Rigoberta Menchu. Leben In Guatemala
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Rigoberta Menchu. Leben In Guatemala

3.64 of 5 stars 3.64  ·  rating details  ·  2,540 ratings  ·  284 reviews
This book recounts the remarkable life of Rigoberta Menchú, a young Guatemalan peasant woman. Her story reflects the experiences common to many Indian communities in Latin America today. Rigoberta suffered gross injustice and hardship in her early life: her brother, father and mother were murdered by the Guatemalan military. She learned Spanish and turned to catechist work...more
Published by Lamuv Verlag GmbH (first published 1983)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Regan
Reading through some of the reviews written by others, I've found that David Stoll's indictment of Menchu for not adhering to the "pure facts" is still alive and well in the academy. There seems to be a tendency to ignore some very important factors that lead to the creation of this book, particularly the genre, testimony, and the nature of memory itself.

Testimony, or testimonio, is a literary genre that in many cases (although certainly not all) involves a testimoniante (one who testifies) and...more
Anna
This book is a memoir of Rigoberta Menchu's childhood and later years in Guatemala as an Indian woman. According to her story, she grew up uneducated in a small community with very strong rules and traditions. Her people, the Indians, were in conflict with the Ladinos (specifically the wealthy) for many years. As a result, her father, mother, and several siblings died.

After reading this book, I found out that she had fabricated many important details in the story. On the very FIRST page, she te...more
Francesca Helm
Had been looking for a book related to Guatemala as am travelling there and this seemed like an obvious one but got totally put off after reading various reviews. After talking to people here in Guatemala, who say despite any inaccuracies (lies critics say) and despite her subsequent political career which is also somewhat controversial here - her book really brought world attention to the Mayan cause and is an incredibly important book to read, I bought it. Though clearly not 'great literature'...more
Rita
In 1983 Elisabeth Burgos met the 23-year-old Rigoberta Menchu and spent a week interviewing her and made that into this book, which is partly autobiography and partly 'testimonial' speaking for the experience of the whole Indian community of Guatemala [[60% of the popul. is pure Mayan, tho divided into 3 language groups and many smaller subgroups:]. [Book transl. into English by Ann Wright.:]

Horrifying how the mountain peasants are exploited by plantation owners on the coasts, living in subhuman...more
David
Oct 27, 2007 David rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: grown ups
Shelves: 10th
one of those books that are sad and leaves nightmares. The book written by Rigoberta Menchu tells the world of the cruelty that went in Guatemala as the "Silent Holocaust", a genocide upon the Indians in Guatemala. The conflict all start off when the new president took land from the rich to give to the poor as a civil rights movement, but a US Fruit company disliked the idea and took the US gov. that communist activity was going on in Guatemala, therefore triggered the genocide...

The peasants (i...more
Max
This book with an incredibly uncreative title is a falsified memoir by Rigoberta Menchu. The book describes a poor family who was forced to work and work until they got fired and then the Guatemalan army came in and destroyed their lives. First, Rigo's brother got killed and tortured in a completely unsituational way, and then her father got killed. After that, her mother was caught and raped. Then, she had to run away to America. This book at first made me feel pity for the narrator but eventua...more
Susan
Read this book a long time ago, when I was in Berkeley in the 1980s, it was kinda de rigeur. Just picked it up again from the bathroom reading pile in the house in Vancouver where I'm renting a room for the year (my new roomie is really active in native radical politics). I hadn't given much thought to the book since I heard the news that Menchu fictionalized certain parts of it, wanted to see if I still found it powerful. I did. Not so much for the politics, which even when I read it the first...more
Ling Juan
This book is about Rigoberta, her family and her community. They were going through a harsh, grief and tragic time. They are Indians that lives high up in a mountain with no fertile lands. Oneday the landowners decided to get back their lands because the Indians started to have crops. Rigoberta and her community thought of traps that will prevent the people from coming into their lands. During this period, a lot of people stuffer from torture and death, including Rigoberta's mom, dad and brothe...more
Suzanne moodhe
I know all about the controversy - did she write the book? Didn't she? The point is that whether or not all of these things happened in particular to this one woman, Rigoberta Menchu, but whether or not they happened to not only her but women that she knew. I believe that this is a collection of events that happened all around her - and having lived in Guatemala for a short period and seen the reconstruction efforts of the Mayan people after the war that was waged on them during the 80's with Jo...more
Jane Mettee
This is the auto biography of an Indian woman who won the Nobel Peace prize in 1992. It tells about her life of severe poverty and harassment, killing and torture, of the Indian people by factions of the Guatemalan government that was engaged in civil war. She devoted her life to resistance and support for her people. She dictated the book to get it into print and get the message out to the world. Tragic but interesting and important message.
K M
It took me longer to get through this than I had anticipated- probably because of the controversy this book stirred regarding the authenticity of some of the contents. I kept putting it down for a few days, trying to decide if I wanted to continue (which I did.) It was a very interesting account of Rigoberta's life in rural Guatemala. She detailed the rich cultural life of her people, including descriptions of many rituals, ceremonies, and practices of the her indigenous group. It was quite inte...more
Derek
I fully recognize that Menchu's voice--conversational, unpretentious, emphatic--is what draws most readers to I, Rigoberta Menchu. At the same time, I found it the most grating aspect of the book, full as it was of contradictions, superlatives, and simply repetitive insistences on the positive aspects of her culture and the crimes committed by her country during the Guatemalan Civil War. Which isn't to say, of course, that I don't think she has every right to tell this story; the crimes she righ...more
Terri Lynn
While I found the story interesting, this is supposed to be Rigoberta Menchu's autobiography and my standard for autobiography is that it should be TRUE and HONEST yet this is nothing but a pack of lies and that taints the story. I had to read this for a graduate school seminar and fortunately the university allowed us to write papers about the controversy rather than accept the book as factual.

