28th out of 82 books
—
49 voters
The Influencing Machine: Brooke Gladstone on the Media
by
Brooke Gladstone ,
Josh Neufeld (Goodreads Author)
Nearly one million weekly listeners trust NPR's Brooke Gladstone to guide them through the distortions and complexities of the modern media. This brilliant radio personality now bursts onto the page as an illustrated character in vivid comics drawn by acclaimed artist Josh Neufeld. The cartoon of Brooke conducts the reader through two millennia of history-from the newspape...more
Hardcover, 172 pages
Published
May 23rd 2011
by W. W. Norton & Company
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,007)
Gladstone used graphic non-fiction to deftly communicate the historical, psychological and sociological truths of the media's influence in society. From Caesar's Acta Diurna, the first daily news which pressured the Roman Senators to be accountable (and reminiscent of the Daily Stand-Up Meeting) to the digitally borne diseases stemming from the homophily echo chamber (where people only consume media "facts" that substantiate their entrenched belief systems resulting in polarization), our relatio...more
Have you ever watched the news? Read a magazine? A newspaper? If so, you have engaged in the media by consuming it. If you have engaged in the media, do you agree with it? Do you think that it is accurate? That it shows objectivity and has no bias? These are some of the topics that Brooke Gladstone addresses in her non-fiction memoir The Influencing Machine. The author is very knowledgeable on the topic and (aided by the format) shows the information clearly. The Influencing Machine is written...more
Gladstone is both narrator and visual tour guide, popping up throughout Neufeld's comic panels as both her contemporary self and camouflaged alongside historical figures.
The comic book format permitted me to read and learn about a subject I would not have attempted in a formal book format; the graphic format makes sense as a way to ease the "pain".
Beginning with the Incas, Herodotus, and the Acta Diurna of the Roman Senate, she wends her way to the present. The history’s always interesting, and...more
The comic book format permitted me to read and learn about a subject I would not have attempted in a formal book format; the graphic format makes sense as a way to ease the "pain".
Beginning with the Incas, Herodotus, and the Acta Diurna of the Roman Senate, she wends her way to the present. The history’s always interesting, and...more
This book offers a robust opinion on the state of the media and explains why there is still a lot of work to do but no reason to despair. A lot of insight is gleaned from the history of journalism but also from technology experts like Clay Shirky or Cass Sunstein. The author is also the co-host of On The Media. Here are my lecture notes.
# The Influencing Machine
The influencing machine is a typical invention of the mind that is trying to explain in a somewhat paranoiac way how ideas are spreading...more
# The Influencing Machine
The influencing machine is a typical invention of the mind that is trying to explain in a somewhat paranoiac way how ideas are spreading...more
Brooke Gladstone is wonderful. And Josh Neufield is an able illustrator/ comic artist. If each could be judged apart from one another, I would rate them both much more highly on their individual merits.
Unfortunately, I think Gladstone should have just written a proper book. The writing achieves its aim of balancing the light and entertaining with the heavy and intellectual but when rendered as a comic it starts to feel super heavy and dense. (A woman next to me at a coffee shop, who clearly rea...more
Unfortunately, I think Gladstone should have just written a proper book. The writing achieves its aim of balancing the light and entertaining with the heavy and intellectual but when rendered as a comic it starts to feel super heavy and dense. (A woman next to me at a coffee shop, who clearly rea...more
This was a very entertaining and interesting read, exposing me to a lot of concepts, points of contention, types of bias, and a few historical facts about which I was previously unaware.
The first half of the book seems to be declaring that there is no Media with a big 'M', controlled by public manipulators, or any other sorts of organized conspiracies. I have to wonder who her intended audience is here, since anyone who doesn't believe it doesn't need to be told; and anyone who does believe it,...more
The first half of the book seems to be declaring that there is no Media with a big 'M', controlled by public manipulators, or any other sorts of organized conspiracies. I have to wonder who her intended audience is here, since anyone who doesn't believe it doesn't need to be told; and anyone who does believe it,...more
An interesting history of journalism, but I don't think Gladstone quite proves her point that the readers control journalism, despite the fact that journalists to varying degrees at different times in history try to give the people what they want (as opposed to what they need), keeping to the "sweet spot" of "legitimate controversy" but away from the sphere of "deviance," which "the mainstream of society rejects as unworthy of being heard." Perhaps therein lies the problem--she equates "us" with...more
Apr 04, 2012
Bruce
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
fans of "On the Media," Scott McCloud, Jon Stewart, and Rush Limbaugh (just to piss him off)
Inspired by Scott McCloud, Brooke Gladstone was brimming with ideas about the history of journalism and the impact, evolution, and continuing relevance of the media. So she called up Josh Neufeld out of the blue (with help from her agents) and asked him to help her unburden herself. What resulted was this excellent manifesto. I just picked this off the library shelves out of curiosity and then we got this week's Muse magazine, which coincidentally includes an excerpt from the book. So then I had...more
A wise and challenging little book (and one that makes me feel negligent for not listening to Gladstone's NPR show).
