Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences” as Want to Read:
Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences

4.07  ·  Rating Details  ·  388 Ratings  ·  42 Reviews

What is the score card for economics at the start of the new millennium? While there are many different schools of economic thought, it is the neo-classical school, with its alleged understanding and simplistic advocacy of the market, that has become equated in the public mind with economics. This book shows that virtually every aspect of conventional neo-classical economi
...more
Paperback, 352 pages
Published February 23rd 2002 by Zed Books (first published 2001)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Debunking Economics, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Debunking Economics

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,068)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Whitaker
Dec 03, 2011 Whitaker rated it really liked it
Update (3 December 2011)

Steve Keen's done an excellent interview with BBC Hard Talk. Check it out on his author profile. In summary, he explains that the last 30 years of growth have been fueled by a credit bubble where banks basically went wild making money from lending. Where credit is used to fund speculation (i.e., making money from the increase of asset prices as opposed to funding new business ventures), it's a Ponzi scheme. We were assured by the economists it was all stable because the b
...more
Sean Fernyhough
Nov 25, 2011 Sean Fernyhough rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
"Thirty years ago I experienced a highly conventional education in Economics. I always had an immense difficulty in reconciling the irreconcible; the economics inside the lecture theatre and the seminar room with that in the outside world. Without the internet and books like Debunking Economics it would have taken extraordinary luck and perseverance to find the literature I needed to counteract the wrongheadedness of what I was being taught. I can even recall one of our lecturers saying that it ...more
Hadrian
This deserves a longer and more in-depth review than I can provide right now (or perhaps ever). Safe to say that Keen is vicious in his aim to dethrone neoclassical economics - anything they produce is either nonsensical, absurd, or that the author should be institutionalized (his words). His reasoning is equally savage, however, and that is where this book should be studied.

More comments should follow after I finish up a few projects elsewhere and complete J R.
David
Apr 23, 2008 David added it
A crucial work for understanding the failures of neoclassical economics: For people, like me, who had almost given up entirely on the academic field of Economics because of ridiculous theories and poor teaching, there is fortunately still Steve Keen. In this book, the Australian Keen shows the errors of the standard views of neoclassical (orthodox) economics.

Not just some side aspects of the theory, but the actual core views of economics as it is taught in universities everywhere unravels befor
...more
Gregg Wingo
May 13, 2013 Gregg Wingo rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves:
This book is a fantastic critique of the neoclassical synthesis and an exploration into the world of heterodox economics. Keen bravely attacks static economics at its mathematical roots and assumptions, revives Marx' theory of value and crowns him the greatest of Classical economists, defends Keynes against his opponents and heirs, and introduces the elegance and irrationality of dynamic analysis into the inherent instability of the market.

The author succeeds in trashing the NeoLiberal argument
...more
Justin
A manifestly important book. It's hard to capture the scope of Keen's work —his erudition of the real history of economic thought and demolition of the neoclassical house of cards is breathtaking, exciting, urgently necessary.

If, like me, you sat in undergrad economics classes thinking (or even saying) 'but... huh?' then it may just be that you were quite capable of understanding what was being presented, it simply made no sense.

Eagerly await his next book.
...more
Munthir Mahir
First off I stopped reading past chapter 9. This book covers a subject that is huge (a whole social science field) and that is the problem. The book is one too many things; it talks to too many audiences about too many topics using too many tools. It reads like a textbook, scientific paper, dissertation and a non-fiction book all at once. It certainly requires great concentration to follow the ancillary comments and supplements. It is not organized in a manner that is easy to follow because of t ...more
Samson
I have to confess that I glaze over parts of the book because the material is just over my head. Not having taken even basic Economics 101 courses, things like demand curves, supply curves, indifference curves etc., are a bit hard to grasp, though I feel that the author has tried hard to explain them for laymen like myself. Having said that, I still got some good insights from the author's narrative:
1) Some fundamental assumptions that neoclassicals made on which their theories are built upon do
...more
Kevin Varney
Aug 21, 2015 Kevin Varney rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: food-for-thought
I am only part way through at the moment, but he has convinced me. I've never studied economics properly but I have read a few books. It seems that neo-classical economics is a mathematical theory that relies on some assumptions, but the maths is wrong and the assumptions are unrealistic. Substituting an infinitesimal for zero seems like a really invalid thing to do in a mathematical equation. Then, if someone does deduce a grand theory as a thought experiment, someone else should at least be ab ...more
Petter Nordal
May 13, 2014 Petter Nordal rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Every adult living in a democracy should read this book.

