Summer Breeze (Coulters Historical #3)

by Catherine Anderson

book data

112 ratings, 3.81 average rating, 13 reviews (more data...)

rating	frequency	%
5		25%
4		36%
3		31%
2		5%
1		0%

edit

published

January 3rd 2006 by Signet

binding

Mass Market Paperback, 421 pages

url

http://www.catherineanderson.c...

characters

Rachel Hollister, Joseph Paxton

setting

The United States

isbn

0451217101 (isbn13: 9780451217103)

description

The year is 1889, and Rachel Hollister hasn't set foot outside her house in five years. Ever since a savage attack left her family dead, she's cordone...more

find at: Amazon | Half.com | Barnes & Noble | compare prices ($0.90)…

new topic
discuss this book

topics	replies	views	last activity
Romance Series Lists: Atypical Heroines List	15	43	10/30/2008 07:24PM
Historical Romance: Catherine Anderson (Westerns)	9	26	09/26/2008 02:55PM

friend reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

lists with this book

Favorite Historical Romance Novels

186 books | 106 voters

More lists...

other reviews (showing 1-20 of 159)

all | this edition

Kathrynn rated it:

06/19/08

bookshelves: 2008, author-catherine_anderson, own, romance-suspense, romance-western-historical

Read in June, 2008

A little history:
It looked to me like this was a transitional book as the author moves this series from western to modern romance. This book begins in 2005 and introduces readers to Tucker Coulter when he discovers a journal written in 1889 that belonged to Rachel Hollister/Joseph Paxton. Joseph Paxton is the step brother to Ace Keegan (Keegan's Lady) and has brothers, David and Esa Paxton, and a step sister, Eden O'Shannessy. This one has a brief mention of Patrick O'Shannessy (Caitlin's b...more A little history:
It looked to me like this was a transitional book as the author moves this series from western to modern romance. This book begins in 2005 and introduces readers to Tucker Coulter when he discovers a journal written in 1889 that belonged to Rachel Hollister/Joseph Paxton. Joseph Paxton is the step brother to Ace Keegan (Keegan's Lady) and has brothers, David and Esa Paxton, and a step sister, Eden O'Shannessy. This one has a brief mention of Patrick O'Shannessy (Caitlin's brother) and his new wife, Faith, and their child. They are in the anthology "The True Love Wedding Dress" which has story #2 of this series.

My review:
I thought this book was a bit slow at parts and took me awhile to get into, but once things got moving along it was enjoyable. There is a mystery here that unravels nicely and a dose of suspense to boot. I enjoyed the characters interactions and personalities. They developed well throughout, but I was frustrated with a couple of things in this book:

1) For five years the town turned a blind eye on Rachel, who after her family were all shot and she survived became an Agoraphobic (with panic attacks)--inability to leave her home

2) FIVE YEARS!! Someone should have helped her long before the phobia advanced, IMO, they aided the illness in lieu of trying to help her

3) There sure were a lot of modern phrases and dialogue in the book for a western in 1889

4) Joseph enabled her in lieu of helping her. If he put just as much effort into helping her as he did in reinforcing her self-imposed prison, I would have been a much happier reader.

On the down side, I thought a few things could have been edited out, recaps of conversations that I just read about, retelling to other characters. That sort of thing gets on my nerves.

I loved the dog, Buddy! He really added to the story, for me, a dog lover. ;-)

The love letter at the end from Joseph to Rachel was a tear jerker, so have a box of tissues handy for that. This book ends back in 2005 with Tucker Coulter (in Oregon) deciding to try to locate some long lost relatives, Paxtons and Keegans (in Colorado), but I don't see Tucker's story yet. For me, the stories aren't planned out that far in advance and why introduce Tucker here then not write about him in the next 3-4 books? There just needs to be better organization with the characters, IMO.

The switch from past to present relatives in a series can be done. Linda Lael Miller's series starts out in western times and they succinctly follow the family tree and they are in modern times now. I like that! Going back to read David, Esa and Edens stories after going into modern times, I don't like that. I can see me loosing interest in this series and this author writes wonderful romantic westerns....less

Like this review? yes (6 people liked it)

6 comments

Julie (Mom2lnb) rated it:

11/03/08

bookshelves: historical-romance, read-2008

Read in October, 2008

recommends it for: Fans of Catherine Anderson

Reviewed for www.thcreviews.com

"3.5 stars" Summer Breeze was a pleasant read, but the first 2/3 of the book was rather slow and at times, mundane. In my opinion, this was due in part to story limitations because of Rachel's agoraphobia. She interacted with few characters other than Joseph, and all those interactions were limited to her safe, barricaded room. Hence, most of this part of the story felt like little more than an average frontier couple going through their daily ...more Reviewed for www.thcreviews.com

