I, Coriander
With atmospheric writing, Gardner creates a new exhilarating fairy tale of a young girl who in the 17th century discovers she has inherited mysterious abilities from her mother.
Hardcover, 280 pages
Published
August 15th 2005
by Dial
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I, Coriander is a fairy story set in Puritan England. Coriander is a young girl befallen on hard times--her mother passes away, her father is driven out by her evil stepmother and the rise of Oliver Cromwell ('cause he's a Royalist), and her stepmother's crazy Puritan zealot friend is out to get her. At one point, they even cut off all her hair and lock her in a cupboard, leaving her in there for three years. Except she went to fairyland, so it's all okay. Yup, Coriander is one of those characte...more
I believe this is one of those select fairy tales that you have to be older to appreciate. I first received this book as a child, maybe ten years old, and tried to read it. I grew bored and impatient, as most ten-year-olds are, and wrote it off as a bad book. I got to organizing my bookshelves several years later, and came across it. Having it in my mindset that I would,once again, despise it, imagine my surprise and pleasure when I found the truth. I simply...loved this book. I found myself hav
...more
This book is magnificent, really. I am in awe of Sally Gardner, who didn't even learn how to read or write until she was 14 due to dyslexia! She sure showed all the people that wrote her off, didn't she?
This is a fairy tale...the story is lovely and lyrical and SO well written. It was at times hilarious...and other times, gut-wrenchingly horrifying. The evil stepmother is taken to a whole new level in Maud Leggs and Arise Fell.
The storyline with the prince isn't very well developed, but that is...more
This is a fairy tale...the story is lovely and lyrical and SO well written. It was at times hilarious...and other times, gut-wrenchingly horrifying. The evil stepmother is taken to a whole new level in Maud Leggs and Arise Fell.
The storyline with the prince isn't very well developed, but that is...more
Aug 01, 2009
Becky
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Becky by:
Allison Mason
Shelves:
fantasy,
historical-fiction,
young-adult,
2009,
dystopias,
multi-dimensional,
political,
religion-related,
reviewed
This was a lovely little fairy-tale story. I can just imagine reading this to little girls, who will inevitably beg for just one more chapter before having to go to bed. It's so easy to imagine said little girls dreaming of being a fairy princess, even though this isn't your typical fairy princess story.
From the very start, this story reminded me strongly of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke. Except, this story was much more entertaining, and fun, and concise. And not a single...more
From the very start, this story reminded me strongly of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke. Except, this story was much more entertaining, and fun, and concise. And not a single...more
A very different book! The cover and the description of it make it seem like it's for younger readers, a magical story about a girl with magical slippers. It's not! It's a very fascinating, multi-faceted tale about life in London during Cromwell's revolution, with its passionate politics and literal witch hunts. It's a story about fairies, and witches, friendship and love, evil preachers, charlatans, tailors, and spies. During the course of the book, Coriander ages from a naive nine to being a y...more
This is really just under a four. Woulda been a solid 4, but the ending knocked it back to 3.5 territory.
Sally Gardner pulled no punches in I, Coriander. Her Cromwell-era England is harsh and full and the perfect backdrop to the very dark - and very darkly human - tale she tells. No one's life is simple or all that pretty in the book, but Coriander's is made even less so upon the arrival of her strictly religious stepmother, Maug Leggs, and Maud's...'preacher' Arise Fell. Maud is pretty damn bad...more
Sally Gardner pulled no punches in I, Coriander. Her Cromwell-era England is harsh and full and the perfect backdrop to the very dark - and very darkly human - tale she tells. No one's life is simple or all that pretty in the book, but Coriander's is made even less so upon the arrival of her strictly religious stepmother, Maug Leggs, and Maud's...'preacher' Arise Fell. Maud is pretty damn bad...more
Oct 15, 2008
Miss Clark
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Fans of Fairytales and Sally Gardner
I enjoyed the fairytale aspects of this book and I really wanted to give it three stars, both for a unique writing style and the artful inclusion of the history of the period, which I thought was done very well. I especially liked how Gardner presented such a wide range of poltical and religious viewpoints, but allowed the individuals that held them, like Ned or even Coriander, who is literally of another world, to all be able to show true tolerance for the other person and respect their belief,...more
May 05, 2008
LFPL Teen Services
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
fans of fairy tale novelizations
Coriander is a girl living in Puritan-oppressed England. When her beautiful and kind mother dies in a mysterious way, her father is forced to marry Maude, a so-called holy woman with a daughter of her own. Soon after their marriage, Coriander's father flees into exile, as he is a royalist and is threated by the Puritan government. Maude, an evil woman, verbally abuses Corinader and her new sister Hester and encourages the live-in reverend to physically abuse her.
