The Historian

The Historian

3.71 of 5 stars 3.71  ·  rating details  ·  123,486 ratings  ·  10,715 reviews
Some stories can be told again in endlessly different ways. Elizabeth Kostova's The Historian combines a search for the historical Dracula with a profound sense that Stoker got some things right--that the late Mediaeval tyrant kills among us yet, undead and dangerous. From Stoker, she also takes a sense that the supernatural seems more real when embedded in documentary evi...more
Mass Market Paperback, 816 pages
Published January 2006 by Back Bay Books (first published April 1st 2003)

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Sparrow
Aug 01, 2009 Sparrow rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Henry James Fans
Recommended to Sparrow by: Laura Rice said not to read it. She was right.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Elizabeth
Dear Little, Brown, and Company,

You know what you get if you type the words seventeenth century dutch trade ottoman empire into google?

You get tulips.

Before you give another author a two million dollar advance for a book, please make sure that the author has done the most basic research on topics that she brings up over and over again.

Best Regards,
Elizabeth, not even a historian


I lose it all the time over authors who pick up on some idea and with very little information run away with it. Do yo...more
J
This novel is better than I had any anticipation of it being. I’d seen it among a friend’s luggage then later saw it at the library. Having just come off three weeks of nineteenth century novelists, I thought, Oh, something light would be a nice change. After all, I thought. Vampires. The book is about vampires. And not just any vampire, but the mack daddy himself, Dracula, the real Vlad the Impaler, who turns out to be the undead.

Light reading. Sure. Six hundred and fifty pages of vampires that...more
Elizabeth
Nov 24, 2007 Elizabeth rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: insomniacs and very bored librarians
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Martha
Aug 09, 2008 Martha rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: compulsive letter writers and dull historians
This has got to be one of the most disappointing books I've read in a long time. Although the descriptions of the various eastern European cities are often pretty and atmospheric, my frustration with this book won't let me mark it above one star.

It starts out well; very interesting and suspenseful for about the first 100 pages or so. But as you read it, the book just gets more and more ridiculous. It's about 600 900(!) pages long (which is way, way too long) and I urge anyone reading this book t...more
Gena
The Historian

By Elizabeth Kostova


Kostova received two million dollars for this debut novel, an almost unheard of sum for an unknown writer, but I’m sure it went a long way in reimbursing her expenses for the research that would have been required to write The Historian. Make no mistake, this is a lush and beautiful book, each passage is fleshed out in detail reminiscent of the grand medieval cathedrals and libraries in which it takes place. The reader is drawn into the past quickly and presented...more
Stacey
It has been some time since I read this, so my recollections may not be that accurate. I tend to make these decisions (do I like or not like a book?) viscerally, rather than by formula. But I figured that any book that merited my little used "pissed me off" category, deserved an explanation.


The Historian:
Kostova sets her book partly in the 70s, partly in history, and she tries to write in a flowery language, like the great masters of novel from the 19th century- but to me, she really just comes...more
Alex Telander
THE HISTORIAN BY ELIZABETH KOSTOVA: Welcome to a retelling of Dracula for the twenty-first century, only think much better and more interesting; less of the weak and pitiful women and demanding men; more history and research. Elizabeth Kostova, while no doubt being a very well off person who went to the best schools for writing, has nevertheless spent a long time researching and writing The Historian with the resulting book being little about vampires and undead and more about books and history...more
Sabrina
Feb 08, 2008 Sabrina rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: no one
Wow, was I ever disappointed in this one! I initially read the dust jacket on one of my many excursions to the book store and was very excited. It had been a long time since I read a really good scary story with vampires. The dust jacket alluded to sleepless nights filled with suspense and horror. I eagerly bought my very own copy and returned home to crawl into bed and begin reading this tale of terror.

Okay, so sometimes books have to start slow. You've got to get the setting right, introduce...more
StoryTellerShannon
Tale focuses on whether Dracula truly still exists in vampire/undead form.

Most of the tale is told through backstory and letters. In itself, this is quite a feat for a novel.

People who appreciate History as well as a mystery with esoteric/intellectual sprinklings will most likely find this tale appealing. There is a great deal of focus on academic types and their personalities as well, so, be sure you want to spend time with such characters.

I found it quite entertaining, and, even though I sk...more
Michelle
Jun 23, 2007 Michelle rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Everyone
Shelves: bookclub
This is actually the second time I've read this book. For a first novel, it is outstanding. I was completely engrossed in the story. I really love history and the whole Dracula lore. I thought it was a great mix of both. It added a lot of suspense that made me read it with the lights on. I think I read it in about four days, I just couldn't put it down. I will say this though, if you are not really into history or researching, I would skip it. If you are wanting to read it just because it has to...more
Josh
Aug 15, 2008 Josh rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Torturers, both medieval and contemporary
Tentatively, my hand crept towards the mouse. What dark and unholy specter could be contained in other people's reviews of Elizabeth Kostova's The Historian?