Journalism and Americanism are heavily entwined concepts for me - take the season of The Wire that exposed the workings of a Baltimore newspaper. Gladstone describes 'the American exception', where at the end of the 18th century, the American legal system decided that truth could be used as a defense against libel charges, removing the government's right to suppress criticism of it...more
Journalism and Americanism are heavily entwined concepts for me - take the season of The Wire that exposed the workings of a Baltimore newspaper. Gladstone describes 'the American exception', where at the end of the 18th century, the American legal system decided that truth could be used as a defense against libel charges, removing the government's right to suppress criticism of it...more
Newspapers (now broadened to "the media") influence public opinion and the course of political affairs. This deft little book tells the story of media and influence, historically and technologically, and manages to be not just readable but also extremely difficult to put down. I read it in one sitting and got a lot from it. It is easy to read because it is both well-written and well-illustrated--most of the book is in the form of a comic: panels, pictures, captions. The potentially dry topics ar...more
A lively and informative book on the history of public media. I have a few quibbles along the way, but I'm willing to ignore them because I'm learning some interesting history, competently arranged to get me from points A and B to points U and V with the dots nicely connected. The trouble is that I totally reject the conclusion Gladstone presents, that "We get the media we deserve."
That's bogus. We the people don't control journalism -- despite the nice point she makes that journalism does spend...more
That's bogus. We the people don't control journalism -- despite the nice point she makes that journalism does spend...more
"Everything we hate about the media today was present at its creation: its corrupt or craven practitioners, its easy manipulation by the powerful, its capacity for propagating lies, its penchant for amplifying rage. Also present was everything we admire- and require- from the media: factual information, penetrating analysis, probing investigation, truth spoken to power. Same as it ever was."
"There's a long-standing debate in the media biz over whether news outlets should give the public what it...more
"There's a long-standing debate in the media biz over whether news outlets should give the public what it...more
I saw the author of this book, Brooke Gladstone, speak at the Brooklyn Book Festival, and after returning home I resisted the idea of reading her book: I'd felt her to be patronizing to Jennifer Pozner, author of "Reality Bites Back", which I found fantastic. However, I happened to see this book available at the library a week or so later and decided I'd check it out anyway. I'm glad I did. This is an excellent meditation on the history and role of the media, told in accessible and fun graphic n...more
Jul 30, 2011
BHodges
added it
Gladstone writes: "Everything we hate about the media today was present at its creation: its corrupt or craven practitioners, its easy manipulation by the powerful, its capacity for propagating lies, its penchant for amplifying rage. Also present was everything we admire--and require--from the media: factual information, penetrating analysis, probing investigation, truth spoken to power. Same as it ever was" (20).
This astute observation loses none of its punch despite being situated next to a c...more
This astute observation loses none of its punch despite being situated next to a c...more
To call this graphic novel a visual depiction of the history and purpose of the news media would be a vast simplification, and would not speak to the wry wit of both the author and artist as they explore the complexities of how media influence and determine the way we think. With almost up-to-the-minute research (citing books just released in paperback this year and reports still current), Brooke Gladstone (from NPR's On the Media) demonstrates the purposes, biases and motivations of the news me...more
Jul 07, 2011
Gregory
marked it as to-read
From:http://www.boingboing.net/2011/0...
Brooke Gladstone, co-host of the excellent NPR-syndicated "On the Media," has teamed up with illustrator Josh Neufeld to produce a fantastic nonfiction comic book called The Influencing Machine: Brooke Gladstone on the Media. This is one of those books that feels like the author has been working up to it for her whole life, distilling all her varied experience and insight into one mind-opening, thought-provoking, and incredibly timely volume.
