In the Path of Falling Objects

In the Path of Falling Objects

by
3.82 of 5 stars 3.82  ·  rating details  ·  264 ratings  ·  76 reviews
Jonah and his younger brother, Simon, are on their own. All they have left in the world is ten dollars, a backpack full of dirty clothes, and a stack of letters from their older brother, who’s fighting in the war. They’re on their way to Arizona when they catch a ride from a couple. The girl is friendly—and beautiful. But the man is different, maybe dangerous, maybe deadly...more
Paperback, 352 pages
Published October 12th 2010 by Square Fish (first published September 22nd 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 769)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Kelly
Mar 27, 2009 Kelly rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Any reader 12 and up.
Shelves: top-of-the-heap
From page one, Andrew Smith's new novel IN THE PATH OF FALLING OBJECTS takes the reader by the throat and holds on tight. Maybe that's an exaggeration. And maybe it implies reading the book is not a good experience, which isn't true. So let me rephrase. Smith's new novel hits the ground running, thanks to the vulnerability of his protagonist Jonah (and his younger brother), and the brutal intensity of the story's psychotic villian, Mitch (who looks, in my imagination, like Charlie Manson, perhap...more
Kwesi 章英狮
Jun 16, 2012 Kwesi 章英狮 rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Kwesi 章英狮 by: LadysBookStuff.blogspot.com
Shelves: owned, andrew-smith, 2012
Sneering Imperialist
Siiii~iiiigh.
After purchasing the Marbury Lens, which is also by Andrew Smith, Amazon recommended In the Path of Falling Objects to me, because hey, Smith’s written other books, you know. Well, I’ll be blunt and admit I bought Falling Objects when I was only six chapters into Marbury. If you by chance happened to read that review, this reasoning will make sense. If you haven’t, long story short, I was impulsive. I had money and I needed to spend it, and Andrew Smith was lucky enough to be around...more
Syndey
..."Our brother fell apart in the war.
Mother fell apart after that.
Then we had to leave."...


I don't think that Andrew Smith can write a novel that I wouldn't love. He has a unique writing style that is all his own. In The Path of Falling Objects is Andrew Smith's 2nd novel that I've read to date.

In the very beginning of the story we get a huge shocker, then we are left to let it digest for a little bit. I think Smith likes to wow us with an introduction like that. The kind that just kind of sne...more
Cornmaven
This book is extremely complex, and will have a small young adult audience, but it's well worth the read. A road trip/Shakespearean tragedy of epic proportions would be a good description. Smith's writing style is fabulous, with tons of descriptive passages that are very detailed but not overly long. You really feel as if you are there on the journey.

The final scenes come in short bursts and build the tension very well. The reflective final paragraphs leave much to discuss.

This has an element of...more
Kat
The year is 1970, and brothers Jonah and Simon are hitting the road and heading west. Their negligent mom has taken off, their dad is in jail, and their oldest brother Matthew is MIA in Vietnam. When their horse dies on the side of the road, all they have left is each other, some letters from their brother, and a gun buried under some dirty clothes in their pack. While making their way across the desolate Southwest, the brothers end up in a Lincoln convertible with a metal statue of Don Quixote,...more
Tabitha Olson
In The Path of Falling Objects is sharp and gripping, and I read it nearly in one sitting. The two main characters are very realistic, and such brothers. I have two boys who are close in age (granted, they are 4 and 6, not 14 and 16), but they behave in very similar ways that Jonah and Simon behave. They’re close, but can fight something fierce. So I identified with Jonah and Simon right away.

Actually, all the characters are vivid and fully-developed. It’s clear Lilly is in it for survival, and...more
Donna Burtwistle-Popplewell
Smith has written a terrifying tale that sees two teenaged brothers leaving their home in New Mexico during the late-1960s to go to Arizona to find their father, who has been released from prison. Forced to go through the desert on foot, they are somewhat relieved when they are picked up by a couple heading to California. Brother, Jonah, immediately suspects the couple of wrongdoing and tries to convince his younger brother, Simon, that they should leave. However, Simon is sick of being bossed a...more
Julie Hucke
An engaging read that suffers from a lack of organization. In the end, I had to wonder how some of the elements of the story contributed to the overall brothers' journey/coming of age story. Smith's writing is lush and beautiful throughout; there are so many lyrically beautiful sentences that the book is worth reading just for them. However, it's hard to see by what right the narrator was able to wield those sentences. Loner poor kid/artist I get, but too often, what could have been emotionally...more
Angie
Two brothers of a mother who ran off, a father who's in jail in a nother state, and an older brother who enlited and went to fight in Vietnam, decide to take the family horse and travel to Arizona to see their father when he gets out of jail. The horse dies shortly after the trip starts and teh rest is downhill from there for Jonah and Simon. They get picked up by a beautiful girl and a psychopath, and spend the next several interminable days on the road to hell.

