109th out of 948 books
—
759 voters
The Colony: The Harrowing True Story of the Exiles of Molokai
by
John Tayman
Beginning in 1866 and continuing for over a century, more than eight thousand people suspected of having leprosy were forcibly exiled to the Hawaiian island of Molokai -- the longest and deadliest instance of medical segregation in American history. Torn from their homes and families, these men, women, and children were loaded into shipboard cattle stalls and abandoned in...more
Paperback, 432 pages
Published
January 9th 2007
by Scribner
(first published 2006)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,109)
May 29, 2011
Lisa Vegan
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
those interested in Hansen’s Disease & its history & its sufferers and in quarantining
I read this because I recently read and adored the novel Moloka'i by Alan Brennert and wanted to learn more about Moloka’i by reading a non-fiction account. I nearly gave this book 5 stars (it’s a definite 4 ½ star book) because it does what it does so impressively. but the fact is I felt as though I got a better feeling of what leprosy was like and how people with the disease were treated from the novel, even though this book covers so much more ground. I was definitely fascinated by some of th...more
I would have liked to read this book in connection with a visit to Molokai. Instead, I started it while on the island of Maui, from where you can look across the open seas to Molokai. Perhaps that "distant view" was more symbolic of this isolation of the leper colony which was located on the island's isolated northern peninsula from 1866 to 1969.
The author presents a sweeping history both of "Hansen's disease" (the modern designation) and its physical impacts, the creation and evolution of the c...more
The author presents a sweeping history both of "Hansen's disease" (the modern designation) and its physical impacts, the creation and evolution of the c...more
Pretty interesting book and a somewhat quick read. I came away with a slightly more sympathetic view towards those who created the colony. I by no means think it was appropriate, but after you read that half of Oahu died of small pox, 5000 died of typhoid, 10000 died of various std's, and one year nearly every new born baby died of influenza, it creates more context for the reader. It's not a simple case of people unreasonably thinking a disease could wipe them all out. Actually, that WAS a reas...more
A very, very dense book--I'm down to the last 20 pages, and it's dragging hard (why I'm writing a review instead of finishing it). Tayman tells a good story, but to some extent sacrifices narrative and style for what can feel like a master list of the exploits of every case of leprosy in America...though I will admit I did enjoy John Early's periodic appearances (if you've read it, you know what I mean), I wish he'd narrowed his focus just a little, or turned down the magnification on his lens....more
This history of the leper colony on Molokai is truly a fascinating read!
Meticulously researched, the historical aspects are backed by mountains of documentation. However, the book reads more like a novel. Tayman includes life stories of several key players, including Father Damien, Mother Marianne, numerous directors and physicians who served the colony,(both good-hearted and greedy) several politicians and Board of Health members and several patients who spent years in exile. He draws informati...more
Meticulously researched, the historical aspects are backed by mountains of documentation. However, the book reads more like a novel. Tayman includes life stories of several key players, including Father Damien, Mother Marianne, numerous directors and physicians who served the colony,(both good-hearted and greedy) several politicians and Board of Health members and several patients who spent years in exile. He draws informati...more
Why did we deprive people of their homes and families? Because no one knew how leprosy was transmitted back in 1860, so it seemed prudent to ship people off to a colony. It was not just in Hawaii that this happened; there were leper colonies all over the world in all times, until the cure, sulfate drugs, were discovered. However, what makes this colony especially abhorrent is the lack of care to the patients once they arrived. They had little or no shelter or medical care for most of their stay....more
Overall I enjoyed this read and would definately recommend it to adult readers. It is a non-fiction piece about the last lepor colony in the United States that wasn't actually shut down until the mid 1960's. It's a very story-based and personal work that honors the memory of the exiles. Tayman has a captivating way of weaving story through facts and is able to cover 100 years without tossing the reader through lists of stats or names. The book was a bit heavy and emotionally overwhelming at time...more
On the surface, this book is about some people, who happened to contract Hansen's disease (leprosy) and how they were taken forcibly from their families and exiled. The deeper story is our human response to physical illness. Leprosy, prior to the 1950's was a terrible, disfiguring and painful disease. Although it is not highly contagious in most forms, the fear surrounding it is both literally and figuratively Biblical. It is both fascinating and disturbing to read about the level of fear and di...more
This is an enjoyable and easy reading book charting the history of the leper colony on Molokai, a sort of popular history of the exiles there. I don't begrudge it these things, and in fact I often marvel at how entertaining some of these historical non-fiction accounts can be. But at heart, I'm a fiction guy, so the few literary devices that Tayman uses make me measure this book up against the best novels I've read, and it's got some big flaws.
