Why God Won't Go Away: Is the New Atheism Running on Empty?
""A robust defense of the God of the Bible...This is a book for serious thinkers who wish to make God real in a world that has forgotten its Creator and Maker." ""-- Joni Eareckson Tada"
In a decade embroiled in fanaticism and fear, a renewed interest in the age-old debate over the question of God has reignited, giving rise to a new group of media-savvy contenders dubbed...more
In a decade embroiled in fanaticism and fear, a renewed interest in the age-old debate over the question of God has reignited, giving rise to a new group of media-savvy contenders dubbed...more
Paperback, 191 pages
Published
May 17th 2011
by Thomas Nelson Publishers
(first published February 1st 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
182)
This was an excellent book which is well titled. After recently reading the book by Lennox “gunning for God” on a similar topic, I assumed that the books would also be similar. This was not the case. This book my McGrath does not seek to answer the questions of the new Atheism or to provide any apologetic for Christianity. Instead McGrath provides a short biography of the four dominant new atheists: Dennett, Harris, Dawkins and Hitchens. Then he proceeds to first outline their main lines of argu...more
Alister McGrath provides a brief yet well researched overview of New Atheism. McGrath divides his text into three main sections where he discusses the development of the New Atheistic ideal, how to effectively engage those who adhere to such a belief, and where McGrath believes the agenda of New Atheism is headed. I must note this book is not an apologetic for Christianity; conversely, it is a discussion of New Atheism, its agenda, and how to address this movement. With that said, McGrath nevert...more
A stimulating and sometimes correct critique of the "New Atheism" but it ultimately fails to make its case.
After initially finishing writing this review, I looked down and saw that it was a 2,500 word monster. To make it more reader-friendly, I cut out everything except the central issue that I had with the book and a very brief concluding remark.
The biggest problem in this book is the faulty critique of the by-product theory of religion. Briefly stated, the by-product theory of religion posits...more
After initially finishing writing this review, I looked down and saw that it was a 2,500 word monster. To make it more reader-friendly, I cut out everything except the central issue that I had with the book and a very brief concluding remark.
The biggest problem in this book is the faulty critique of the by-product theory of religion. Briefly stated, the by-product theory of religion posits...more
New Atheism is not to be confused with classic Atheism of the stripe of Iris Murdoch or other older classical authors. New Atheism, as opposed to classic Atheism, is characterized by dogmatism, polemic and as the author shows throughout this book, uncritical thinking which has devolved into brute force and name calling.
While Alister McGrath gives plenty of leg room for the classic Atheistic writers, showing them respect for their open minded and open handed approach to their world view; where th...more
While Alister McGrath gives plenty of leg room for the classic Atheistic writers, showing them respect for their open minded and open handed approach to their world view; where th...more
If you are looking for a book on apologetics, this is not it.
This book I a critique of new atheism, and critique it does! The religious fanaticism of the neo-atheist movement is exposed and shredded easily and in a very readable manner.
There were points where I was concerned that McGrath may resort to personal attacks on authors such as Dawkin's and Hitchen's, but whilst anecdotal evidence of them is used to discredit their statements of belief, he never goes so far as to ridicule or humiliate...more
This book I a critique of new atheism, and critique it does! The religious fanaticism of the neo-atheist movement is exposed and shredded easily and in a very readable manner.
There were points where I was concerned that McGrath may resort to personal attacks on authors such as Dawkin's and Hitchen's, but whilst anecdotal evidence of them is used to discredit their statements of belief, he never goes so far as to ridicule or humiliate...more
McGrath comes out of the gates with guns blazing against the New Atheism. He’s a debater, having met Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, and Christopher Hitches in debates, and his competitive stance shines through. He refuses to meet atheists on their level, insisting that "faith doesn't contradict reason, but transcends it." Questions such as, "What are we all here for?" and "What's the point of living?" are legitimate questions, and we're right to seek answers to them, but science isn't going to...more
“Christopher Hitchens recently slammed Mother Teresa, declaring her ‘a fanatic and a fundamentalist and a fraud,’ arguing that ‘millions of people are much worse off because of her life‘ It was a shame, he declared, that there was no hell for her to go to. It was a foolish move, and Hitchens later generously apologized for it. (One of Hitchens’s former colleagues drolly commented, ‘My sympathies were with Mother Teresa. If you were sitting in rags in a gutter in Calcutta, who would be more likel...more
If you are like me you may have noticed more atheism in pop culture or may even know some Atheists. You may not even understand what atheism is or where it originated. That is exactly why I was excited to read “Why God Won’t Go Away” by Alister McGrath. Thanks to McGrath's "Why God Won't Go Away" I can have lively, intelligent, and well informed discussions with my atheist friends.