Interspersed with the dreadful a...more
Ricki
Phew. If you want a book that is going to make you incredibly uncomfortable and nervous, I highly recommend this one! This book is absolutely frightening. I couldn't stop reading it, but I found it to be very disturbing, and I don't think I can recommend it to students because the violence was a bit excessive to me. I limit authors to one animal killing per book (not three). There were murders of innocent people, throat slashings, etc. I was shocked when I made the connection that this is the sa...more
Bridget
I was torn about how many stars to give this book. I wavered between three and four. Smith is an expert craftsman at slowly revealing plot and content. The tension of wanting the story to explode is almost unbearable. The end of the story certainly does explode.

I had very strong feelings about all of the characters. I could picture them and reacted to what they said and did. I thought their dialgoue was not always consistent though.

The story was dark and the topic was a definite break from Ghos...more
Dodie
Smith delivers another stunningly intense story, following up on his debut novel, Ghost Medicine. Two brothers, 16 and 13 years old, abandoned by their mother, set out on a road trip to find their father who is soon to be released from prison. Their older brother Matthew is serving in Vietnam, and through his letters home, readers see his life unraveling as the list of atrocities he's experiences grows. These letters parallel a similar falling apart by the two brothers who have hitched a ride wi...more
Erika
This is a tense novel that grabs you on the first page, but comes to a slow boil. You keep reading because you want to find out what Mitch did and what he's going to do. Once the action starts it's hard to put the book down. Considering the level of violence in the novel I'd rate this for 15 and up.

My only criticism is that sometimes it's difficult to figure out who the narrator is in the book. At first I thought it was shifting from one character to another, but it appears to be from Jonah's po...more
Jennifer
Jonah and Simon are brothers on a search to find their brother, whom they believed escaped from the Vietnam War and is now back in America. When the brothers leave their home, they hitch a ride with Mitch and Lilly. So begins a bloody, violent and disturbing road trip.

Mitch's character is a well-developed sociopath and the brothers' sibling rivalry feels real and honest. I only wish the character of Lilly was a bit more developed. She felt more like a device to move the plot along rather than a...more
Terri
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Lottie Eve
In the Path of Falling Objects made me feel, in a word, dusty. Not the itchy-dust kind of dusty, but the kind of dusty where one feels like they are in a desert, in the presence of miles and miles of sand. With the hot, burning sun on their back. That’s the kind of dusty I felt when I was reading this. The genuine, realistic kind of dusty. Does that make sense? I hope so.

This is a story following the journey of Jonah and his younger brother, Simon. The boys are on their own and had run away from...more
Starr Griggs
In the Path of Falling Objects by Andrew Smith

Feiwel and Friends – Sept 29, 2009
http://ghostmedicine.blogspot.com/
Facebook: Yes
Twitter: @marburyjack
Source: Own
Rating: Excellent and emotional read


I participated in the Andrew Smith Saturdays, hosted by: Roof Beam Reader, Not Now I'm Reading, Smash Attack Reads and Lady Reader's Bookstuff


Jonah and Simon has had a pretty hard life. Their older brother, Matthew, is deployed in the Vietnam War. Their father is in a prison and their selfish mother ha...more
Smash
Courtesy of Smash Attack Reads

First Impressions:

"Our brother fell apart in the war.
Mother fell apart after that.
Then we had to leave."


Wow. This book opens up on a bleak scenario.Simon and Jonah are up shits creek, so to speak. Ma is gone, dad is incarcerated, older brother, Matthew, is in Vietnam fighting for his country. These two are as poor as dirt and Jonah has decided it is time to leave and find their father. They set out with $10 in their pocket, some tattered clothes and Matthew's lett...more
Jo
I have a sneaking suspicion that Andrew Smith reads my reviews.

Actually, OK, that’s definitely a lie. That probably… fine definitely doesn’t happen.

But all I’m saying is that it’s a massive coincidence that he knows all the things that I harp on about wanting to be featured more in YA books and writes stories about them.

