Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Eternally Yours (Immortal Beloved, #3)” as Want to Read:
Eternally Yours (Immortal Beloved, #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Eternally Yours (Immortal Beloved #3)

4.25 of 5 stars 4.25  ·  rating details  ·  3,481 ratings  ·  412 reviews
After 450 years of living, Nastasya Crowe should have more of a handle on this whole immortal thing....

After a deadly confrontation at the end of Darkness Falls, the second Immortal Beloved novel, Nastasya Crowe is, as she would put it, so over the drama. She fights back against the dark immortals with her own brand of kick-butt magick...but can she fight against true love
Hardcover, 458 pages
Published November 6th 2012 by Poppy (first published January 1st 2012)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Eternally Yours, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Eternally Yours

Insurgent by Veronica RothCity of Lost Souls by Cassandra ClareThe Fault in Our Stars by John GreenPandemonium by Lauren OliverRapture by Lauren Kate
YA Novels of 2012
118th out of 1,296 books — 10,261 voters
Insurgent by Veronica RothCity of Lost Souls by Cassandra ClareHallowed by Cynthia HandThe Golden Lily by Richelle MeadPandemonium by Lauren Oliver
2012 Books I'd Sell Smurfs to Purchase
93rd out of 332 books — 479 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
May 20, 2012 Hannah marked it as to-read
January 2012
Lusting after this. I picture the cover... Yellow! Or maybe... White?
Until I can hold this baby in my arms I'll have to be content with re-reading the first two over. And over... And over.

May 2012

I AM GOD. Seriously dying right now, I predicted the damn cover, bitches.
♔Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ Veronica Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ♔

GAH! Can't wait..canNOT wait! I love Nasty =D she cracks my shit up
Ashley Brooke
Post Reading: Oh Reyn, I already miss you! Best male lead in a book series in a LONG time!

Pre-Release: If I had a TARDIS, I would totally pop into the future to pick this book up!!! The wait will not be easy!
sunset shimmer
This review is also available over at my blog.


Edit 04/18/2013: One of the reasons this series is so close to my heart is that me and my best friend shared such love for it and its characters, and it even brought us closer together in a way. She passed away this February, and even though it was one of the most painful experiences I'd ever had to go through, I still found myself smiling and even laughing when I took a whole day to skim through the entire series.

I think a
Review Posted at

I reviewed the first two books in this series, Immortal Beloved and Darkness Falls on my own but for this last one, Christine has joined me:

Caitlin: I feel like I waited forever to read this book. I’m not even sure why. It isn’t as if Darkness Falls ended on a cliffhanger or anything. Or that there is an over-arcing plot that needed to be wrapped up. I just love these books and these characters and needed more for the simple pleasure of having more.

Katrina Passick Lumsden
3 1/2 Stars

This was a bittersweet ending for me because Immortal Beloved is one of my favorite all-time books, but I absolutely loathed Darkness Falls. This book fell somewhere in between, not nearly as good as the first installment, but way better than the second. I'm glad to finally get some closure, but at the same time, the build-up between Nastasya and Reyn (that's been brewing since book 1) became almost pointless when Tiernan decided to (view spoiler)
Jenni Arndt
You can read all of my reviews at Alluring Reads.

I had been looking forward to Eternally Yours ever since devouring the first two books in the trilogy earlier this year. I am happy to say that it did not disappoint! Nastasya (our 459 year old immortal) is back and she is just as snarky and sarcastic as ever. We catch up with her and the residents of River's Edge about a month following her gallivants to Boston and the tragedy with Incy. I was happy to get to see Nas back with River and relieved
Final rating: ★★★★★/★★★★★



Story :

This was such awesome conclusion <3. I officially love all three books. The story proved to be great, but it just felt rushed toward the end. I guess few more chapters wouldn't hurt but oh well. I was surprised about few things and i pity Egthor, poor guy had it rough. There were some times where i was pissed off and practically yelled at screen because of Nasty because
Think I'll wait to start reading this trilogy until this last one comes out...


Action packed with good pacing, solid writing, and surprisingly laugh out loud funny. Plenty of one line zingers from Nastasya.

Brilliant end to a series. When a series is so great and then it wraps up in the most perfect way - everything is kittens and clouds and sunshine and cupcakes :D :D
(I may or may not have hugged my Kindle when I finished this)
A wonderful ending to the series! I absolutely love Nasty, and have been in love with her, and Reyn, and River, and just about every other character since the first page of IMMORTAL BELOVED. It was so good to find out how they're doing and what they're doing and what they're going to do next. Tiernan really explores the nature of evil, and how everyone can change, and has worth, making the book poignant and hilarious by turns.
Jessica (Rabid Reads)
Excellent ending to an excellent trilogy. That's all I'm saying, lest there be spoilers. SORRY.