The next time someone tells you that rewards for the rich are the way to fix the economy, ask them what the relationship is between private debt and the supply curve. If they cannot answer (they will likely tell you that private debt is not an important factor in a capitalist economy--insane as that sounds) then you can whip out some Keen and leave them backpedaling. Even if they do answer, you will be prepared to pummel their simplistic,
...more
Grig O'
Feb 16, 2014 Grig O' rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: kindle
5 stars for content, 3 stars for presentation.

While Keen's intent to present complex facets of economics in layman terms is certainly laudable, his efforts to bypass mathematical formulas at all costs by use of textual, tabular and graphic illustration (even if that occasionally means spelling out formulas in sentence form) sometimes go too far.

There's quite a bit of redundancy between chapters, as well as less-than-perfect mixes of the first (2001) edition and the revised (2011, post-crash) one
...more
tom bomp
Jul 23, 2014 tom bomp rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: paused
Not very clear or convincing. Constantly feel like I need a glossary (uses "marginal productivity", "marginal product of labour" and "marginal revenue product" near interchangeably for example. No idea what makes each different). I fully admit this is at least partially my own fault - it would be ridiculous to expect to understand a huge amount of economics just reading straight through. But I felt it could have been made easier. I felt often like I could see how a neoclassical economist would r ...more
Patrick
Some Anvils Need to be Dropped

JDN 2456534 PDT 15:58.

A review of Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor Dethroned? by Steve Keen.

The basic message Keen is trying to send is a vitally important one: Neoclassical economics is failing. Models based around rational agents and static equilibrium simply fail to represent the real world, and and as a result give policymakers a false sense of security against economic crisis.
The way Keen delivers this message is by avalanche: Page after page, chapter af
...more
Karl H.
Jun 17, 2012 Karl H. rated it it was ok
Debunking Economics is a non-Marxist, non-neoclassical portrait of the field of economics. It attempts to explain why economics is a field filled with unproven and erroneous assumptions. While his prediction of the present economic crisis is impressive, I feel the rest of the work is merely okay.

The style of Debunking Economics alternates in feel between an off-handed chumminess and the dryness of an economic textbook. The introductions and conclusions are too familiar in tone to feel impartial
...more
Elinor Hurst
Jun 04, 2013 Elinor Hurst rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book was not an easy read, but it gets four stars from me as in many ways I found it an utter eye opener.

Steve Keen analyses and documents in methodical detail the flaws in neoclassical economics. While there are many other books that have done this before, his is the only one that I am aware of that takes the economic academic profession head on, and plays them at their own game. He exposes their flawed thinking and gross mathematical incompetence, which to anyone who has studied mathemati
...more
Chuck
Apr 02, 2008 Chuck rated it it was amazing
Shelves: economics
From a review by Joe McCauley

"This book provides a far more clear explanation of the ideas of standard economic theory (neo-classical economics) than do the standard texts (compare with Samuelson, Mankiw, or Barro, e.g.).