Periodically, the magical world t...more
Periodically, the magical world t...more
May 04, 2007
Clelland
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
People who like a twisted tale
I loved this book. It was so refreshing to finally have an author capture the true essence and dignity of a child. Here's the thing: Do you remember that teacher in school that gave you respect and treated you like an adult. You were held accountable, treated with respect, and your opinions were really appreciated. For some reason, people talk down to children or act like they are not that intelligent. Kinda like a person talking really loud and slow to a deaf person. It looks stupid and doesn't...more
Spellbinding. All the attention to sensory detail made the experience of reading it so immersive I finished the book in one late night. Dramatic & atmospheric, full of allusions and symbolism. Good vs. evil - the only truly complex character is Coriander's father who is a good man who makes some bad decisions. I especially loved how painlessly I actually learned a bit more about English history, both political and cultural. I'm excited to discuss this in the Children's Books group - come joi...more
Genre- fantasy
Summary: set in 1650s, I,Coriander tells the tale of tragedy in during the time of Puritan England. After both her mother and father pass and leave coriander hobie is left at the mercy of her wicked stepmother. After being confined to a dresser shelf, coriander escapes to a fairy land where she is able to master skills that will help her in the future.
1) evaluation of plot
2) although I,Coriander is a complete fantasy tale full of fairies and a wondrous land, Sally Gardner stays t...more
Summary: set in 1650s, I,Coriander tells the tale of tragedy in during the time of Puritan England. After both her mother and father pass and leave coriander hobie is left at the mercy of her wicked stepmother. After being confined to a dresser shelf, coriander escapes to a fairy land where she is able to master skills that will help her in the future.
1) evaluation of plot
2) although I,Coriander is a complete fantasy tale full of fairies and a wondrous land, Sally Gardner stays t...more
Coriander tells us of her adventures in the form of a written memoir, a saga set in the time of the aftermath of the English Civil War. King Charles is dead, and "Old Noll" Oliver Cromwell holds the nation in his Puritanical grip. In the midst of this, Coriander's family is riven by troubles not only of this world, but of the fairy world as well. Forces are at work to deny her her rightful inheritance, and to allow a usurper to control the fairy world, just as Cromwell is controlling England.[re...more
It was a Friday morning and we had what we like to call "A Book Challenge" at homeschool. This meant that my mom picked out some books for us, and we spent the day reading. As long as we stayed in our rooms and continued to read, we didn't have to do that day's school work.
I had just finished reading Child from the Sea, and Children of the New Forest, so I was well informed about the British civil war, and Oliver Cromwell's reign. Because the book was written about England during that time, my m...more
I had just finished reading Child from the Sea, and Children of the New Forest, so I was well informed about the British civil war, and Oliver Cromwell's reign. Because the book was written about England during that time, my m...more
Coriander lives a good life until her mother dies when she is young and her father remarries another woman- then has to run for his life. Coriander's stepmother is an abusive puritan, and her 'partner in crime'- a minister named Arise- is even more cruel. They try to kill Coriander by shutting her up in a chest, but Coriander is instead transported to a different world, a fairy realm. As it turns out, Coriander's mother was a fairy and came from this world. But things are not well in this realm...more
This is a lovely book that I enjoyed so much when I was younger. Coriander, a young girl that lives with her father and mother in 17th century London, has a fairy-tale life. Her only worries are the stuffed crocodile in the study of her father and a pair of silver shoes that her mother doesn't let her have. It's not until her mother dies mysteriously and her father needs to remarry that everything goes downhill. And though Coriander feels worthless, the stephmother of her mother is after her, an...more
It was ? read, well, I am still looking for the right word.... Since I did not like very much darkness of this era. Its cover, which is very bright, does not give back the darkness of the story, well, I expected a light read, but I got a tough one, and not because of the story itself, that was very simple, predictable at least considering the heroine's journey... but the used words, vocabulary. made this story so dark.
