Dreams of Significant Girls
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Dreams of Significant Girls

3.15 of 5 stars 3.15  ·  rating details  ·  323 ratings  ·  80 reviews

Shirin is an Iranian princess; Ingrid, a German-Canadian eccentric; and Vivien, a Cuban-Jewish New Yorker culinary phenom. The three are roommates at a Swiss boarding school, where they spend their summers learning more than French and European culture. As the girls’ paths cross and merge—summers together, school years separate—they navigate social and cultural differences

...more
Hardcover, 238 pages
Published July 12th 2011 by Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Wither by Lauren DeStefanoWhere She Went by Gayle FormanLegend by Marie LuThe Future of Us by Jay AsherThe Name of the Star by Maureen Johnson
2012 YALSA Nominees - List 1
39th out of 100 books — 48 voters
Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay AsherThe Hunger Games by Suzanne CollinsThe Fault in Our Stars by John GreenMockingjay by Suzanne CollinsCatching Fire by Suzanne Collins
Teen Girl Book Club
121st out of 127 books — 76 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,662)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Aleeeeeza
The first thing I’m going to say about this book on my review is: What is up with the title?! Because honestly, when I first saw it on Galley Grab, I sort of assumed it was a story about lesbian lovers and decided to skip it, since I wasn’t in the mood for that kind of book. And then I stumbled upon a Goodreads review of it by this fantastic blogger, and I went, “Hey, this sounds really good!”

It turned out the book was NOT about lesbian lovers, no, but actually three girls and three summers they...more
Morgan F
This book failed. It was about three privileged girls from different backgrounds around the world building a friendship over the course of three summers at a posh summer camp (which was really just a boarding school). Oh yeah, and it took place in the 70's. I don't know why it took place in the 70's, but WWII did play a small (and hilarious) part in the novel.

Well, I can tell what this book wanted to be. It wanted to be this beautiful, stunning story of how three girls from such different backg...more
Linds
This is not a book. Dreams of Significant Girls is a finely crafted vessel, and the story beautifully braids together three different narratives into a single, strong anchor. I didn't want to put it down.

As the synopsis says, the three girls are sent by their families to a premier Swiss boarding school for a summer session. Each girl is sent for a different reason, and each has her own goals and gripes associated with the trip. The three are placed in the same dorm room together, and each fills...more
Cass -  Words on Paper
2.5/5

DREAMS OF SIGNIFICANT GIRLS reads like The Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants, aimed at a substantially higher age group. Set in the 1970s, Garcia's strengths lie in honestly exploring mature awakenings in young teenagers with an air of both sensitivity and brashness, but also the friendships that the girls develop. The three girls who we follow in this book, Shirin, Vivien and Ingrid, change so much during and inbetween the three summers at PierPont Boarding School for Girls, that it makes...more
Julie
A beautiful narrative, rendered so faithfully I can't believe I wasn't reading about real people.
Grace
3.5 stars

I don't even know why I picked up this book in the first place. The title was really unappealing, and the synopsis portrayed the characters as complete snobs. Yet I still grabbed this book off that library shelf, and now I do not regret doing so.

This story revolves around three girls, and three summers. Vivien comes from a loud and boisterous family, but still struggles to find her true self; Shirin is the baby of the family, the Iranian princess that has it all; and Ingrid is a feisty...more
Kelly
I loved the writing, as it was really literary, and the food descriptions could almost be tasted. This book reminded me a lot of Nina de Gramont's GOSSIP OF THE STARLINGS, right down to the boarding school, the drug and sexual content and brutality therein, the acts of defiance on the parts of the characters, and the writing style.

However, I found it hard to understand the motivations of the characters. They acted on impulse, all three of them, but I never quite got the whys of it. It made it d...more
kristin (paper reader)
This book was almost like stepping into a painting: bright, vivid, and realistic.

Lasting.
--
This was less like a book and more of a glimpse into a looking glass showing us a reflection of the story of three completely different girls. Through varying situations in their lives they ended up at a posh Swiss boarding school, each wondering just what they could possibly get out of the situation. But more than getting something out of it, their experience changes their worldview and themselves.

To be h...more
Jordyn
May 11, 2012 Jordyn marked it as abandoned  ·  review of another edition
DID NOT FINISH.

