Silhouetted by the Blue
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Silhouetted by the Blue

3.76 of 5 stars 3.76  ·  rating details  ·  193 ratings  ·  37 reviews
Seventh-grader Serena Shaw istrying to keep upat school while rehearsingforthe lead role in the spring musical and dealing with a father so "blue" he is nearly catatonic. With theaid of a not-so-secret admirer as well as a growing sense of self-confidence,she faces the challenges of caring for herself and her ball-of-charm younger brother, all while attempting to lead the...more
Hardcover, 208 pages
Published July 19th 2011 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Marcelo in the Real World by Francisco X. StorkThe Alienist by Caleb CarrAnd Then There Were None by Agatha ChristieWuthering Heights by Emily BrontëThe Ghost in the Crystal by Matt Posner
In Silhouette
272nd out of 294 books — 35 voters
Somewhere Only We Know by Cheyanne YoungThis is Not a Test by Courtney SummersThe Bell Jar by Sylvia PlathThirteen Reasons Why by Jay AsherIdentical by Ellen Hopkins
Oh, the Books! Bookish Guide: Mental Health in YA
40th out of 102 books — 11 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 443)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Kia
Silhouetted was a touching read. It made me cry. I know what its like to feel blue. I have listened to my students talk about losing a loved one as well, and know that after a huge loss things change. Many times the person can feel as if there is no one to talk to or that people feel like they will catch the "dead mom" cooties.
The novel had many realistic moments. However, I don't like that the friendship with Elijah was pushed into a romantic relationship. I felt like she should have developed...more
Jamie
I'm a little torn about this one. It's a strong tale, with believable characters. I loved Serena, she is strong and weak at the same time and I think child readers would root for her and be glad they are not her at the same time. Sometimes I think the dialog was reaching too hard to be "on point" but I'd like to know what kids would think - I think the author got it pretty close.
Susan Dove Lempke
A 7th grade girl tries to keep things together at home as her father is incapacitated by depression. The main character has a tart, down-to-earth personality that keeps the book from being gloomy. There's much to like but the ending is a little too tidy.
Doret
Serena will be starring in the school play The Wiz even though she's only in the 7th grade. She lives with her dad and younger brother Henry. Serena's dad has a very bad case of the blues forcing Serena to take on more responsibilities at home. Living by the code of what happens at home is no one's business, everything soon becomes too much for Serena.

I loved Serena's voice and this story. This is the first YA novel I've come across that truly explores the topic of depression. The author handles...more
Katrina Burchett
Serena Shaw is a seventh grader. It's been over a year since her mother died and her dad is suffering from depression or - as she calls it - the blue. She'd like to spend time with friends and focus on her lead role in the school play, but most of her time is spent taking care of her little brother and her dad (as best she can). She makes meals for the family, and she does the grocery shopping and the laundry. All she wants to do is live her life under normal circumstances and go for her dreams....more
Julia
A simply told but profoundly touching tale of a girl (7th grade) who is trying to hold her family together after her mom's death & her dad's fall into severe depression. Serena just wants a normal world, but instead she has to take care of her little brother & maintain her household, cooking, cleaning, laundry & all of it. When she gets cast as the star of the school play it all becomes too much, especially as Dad gets worse, not better. He spends weeks wearing the same pajamas &...more
 Imani ♥ ☮
Overall, I thought that this book was pretty cute. Pretty being the operative word. After reading Jones' other novel, Finding My Place, I thought that I was done with trying to read her work. I'm not saying that this was a very excellent book or anything, because it wasn't. It was just a nice, short read that kept my interest until the end. Although, if I am to be honest, the ending kind of sucked.

This is the story of a seventh grader named Serena.(Her age kind of threw me off, but whatever. Bec...more
Beaverton City Library Teens
Ever since their mother died in a car accident, Henry and Serena's life has been going downhill. It's not necessarily dealing with the grief, but more their father's reaction to it - he has what Serena refers to as "the blue," or severe depression so crippling that he cannot take care of himself or his children, much less get out of bed. Meanwhile, Serena keeps plugging along. Her grades may not be the best, but she just scored the coveted lead role of Dorothy in her middle school's production o...more
Lesley
A great book about an Issue (actually, more than one Issue) that really shows how Issues (in this case, a mother's death and a father's downward spiral into depression) affect every aspect of a girl's life (relationships with friends and with her little brother, her role in the school musical) while keeping those aspects realistically relevant. It felt like a real slice of a girl's life at a moment of crisis. I especially appreciated how she didn't react to everything perfectly--she lashed out a...more
Marcia
I liked this book, but it wasn't my ultimate favorite. I read it for the MO Truman Awards I probably would not have picked it up otherwise. This will be a good book for my MS students since it is a modern story and unfortunately a few of my students can relate to the frustration she is feeling when everything starts falling apart. As I was reading, I wished I could reach inside the book to help her. I wanted to yell at her dad to snap out of it and be there for his kids...they needed him. I am g...more
Abby Johnson
"Take care of my boys, baby girl. Take care of them till I get home." That's what Serena's mom told her before she left on a business trip... but she was in a car accident and never came home. Now Serena's trying to deal with her grief while she keeps up with everything else - taking care of her little brother and a dad who won't get out of bed, schoolwork (her grades are slipping), play practice (Serena's playing the lead), grocery shopping, laundry, cleaning...

