Gottes Werk und Teufels Beitrag
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Gottes Werk und Teufels Beitrag

4.06 of 5 stars 4.06  ·  rating details  ·  98,902 ratings  ·  2,416 reviews
»Hier in Saint-Cloud’s haben wir nur ein Problem«, schreibt Dr. Wilbur Larch, Amateurhistoriker, Arzt, pessimistischer Philanthrop und Waisenhausvorsteher 193... in sein Miszellenjournal, »und sein Name ist Homer Wells.« Homer Wells ist anders als die andern Waisen, welche von ihren Müttern in dem gottverlassenen Waisenhaus hinter den grünen und nebelverhangenen Hügeln und...more
Paperback, 833 pages
Published 1990 by Diogenes Verlag AG (first published 1985)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Gottes Werk und Teufels Beitrag, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Gottes Werk und Teufels Beitrag

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
I shouldn't be throwing semicolons around too often; and yet, after reading Irving, what do I find myself doing? semicolon, semicolon, SEMICOLON ; ; ; ; I'm not winking at you; those are semicolons.. now you know what I mean. Irving affects me in many ways -- the semicolons are just one example. (And yes, I know I'm probably not using them correctly -- you don't have to point that out. You really don't.)

More than a week after finishing, The Cider House Rules, it's still on my mind, still sneakin...more
Katie Abbott Harris
I just finished reading this novel, and it is so phenominal that I'm almost speechless, and I'm sad that it is over. The story is engrossing, rich, moving, tragic, and satisfying, and the imagery is extraordinarily powerful. The plot takes place during the first half of the 1900's in rural Maine, and tells of Dr. Larch, an obstetrician, founder of an orphanage, abortionist, and ether addict, and his favorite orphan, and heroic figure, Homer Wells. Irving develops the characters superbly, such th...more
Jan 23, 2008 Pamela rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: everyone...
Recommended to Pamela by: Tanja
I was actually really surprised at how much I enjoyed this book. I am VERY Pro-Life and was very skeptical before about picking it up...although I love John Irving as an author. He is excellent at character development and his stories are so multifaceted that you are never disappointed. This is certainly true here in this novel. My surprisingly favorite character was Melony. She was hauntingly creepy, pathetically adorable and demanding of your attention although not a primary character. I loved...more
this may be my favourite john irving book. i like his deceivingly lighthearted style, and the deadpan humour he gives his characters. the cider house rules in particular seems more real than the others, the orphanage and apple orchards seem more tangible, the emotions less idiosyncratic and the characters more human.

the direct issue here is abortion. the medical procedures to, the right to, the choice's enough to make me want to cross my legs to prevent any traffic in or out.

the less dir...more
Jr Bacdayan
In other parts of the world, they love John Green. Here in St. JR's, we love John Irving.

According to my dictionary, Green is of the color of growing foliage, between yellow and blue in the color wheel. While Irving on the other hand, is a genius, hard-working, persevering person who can manage time efficiently; knows how to balance important aspects of life. This has led me to conclude that Irving is a much more suitable name for a writer than Green, and has also solidified my belief that Irvi...more
Aug 31, 2008 Chloe rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Chloe by: Jeremy
I've always struggled with Irving and Cider House Rules is no exception. It's not that Irving is a poor writer, no one can argue that. His characters are always fully-fleshed and alive on the page and each sentence drips with so much detail that you think you're going to get splinters when Homer and Melony are messing around in the abandoned millworker's dorm. I just think that most of the time when I put the book down I feel like I've read the equivalent of cotton candy: really pretty but not m...more
Cathy DuPont
Fortunately all readers all the time do not like the same book. (Just finished a book of the bestsellers the past century and publishers do not favor that opinion.) Tastes and opinions differ which, of course, is a good thing.

There are a handful of books though which I simply love because of the way the author uses the English language and/or the story itself and how it unfolds. Other times there's just that "indescribable something" which makes me love a book. This book which made the bestsell...more
I started the Cider House Rules after giving up on 3 novels that just couldn't hold my attention.
John Irving will certainly make you love reading again. The Cider House Rules is once again a novel rich with characters so real you forget this is fiction and you care about what happens to them.
Why can I only say that about a mere handful of writers?