A few years after the book came out, David Stoll (he has his doctorate from Stanford University) was...more
Fiona
I once heard Ms Menchu speak at a conference. She was always smiling. How could she smile when she has lived a horrendous life?! So, I wanted to read her story.

This was written in 1982 (give or take a year) during the Guatemala's Civil War. This is her story about living and working in the antiplano (highlands) of Guatemala. It was a tough life. She had no formal schooling and she worked at such a young age. She had no childhood. She worked in the finca's (large estates growing cotton and coffee...more
Ashley
This book is about an Indian women living in Guatemala. This book was ridiculously sad and later I learned that some of the events that took place didn't happen and that she over exaggerated which made me feel so betrayed because she's a liar and I don't like that. This book is an autobiography about her life and the hardships she had to overcome.
Tari
Dec 17, 2013 Tari rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: NO ONE!
Recommended to Tari by: A sociology class
If I could give a book a -, I would. It was most frustrating to read this book for a class knowing that the horror written about was found to be a lie. Yuk! Plus, she won such an honor for a book that was untrue about her life. Pathetic!
Sarah
Really powerful book. Important insight into the struggles and oppression that still exist in modernity. Slavery has not been extinguished.
Jill
This was a very interesting read for me. I started it before I went to Guatemala on a service trip and finished it almost two months after I came home. Before I decided to go on this trip, I knew next to nothing about Guatemala and it's bloody history. I feel a little more enlightened after reading this book, but not much. Since it's told to someone and then translated by another person, I wonder how much is lost in translation. So sometimes its hard to follow what she's talking about because yo...more
Anne
My goodness, the misery that has been heaped upon this woman and all the ethnic Guatemalans. That is my main takeaway from this book: a parade of murders and kidnappings and more prosaic cruelty. Sure, some individual instances might not be strictly factual, but the essence of it is true, and if x didn't happen to Menchú, it probably happened to someone much like her. So in that sense, this oral history is extremely effective and moving, if the goal is to paint a picture of the appalling situati...more
Cathy
Rigoberto tells the story of her life as a native Indian in Guatemala in the 60s and 70s and her activities to try to survive against the wealthy and the government as their land was manipulated away from them. It is sad, terrifying, poignant. The native culture described is incredibly supportive of each community member and very wise in its practices, almost what China was trying to achieve with its Cultural Revolution - everyone working for the good of everyone, but Quiche handle it well. Rigo...more
Kenny
Review on I,Rigoberta Menchu
By: Rigoberta Menchu

This book was absolutely depressing and quite a life for Rigoberta. This explains the life of one of those individuals who would be living in that community. It tells how a girl who have to get married to a boy; when eventually the girl must live up to her responsibilites and so as the child being born. On the other hand, things are not romantic as it seems. Life for Rigoberta was terrible because her mother and father were raped and tortured. Pre...more
Elida
Elida Almaraz
Advisory
Ms. kwan
201-10C

I, Rigoberta Menchu

In the book Rigberta Menchu, by Rigoberta Menchu is about no one other then a woman called Rigoberta Menchu, her biography. Rigoberta at the time was a twenty-three year old Guatemalan woman who wanted to see change in her country. Rigoberta has always struggled as a kid, so did her parents and the rest of her family. Her family and her community have tolerated a lot of discrimination and racism from the land owners, the much lighter skin p...more
Liz
I took an anthropology seminar called Narrative Lives in which the first half of the semester was spent reading 3 life-histories followed by another book that evaluated, or bluntly stated, debunked much of the narrator and interviewer's credibility. I, Rigoberta Menchu was the third life-history we read, and I was completely touched by her eloquent story-telling, and her dreadfully touching and powerful struggle. I remember sitting outside, near done with the book, and dreading reading David Sto...more
Maiga Milbourne
While in Guatemala I brought a copy of "I, Rigoberta Menchu" to better understand the culture, politics, and history of the place I was visiting. It's a beautiful book especially to read while surrounded by the described scenery. I asked many Kakchiquel Maya in the Atitlan region their thoughts on Rigoberta. Many were inspired simply by her incarnation of an Indigenous woman who had shared their struggles on a world stage.