Mc Grath, a former atheist, is a historian and theology scholar who knows the New Atheist movement well. McGrath has...more
Mc Grath, a former atheist, is a historian and theology scholar who knows the New Atheist movement well. McGrath has...more
I found the "Universal Declaration of Human rights" analogy very interesting, as well as the Dawkins "re-write" (pages 90-93) and the "meme of memes" argument humorous, compelling and to-the-point.
The book is essentially a 'situation report' of the New Atheism in our society.
The book isn't very complicated, but that in no way takes away from what you can learn from it! I think McGrath is very fair with his analysis and avoids immature jabs against its supporters. I was particularly happy with t...more
The book is essentially a 'situation report' of the New Atheism in our society.
The book isn't very complicated, but that in no way takes away from what you can learn from it! I think McGrath is very fair with his analysis and avoids immature jabs against its supporters. I was particularly happy with t...more
Why God Won't Go Away: Is the New Atheism Running On Empty? by Alister McGrath, is a thought-provoking book about the flaws of the New Atheist movement. While the title is a bit misleading - McGrath states in the final chapter that this book isn't the forum to explain why humans continue to be drawn to a higher power - the book is an interesting read.
The first section of the book contains a literature review of New Atheist authors and ideals. It also discusses the difference between New Atheism...more
The first section of the book contains a literature review of New Atheist authors and ideals. It also discusses the difference between New Atheism...more
I was keen to read this book because I have enjoyed reading some of Alistair McGrath's previous work and have found his online articles regarding science, evidence and reasoning to be quite good. On finishing this book I was left a little disappointed, probably because I would have liked him to go into some of the points in more depth. He does point you in the right direction to do further reading, so as an introduction to the issues this is a good start but I wouldn't recommend it for someone w...more
When I began this book, I had not even heard of the "new atheist" movement. I knew what an atheist was, but I was not aware of the new direction it had taken. I was amazed with how brazen this movement had become and how hostile to religion it is. I am only familiar with tolerant atheists, and this book showed me that new atheism has gone far beyond that. It is kind of funny that new atheism, in a way, has become a religion or a church group in itself. The very thing they are fighting against is...more
In Why God Won’t Go Away, Alister challenges the beliefs embraced by four main writers: Richard Dawkins, Daniel C Dennett, Sam Harris and Christopher Hutchins. He refers to them as “The Four Horsemen” , the result of an informal discussion among the four in 2007.
I believe the best way to understand someone’s point of view is to read what they write. Alister not only reads their books, he challenges them in debate and interacts with them in online communities. He isn’t another Christian talking a...more
I believe the best way to understand someone’s point of view is to read what they write. Alister not only reads their books, he challenges them in debate and interacts with them in online communities. He isn’t another Christian talking a...more
In this book McGrath introduces the reader to the characters of the New Atheism movement as well as their ideas. He does a good job showing that the movement is much more bark than bite. Those who are well-versed with New Atheism will probably discover little new here. The book, however, would serve a great introduction.
CB
CB
“Yet I've noticed recently that all is not well within these virtual communities. They had an upbeat feel in the heady days of 2006 and 2007 when the New Atheism seemed to be like a bright new sun dawning on the world. But not now. Is a “crisis of faith” beginning to emerge?” - Pg. 41
A recent debate with atheists and memories of old debates with atheist family members gave rise to the yearning to learn more about atheism and it's roots. Alister McGrath, a former atheist, holds the chair of theol...more
A recent debate with atheists and memories of old debates with atheist family members gave rise to the yearning to learn more about atheism and it's roots. Alister McGrath, a former atheist, holds the chair of theol...more
Being a person questioning religion, but being of a religious bent, I dislike findamentalist athiests, much the same as I dislike fundamentalst anything. This book discusses how by being so agressive many athiests are actually sending people back to religion. I found it interesting in light of several discussions I've seen recently about some very prominent athiests and their attitude to women, which doesn't differ much from their religious counterparts. It's not a neutral book, the author is ch...more
How can a book of this nature be a "page-turner"? I'm not really sure how McGrath pulled it off, but I could not stop reading this book. As someone who is relatively new to understanding the "New Atheist" movement and philosophical debates, I found McGrath to be a capable and entertaining guide. First, he introduces the reader to how the "new" atheist movement started and what it is. Secondly, he tackles three major challenges that new atheists pose to theists (violence, reason, and science), s...more
A stimulating and sometimes correct critique of the "New Atheism" but it ultimately fails to make its case.