I don't mind reconstructed conversation in a non-fic...more
I don't mind reconstructed conversation in a non-fic...more
I first learned of the leper colony in 4th grade while studying the Hawaiian Islands and the story stuck with me. It's a shame that I have always associated Molokai with leprosy because there's so much more to the story than that. John Tayman spells it out here, in this somewhat dry but factual account of the Kalaupapa peninsula, an outcropping of rock off a sheer rock face (incidentally, the island of Molokai is an anomaly in the Hawaiian chain; it's shape suggests a massive explosion may have...more
Regardless of the subtitle, this is not a story: it's a report. One shouldn't try reading this book unless one is truly interested in the story of leprosy and their exile on Molokai. The author is a writer and editor, who researched this topic extensively. Every statement and quote gets a citation in the voluminous notes at the end, although the author says he doesn't give a citation for everything. He will, however, give you a citation for anything if one writes him.
There is just too much infor...more
There is just too much infor...more
The book was hard for me to follow ... I felt like the writer skipped around a lot. Like he would start to write about person A who knew person B, then talk about person B for a while, then jump back to person A and not becuase he was saying things chronologically. It was also hard to keep up with all the people he mentioned ... nonfiction isn't always the easiest to follow, especially when I am used to reading fiction, but this book just seemed harder to follow than normal.
I admit I though it w...more
I admit I though it w...more
Nov 27, 2008
Elizabeth O'Callahan
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
anyone
Recommended to Elizabeth by:
no one
I usually have a hard time getting through non-fiction, but the content was so interesting that I had to keep reading -- fast. The story is sad, but I found fascinating the necessary moral dilemma at the heart of the book: at what point do we deprive those who are dangerous (through no fault of their own) of their homes and families? I tend to agree with quarantine of those with highly contagious and highly destructive diseases, so I can't say I blame the officials for the colony they created. H...more
A fascinating book on many levels. It tells the story of a leprosy settlement on the Hawaiian island of Molokai and focuses on the human element without overlooking the science of the disease and its eventual cure. Robert Louis Stevenson and Jack London appear in the narrative along with some Mormon history and the eventual canonization of two saints who serve many years at the settlement. As the colony comes to an end after a cure to the disease is found there is relevant comparisons to the AID...more
Okay, I finally finished this book, but I really just skimmed the last hundred pages or so. It was nothing but dates and names, and the people began running together after awhile. I couldn't remember who was who, and I know it was nonfiction, but gosh, was it boring. There are ways to make nonfiction interesting, but this guy doesn't know them.
I read some reviews of the books that mentioned controversy--apparently after the book came out, some of the recent people profiled took offense to some...more
I read some reviews of the books that mentioned controversy--apparently after the book came out, some of the recent people profiled took offense to some...more
Revealing the history of leprosy in Hawaii, this books tells a story I had never before heard. The individuals with the disease lived such sad lives for the most part. Later, as better treatments were discovered, their lives began to improve. Sadly, the stigma of the term "leper" never completely dissipated. This book began slowly for me. It became truly interesting about the time Father Damien and Sister Marianne came to the settlement. Prior to that the story was just so tragic. An excelent re...more
This was a fascinating book - the sort that stays with one for a long time.
Strictly speaking, there were some digressions that were a bit meandering and not entirely germane to the narrative - but they were interesting in their own right, so I didn't care.
The other issue (not unique to this book) is the uneasy balance between the carers and the exiles. When the point of view is that of the former, the latter lose their individuality.
But I recommend this book because of the many interesting sto...more
Strictly speaking, there were some digressions that were a bit meandering and not entirely germane to the narrative - but they were interesting in their own right, so I didn't care.
The other issue (not unique to this book) is the uneasy balance between the carers and the exiles. When the point of view is that of the former, the latter lose their individuality.
But I recommend this book because of the many interesting sto...more
Just what the dust jacket promised: this was a fascinating history from both the medical and the personal perspective, full of colorful characters. I had never heard of the Molokai colony before and hadn't even realized that leper colonies ever existed in America. The way the patients were treated early on reminded me very uncomfortably of the Jewish ghettos the Nazis created. Even after conditions improved, the patients still faced hardship and a great deal of prejudice.
