Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Black Butterflies” as Want to Read:
Black Butterflies
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Black Butterflies

3.82 of 5 stars 3.82  ·  rating details  ·  243 ratings  ·  22 reviews
Including 16 stories never before assembled, "Black Butterflies" follows on the heels of the author's notorious collection, "New Noir". "John Shirley is an adventurer, returning from dark and troubled regions with visionary tales to tell. I heartily recommend a journey with John Shirley at your side".--Clive Barker.
Mass Market, 350 pages
Published March 1st 2001 by Leisure Books (first published 1998)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Black Butterflies, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Black Butterflies

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 491)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
mark monday
finally finished this one; ugh what a chore. it was just sitting on my Unfinished shelf, staring me down, and finally i couldn't take it anymore.

Shirley knows how to construct a story, that can't be denied. he has interesting themes, can set a tone immediately, and his characters are diverse and often surprisingly well-developed. he's no hack; he knows how to write. which makes this overrated collection of short stories all the more frustrating. whether writing about junkies, the middle class, t...more
Evans Light
If you see this review pop up in my status update over and over, it's because I'll be adding reviews for each story as I work my way through the book. Reviews are possibly, but not necessarily, in order.

I've never read anything by John Shirley before (at least that I can remember), but have heard many good things. Fingers crossed.

Now on with the individual story reviews:

***** Barbara

What a great short story! A woman gets kidnapped by amateur thugs hoping to force her to withdraw cash from an ATM...more
Garrett Cook
Writing one good piece of short fiction is hard. Writing one good piece of short fiction that defines a personal aesthetic is really hard. Writing several good pieces of short fiction that do that borders on the impossible. Splatpunk and Cyberpunk meet. Genre disappears and nothing's left behind but John Shirley. This, to me, is what great short fiction collections are about and that's why I consider this to be one of them. There's a lot in here to haunt you.
Randolph Carter
Okay, first off this won the Stoker award. No way is it that good. Second, a lot of people seem to bum out over it's explicit sick (as in unhealthy) sexuality and lack of ANY healthy relationships. That's just what Shirley is doing here, part of his morbid theme. I think you have to go there to get his point across in some of these stories. Third, people seem to turn off at Shirley's almost unrelieved grim world-view. I don't get this. He is just a little less pessimistic than Ligotti about the...more
Adam Wilson
Black Butterflies by John Shirley is BY FAR the worst short story collection i've ever read. Compaired to Peaceable Kingdom by Jack Ketchum, Night Shift by Stephen King, Blue World by Robert R. McCammon, and Strange Highways by Dean Koontz, this is a tree who's life should not have been wasted to form this book. Each story seems to me as if were written by a thirteen year old who only cares about sex and violence. Each story is incredibly thoughtless and pointless. This short story collection wo...more
John Shirley must be one of the most reckless writers of short fiction in the horror genre. He takes chances which would make other writers blanch, and much of his fiction is precariously poised between the outrageously brilliant and the outrageously ridiculous. Fortunately, the former usually prevails, as in this collection. It contains many stunningly effective tales, such as "Barbara", "Cram", and "Delia and the Dinner Party", and only a few where Shirley's distinctly unusual internal censor...more
Crabby McGrouchpants
This Shirley collection brings together (yet another) collection of Stories That Go Places Most Don't Dare: somehow singular, and feeling so right at the same time.

The requisite knowledge of drives and desires and sub-cultural modes (that being: any cultural strata's unspoken rules of conduct & behavior) that Shirley masterfully flaunts his command of like a composer or violin virtuoso "just warming up" with a trill over-and-back-again is something few would know how to fake, or covet, so ra...more
Thom Foolery
I can't remember whether I first heard of John Shirley in the context of cyberpunk, the Church of the SubGenius, or the Gurdjieff Work. Regardless, when I found this anthology at the BOGO sale at the local public library, I was impressed enough by his provenance and diverse preoccupations to check it out, in spite of the horrible cover. (Half off of $1 makes me overlook bad covers, fyi.) As other Goodreaders have noted, Shirley is an excellent writer in terms of concepts, plotting, dramatic tens...more
Did I love it? Yes. Did I hate it? Yup. Did it take me 5 months to finish? Yeah, yeah. That, too.

Black Butterflies is an anthology that polarizes many readers, so I guess I shouldn't be too surprised that I, myself, was polarized. Hell, even the book itself is divided into two sections "This World" and "That World," referring to complete reality-based vs. stories with supernatural or science fiction elements.