I was filled with passive-voiced dread as the link was clicked by me. I was horrified to read:

xdragonlady's review:
"My main problem with the book being that the author told the tale from so many different points of view, but that they were each told in first person without giving the reader any notice as to who was telling the tale. [...] I...more
K.D. Oliveros
Nov 28, 2012 K.D. Oliveros rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to K.D. by: GR-TFG 100 Favorite Books (2011)
The first third of the book is boring. The action builds up only on the second. The third is exceptional. It seemed to me that Kostova saved the best for last. Considering that this is her first novel, I would like to think that she still has a lot to offer.

I found the first third boring because of the basic premise: that Dracula and/or his cohorts, Vlad the Impaler to be specific are still alive. What triggers this is the book that is found in the bookshelves of a university professor who has a...more
Jason Pettus
(Reprinted from the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography [cclapcenter.com]. I am the original author of this essay, as well as the owner of CCLaP; it is not being reprinted here illegally.)

So first, a disclosure: I actually received a free used copy of Elizabeth Kostova's 2005 modern vampire tale The Historian unexpectedly in the mail one day, from author Akmal Shebl at the same time he sent in his own book Prisoners in Paradise for review, not as a bribe I think but rather an example o...more
Kirsten
Don't let the 2 star rating fool you - I would still recommend this book for fun. POSSIBLE SPOILERS AHEAD.

It strikes me that scholars and graduate students (even sexier!) are now the go-to heroes for this continuing genre of suspenseful historical/mystery/magic quests. Da Vinci Code blah blah blah. That's right, to save the world, one must be a careful reader, and in this book, it struck me as especially humorous that in his infinite evil, Dracula infiltrates the minds of those who can truly com...more
Moderatrix Lori
Jan 14, 2010 Moderatrix Lori marked it as abandoned  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: people who enjoy watching paint dry
I really wanted to like this book but God is it boring as hell. I hate not finishing a book but I just can't waste one more minute reading something akin to watching paint dry. I kept waiting for the story to take off and for something, anything, exciting to happen. This felt like an exercise in cold war geography and a self-indulgent author letting us know how smart she is and how much research she'd done. Who cares?! The premise for this book was really intriguing but the story gets lost in pa...more
Nicole
The research was admirable, although I question the author's decision to include certain historical documents, rather than interpreting them for the reader. I get it, I get it, the book is called The Historian, because the main characters are all historians and that's why she chose to include too much detail. Duh. Nevertheless, there were too many moments where I felt bogged down in a swamp of wordiness rather than feeling like I was effortlessly swimming through brilliant prose.

It had so much...more
Rachel
so here's the thing. I really didn't hate this book and I wanted to for some reason. in fact, I kept thinking that I loved it but that it was the kind of love that you keep secret from everyone who cares about you because they will fear that you have gone off the deepend and are going to follow the object of your affection into his plot to hold a bank full of people hostage.

I have become an eastern/central europe-phile over the past year. those parts of this book I adored. she describes place be...more
Lara
This book reminded me of the DaVinci code in some ways, but was much more interesting and better written. All of the research and historical documents were fascinating. I was especially interested in the subject matter, because it was about Vlad Ţepeş, the Wallachian (Romanian) prince, who Bram Stoker popularized as Dracula. (Not because I'm interested in vampires, but because I served my mission in Romania and was interested in Vlad himself. Evil and terrible as he was, the Romanians actually a...more
Jackie "the Librarian"
I'm disappointed. I wanted to love this book soooo much. I love vampire stories, and I loved Dracula, with its long expository letters and journal entries. I love the idea of historians being drafted by Dracula. But I didn't love this book.
Why? Well, let me tell you:
1)I was annoyed by the fact that we never learn the name of the main character. No, I didn't think that was intriguing. I thought it was annoying.
2) The historic research was dry dry dry, and I dreaded seeing section after section w...more
Parvathy
1.5 stars

Confused is the one word that describes this book. Who is more confused the characters or the readers, I am not sure. Maybe it is my ignorance that made this book reading venture unsatisfying, but in my defence I was not aware that I had to brush up on some history before diving in to this book. The writing was confusing and the descripitions so unnecessary that I was leafing through the pages like a mindless puppet most of the time. Reading for the sake of reading, that was what
I was...more
Jackie
It has all the promise of a great novel. Reading the jacket I couldn't wait to get started. Unfortunately, it didn't excite me, or thrill me or even hold my interest. It was an utter disappointment. Touted as a most suspenseful novel, I kept waiting for the suspense to begin.
One of my biggest pet peeves is long winded commentaries on something that has nothing to do with furthering the plot. And this book did that entirely too much for my liking.
I can bear it if I must, if it has something to do...more
Maurean
It took me the better part of three weeks to complete this 642-page novel – that, I believe, is the longest it has ever taken me to complete a book that I was reading strictly for pleasure. Not that this is, necessarily, a bad thing, that is just to say it is not a “light” reading.