The story was taken place from 1643, yeah those years are not known from their...more
The story was taken place from 1643, yeah those years are not known from their...more
While this book was a very unique and frequently well-written story, I did not enjoy it. The more the book went on, the more convenient things became. By the end all I could think of was "what the heck?"
The plot surrounds young Coriander Hobie, who at age six disobeys her mother and puts on a pair of silver shoes that transport her to another world. Upon returning, her mother dies, an evil step-mother appears, and her Father disappears.
Sounds like a perfect Cinderella set-up.
But it isn't! I, C...more
The plot surrounds young Coriander Hobie, who at age six disobeys her mother and puts on a pair of silver shoes that transport her to another world. Upon returning, her mother dies, an evil step-mother appears, and her Father disappears.
Sounds like a perfect Cinderella set-up.
But it isn't! I, C...more
Like _The Perilous Gard_, this is a variation on the Tam Lin story. And like _Perilous Gard_, it is set in a historical period that is vividly and convincingly drawn. I, Coriander is set in the Puritan period in England and the early years of the Restoration. Spoiler ahead: Master Hobie, Coriander's father, is in danger because of his support of Charles I, which causes him to leave his Thameside home and his outspoken daughter in the care of his vicious Puritan second wife, Maud. Maud is surely...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
“I am Coriander Hobie.
I was born in the year of Our Lord 1643, the only child of Thomas and Eleanor Hobie, in our great house on the River Thames in London. Of my early years I remember only happiness. That was before I knew this world had such evil in it, and that my fate was to be locked up in a chest and left to die.
This is my story. This is my life.”
And it is a wonderful story, quite beautifully told.
Coriander writes her story of life in 1650s London by candlelight, with each of her seven c...more
I was born in the year of Our Lord 1643, the only child of Thomas and Eleanor Hobie, in our great house on the River Thames in London. Of my early years I remember only happiness. That was before I knew this world had such evil in it, and that my fate was to be locked up in a chest and left to die.
This is my story. This is my life.”
And it is a wonderful story, quite beautifully told.
Coriander writes her story of life in 1650s London by candlelight, with each of her seven c...more
Jul 03, 2010
Carmine
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
middle school girls
Recommended to Carmine by:
Anna S.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Loved this novel from its first words. Immediatley taken back to C17th London just after kiing charles I has been beheaded and the puritans are out in force accusing all and sundry of witchcraft and making people fearful for their lives. Its to this backdrop that the story begins.
Its essentially a fairy story-part cinderella part the Snow Queen. A young girl grows up in an idylic family-much doted upon by her mother and father. One day she gets sent some beautiful silver shoes but her mother wo...more
Its essentially a fairy story-part cinderella part the Snow Queen. A young girl grows up in an idylic family-much doted upon by her mother and father. One day she gets sent some beautiful silver shoes but her mother wo...more
I, Coriander is an original fairy tale for young adults set in the aftermath of Charles I's execution. With its emphasis on the interweaving of the mundane and fairy worlds, this novel also reminded me of Stardust at times, although more emphasis is placed on the historical setting and less on mythological puzzle-solving. Because I, Coriander isn't a traditional historical fantasy, there may be fantasy lovers bored by the historical aspects of the tale, and history lovers turned off by the fanta...more
Coriander lives in London at a time of political instability. Charles I, King of England has been beheaded and now Oliver Cromwell and the Puritans hold the country. But this means little to Coriander for her world only contains her parents and their friends. But when a pair of silver shoes arrive at the house the outside worlds begin to encroach on hers.
By the light of seven candles, Coriander tells her story. It is a tale of silver shoes, a stuffed alligator, lost treasure and fairies; for Cor...more
By the light of seven candles, Coriander tells her story. It is a tale of silver shoes, a stuffed alligator, lost treasure and fairies; for Cor...more
Sometimes, the best books are the ones you expect nothing from. I had never heard of this book before. But it was on sale for $3 and the synopsis sounded interesting. So, why not?