The book explains utility maximization, indifference curves, and the assumptions underlying the standard economic model that is used by the IMF, the World Bank and all major western governments. Keen uses simple language that even the lay person can follow. The text should be s
...more
Trashy Pit
Stevey-boy is my kind of guy! He’s a super-expert on standard mainstream economic theory but he doesn’t buy any of it. If you choose to read only one book in your entire life on economics, don’t read one that tries to convince you that it all makes sense (much less a book that claims to “explain it all in simple language” or some other similar nonsense). Keen knows all the Economic Theories and all the arcane math they use to obfuscate the total absurdity of what they are saying, and he carefull ...more
Chad
Feb 25, 2016 Chad rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This is probably the single best economics book I have read, and I have read more economics books than is good for one's health. Keen does an excellent job of pulling back the curtain to show the true lunacy that sits underneath most of our economic dogma. From the insanity of perfect competition, to flaws in the theory of the firm (MC does not equal MR in any real world case) to the SMD issue with aggregating market demand curves, Keen details and debunks all of the flaws in the religious disci ...more
Emre Poyraz
Mar 11, 2011 Emre Poyraz rated it really liked it
I agree with other reviewers that is book is one of the most accurate and brilliant criticisms of mainstream/neoclassical economics. Some of the points Mr. Keen makes are very original, and if you are looking for "ammo" to shoot at mainstream economics, this book will give you plenty.


However,I am not sure how much this book will appeal to the non-economist reader. Much of it is discussion of the existing economic theories, and without a knowledge of these theories, much of the book would be imco
...more
Ryan Melena
Mar 07, 2016 Ryan Melena rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Debunking Economics offered an excellent and thorough dressing down of modern neoclassical economics. The author does so using the very same tools and mathematics that neoclassical economists hold up as proof of the correctness of their theories. He shows that more so than a science, and despite its own claims to the contrary, modern neoclassical economics operates as an ideology (or even a religion) that refuses to acknowledge its own shortcomings and inconsistencies. In addition to his fierce ...more
Muhammad al-Khwarizmi
Keen is brilliant but there are two problems with this book on my end: it assumes too little mathematical knowledge at the same time as it assumes too much knowledge of the neoclassical theory he is rebutting in general.

The result is often a confusing, hard and overly verbose slog. As much as I don't like pages and pages of equations like you see in some texts, I see what he's doing sometimes and wish he would just fill it in in a box set apart from the rest of the material. He has supplemental
...more
Michael
May 18, 2014 Michael rated it liked it
This book has the makings of an interesting and important polemic, but the writing style is too loose.

Many people may have trouble with his self-righteous tone, but as he was self-aware on this point, I found it tolerable.

What was intolerable was the rambling and repetitions. All his chapters start with sections titled "Kernel" and "Roadmap" - don't bother reading those. Don't bother reading chapters 1, 11, 12, or 17 either. If you like graphs, then go to his website for the extra graphs, in whi
...more
Kevin Vejrup
Jul 10, 2014 Kevin Vejrup rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Erich Kohlhöfer
Jun 18, 2013 Erich Kohlhöfer rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Steve Keen has eventually shown me, something that I have thought for a very long time, that my assumptions that most of contemporary economics is actually far too simplistic and thus basically invalid.

Unfortunately, the book gets rather complicated in some places, some things could actually benefit much by using real-life examples.