I feel like I'm getting (even) more selective with the books I read. This was one I was really looking forward to, also. A combination of Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants with a Swiss boarding school/summer camp element (which OF COURSE reminds me of Bloomability) meant this book had a lot to live up to. And it never really captured me, sadly. Though the writing has a very pretty quality to it, the characters themselves were difficult to like. Both Ingrid and Shirin seemed extrem...more
Barbara
I think I loved the title of the book a whole lot more than I ended up loving the book. While it held promise in tackling several issues, on the whole it didn't deliver. The premise is not particularly new: Three very different girls bond over the course of three summers at a Swiss boarding school. The story is told, by turns, by the three girls--Shirin from Iran, Ingrid from Canada, and Vivien from New York City. Although Vivien's ancestry is Cuban-Jewish, she seems more preoccupied by her pare...more
Becky
Dreams of Significant Girls manages to touch on all the "issues" of issue books - depression, divorce, sexual assault, slut-shaming, statutory rape, absent parents, suicide, abortion, homosexuality, revolution, war, genocide, you name it! - without actually saying much about any of those experiences. To do this, Garcia uses three rich girls, one American (of Cuban and Jewish descent), one Canadian (of German descent) and one Iranian Princess. Vivien, Ingrid, and Shirin are thrown together as roo...more
Salma Phaosoung
If you are going to read this book, you have to be a girl, into boy drama, and used to listening to others perspective. This book also has curse words and it talks about relationship pro's and con's.
Stories & Sweeties {Becky}
While I didn't absolutely love this one, Dreams of Significant Girls had a strange way of keeping me captive for the few days it took to read it. Watching these three girls from completely different walks of life interact with each other was somehow completely fascinating. The story went along at a bit of a steady, quiet pace. This had a lot to do with the way it was told---alternating perspectives of the three girls and with a journal entry-style tense. Much like you would if you were reading s...more
Hannah
Dreams of Significant Girls just has too much going on. The book's 250 pages just aren't enough to explore the stories of three narrators over the course of three years. There were a lot of interesting storylines, but nothing gets explored in enough depth, making Dreams of Significant Girls a very underwhelming read for me.

I liked the idea of these characters, but the characterization leaves much to be desired. Ingrid seemed like an intriguing character, but she turned out to be nothing more tha...more
Ms. Library
A lot of people have made the comparison to Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. I definitely think its an apt one, because this book also focuses on teenage girls being friends, and how that affects their lives. It takes place during three summers in the seventies at a Swiss boarding school camp, and it focuses on three different girls: Shirin-the the Iranian princess, Vivien, a Cuban-Jewish New Yorker, and Ingrid-the German-Canadian. These girls past informs their present, and I think Garcia doe...more
Books and Literature for Teens
Advertised as being similar to Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, Dreams of Significant Girls was not at all what I expected it to be. First of all it takes places in the 1970s at a boarding school for wealthy girls. Not only do these girls attend the summer camp to get away from their parents, but to mingle with boys, take drugs, and drink. Perhaps not all of the three girls had these intentions but one girl in particular–Ingrid–was up to no good throughout most of the book. I dislike the atmos...more
Cheryl A
Jun 06, 2013 Cheryl A rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: ya
Other than novels written in the 1970's, this is a decade mostly forgotten, especially in the young adult area. Although there were no iconic events as in earlier decades (WWII, Cold War, Vietnam), the 1970's were a time of great upheaval and change - dealing with the past and moving into the future.

This is the theme for this thoughtful novel. Ingrid is a rebellious Canadian-German whose father is haunted by his Nazi past. Vivien is a Jewish Cuban whose family has fled not only Cuba, but Miami a...more
Monica
Vivien, Shirin, and Ingrid have absolutely nothing in common, at least on the surface. One is a Cuban-Jew who loves food and lives in New York, one is a German-Canadian wild child, and one is quite literally an Iranian princess. The only thing they share are three summers together at a boarding school/camp in Switzerland in the early 1970s. During that time, these girls become the unlikeliest of friends as they navigate relationships, families, expectations, and the desire to follow their own dr...more
Melee
Apparently the 'dreams of significant girls' don't involve much more than boys and sex. Okay, maybe that's a bit harsh - the girls did have passions that later developed into careers but those took backseat and I feel more space than necessary was devoted to the girls' amours. My inner feminist made her presence known, making grumbling noises practically the entire time I was reading. (And it takes a lot to get my inner feminist up and running. She's buried pretty deep down.)

It's a shame, really...more
Rachel
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Alex
At First Sight: Three different girls clash at an exclusive Swiss summer camp - at a boarding school - in the early 1970's. The three of them come from privileged backgrounds but couldn't be more different. German/Canadian Ingrid is loud, bold and eccentric; Iranian Shirin is conservative, quiet and a brilliant mathematician; Cuban Jewish Vivian moved from Miami to New York, likes to dance and LOVES to cook.

They get stuck as roommates during that first summer - and the two following ones - as th...more
Andy
In theory this book could have been fabulous, but I felt that in execution it fell a bit short. Granted that this is not generally the type of book i'd read maybe I'm being a bit harsh, but this is what I thought of it.
Good characters- I thought the three girls, Vivien, Shirin and Ingrid, were well done. They're personalities were as diverse as they're brackrounds. They were fun to read about and well formed.