After initially finishing writing this review, I looked down and saw that it was a 2,500 word monster. To make it more reader-friendly, I cut out everything except the central issue that I had with the book and a very brief concluding remark.
The biggest problem in this book is the faulty critique of the by-product theory of religion. Briefly stated, the by-product theory of religion posits...more
After initially finishing writing this review, I looked down and saw that it was a 2,500 word monster. To make it more reader-friendly, I cut out everything except the central issue that I had with the book and a very brief concluding remark.
The biggest problem in this book is the faulty critique of the by-product theory of religion. Briefly stated, the by-product theory of religion posits...more
Thoughtful, pleasant, lucid, and brief.
Useful note: quotes Isaiah Berlin's observation that human conviction can be classed in three categories:
1.Those established by empirical observation.
2.Those established by logical deduction.
3.Those that cannot be proved in either of these ways.
Examples of convictions in the third category include adherence to human rights, acknowledgement of other minds, and belief in the existence God (a la A. Plantinga); see pages 86-7.
Useful note: quotes Isaiah Berlin's observation that human conviction can be classed in three categories:
1.Those established by empirical observation.
2.Those established by logical deduction.
3.Those that cannot be proved in either of these ways.
Examples of convictions in the third category include adherence to human rights, acknowledgement of other minds, and belief in the existence God (a la A. Plantinga); see pages 86-7.
Alister McGrath exposes billiantly the flaws in New Atheist thinking, while at the same time is quick to remind people that there are academic atheists which much more intelligent things to say. McGrath expresses his his ideas in a simple easy to follow manner and very respectful of his opposition. I would recommend this book to anyone willing to look into the New Atheism from an academics stand point.
This is a fairly good exposition of the weaknesses of the "new atheism". He drives home the point that thorough-going atheism just does not sit well with the human psyche. He also makes a good point, however, that persons of religious faith need to at least consider some of these challenges -- that only by analyzing one's faith can it ever advance beyond naivety.
I enjoyed this impressive work very much. This is the first time I've read one of McGrath's works, and I'm sure to be reading more. Why God Won't Go Away was very logical and convincing that New Atheism didn't work. I don't think it would be very useful as a flip-through handguide to refuting New Atheism, as it is very condensed and takes a while to read. It is more for understanding New Atheism as a whole, and I appreciate that approach. It doesn't necessarily try to prove Christianity, but sho...more
Aug 31, 2011
Ste21 Donaldson-Ellison
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
religious
Very good read, at first it seemed as if it was simply a criticism of the New Atheism. However McGrath highlights the origins of this movement, what makes it tick as well as it's pros and cons. He goes indepth showing us how on the one hand religion can be used for evil and on the other good all the while showing that one should not be highlighted over the other. What impresses me most overall is that he talks extensively of science as a way forward for religion, i would have expected him to ste...more
Dec 27, 2011
Dennis Wahlquist
marked it as to-read
10/2012 bookclub book
Even if Alister McGrath's arguments were successful and convincing (which they aren't), Why God Won't Go Away is too short to have any real impact. Like the majority of religion/atheism books on the market today, this book preaches to the choir. Granted, McGrath ain't bad at it, but he's still got his back turned, as it were.
My review here: http://lunchboxsw.wordpress.com/2011/...
May 16, 2013
Courtney Roper
marked it as to-read
May 12, 2013
Steven Dunn
marked it as to-read
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Alister E. McGrath is a biochemist and Christian theologian born in Belfast, Northern Ireland, and currently enjoys the Title of Distinction “Professor of Historical Theology” granted by the University of Oxford. He is the author of several books on theology and history, including In the Beginning: The Story of the King James Bible and How it Changed a Nation, a Language, and a Culture and The Twi...more
More about Alister E. McGrath...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...
view 1 comment