This is a novel about abortion in the 1940s. The dilemmas of abortion are obvious, and this novel does lean towards pro-choice. I think pro-lifers woul...more
I love John Irving but stayed away from this work for years because of the "abortion" issue. I didn't want to be preached to, (in principle I am against abortion) and I foolishly underestimated Irving's ability to create a complete work, one in which "abortion" was a small part. This is one of his finest works and I recommend it without reservation. Irving forces the reader to view the world from many angles and does it with his usual excellence in creating characters with depth and a plot that...more
Richard Reviles Censorship Always in All Ways
Rating: 5* of five

My very favorite John Irving book is a $1.99 Kindle Daily Deal today. So very worth the tiny cost.
Oct 25, 2009 Leah rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Leah by: Viluna Jennings
Shelves: favorites
I finally finished The Cider House Rules this morning; I've been working on it since mid-August. Usually if I take that long to read a book it's because the book isn't very good, I've gotten bored with it, or the writing is hard to comprehend. None of those things are true of The Cider House Rules. Instead I found the book to be wonderfully written with rich and complex characters (not to mention a moving and controversial storyline). I think the main reason I took so long to finish it (aside fr...more
November 2009
What is hardest to accept about the passage of time is that the people who once mattered the most to us are wrapped up in parentheses.
(The Cider House Rules, p. 429)

In 19__, when abortion was still illegal (when women who did not want their babies were criminals; when pregnancy was a sentence and a fine), there were still ways to avoid the accident of birth: there were medicines and various chemicals to gamble with, or else there were grim back-room doctors, butchers, and other shad...more
What I love about John Irving's novels is how they chronicle ordinary people living mostly ordinary lives, but somehow manage to come off as great, sweeping epics. I don't know how he does it - The Cider House Rules contains no epic journeys, no great battles, no romances for the ages, and no heroes. It's an ordinary story, but Irving's writing makes it seem just as incredible and important as The Odyssey.

Maybe it's the time span - the book covers a period of over 50 years, and centers on two c...more
Christopher Green
I really can't stand John Irving's style of writing. This was a six hundred page novel that should have been three hundred. Also, I found it to be a little heavy-handed. He admits that it is deliberately didactic, but I think he pushes it the the point that it starts working against him. Any character opposing his ideals is put up as a two-dimensional straw man that he villainizes and knocks down, which doesn't help convince anyone of his views. I was surprised to learn that he wrote the screenp...more
Over all a pretty crappy book. There were some good points. There were some very powerful and strong characters, and then some really flat see-through personalities. Ultimately the book had a very good point. Everyone makes rules, and as people we have to pick which ones we follow and which ones we don't. Should we follow rules? Should we make our own rules? How relevant and practical are actual rules in the real world? More specifically, how relevant are ant-abortion laws? As the readers we tak...more
While The Cider House Rules is an undeniably well-written novel, I grew impatient with the lengthy narrative and the idle characters. It was hard for me to feel any sense of connection to the different characters, and I cared very little about Homer's life at Ocean View - I was always anxious to get back to St. Cloud's and the orphanage. For me, the real story was about the relationship between Dr. Larch and Homer Wells, and I lost interest in the story once Larch and Homer ceased to communicate...more
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” ― Edmund Burke"

In what many consider John Irving's masterwork, we're asked to consider abortion and the rights of society in imposing laws on its citizens. Even the title, The Cider House Rules is an allusion to this idea of rules and the authority to impose them. The Cider House Rules were posted by well intentioned people who didn't live in the cider house and who didn't really understand what life there was like...more
John Irving might just be my favorite contemporary author. No current author can move me with their storytelling quite as capably as he.

I picked up this book to read on a recent trip to New England, specifically Maine and New Hampshire. I had previously seen the movie and I knew that the story was set in the land of lobsters and blueberries. Although I had enjoyed the movie version quite a bit, I enjoyed the book infinitely more. Indeed, the character of Melony, who is absent from the movie, may...more
Oct 08, 2007 Jennifer rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Most bookworms
Cider House Rules started fairly slow, but I found myself engrossed in it more and more as I waded through. The novel focuses largely on the issue of abortion and often confronts the main points with such bald truth that it can feel a little harsh. The story itself isn't as predictable as many novels in this sort of genre, and I found myself really wondering how everything would turn out in the end. I found the moral dilemmas very intriguing and it actually made me evaluate my own beliefs in the...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jul 25, 2007 Belinda rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: anyone who is speculative about others
Like "A Prayer For Owen Meany," one to make you reflect on yourself and the world around you, while you laugh, cry and everything in between. Irving's skill with manipulating the English language for effect has never been more in evidence.
Scarlett Rains
The Cider House Rules by John Irving provides insight into the painful, politically charged, topic of abortion. Homer, an abandoned orphan, is the champion of life and finds the idea of abortion repugnant. Wilbur, the surgeon Homer considers father and mentor, feels passionately that a woman must have the right to choose. Each man sways us.

The emotional devastation wrought by the abandonment of unwanted children is sensitively told. We imagine the orphans waiting for adoptive parents, listening...more
Questa è una storia di formazione, ma non solo. È la storia di una vita, di una presa di coscienza. A cosa servono le regole? C'è differenza tra quelle imposte e quelle morali?
Homer Wells è cresciuto nell'orfanotrofio di St.Cloud's, e rimarrà sempre un orfano, malgrado tutte le persone che lo amano e malgrado abbia trovato, ormai adulto, una famiglia con cui vivere. Un orfano ha bisogno di sicurezza, di certezze, ma l'eterna condanna umana è "aspettare, poi si vedrà".
Una galleria di personaggi i...more
This is the third of Irving's novels I've read (the other two being The World According to Garp and A Widow for One Year), and I think I'm about done with Irving now. None of those three books were outright bad, but each one started with such promise and ultimately ended up disappointing me.