Influencing Ma...more
Brooke Gladstone, co-host of the excellent NPR-syndicated "On the Media," has teamed up with illustrator Josh Neufeld to produce a fantastic nonfiction comic book called The Influencing Machine: Brooke Gladstone on the Media. This is one of those books that feels like the author has been working up to it for her whole life, distilling all her varied experience and insight into one mind-opening, thought-provoking, and incredibly timely volume.
Influencing Ma...more
I'm not much of a radio listener, so the fact that Brooke Gladstone is a well regarded NPR managing editor did not bring this book to my radar. I happened to listen to her highly entertaining talk with our local radio host, Rick Kleffel, and resolved to read it at first opportunity. Brooke claims that she wanted to write a comic book about something even before she found her topic, and with the help of illustrator Josh Neufeld, who has previously done another comic or graphic novel about New Orl...more
A graphic novel that gives you a history of the media in visual bits that bite deep.
The main point; "We hunger for objectivity, but increasingly swallow "news" like Jell-O shots in ad hoc cyber-saloons. We marinate in punditry season with only those facts and opinions we can digest without cognitive distress. I see our most hallowed journalistic institutions crumbling, I see our business model that relied on mass audiences being displaced, with stunning speed, by one that survives by aggregatin...more
The main point; "We hunger for objectivity, but increasingly swallow "news" like Jell-O shots in ad hoc cyber-saloons. We marinate in punditry season with only those facts and opinions we can digest without cognitive distress. I see our most hallowed journalistic institutions crumbling, I see our business model that relied on mass audiences being displaced, with stunning speed, by one that survives by aggregatin...more
Not entirely sure what to think of this one just yet. I love the premise but I'm not convinced it was entirely well-written. Having said that, I don't typically read graphic novels or non-fiction so the format took some getting used to and it's possible that was my real challenge.
I laughed when Gladstone cited Douglas Adams' comment that "Anything that is in the world when you're born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that's invented between...more
I laughed when Gladstone cited Douglas Adams' comment that "Anything that is in the world when you're born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. Anything that's invented between...more
"We get the media we deserve," declares NPR's Brooke Gladstone in her excellent The Influencing Machine, an insightful graphic manifesto that sits comfortably alongside Neil Postman's Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business and Jaron Lanier's You Are Not a Gadget: A Manifesto, both of whom make cameo appearances.
Gladstone, aided by Josh Neufeld's seamless visuals, makes a compelling case that the ills that plague media today -- mass and social -- are nothing new,...more
Gladstone, aided by Josh Neufeld's seamless visuals, makes a compelling case that the ills that plague media today -- mass and social -- are nothing new,...more
I had high hopes for this "media manifesto in comic book form," as it seemed to be very similar in style (both graphically and narratively) to Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics. McCloud's book maximized the potential of "sequential art" to explain complex issues in an immediate, simple way. And there are some very clever visual choices in The Influencing Machine that manage the same trick.
But ultimately, I ended up feeling the same way about this book as I do about Brooke Gladstone's better-k...more
But ultimately, I ended up feeling the same way about this book as I do about Brooke Gladstone's better-k...more
As a cool lady and an expert on a topic -- media influence -- that comes up constantly on my feed and inspires waves of heated commentary, Brooke Gladstone seems like a natural candidate for Internet intellectual celebrity, but I never heard of her until this, her first foray into my field of special interest, comix. Following the Scott McCloud model -- in which a shape-shifting narrator speaks directly to the camera, bridging dramatic representations of important concepts -- Gladstone takes us...more
I learned about this book from the same ALA "Best Graphic Nonfiction" list that yielded Harvey Pekar's forgettable Beat history. In this case, fortunately, the praise was warranted. The Influencing Machine (Gladstone's central metaphor for the media is to equate it with the mechanical mind-control engines that feature in the delusional fantasies of some famous 19th-century paranoids) is a smart and funny graphic history of journalism and a meditation on the roles and responsibilities of journali...more
3.5 stars. My wife told me about this book via an NPR program she heard, and I've been excited to read it, to say the least. I wanted to read it with the goal of assigning it to one of my media classes as a textbook. The verdict is...maybe.