This was (far and away) the best of the trilogy! I really, really liked this book! Nastasya has grown so much, but she is essentially the same sarcastic (459 year old) teenager, and I love that about her!! I didn't feel like we got enough about the other immortals at River's Edge in this book...there were so many great characters (with really long histories to explore), and we just barely scratched the surface with most of them. But Nasty's "project" was a great way to both show her growth,
Rating: 4.5 Stars

I've found it increasingly difficult to be satisfied with conclusions this year, but thankfully, Eternally Yours lived up to all my expectations - and then some. Nasty continues to shine, both as a character attempting to attain more from her immortal existence and as a narrator who never fails to make me laugh. After the events of Darkness Falls, Nasty is a changed immortal and Eternally Yours captures her mindset perfectly. Now, finally settled into River's and with close frie
She changed the course of my life, the way a storm can make a river jump its banks and surge ahead.

Nastasya is back at the farm, the reform 'school' for immortals. She's been working to learn about her magic, to stay on course. Suddenly, the place and people she's come to love are under attack by dark, unknown forces, and she's unsure of her role in it all.

Really, really fulfilling conclusion to the trilogy. Solid writing, good pacing, and much appreciated humor (!). Plenty of action, exploratio

5 million MAGICKAL stars!!! (*u*)

Why didn't I read this super kick-ass one of kind book sooner?!

Oh My Geeee, I just love Nastasha more and more, and her amusing epic thoughts.

This trilogy is definitely worth reading and worth having. You'll always want to read Nas' snide remarks (& her annoying baggage), River's compassionate side, Asher's supportiveness, did I mention Reyn's (OH MY OVARIES) sizzling HOTNESS?? haha.. Ok enough of that, so in this book you'll also be able to meet River's b
To Reyn for being a sweetheart:

4 "Eternal" Stars

Ever will men go to war, for all reasons or none

Here's the thing, if you kill off one of my favorite characters who just so happens to be a universally liked character, as a reader, I'm going to be pissed and as a critic, I'd applaud you for such a daring move.

On the other hand, if you kill off one of my favorite character who just so happens to be a universally hated character, as a reader, I'm going to be pissed and as a critic, I'd still be pissed.

There is just no appeasi
PepperP0t (
The swan song for this trilogy theoretically takes us on a search for The Master, but is actually a window to the past of the lives of Nasty and her housemates. For me it was a somewhat interesting but not compelling read.

In their quest to prove that Nasty is an agent of The Master, Rivers brothers ratchet up the tension and conflict levels in the household as "battle" lines are drawn for and against Nasty. Meanwhile the dance that is Nasty and Reyn take several steps down happiness road when o
This review may contain a few small spoilers of Immortal Beloved & Darkness Falls

This book was just so perfect. I loved every page of it, Cate Tiernan really knew how to wrap everything up without it seeming too happily ever after or even too open ended. She always manages to be realistic in her books no matter their genre. Eternally Yours is my favorite book from this trilogy. The journey Nastasya took together with us was full of laughs, sarcasm, immaturity (mostly from Nasty), character
Stacey Brown
I’m a complete Reyn fan so I don’t really want this series to end…more Reyn please!

Overall I really enjoyed it, but have to admit a few things really bothered me. I felt the end was EXTREMELY rushed. We’ve waited for 3 books now for the Reyn/Nastasya really getting together moment and it was completely bypassed. The last chapter felt more like an epilogue and I just thought the shift between her being scared of the L-word and being fully committed to it was just to fast. Her admitting it was slo
Review originally posted

I’m not even sure how to write a review for Eternally Yours by Cate Tiernan. I have been fangirling her since I was like 11 years old and first read the Sweep series, which I’ve read and reread 100 times since.

And oh, how I love the Immortal Beloved trilogy. Each book in this series has captured me fully with an exciting and interesting spin on the immortal/witchy side of the paranormal genre, light and entertaining writing that so
Book Angel Emma
Please bear in mind that this is the third and final book int the Immortal Beloved series and the review may therefore contain spoilers for the previous books.

I have to say Eternally Yours was not at all what I was expecting from the last installment of the Immortal Beloved series. Don’t get me wrong I love Nastasya’s narrative voice, her internal battles and her direct address to the reader made some laugh out loud moments. However, I felt this book is more character driven than plot driven. Na
Eternally Yours is the final book in Cate's Immortal Beloved trilogy.