"3.5 stars" Summer Breeze was a pleasant read, but the first 2/3 of the book was rather slow and at times, mundane. In my opinion, this was due in part to story limitations because of Rachel's agoraphobia. She interacted with few characters other than Joseph, and all those interactions were limited to her safe, barricaded room. Hence, most of this part of the story felt like little more than an average frontier couple going through their daily routine. Around the time that Joseph and Rachel got married, things picked up a bit, but I have to say that the sensuality was extremely mild throughout the entire book with nothing even resembling passion occurring until about 2/3 of the way in. This would not have bothered me except that I wasn't feeling a strong connection between the two protagonists already. One might think that having a couple spend the majority of their time together day and night would lead to some really deep and expressive emotions, but for me, it did not. I think part of this was the previously cited limited scope of their interactions and part was Joseph stubbornly holding Rachel at arms length, but the primary issue was how Joseph handled Rachel's agoraphobia. In most romance novels where one protagonist has a major obstacle to overcome, the other one is usually doing everything he or she can to aid in their recovery, and all of their efforts are part of what makes the story so romantic. In Summer Breeze, I felt that Joseph spent more time facilitating Rachel's disability than helping her to overcome it, and in the end, they failed to really light that romantic spark for me. Also, all the folksy colloquialisms, many of which I had never even heard of, were overused to the point that they became a bit annoying to me, and there were other phrases that seemed rather anachronistic. Additionally, there was a scene where Ace expounds on the true meaning of a long happy marriage as though he's been down that road when in reality, he's still a virtual newlywed himself. It was really lovely, but he just didn't seem like the right character for the speech. For me, the best part was the strong, suspenseful ending and a sweet epilogue. The mystery aspect of this story was good, and kept me guessing all the way to the reveal of a surprise villain, although I would say that Joseph's retelling of the whole story to Rachel in the second-to-last chapter was pretty dull and redundant. Also, Joseph's love letter to Rachel in his waning years was extremely romantic. Overall, this was just a light, easy read.

While Joseph and Rachel were both certainly likable, I can't say that they really stood out to me. In my opinion, Catherine Anderson has a talent for writing heroes with more beta-like characteristics, but her alphas thus far have fallen rather flat for me. Joseph was definitely an alpha who could be very stubborn and even a bit prickly at times. He denied his feelings for Rachel for a large part of the story, constantly saying that he liked his freedom and had no intentions of marrying, but then rather suddenly proposed, which was another reason that the relationship was a little hard for me to believe. Joseph was very physically attracted to Rachel, but very adamant about not making love to her until they were married. While I found the sentiment to be commendable, the timing of his proposal almost made it seem like an excuse for sex, even though I know that wasn't the author's intention. Also Joseph was a very plain-spoken man who always said what was on his mind, which for some readers may be endearing, but didn't really do anything for me. Overall, Joseph was a good and admirable man, just not really my favorite kind of hero. I suppose that the agoraphobia made Rachel a very unique and rather memorable character, but other than that one aspect of her life, she just didn't stand out to me either. I think that part of it was once again the storytelling limitations due to her affliction that made her seem very ordinary and also her suppressed memories of her family's deaths made it difficult to get inside her head to fully understand her condition, as she never really expressed her feelings about the tragedy. Rachel was a sweet and lovely girl who I liked and wanted to connect with, but again just never completely did.

The secondary cast was strong and varied. Readers get a decent visit with Ace and Caitlin from Keegan's Lady, as well as their son, little Ace. Joseph's other two brothers, David and Esa, play substantial roles, particularly David, who I would have guessed to be the next member of the family to get a story, but that is not to be the case. There was also a brief mention of Patrick (also from Keegan's Lady) and Faith from the novella, Beautiful Gifts, and even a quick nod to Luke Taggert, the hero of Simply Love, a completely unrelated book except that they both take place in Colorado. I also liked the appearance of Tucker Coulter and his mother from the present day in the prologue and epilogue, and how Ms. Anderson used this story as an inspiration for his own future romance in Sun Kissed, though I agree with another reviewer who pointed out the oddity of the diary never being mentioned in the main body of the narrative. I really enjoyed Joseph's dog, Buddy, who was quite the character. I thought it was very cute how Joseph would talk to Buddy and Buddy would “talk” back. Ms. Anderson has a talent for creating love not just for the young, but the young at heart too. I liked the secondary romance between Rachel's ranch foreman, Darby, and her spitfire aunt, Amanda. I thought this senior love story was very sweet, but also very sad that they had loved each other for decades and had basically been kept apart by a big misunderstanding. All the residents of No Name really came together in a loving show of frontier community oneness, when they each contributed to Rachel's courtyard, but one has to wonder why they didn't try to reach out to her sooner instead of leaving her to languish in solitude for five years. There was also the distasteful, bullying Pritchard clan who had a longstanding feud with Rachel's father. All in all this was a very well-rounded supporting cast, though I have to say that a few of them reminded me very strongly of some characters from the Little House on the Prairie television show, which makes me curious if that is where Ms. Anderson got her inspiration for them.

Summer Breeze is the third story in the Keegan/Paxton Family series (aka Coulter Historicals). It is preceded by Keegan's Lady and the novella, Beautiful Gifts, from the anthology, The True Love Wedding Dress. At present, Ms. Anderson is working on the next book in the series which will probably be released sometime late next year or in early 2010, and will feature Eden Paxton and Matthew Coulter. It appears that she also has plans to eventually write stories for David and Esa Paxton as well. Even though Summer Breeze was not one of Ms. Anderson's best novels, in my opinion, it was still a pleasurable read that was worth the time spent on it. I intend to continue this series when the next book comes out, and look forward to continuing my exploration Ms. Anderson's backlist until then....less

Like this review? yes (2 people liked it)

3 comments

Gwen rated it:

07/23/07

bookshelves: romance

Read in February, 2007

Anderson frames this sweet historical love story with a prologue and epilogue set in modern 2006 where a family member comes across the diary of Rachel Hollister and Joseph Paxton, allowing the modern reader to travel back in time just as the family member does. Although she does a good job of describing the small Colorado town, ranch life, and community ties, she doesn't bog the reader down with minute details of any specific tasks. Instead she concentrates on the feelings and emotions of Rache...more

Like this review? yes (1 person liked it)

title link
avg rating
small image
med image
large image

Summer Breeze (Coulters Historical #3)

book data

new topic discuss this book

friend reviews

lists with this book

other reviews (showing 1-20 of 159)

blog this book

combine other editions (2)

view this book

view this book

trivia questions

popular shelves

groups with this book

new topic
discuss this book

combine
other editions (2)