As a reader, did I enjoy it? Well…yes, I think so, but I’m still debating myself in just how much; either I found it rather mediocre, or utterly brilliant, I just haven’t settled on which..

The storylines contain all of...more
Brooke
Jun 12, 2007 Brooke rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: historians
Shelves: 2007, own, horror
What if Vlad Ţepeş, Prince of Wallachia and the inspiration for Bram Stoker's Dracula, really was a vampire? Elizabeth Kostova's The Historian explores this question, following three different characters: in the 1930s, Bartholomew Rossi, an English professor, in the 1950s, his protégé Paul, and in the 1970s, Paul's unnamed daughter. Mysterious books and Rossi's disappearance spark a hunt for Dracula's tomb that crisscrosses Europe and lets Kostova use a buttload of historical and geographical re...more
Jennifer Graham
Cold war era vampires, you say? A postmodern Gothic? An examination of Carpathian politics and post-colonialism? An intellectual thriller? Vlad the Impaler plus Dracula, secret societies, musty old tomes, evil librarians? All of these promises got me in the door. It sounded like my kind of book exactly.

The problem is the book seems to lack the focus to truly follow any one of these promises to completion (except the evil librarians; those are actually pretty amusing). The thrills of this thrille...more
Jason Huffman-black
I really need to give a reason that this book received such a low rating from me.

First, I want to say that the majority of the book was amazing. It was mysterious, and the descriptions were vivid. the author pulled me totally into this story. This book is over 700 pages and I rushed through it to find out what the great mystery was...only to be disappointed by a silly and rushed ending. I felt so robbed that I was tempted to throw this massive book but knew it would do a great deal of damage.

I...more
Eileen
If there were negative stars, I would give them to this book. OMG, words fail me.

On second thought..they don't. Let me describe the ways this book sucked.

First off, it sucked because it COULD have been a brilliant book....its IN there...somewhere in the 642 pages. I would venture to say....its about 300 pages too long. At page 201 into the book, it was still plodding along unmercifully.

They way it is written, in first person, is way too choppy. Some chapters are being told by the "dad" characht...more
Ricky
Jan 08, 2009 Ricky rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Ricky by: Kenci, Dad, Jenn
I wanted to like this book, especially after it was talked up so much by Jenn and Kenci.

Alas, liking this book was not to be...

It was a love hate-relationship, mostly hate. This book wanted to tell me the story of a "real" vampire, but mostly the book got bored and decided instead it wanted to talk about ancient Arabic tapestries. Of course to some, the Ottoman empire might be the most awesome thing ever, unfortunately it only seemed to act as the dirt under which a really good vampire story wa...more
Blair
Meandering, slogging, hair-pulling, mess of a read. The Da Vinci code on crack-cocaine. This book needs to lose some weight. The book started off paced really well but quickly lost steam. The SLLLOOOWWW build up dies in the arms of the final pages, thankfully. By the end of this novel? historical fiction? university dissertation on the Ottoman invasion of the Byzantine empire as seen through the eyes of Dracula enthusiasts? I was ready to be staked through the heart. The one good point was that...more
Jessica
This book had a weird, dreamy quality that I enjoyed . . . up to a point. The narrarator was a bit too schoolgirlish after a while, and I enjoyed that you never knew her name, even though they hinted at it. I was a bit baffled by the "stinger" ending, though.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
There's No Worse Thief than a Bad Book 292 1987 Jun 17, 2013 06:53am  
Geek Girl Pen Pals : The Historian 4 19 Jun 11, 2013 11:15am  
Chaos Reading: THE HISTORIAN--Theo's Challenge 15 73 May 21, 2013 11:38am  
Favorite aspect of the book. 1 30 May 14, 2013 11:17am  
Next book 16 295 Apr 30, 2013 07:56am  
Movie? 19 186 Apr 10, 2013 08:25pm  
The Historian (Paperback)
The Historian (Hardcover)
The Historian (Paperback)
The Historian
The Historian (Paperback)

5918
Elizabeth Johnson Kostova is an American author. She a graduate of Yale University and holds an MFA from the University of Michigan, where she won the Hopwood Award for the Novel-in-Progress.

Her first novel, The Historian, was published in 2005, and it has become a best-seller.

More about Elizabeth Kostova...
The Swan Thieves L'historienne et Drakula, Tome 2 L'historienne et Drakula, Tome 1 Frankenstein Dracula

Share This Book

Your website
“It was good to walk into a library again; it smelled like home.” 305 people liked it
“When you handle books all day long, every new one is a friend and a temptation.” 286 people liked it
More quotes…