He must have seen all the not-so-subtle pleadings I’ve had with authors to write books about road trips (and not just ones girls take with a mysterious boy in a leather jacket wh...more
Kenaia
I honestly don't know whether to hate or love this book. It's vividly, gruesomely written. It is the ONLY book in my memory that has left me nauseous and not wanting dinner. It is also one of the few books I've read with such amazing make-you-sit-up-straight-and-read-for-hours qualities, like it's amazing descriptions and the way you sort of see into everyone's mind. It was unique, it was original... but it was also terrifying. It was magnificent. It was terrible. It is a book I strongly encoura...more
Warnie B.
Andrew Smith. I seriously don't know how this guy does it.

I've now read every book of his that's been published so far, and I've been forced to rate every one of them five stars. I might as well just go ahead and rate all the books he hasn't published yet five stars as well, cause it's kind of inevitable.

Anyway, what to say about this one... I mean, the tagline (Two brothers. One road trip from hell.) will definitely give you a hint, but makes it sound like some sort of slapstick buddy-com like...more
Amy
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Terry
Great premise. First two pages rock. Then, it comes to a complete halt. Not a good feature in a road book. The gist goes something like this: two brothers leave home on a horse, which promptly dies. They fight, or fight the urge to fight, while reading over the letters oldest brother has sent home from Vietnam. The brothers are then picked up by two characters who would need neon signs blinking "Danger" to appear both more hazardous and symbolic. First words exchanged? "Well, Tom and Huck..." I...more
Michele C.
If you read this book for no other reason, read it for the heart breaking letters from a young soldier serving a tour in Vietnam at the beginning of most chapters. Andrew Smith knows how to break my heart and makes me fall in love with his characters from page one. I instantly loved these three brothers and wished I could protect them from the horrors that they endure. One brother, Matthew, fighting a war in Vietnam, the other two,Jonah and Simon, have been abandoned by their mother while their...more
Terrie
This book is violent, intense, brutal and made me extremely uncomfortable. I was holding my breath throughout most of it. The relationships felt very authentic- brothers who fight constantly, yet would do anything for each other. The strange thing was that the main theme (which goes way beyond what I have described)could have been delivered in a much rosier plot, which just goes to prove that rich or poor, black or white, all humans have the same basic needs, desires, jealousies and fears. I too...more
Matthew Benson
This book is a must read! It keeps you wanting more, and I often found myself not wanting to put down the book! The book has its positive aspects, and believe me, it has its negative aspects as well. This book will leave you wanting more, and will often make you wonder what would you do if you were in the same situation. This book, also, has a very shocking ending, and will make you value what you have in life. Smith definitely went above and beyond expectation with this book!
Sue
The meteor that falls near Simon and Jonah is truly the most innocuous thing to fall on them, literally or figuratively. Jonah and Simon are brothers living in rural New Mexico. Their older brother is fighting in Vietnam. Their mother has gone off and left them alone. Their father is in prison in Arizona. They have no electricity and have run out of food. They believe their only option is to leave their home and go to Arizona to try to find their father and find their brother's army buddy. Their...more
Charlou Lunsford
Disturbing. Scary. Hard to put down. Three brothers. Matthew is serving a tour in Vietnam and his experiences are shared in letters to his brother Jonah. Jonah takes his younger brother, Simon, away from their shack of a house in New Mexico after their mother disappears to find their father who should be getting out of prison soon in Arizona. They catch a ride with a man, Mitch, and a pretty girl, Lily. Mitch is a psychopath. Who survives?
Christina
Talk about the "road trip from you-know-where"--2 teen brothers, trying to get to see their father when he gets out of jail. Their horse dies, stranding them out on a lonely desert highway, and they have no money, only each other and letters from their older brother in Vietnam (oh and there's the matter of the handgun hidden in their backpack). But when a mysteriously creepy guy and a hot girl in a car (with a weird tin statue in the backseat) stop to give them a lift, it's no longer a simple hi...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 25 26 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
LOVE IT 1 7 Oct 17, 2009 01:38pm  
In the Path of Falling Objects (Hardcover)
In the Path of Falling Objects (ebook)
In the Path of Falling Objects (Audio CD)
In the Path of Falling Objects (Audio CD)
In the Path of Falling Objects (Audio)

1383409
Andrew Smith is the author of GHOST MEDICINE, a 2009 ALA/YALSA "Best Books for Young Adults," and IN THE PATH OF FALLING OBJECTS, a 2010 ALA/YALSA "Best Books for Young Adults."

In November, 2010, Andrew Smith's THE MARBURY LENS will be released by Feiwel and Friends, an imprint of Macmillan.

I won't rate books by other authors here on Goodreads. I think there are obvious reasons why an author might...more
More about Andrew Smith...
The Marbury Lens (The Marbury Lens, #1) Stick Ghost Medicine Passenger (The Marbury Lens, #2) Winger

Share This Book

Your website