I wanted it to be more streamlined, perhaps more humorous. As it is, it's pretty deep and insightful. Definitely a good thing. Gladstone definitely is well-researched here, and I like how she is able to put it all together. She picks great sources. I do wish...more
I wanted it to be more streamlined, perhaps more humorous. As it is, it's pretty deep and insightful. Definitely a good thing. Gladstone definitely is well-researched here, and I like how she is able to put it all together. She picks great sources. I do wish...more
I loved this book. Must admit, being on the other side of the world and, er, not American, I hadn't heard of Brooke Gladstone, but the recommendation from the Brain Picking blog was enough to tell me I'd love this book, and I did.
It's a great summary of thinking on the media and with a hefty dose of humour and iconoclasm that you'd expect from being in comic book form. Her argument, that we are the media - so we get what we deserve - seems irrefutable to me, and her anecdotes and references wer...more
It's a great summary of thinking on the media and with a hefty dose of humour and iconoclasm that you'd expect from being in comic book form. Her argument, that we are the media - so we get what we deserve - seems irrefutable to me, and her anecdotes and references wer...more
The Influencing Machine: Brooke Gladstone on the Media is not your typical graphic text. It’s a sweeping look at the history of the media, as well as a forecast on how technology will influence human evolution.
Equal parts philosophy, cultural criticism, and polemic, Gladstone’s Machine shows her reader how news has been reported and how public policy has been shaped from an American perspective.
Compared to a text-based book, Machine sometimes seems to dispense its information in bits and pieces...more
Equal parts philosophy, cultural criticism, and polemic, Gladstone’s Machine shows her reader how news has been reported and how public policy has been shaped from an American perspective.
Compared to a text-based book, Machine sometimes seems to dispense its information in bits and pieces...more
Gladstone used graphic non-fiction to deftly communicate the historical, psychological and sociological truths of the media's influence in society. From Caesar's Acta Diurna, the first daily news which pressured the Roman Senators to be accountable (and reminiscent of the Daily Stand-Up Meeting) to the digitally borne diseases stemming from the homophily echo chamber (where people only consume media "facts" that substantiate their entrenched belief systems resulting in polarization), our relatio...more
It's pretty rare that I read non-fiction, but when it's packaged up all nice and comic-like, it's much easier for me to be willing to pick it up. And this book is well-worth picking up. Brooke Gladstone of NPR takes the reader through an extensive investigation into journalism and the media. If you think you know the media, you likely don't even know a fraction of the story. Gladstone not only tells us of the history of media, particularly American-style reporting, she also reveals the biases of...more
Disappointing. This book is not "visionary," nor is it particularly "opinionated"as it has been billed; it is certainly not a "manifesto" as that implies the book is articulating some idea outside of normal liberal-establishment orthodoxy. And man, you need some outsized blinders on to consider that orthodoxy coherent.
Gladstone starts the book by saying there is nothing "conspiratorial" about mainstream media - a remark I can only imagine is an unnamed naming of Manufacturing Consent, which, wh...more
Gladstone starts the book by saying there is nothing "conspiratorial" about mainstream media - a remark I can only imagine is an unnamed naming of Manufacturing Consent, which, wh...more
The Influencing Machine by Brooke Gladstone is a wonderful book!
Its one of those rare titles I didn’t know I wanted and now I can’t live without.
Whether it’s the “liberal media” or “the lame stream media,” we’ve all heard about “media bias.” Most of us now expect our news to be flavored to suit our taste. Isn’t that why we have Fox, MSNBC, CNN, and NPR? So, everyone can partake of the kind of news they like. Brooke Gladstone, however, turns most of our media expectations wonderfully upside down...more
Its one of those rare titles I didn’t know I wanted and now I can’t live without.
Whether it’s the “liberal media” or “the lame stream media,” we’ve all heard about “media bias.” Most of us now expect our news to be flavored to suit our taste. Isn’t that why we have Fox, MSNBC, CNN, and NPR? So, everyone can partake of the kind of news they like. Brooke Gladstone, however, turns most of our media expectations wonderfully upside down...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Brooke Gladstone is cohost of NPR's On the Media and a former senior editor at Weekend Edition and All Things Considered. She lives in Brooklyn, New York.
More about Brooke Gladstone...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Objectivity works to repel the attacks of critics, like a kind of ethical pepper spray.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view 1 comment