The story of the Molokai...more
The story of the Molokai...more
This book WAS AMAZING. riveting. Caused me to ponder the nature of humans and how to be a more selfless and compassionate person. Inspired me to look around for opportunities to reach out to those who are shunned or spurned. The author's descriptions of life on the colony and how it evolved over time and what was accepted as a good idea were unbelievable. Made me think of guantanamo. and refugee camps. after reading this book and passing it on 6 of us got on a plane and headed to Molokai and wen...more
I borrowed this book from our friends, the Harwoods. I liked it even more than the fictional story, Molokai! This work of nonfiction is vivid and griping; its tales are of tragic suffering and persecution, yet also of inspiring love, selflessness and the strength of the human spirit! I really enjoyed learning about this time in Hawaiian history and work that went towards a cure for Hansen's Disease. There was absolutely too much information to learn and remember in one reading, so I definitely w...more
I really enjoyed this book. It really opened my eyes to things I'd never thought about. It's such a commentary on how we treat each other when we're afraid of them. It also highlighted the good that we're capable of, even in the worst situations. The author makes it clear that there were no easy answers to the problem of leprosy, but terrible things were done in the name of public safety. This book was fascinating. It was fun to get to know the people involved, especially the ones who are living...more
The wealth and accuracy of the information and the importance of the underlying messages are undeniable, but the book was written in a noticeably disjointed manner. It wasn't strictly chronological, it wasn't driven by focusing on one historical figure at a time, and it wasn't segmented by larger categories such as survival in the colony, medical advances, political involvement, worldwide comparatives, individual memoirs, etc. This disorganized approach made the book a bit difficult to follow, b...more
I have been looking forward to reading this book for quite some time, since I enjoyed the fictional account "Molokai". When I finished that book, I thought the end was the actual end of the colony/settlement. However, it wasn't. I was surprised to learn that it was on-going during my lifetime. I was also surprised to learn what causes leprosy, and how it was treated in other places in the U.S.
Another surprise was the story of St. Damien is accounted in a portion of the book. I wasn't expecting t...more
Another surprise was the story of St. Damien is accounted in a portion of the book. I wasn't expecting t...more
This book was both informative and heartbreaking.
Due to fear and ignorance these poor people were treated literally like criminals.
They were hunted down and stripped of all their rights.
They were swept up, dropped without ceremony on the island of Molokai, with the full expectation that they would die, and in fact they were considered to be legally dead to the rest of society once they received a diagnosis and then put on a transport ship to the island.
Once on Molokai, they were initially all...more
Due to fear and ignorance these poor people were treated literally like criminals.
They were hunted down and stripped of all their rights.
They were swept up, dropped without ceremony on the island of Molokai, with the full expectation that they would die, and in fact they were considered to be legally dead to the rest of society once they received a diagnosis and then put on a transport ship to the island.
Once on Molokai, they were initially all...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
In 1866, Hawaii was trying to save it's reputation as a beautiful, tropical place to visit and tried to hide the fact that it had a large number of citizens who had leprosy. So in an effort to keep the streets clean, it passed a law where anyone found with the disease would be sent to the island of Molokai, an "almost island" that boasted one small claim, it had the tallest sea cliff in the world. The "patients" were virtually prisoners on the island. There were no landing sites along the island...more
by John Tayman, Backyard BBQ (50 States Challenge)
Themes: illness, superstition, compassion, love, science
Setting: Molokai, Hawaii 1866-1970s
Leprosy. It's a horrible disease. It makes your extremities fall off. It's horribly contagious. It causes nasty oozing sores that spread germs to everyone you pass by. It's always fatal. And there's still no cure.
Except that none of this is true. Except that is a pretty horrible disease, if not treated. But there is a very effective treatment available. It'...more
Themes: illness, superstition, compassion, love, science
Setting: Molokai, Hawaii 1866-1970s
Leprosy. It's a horrible disease. It makes your extremities fall off. It's horribly contagious. It causes nasty oozing sores that spread germs to everyone you pass by. It's always fatal. And there's still no cure.
Except that none of this is true. Except that is a pretty horrible disease, if not treated. But there is a very effective treatment available. It'...more
This is seriously a fantastic book. I consider myself a pretty educated person, not brilliant or anything, but when it comes to American history, there's not a lot that I haven't at least heard about. Until I started doing research on Hawaii (I'm writing a book of my own that takes place there) did I discover this hidden piece of history: the leper colony of Molokai.
John Tayman tells this story vividly and with more detail than any historian could ever ask for. The book itself is filled with dat...more
John Tayman tells this story vividly and with more detail than any historian could ever ask for. The book itself is filled with dat...more
Jul 27, 2008
Sarah
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
People who like history, Hawai'i and medical history
What does it mean to "feel like a leper?" Well, the 4,000 people send to the Kalaupapa peninsula on Molokai island could tell you. The Hawaiian government began sending people with lerosy to Molokai in 1866 and it's clear that original purpose was to exile and forget them. They were sent with no provisions, no building materials and no money to a place that had nothing. They were expected to grow their own food and support themselves but they were sent there in the winter and they were sick!
If t...more
If t...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...



























May 29, 2011 03:58pm
Changed it to 1789 but it might have been even earlier. I'd...more
updated May 29, 2011 05:22pm