Several of the stories were top notch, including "Barbara," "The Rubber Smile," "How Dee...more
Despite my rating, I would not call John Shirley a bad writer. Not in the slightest. There are some very creative story set-ups here, and some brilliant writing.

But...while I don't consider myself prudish by any means, I really have a problem with writing that is this sexually explicit for seemingly no purpose beyond being explicit. By the end of this 250 page short story collection, I really felt like I needed a shower. The best reference point I can come up with is the later Anita Blake books...more
Two and a half stars.

For gruesome horror that you can't look away from because of how beautifully-written, funny, kinky, weird, and amazing it is, see Clive Barker.

For gruesome horror that's just disgusting, degrading, and more than occasionally stigmatic toward homosexuals and transvestites, read this.

But on the other hand, to be perfectly fair, "Barbara," "Rubber Smile," and a couple of others were kind of nifty. For those, I'll not dismiss Mr. Shirley entirely - but I'm done with this book.
Spencer Distraction
"Cram". A short story about an earthquake in the Bay Area that focuses on the people that are on the BART, UNDER the gawdsdamned sea, going vertical as the earth opens a hole to swallow the train, & the mofo water starts to seep in. AW HELL NAW! After reading this (years ago) I have not been able to ride the BART without thinking of this and needing xanax. Shivers...
Jan 23, 2012 Maggie rated it 1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: nobody
Shelves: gave-up-on
i read the first story in this collection and that was it for me. just awful. terrible, horrible, choose your own adjective. not well-written AT ALL, and i felt dirty reading it. if only there were an option for zero stars.
This is by far my favorite John Shirley book. I don't care for short stories but this book is fantastic. The stories are strange and strangely horrific in an interesting way.
I believe I picked this book up at a bookstand in an airport. It has got to be one of the best short story anthologies I have ever read. Very dark, very psychologically twisted.
Allan Dyen-shapiro
Short horror fiction by a master; half the book realistic horror, half supernatural. Highly recommended--horror doesn't come any better.
Spooky and engrossing. I read this a few years ago, yet a few short stories still stick relentlessly in my brain.
If you like weird stuff that's nasty for the sake of being shocking, then you'll probably still hate this book.
Dec 31, 2010 Kirby rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: own
If you only read one piece of work by John Shirley, read "Cram" from this book.
S.D. Hintz
One of the more vile and creative books I've read.
Definitely recommend it.
Count Jared
This is an amazing collection, but how do you get over a 5 out of 5?
Joseph Duffy
Twisted, entertaining, dark, never dull.
Glenn Conley
Glenn Conley marked it as to-read
Oct 21, 2014
Lee Cooke
Lee Cooke marked it as to-read
Oct 07, 2014
Billy Coley
Billy Coley marked it as to-read
Oct 03, 2014
cheryl marked it as to-read
Oct 01, 2014
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 16 17 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Goodreads Librari...: Page Count for 0843948442 3 13 Jul 31, 2013 06:12AM  
  • The Nightmare Chronicles
  • Alone With the Horrors: The Great Short Fiction, 1961-1991
  • The Best Horror of the Year Volume One
  • October Dreams: A Celebration of Halloween
  • Under the Fang (The Horror Writers of America)
  • Approaching Oblivion
  • The Dark Country
  • Fruiting Bodies and Other Fungi
  • Fears Unnamed
  • My Work is Not Yet Done: Three Tales of Corporate Horror
  • Borderlands 1
  • Peaceable Kingdom
  • The Small Assassin
  • Ribofunk
  • The Throne of Bones
  • American Fantastic Tales: Terror and the Uncanny from Poe to the Pulps (Library of America #196)
  • Rumpole and the Age of Miracles (Rumpole)
  • Dark Delicacies II (Dark Delecacies, #2)
John Shirley is the author of more than a dozen books, including Demons; Crawlers; City Come A-Walkin’; Really, Really, Really, Really, Weird Stories; and the classic cyberpunk trilogy A Song Called Youth: Eclipse, Eclipse Penumbra, and Eclipse Corona. He is the recipient of the Horror Writers Association’s Bram Stoker Award and won the International Horror Guild Award for his collection Black But...more
More about John Shirley...
BioShock: Rapture Constantine: The Hellblazer Collection Eclipse (A Song Called Youth, #1) City Come a-Walkin' Constantine

Share This Book