Irving is really skilled at writing about tragedy, awkwardness, sexual entanglements, and grief, in particular. He has a gift for describing emotions, dialogue, and social interaction extremely realistically....more
A Prayer for Owen Meany made me want to read more from John Irving. While I know I have seen pieces of the movie, it was barely enough to be worth mentioning. This book was a little slow at first, but I've discovered this is because he takes extra steps in developing his characters and setting the stage for their intertwined lives (a theme in the other Irving books I've since read). Ultimately I want to see the movie now for comparison because the book was just so damn good. Very raw and dark at...more
Loved it like I loved The World According to Garp. Anybody else ever confuse John Updike with John Irving from time to time? Whoops.

Homer Wells is an orphan at St. Clouds, where Wilbur Larch is giving safe, illegal abortions to women and delivering unwanted babies. I still cannot say exactly where I stand on abortion - I waver back and forth. Of course, CHR makes a case for abortion rights based on incest, and an alternative of chemicals and coat hangers. Which is really the only case for it. B...more
my first irving novel----how late i came to irving! this novel is full of secrets that you only start to see in hindsight as you reflect on what you've read. irving's depictions of relationships are uniquely complex and full of mysteries that draw me in as a reader and force me to take a very close look. irving is a master of gestures and nuances in novels that can feel, if you aren't reading carefully, like simply a series of short, small actions.

what is extraordinary to me in irving is how mu...more
Amy Neftzger
This is an outstanding book that was thoughtfully put together to examine the role and meaning of rules, including civil and moral law as it applies to abortion. The issues are artfully addressed in the complexity of real life situations of an orphanage and an apple orchard in rural Maine that includes the time period of WWII. Irving creates such great characters that the reader comes to care about them -- even some of the most unlikeable ones.

The author does a wonderful job of showing how easy...more
This is a good book with a good story. However, it is not one of my favorite of John Irving's novels. There is a sexual scene with a woman and a horse that set me off guard somewhere near the beginning of the novel. I also had a difficult time with Doctor Larch's ether addiction as well as his unreasonable and almost psycho obsession with Homer Wells. The graphic abortion scenes were also not very pleasant for me. I think that the writing of John Irving is still commendable however the tone of t...more
There was not a moment that this book was not on my mind. Whether your view is for or against abortion does not matter, this book presents a view point, a way of life/thinking for a character in a book. It is a novel that should be read in order for those against and for to gain a better understanding of abortion and the thought of one man. Yes, I know that this book is a novel, but it is written so well that Irving was able to truly create a character that is believable and likable no matter wh...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Around the World ...: Discussion for The Cider House Rules 6 37 Aug 30, 2014 07:20PM  
Why 192_? 4 61 Apr 02, 2014 07:11PM  
Goodreads Italia: Le regole della casa del sidro di John Irving - Commenti e discussione 32 109 Oct 27, 2013 09:01AM  
The Cider House Rules = Kindle daily deal 2/21/13 4 61 Feb 21, 2013 04:40PM  
Who Thinks Tobey Maguire Was the Best Actor for this Character? 25 128 Jan 03, 2013 10:21PM  
did anyone else start to get angry at homer? 1 51 Dec 01, 2012 07:15PM  
The importance of the title 2 95 Feb 09, 2012 09:19PM  
  • Nobody's Fool
  • The Lords of Discipline
  • The Shipping News
  • The Last Picture Show
  • Breathing Lessons
  • Cold Mountain
  • Animal Dreams
  • Cat's Eye
  • Billy Bathgate
  • The Road to Wellville
  • The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys
  • Sophie's Choice
  • The Graduate
  • Snow Falling on Cedars
  • Fortune's Rocks
John Irving published his first novel, Setting Free the Bears, in 1968. The World According to Garp, which won the National Book Award in 1980, was John Irving’s fourth novel and his first international bestseller; it also became a George Roy Hill film. Tony Richardson wrote and directed the adaptation for the screen of The Hotel New Hampshire (1984). Irving’s novels are now translated into thirty...more
More about John Irving...
A Prayer for Owen Meany The World According to Garp The Hotel New Hampshire A Widow for One Year The Fourth Hand

Share This Book

“What is hardest to accept about the passage of time is that the people who once mattered the most to us wind up in parentheses.” 465 likes
“Goodnight you princes of Maine, you kings of New England.” 172 likes
More quotes…