In Darkness Falls, Nastasya berates herself. During her 450 years, she definitely mastered the art of pessimism.
You are a such a chickenshit. You act so tough, but really you're a gooey marshmallow of schoolgirl fears. You keep saying you want to get better, but only if you don't have to do anything hard.
However, in Eternally Yours real changes start to occur. She's beginning to finally trust not just her own feelings, but
WOW! Such a good end to a series. I got really wrapped up in this one; knocked it out in about 24hrs.
My only complaint: I WANT MORE.
I would love to see Cate Tiernan put out some short POV's or novellas about some of the other characters. We got to meet a butt-load of new characters in Eternally Yours, and I would love to maybe go back in time and learn more about their histories, (Nas and Roberto? Reyn and Joshua?)I mean what happened there?!?

Anyhow, after finishing Eternally yours I was left wi
 photo 2116_c991_zpsa4041265.gif

It took me ages to finish this.

During the first third of the book, I was underwhelmed by all the "Previously in the Immortal Beloved Series..." info dump and the characters talking and behaving with the same obnoxiousness or downright stupidity than before.

And then boredom set in. Nothing seemed to happen until the end of the book when everything went very fast and we got served with a ridiculous sort of epilogue before we even recovered from the whiplash.

The only thing that even remotely inter
Leah (Jane Speare)
For better formatting and more reviews, check out my blog!


*Minor spoilers for Immortal Beloved and Darkness Falls*

I want to start with Reyn. He is so cool. And deserves to be the start of my review.

All right, I guess i should describe Nastasya's (questionable/weird/love-hate) relationship with Reyn as "lust at first sight", which is now, to her surprise and confusion, turning into actually something serious. In this conclusion to the trilogy, the romance
I have edited my review because I finally stopped fangirling.

I would just like to ask a quick question before we get down to bussiness: How old is our beloved Reyn?
Okay moving on.

What I really am fond about the series is that there really are no great flaws in the books. It is very rare that you find such an author to both humor the readers as well as actually have them be interested in the books.

The characters in the books were really well developed and although I find that sometimes Reyn feel
Immortal, sarcastic, and worldly Nastasya is a personality not often seen in YA fiction. She says it like it is (at least in her narrative). While she can be frustrating at times (she majorly overthinks things), I think a lot of people can somewhat relate to her constant struggle to do the right thing as she actively looks back on every terrible thing she's done in her life in order to come to terms with it and become a better person. From here on out, there are *SPOILERS* for those who haven't ...more
Barbara ★
Once again we have Nastasya, Reyn and River's Edge. The eight ruling houses are systematically being attacked and River's brothers (Ottavio, Daniel, Joshua and Roberto) feel that Nastasya is the cause of all the evil in the world. They descend on River's Edge and make Nastasya's life miserable. Well more miserable than it usually is. For most of the book, she and Reyn dance around their attraction (just like in the previous two books) with incidents of kissy-face. (Yes that is what they call it. ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • If I Should Die (Revenants, #3)
  • Last Rite (Personal Demons, #3)
  • Social Suicide (Deadly Cool, #2)
  • Embers and Echoes (Wildefire, #2)
  • Shine (Shade, #3)
  •  The Mephisto Kiss (The Mephisto Covenant, #2)
  • Losing Lila (Lila, #2)
  • Speed of Light (Fenestra, #3)
  • Enticed (The Violet Eden Chapters, #2)
  • Ghost Flower
  • Deity (Covenant, #3)
  • A Beautiful Evil (Gods & Monsters, #2)
  • Fury (Mercy, #4)
  • Rise (Nightshade Prequel, #2)
  • Chosen at Nightfall (Shadow Falls, #5)
  • Stolen Nights (Vampire Queen, #2)
  • Haze (The Rephaim, #2)
  • Crimson Frost (Mythos Academy, #4)
"was born in New Orleans, LA, in 1961. New Orleans is one of the most interesting American cities, and it has an incredibly rich and exotic culture that had a profound influence on me. Kids in other cities have lemonade stands; we sold voodoo gris-gris and made wax dolls in the likenesses of our enemies. It's a very beautiful city, and the constant heat and humidity make gardens grow out of contro ...more
More about Cate Tiernan...

Other Books in the Series

Immortal Beloved (3 books)
  • Immortal Beloved (Immortal Beloved, #1)
  • Darkness Falls (Immortal Beloved, #2)
Book of Shadows (Sweep, #1) The Coven (Sweep, #2) Immortal Beloved (Immortal Beloved, #1) Blood Witch (Sweep, #3) Dark Magick (Sweep, #4)

Share This Book

“I was of the “When life gives you lemons, make lemonade, then wonder why life didn’t give you freaking sugar so you could drink the stuff” school of thought.” 28 likes
“Is that a hat?" I asked, pouring eight rounds of batter into the griddle.
She grinned at me. "A sweater." She held it up -- it was triangular, made of speckled brown and white mohair.
"For...a Muppet?" I asked.
"For the naked chicken," she said, and snickered.”
More quotes…