Serena's dad has "had the blue"...more
Tina
7th grader Serena Shaw is struggling with responsibilities that no middle schooler should have to face after the sudden death of her mother following a car crash. Serena has no choice but to step up and care for herself and her younger brother as their father spirals further into a debilitating depression. Serena more is added to her plate when she earns the lead role in the school’s production of The Wiz which could earn the school a much needed grant for the theatre department to continue. Kee...more
Rachel
Serena Shaw. Seventh-grader. Older sister. Horrible at math. Even more horrible at Spanish. Made for a pair of ruby red slippers in her school’s musical production of The Wiz. That is, if she can get to practice on time, keep her singing voice strong, finish her homework, clean the house, do the laundry, make dinner and make sure her little brother Henry is taken care of. See, since Serena’s mom died a year ago, her dad has had a serious case of “the blue.” He cries all the time, refuses to work...more
Kaitlin Gelina
It was such an inspiration to see her take care of herself her younger brother and her dad. If my mom died I wouldn't be able to take care of my family and handle school and do a play and be the star of that play I just couldn't do that It was such an inspiration to read this book.
Anne
Serena is an extremely talented singer and lands the lead role in the school musical even though she is still a 7th grader. However, she is struggling to balance a lot of other things, including a younger brother who needs to be picked up from school daily, missing her mom who died in a car accident 18 months ago, and a dad who is suffering from severe depression. Serena needs help, but doesn't know how to ask for it. A touching and realistic account of how lives can be affected by depression an...more
Mackenzie Macklin Mcmillan
I really enjoyed how the author made Serena's life very realistic. I felt bad for Serena when she felt all alone the person who would talk to her about her mothers death would only talk about it, Henry was too young to understand, her friends weren't very supportive, her dad had terrible depression, her uncle didn't understand until he got there to see it for himself, and her grandma was too old to help. The lesson in this book to me is be appreciative of what you have because one minute its the...more
Laura Landis
A sweet story, beautifully sad with a hope filled finish.
Erin
I agree with the reviews that mentioned this was simply told and a little too tidy. Overally, it was a nice story about a girl whose mother was killed in a car accident and her father is battling depression. She is left to care for her younger brother and live her life in the face of her father's ever more alarming symptoms.

The main character is charming and I felt for her as I was reading. What could be a very depressing read was relatively uplifting.

Depression. Death. Suicide.
**bonus points fo...more
Andrew Burden
Simple but remarkably tender and moving. A poignant reminder to me, as a teacher, to look beyond what I see in a classroom for the real stories students are living.
Lisa
It was just such a realistic story to me, and it kept me reading when I picked it up. I think kids would really get into the realism as well. A lot of students don't like all the fantasy in stories, they want to read something they can relate to, or that is just plain "real". And this book is perfect for those kids.

You can read the rest of my review HERE
Meredith
Blech. An issue book. Not helped by the fact that it kept referencing the Outsiders, one of my favorite books of all time. You look especially bad compared to The Outsiders, book. Also, I'm not sure what age group this is supposed to be for. The protagonist is in 7th grade, but it's definitely written more like a teen book. On the bright side, the issues in the book are important. And it only took me about 2 hours to read it.
Kendall
3.75 stars; 2013-4 Truman list. Although the book was profoundly sad, I found it to be a really accurate depiction of a parent who's depressed. As a former caregiver of siblings because of an unavailable parent, I related to the protagonist's day-to-day struggles and found the plot both moving and realistic. I plan to check out Traci Jones' other books...she is a great writer I had not heard of until now.
Emily Hunholz
“Silhouetted by the Blue” ended up surpassing my expectations. I felt so sorry for the main character, Serena, who has to be the only adult in her family when her mom dies and her dad checks out. She is a strong and brave character with no one to turn to. It was a quick read, but I was still able to invest in the characters.
Tracy Hubbard

Having to take of your brother because your dad is upset about the loss of your mom is tough. It's even harder that Dad has many days he can't even get out of bed to help at all. Struck down by depression the roles are reversed in this story that needs an adult to intercede.
1kidder_camryn
This book was AWESOME i loved it! It was really sad and had a lot of conflicts that I could connect to. I expected the book to be a little bit boring, but I gave it a try anyways . . . And all I have to say is that I'm glad I did. It's definatley worth reading.
Becky
Another "teen with stuff going on at home who has to take care of everything and really needs help but is afraid to tell anyone because it's no one else's business" story. There are much better ones out there, if you want to read about this kind of thing.
Alexia Hurt
I think that Silhouetted by the Blue is a very good book. I could relate to Serena in a way, and it was very exciting. I recommend this book to all middle school students and maybe even adults who like teen fictions. Very good book.
Laura W.
I'm glad I finally got this one read. It was a pretty quick one to get through, but I think the subject material is good for middle grade students, especially ones who are dealing with hard things in their home lives.
Lexie
I would not recommend this book through-out the story is ok but jumps a lot. At the end it seems like the author wanted to wanted to quit writing and end the book. So, it time jumped a lot.
Linda
I loved this book and thought it realistically and sensitively portrayed the dad's depression and the impact on his 2 children. I am not sure which students may like it.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 14 15 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Death Catchers
  • Lost in the River of Grass
  • Soccerland
  • Here Lies Linc
  • Camo Girl
  • Wild Life
  • Paintings from the Cave: Three Novellas
  • Sellout
  • How Lamar's Bad Prank Won a Bubba-Sized Trophy
  • Ghetto Cowboy
  • Addie on the Inside (The Misfits, #3)
  • The Underdogs
  • Hidden
  • Dancer
  • Planet Middle School
  • Teenage Waistland
  • Illegal
  • The Absolute Value of Mike
Standing Against the Wind Finding My Place

Share This Book