In the capital, the poor were less admiring. Many felt she had abandoned t...more
Charlotte
I, Rigoberta Menchù
An Indian Woman in Guatemala
(1984)
Edited and introduced by Elisabeth Burgos-Debray
Translated by Ann Wright

The story of an Indian woman in Guatemala, the discrimination and racism practised by the Latinos and of the gradual development of her political awareness. Again, like Mi Nombre Es Victoria, this is a book that you only pick up and read if you are particularly interested in the subject matter.

Originally a Spanish transcription of recorded tapes, the text itself is flat a...more
Bookguide
Dit is een heel indrukkend biografie van een (toen) 23-jarige Quiché Indiaan uit Guatemala, opgetekend door een Mexicaanse journaliste toen Rigoberta Menchu ontsnapte naar Mexico. De eerste helft is een iets kinderachtig, geïdealiseerd beeld van het hard maar zalig leven van de Indianen in hun traditionele dorpen. Iedereen moet hard werken, in het huis en op de velden, ook de kinderen, en het leven van de vrouwen is zwaar maar gezellig, en iedereen draagt zorg voor de andere. Ze beschrijft de tr...more
Ian Mchugh
A tragic story of Rigoberta Menchu's life. The narrative is quite disjointed at times but that is mainly due to the way in which editor, Elisabeth Burgos-Debra, decided to present the material she gathered in numerous interviews with Menchu in the early 1980s.
The story of Menchu's life, as recounted here, is a terrible one. An early life of poverty in the Guatamalan hinterland is followed by a growing political awareness and a realisation of the inequality in which she lives. Stories of brutalit...more
kripsoo
I, Rigoberta Menchu" is one of those books which seems to be overshadowed by controversy. A Quiche Mayan woman of Guatemala, Rigoberta Menchu told her story orally to anthropologist Elisabeth Burgos-Debray in Paris in 1982. Burgos-Debray transcribed the story and published in Spanish in 1983; Ann Wright's English translation appeared in 1984. The book, which both gave a voice to the Native American culture of Guatemala and exposed the brutality of Guatemala's civil war, became an international s...more
Xi
This is a great autobiography about this brave and heroine, named Rigoberta Menchu. As an Indian herself, she struggled and fought rights for her people and really made a great accomplishments in her community. She describes a lot of moments about how unequally Indians were treated from the other races. This book will make people to take action to help the Indians. She made the voice of the Indian people heard.
This book gives me a new knowlege about discrimination of different races. I felt si...more
Katherine
Nov 15, 2010 Katherine rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Katherine by: Yeshica
I did read this book already having mixed feelings about her. Even though this book was on my list it was not up there and if it hadn't been for my work colleague, i might have not read this book any time soon. However, I was inspired by my last trip to Guatemala to read it and really am glad that I did.

The beginning was choppy and dry, focused more on describing details of her indigenous culture. Interesting but not easy flow to read. However, once she gets into the story-telling of her family...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Silence on the Mountain: Stories of Terror, Betrayal, and Forgetting in Guatemala
  • Bitter Fruit: The Story of the American Coup in Guatemala (Latin American Studies)
  • Child of the Dark: The Diary of Carolina Maria de Jesus
  • The Massacre at El Mozote
  • Don't Be Afraid, Gringo
  • Empire's Workshop: Latin America, the United States, and the Rise of the New Imperialism
  • The Heart That Bleeds: Latin America Now
  • The Zapatista Reader
  • Stolen Continents: 500 Years of Conquest and Resistance in the Americas
  • Open Veins of Latin America: Five Centuries of the Pillage of a Continent
  • From a Native Daughter: Colonialism and Sovereignty in Hawai'i
  • Bananas, Beaches and Bases: Making Feminist Sense of International Politics
  • The Country Under My Skin: A Memoir of Love and War
  • Born in Blood & Fire: A Concise History of Latin America
  • They Take Our Jobs!: And 20 Other Myths about Immigration
  • Woman At Point Zero
  • The Revolution Will Not Be Funded: Beyond the Non-Profit Industrial Complex
  • Mankiller: A Chief and Her People
I Rigolerta Menchu:  An Indian Woman in Guatemala

Share This Book

“It doesn't mean that I reject everything because I know that things come in their time and when you do things calmly, they work much better.” 3 likes
More quotes…