That said, the book is actually for people who have at the very least a good understanding of economics, othewrwise they will be quite overwhelmed or won't understand
...more
Jamie Johnson
Sep 14, 2012 Jamie Johnson rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
First book I've read that's seriously looked at the assumptions underpinning the toppling edifice of macro-economics. It's no wonder the solutions don't work. Helicopter Ben may be pump-priming yet more cash into the vampire-squid's lair, but he's going to end up with a Japanese lost decade at the end. Hopefully after than the post-keynsians might actually be considered by the ivory tower mob. And I really liked the critique on Marx's labour theory of value. I've since seen some rebuttals, and n ...more
Syed Ashrafulla
It's just too much. It's hard to buy a scientific argument without knowing the meanings of all the terms, and this book does not lend itself to those meanings well. The points are actually extremely important, from the destruction of the aggregate supply & aggregate demand curves to the bank-reserve relationship of money supply. If you have recent exposure in economic theory (took the intro to econ class, have an econ spouse), then this book is at least 4 stars. I didn't have that exposure, ...more
Jeremy Trouncer
Mar 01, 2010 Jeremy Trouncer rated it really liked it
Shelves: finance, economics
Interesting but technical book on the shortcomings of neoclassical economics. Would have liked to see more information on the Minsky Debt Delfation theory he Dr Keen champions but I understand this is to be in his next book. Provided a good introduction to alternative economics in particular Austrian Economics, Hyman Minksy and Keynes. Favourite part of the book was lst few chapters which discuss the inefficiency of the stock market and the need for serious reform. See Steve Keen's blog for his ...more
John Schneider
Although I am giving this book five stars, I have to alert any interested readers that this book gets technical. From time to time Prof. Keen will utilize very abstract thinking that will leave some people confused and/or fleeing from the book - he even admits to this by advising the reader to drink some coffee. Having given this major qualification, I must contend that this book is the thorough critique of economics since Marx's "Capital." Unlike Marx, however, Prof. Keen does not foresee a wor ...more
Miguel Buddle
Dec 28, 2015 Miguel Buddle rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Fascinating book. It would have helped to have more of a grounding in economics at even the undergrad level, but slow consumption and re-reading make this possible because of Keen's clear language. My basic takeaway is that all of those things that seem a bit ridiculous about economics (perfectly rational consumers, assumed equilibrium) are actually, provably ridiculous. The why and how was definitely the interesting part here.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 68 69 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
goodreads' description of this book seems to describe another book 1 5 Jan 15, 2014 01:55AM  
  • The Economics Anti-Textbook: A Critical Thinker's Guide to Microeconomics
  • ECONned: How Unenlightened Self Interest Undermined Democracy and Corrupted Capitalism
  • Stabilizing an Unstable Economy: A Twentieth Century Fund Report
  • Never Let a Serious Crisis Go to Waste: How Neoliberalism Survived the Financial Meltdown
  • Zombie Economics: How Dead Ideas Still Walk Among Us
  • The Enigma of Capital and the Crises of Capitalism
  • Monopoly Capital: An Essay on the American Economic and Social Order
  • Economyths: Ten Ways Economics Gets It Wrong
  • The Predator State: How Conservatives Abandoned the Free Market and Why Liberals Should Too
  • Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism
  • The New Industrial State
  • The Making of Global Capitalism: The Political Economy Of American Empire
  • An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx's Capital
  • Butterfly Economics: A New General Theory of Social and Economic Behavior
  • The Body Economic: Why Austerity Kills
  • Filthy Lucre: Economics for People Who Hate Capitalism
  • The ABCs of Political Economy: A Modern Approach
  • The Company of Strangers: A Natural History of Economic Life
54872
Steve Keen is a professor in economics and finance at the University of Western Sydney. He classes himself as a post-Keynesian, criticizing both modern neoclassical economics and Marxian economics as inconsistent, unscientific and empirically unsupported. The major influences on Keen's thinking about economics include John Maynard Keynes, Hyman Minsky, Piero Sraffa, Joseph Alois Schumpeter, and Fr ...more
More about Steve Keen...

Share This Book



“Have you heard the joke about the chemist, physicist and economist who get wrecked on a desert isle, with a huge supply of canned baked beans as their only food? The chemist says that he can start a fire using the neighbouring palm trees, and calculate the temperature at which a can will explode. The physicist says that she can work out the trajectory of each of the baked beans, so that they can be collected and eaten. The economist says "Hang on guys, you're doing it the hard way. Let's assume we have a can opener.” 2 likes
“The position I now favor is that economics is a pre-science, rather like astronomy before Copernicus, Brahe and Galileo. I still hold out hope of better behavior in the future, but given the travesties of logic and anti-empiricism that have been committed in its name, it would be an insult to the other sciences to give economics even a tentative membership of that field.1” 1 likes
More quotes…