articles are some of the best writing I’ve come across. Every idea, comparison, and critique is so well-crafted, so thought out that her intent, meaning, whatever, is crystal clear. There is not a single bloated paragraph. What’s great is she’s a fan of the music, so there’s no condescension, none of that “these kids today and their music.” kind of thing. B...more
I liked this so much that it just reminded me how much I usually hate reading music criticism.

From the intro: "Ellen would surely agree that we won't see a revival of revolutionary sentiment until we learn to make it fun. In that respect, Ellen, Emma Goldman, and Abbie Hoffman are part of a lost tradition - radicals of desire."

One great sentence: "Using other people's and other eras' forms, making sure we heard the innocence or the silliness or the melodrama, Midler communicated her need to love...more
Terry Heller
Ellen Willis was The New Yorker's first rock music critic. Along with her contemporaries Lester Bangs, Robert Christgau, and Griel Marcus, Willis showed the intelligensia that rock music was worthy of the same sophisticated criticism and analysis as art and literature. After the mid-70's, Willis' writing focused more on feminism and politics, so she never became the rock writer emeritus like Marcus or Christgau, but her early columns for the New Yorker forever shaped our understanding of Bob Dyl...more
Graham Kearney
Ellen has written an amazing book.Her feminist & sociological perspective on such artists as Bob Dylan,Lou Reed & Velvet Underground & Elvis is insightful.As a fan of that era of music & particularly Bob Dylans music it gave me new insights into their music.Ellen no doubt is much missed from the writing & music scene.She told it as it was & I recommend this book for music fans of that inspiring time in music.
collection of willis' articles (mainly from "the new yorker" 1968-1975) but also some from that same time zone in "village voice", "cheetah", and some rolling stone writing, and some album notes. then from later in salon.com and her book "beginning the see the light: sex, hope, and rock n roll". it's safe to say all are in earnest, most are open minded, some are significant cultural analysis, and a few a just brilliant and could have been written in 2012 instead of 1969 ("don;t turn your back on...more
Jeff Golick
An extremely fine and overdue collection of Willis' music writing. She comes across as an incredibly smart critic and commenter, reviewing both the music itself (and often how it affects her, mind and body), and the social context in which it appeared (mind, and cultural superego, I suppose). If a very few mentions are a tad dated (which is to be expected), she had the good sense and intelligence to go deep on artists who deserved such treatment: Willis is especially good on Dylan (as good as an...more
I'm surprised that Ellen Willis could get her head out of her ass long enough to write these essays.

Actually she's not all bad; she's a fan of some of the same music I love, but her need to pretentiously wring meanings and reverberations out of everything vinyl misses the whole fun part of music. Also a lot of the content seems to be more about Ellen Willis' head than the putative subject. Also she disrespects Bob Dylan, overly respects Mick Jagger, and is unaware of Keith Richards. She does ge...more
Essential reading for fans of '60s-'70s music and music criticism in general. Contains THE definitive essay on early Dylan, plus deeply insightful takes on Bowie, the Stones, the White Album, the Velvets, Creedence, etc. -- and not all of them positive: Because her writing was contemporaneous with the music she covered, it's gladly free of the mythology that has built up around her subjects over time.

Unlike Bangs or Christgau, there's no obvious "style" to her writing. Her style is her substanc...more
I have much ambivalence about this book. I enjoyed the second half more than the first excepting the wonderful Dylan piece that opens the book. I particularly enjoyed the author's pieces on Dylan, the Woodstock festival and two Elvis concert reviews. I would love to see more of her writing on The Stones and Grateful Dead, two acts she had clear affinities for. Sorry to be crass, but probably a great bathroom read given the length of the pieces. I read straight through and found it a slog at time...more
Anthology of reviews written by Ellen Willis, the music critic at The New Yorker from the late 1960s to mid 1970s. The reviews are organized into sections with titles assigned by the editor, Willis’s daughter (examples, “The Adoring Fan,” “The Navigator”). The section called “The Feminist” was reasonably cohesive. In most cases the reviews didn’t clearly fit the section name, which made it hard to overlook introductions of “new” bands that had been covered in depth 50 pages earlier. Janis Joplin...more
If you care at all about Rock & Roll or Pop music you should read Out of the Vinyl Deeps: Ellen Willis on Rock Music. If you ever subscribed to Spin or Rolling Stone you should read Out of the Vinyl Deeps. If you ever searched for most of your adult-life for a smart, female perspective on being a Rock & Roll fan and all but gave up on it, you should read this book.

To say Out of the Vinyl Deeps changed my life sounds like hyperbole, but it’s not. I don’t listen to music the same way after...more
This collection of Ellen Willis columns was something I wanted to check out because I love rock, I've been reading music journalism since junior high, and I'd never heard of her until very recently, even though her first piece was published in 1968. The book was compiled after Willis passed away, not too long ago. She was writing about Who concerts and albums by the Rolling Stones when those artists were still brand-spanking new-- so exciting!! Her writing style doesn't grab me but her documenti...more
I was really interested in this collection of rock criticism columns from Ellen Willis, who was the New Yorker's first rock critic from 1968-1975. Her column, "Rock, etc." is especially interesting, because it offers a look at rock criticism of some of the most important musicians of the time (Dylan, the Velvet Underground, Bruce, The Stones, etc.) and their historic albums and concerts, not with an eye toward their historical significance, but rather with opinions from the time when they were j...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 50 51 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • How the Beatles Destroyed Rock 'n' Roll: An Alternative History of American Popular Music
  • Country: The Twisted Roots Of Rock 'n' Roll
  • Love Goes to Buildings on Fire: Five Years in New York That Changed Music Forever
  • Our Noise: The Story of Merge Records, the Indie Label That Got Big and Stayed Small
  • Perfecting Sound Forever: An Aural History of Recorded Music
  • Sweet Soul Music: Rhythm and Blues and the Southern Dream of Freedom
  • Mystery Train: Images of America in Rock 'n' Roll
  • How to Wreck a Nice Beach: The Vocoder from World War II to Hip-Hop, The Machine Speaks
  • Cinderella's Big Score: Women of the Punk and Indie Underground
  • Girls to the Front: The True Story of the Riot Grrrl Revolution
  • Ripped: How the Wired Generation Revolutionized Music
  • Violence Girl: East L.A. Rage to Hollywood Stage, a Chicana Punk Story
  • The Chitlin' Circuit: And the Road to Rock 'n' Roll
  • White Bicycles: Making Music in the 1960s
  • A Change Is Gonna Come: Music, Race & the Soul of America
  • Hip: The History
  • Retromania: Pop Culture's Addiction to Its Own Past
  • Let's Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste
Ellen Jane Willis was an American left-wing political essayist, journalist, and pop music critic.
More about Ellen Willis...
No More Nice Girls: Countercultural Essays Beginning to See the Light: Pieces of a decade Don't Think, Smile!: Notes on a Decade of Denial The Essential Ellen Willis Beginning to See the Light: Sex, Hope, and Rock-And-Roll

Share This Book