The main plot of the story is that Coriander has to defeat her wicked step-grandmother by finding her mother's shadow. But Coriander knows nothing about the fairy world that her mother came from. The "real world" side of the story is set in Puritan England. I enjoyed the setting of both worlds as they shifted from the h...more
The main plot of the story is that Coriander has to defeat her wicked step-grandmother by finding her mother's shadow. But Coriander knows nothing about the fairy world that her mother came from. The "real world" side of the story is set in Puritan England. I enjoyed the setting of both worlds as they shifted from the h...more
Aug 19, 2011
Matt Richter
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fantasy,
young-adult
I enjoyed this book very much! Especially the first 70% of the book was simply wondrous. There's a great balance of story set in historical England interconnected with a magical fantasy world. I found the plight of the young heroine, Coriander, highly engrossing.
In the closing sections of the book though the climax seemed rather rushed, the last section felt like an overlong epilogue and the plot seemed to tie up a little too neatly.
I particularly like Gardner's emotive and perfectly fitting d...more
In the closing sections of the book though the climax seemed rather rushed, the last section felt like an overlong epilogue and the plot seemed to tie up a little too neatly.
I particularly like Gardner's emotive and perfectly fitting d...more
I read "I, Coriander" with my eight year old daughter, and we thoroughly enjoyed Gardner's lyrical writing style in this original fairy tale set into motion by a mysterious pair of silver shoes. The author engages the senses so well that she put us right there in London during Oliver Cromwell's dictatorship. And the protagonist's travels between two worlds
--17th century London and the fairy world of Queen Rosmore--was also a treat, but at times my daughter said that the book would have been too...more
--17th century London and the fairy world of Queen Rosmore--was also a treat, but at times my daughter said that the book would have been too...more
Apr 23, 2012
Alison
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
confident-readers-chapter-books
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This book is magnificent, really. I am in awe of Sally Gardner, who didn't even learn how to read or write until she was 14 due to dyslexia! She sure showed all the people that wrote her off, didn't she?
It is a beautiful, modern-written (but not modern setting --- 1600s) fairy tale. This fairy tale...the story is lovely and lyrical and SO well written. It was at times hilarious...and other times, gut-wrenchingly horrifying. The evil stepmother is taken to a whole new level in Maud Leggs and Ari...more
It is a beautiful, modern-written (but not modern setting --- 1600s) fairy tale. This fairy tale...the story is lovely and lyrical and SO well written. It was at times hilarious...and other times, gut-wrenchingly horrifying. The evil stepmother is taken to a whole new level in Maud Leggs and Ari...more
Jun 09, 2008
Molly
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
authors-i-adore,
recommended-reads
I was a big of this when I read it a few years ago. It had a few logical flaws and flew pretty far under the radar as far as acclaim but I loved it anyway. Delicious magical realism combined with history, and gorgeous writing on top.
I'll fully admit that part of my love is because of that elegantly creepy, haunting cover! I can't explain why it sucks me in--but I could look at it for HOURS!!
I'll fully admit that part of my love is because of that elegantly creepy, haunting cover! I can't explain why it sucks me in--but I could look at it for HOURS!!
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Children's Books: October 2012 - I, Coriander | 18 | 77 | Jan 17, 2013 01:53pm |
Sally Gardner grew up and still lives in London. Being dyslexic, she did not learn to read or write until she was fourteen and had been thrown out of several schools, labeled unteachable, and sent to a school for maladjusted children. Despite this, she gained a degree with highest honors at a leading London art college, followed by a scholarship to a theater school, and then went on to become a ve...more
More about Sally Gardner...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“What more can anyone take from me?" said my father, his head bent down. "Everywhere I go I carry my hell with me.”
—
9 people liked it
“The floor had become a sea and the bed a ship, seen from a great distance. I could hear their voices calling me from far away. It lasted a minute or less. Maybe I dreamed it. Maybe I did not. It was an image that came to haunt me, and I have often wondered what would have happened if I had done as I was told and left the silver shoes alone. Would everything then have been alright?”
—
8 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...
view all 3 comments





