Interesting setting- I know it's been done before but the whole boarding school for a...more
Natalie
Dreams of Significant Girls by Cristina Garcia, in the genre of Realsitic Fiction, is a compelling book full of friendships, family problems, and heartbreaks. Set in the 1970s, this book is about three girls,Vivien, Shirin, and Ingrid, who all go to a Swiss summer program. Shirin is a Iranian princess, Ingrid a Canidian delinquent, and Vivien a Cuban Jew, and when they all meet their thoughts are as different as they are. As the first summer goes on they don't get any closer, yet are all going t...more
L_manning
Following three summers at a boarding school in Switzerland, this book tells the story of three very different girls who become friends. Ingrid is the "wild" and "crazy" one, Vivien is the sweet one, and Shirin is the more uptight and formal one. The girls are thrown together as roommates, and the slowly bond through shared experiences. These bonds help shape their lives and their futures.

With a title like this one, I was expecting something profound or more interesting that what I got. Apparent...more
Katie
really enjoyed “Dreams of Significant Girls”. It’s a nice story about three girls from different countries meeting up three subsequent years. Each girls has her own problem and story to tell and they grow together. The book is divided into three smaller books, in which one character is the main character. Between the books there are letters, which the three girls write each other until they see each other again at boarding school in summer. I really liked that the girls were so different. I also...more
Sonia Reppe
I think some girl readers will like the three distinct voices of the three characters, of whom the point of view is shared (actually, two of the voices are distinct, one is just bland). I liked the voices of the Indian princess and the bad girl, but unfortunately, that was the only thing I liked about this book. The plot was so unfocused and all over the place, and unbelievable. It takes place over three summers, and by the third summer, two of the three friends already have successful careers a...more
BAYA Librarian
Detorie has made an entry into the growing list of novel-comic book hybrids with this peek into the journal of high school freshman Larkin Pace. While fulfilling an English class writing assignment, Larkin tells us the story of the second half of the school year. He deals with many of the usual teens dramas: the school bully, a lost love, the ups and downs of friendship, and a mean older sister. He also has a special wish: to buy a camcorder and start his film making career.

Larkin is honest, sma...more
bjneary
Thanks so much Jill Ligi for this great read about 3 girls sharing a room at a Swiss summer camp. What transpires over the next three summers between compassionate, food loving Vivien, tough, proud and loud Ingrid and finally quiet, sensitive Shirin is nothing short of funny, adventurous, raunchy and compelling. Over time (beginning in the 70s and traversing back to WWII and jettisoning to the 80's) these girls become very close and revisit love, heartbreak and family disillusionment but through...more
Catherine
YA novel about three teenage girls from very different backgrounds, who become roommates at a summer school/camp in Switzerland in 1971. Vivien is a New Yorker of Polish/Jewish and Cuban descent. Ingrid lives in a small town in Ontario, and Shirin is an Iranian Princess. The book follows their friendship for three summers. The childhoods of Vivien and especially of Ingrid needed a little more attention to explain how they became the way they were. The maturation process was fairly realistic. The...more
Keli
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 55 56 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • And Then Things Fall Apart
  • The Lucky Kind
  • From Willa, With Love (Wedding Planner's Daughter #6)
  • Sharks & Boys
  • The Implosion of Aggie Winchester
  • The Summer I Learned to Fly
  • Small Town Sinners
  • Populazzi
  • Tutored
  • Pearl
  • Sass & Serendipity
  • Lie
  • Paradise
  • Ordinary Beauty
  • Pure Red
  • The Lost Crown
  • Bestest. Ramadan. Ever.
  • The Jewel and the Key
15141
After working for Time Magazine as a researcher, reporter, and Miami bureau chief, García turned to writing fiction. Her first novel, Dreaming in Cuban (1992), received critical acclaim and was a finalist for the National Book Award. She has since published her novels The Agüero Sisters (1997) and Monkey Hunting (2003), and has edited books of Cuban and other Latin American literature. Her fourth...more
More about Cristina García...
Dreaming in Cuban The Agüero Sisters (Ballantine Reader's Circle) The Lady Matador's Hotel Monkey Hunting A Handbook to Luck

Share This Book

“You never knew what to expect with Ingrid. One minute she could be sawing the locks off Pierpont's freezers; the next, providing shelter for the homeless birds of Switzerland.” 3 likes
“...No small amount of schadenfreude. Do you know what that means?"

"Dad, it's the lifeline of gossip. Of course I know what it means.”
2 likes
More quotes…