The Inheritance (Realms of the Elderlings)
by
Robin Hobb (Goodreads Author),
Megan Lindholm
Notwithstanding its author credits, this short story collection was written by one person. "Robin Hobb" and "Megan Lindholm" are both pseudonyms used by California-born Margaret Ogden, who from 1983 to 1992, published exclusively as Lindholm. This generous, 400-page hardcover original brings together short stories and novellas penned under both authorial bylines. As Hobb h
...moreHardcover, 400 pages
Published
March 1st 2011
by Harper Voyager
(first published 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,963)
ORIGINALLY POSTED AT Fantasy Literature.
I've been a fan of Robin Hobb for many years -- her FARSEER, TAWNY MAN, and LIVESHIP TRADERS series are some of my favorite epic fantasies. That's why I was looking forward to reading The Inheritance and Other Stories, a collection of short stories written by Robin Hobb under that name and her real name, Megan Lindholm.
Why write under two names? She explains this in the introduction to the book: the two authors have completely different styles. As Lindholm...more
I've been a fan of Robin Hobb for many years -- her FARSEER, TAWNY MAN, and LIVESHIP TRADERS series are some of my favorite epic fantasies. That's why I was looking forward to reading The Inheritance and Other Stories, a collection of short stories written by Robin Hobb under that name and her real name, Megan Lindholm.
Why write under two names? She explains this in the introduction to the book: the two authors have completely different styles. As Lindholm...more
I am not a short story reader. I find them frustrating because you just puzzle out the characters and the situation and it's over. And what passes for short stories these days mostly read like excerpted novel chapters. However, I love Robin Hobb, though sadly I haven't been able to read any Megan Lindholm because it is so hard to find. The downside to changing your name and becoming wildly popular is that your backlist goes out of print because the connection is tenuous at best. I was shocked SH...more
4.5 of 5. An Endeavour book read. Not sure why I put off reading this one - I guess to some degree I don't particularly pick up non-Endeavour short story collections anymore so I avoid all short story collections. And yet I read Robin Hobb and to a lesser extent Megan Lindholm (who are the same person). And yet ... The Endeavour Award short story collection books seem to be of two basic forms - either every story that the author ever wrote all collected together OR the best stories that an autho...more
This is my first time reading any of Hobb's Lindholm stories. Perhaps my favorite aspect was I had no idea where she was going with each story despite her introductions to each. She writes with a gritty sense of realism that pulls you in immediately and keeps you invested despite the strangeness of the fantastical or bazaar elements. My favorite of these would have to be A Touch of Lavendar, Cut, Strays and Drum Machine. In her introduction to Cut she says "I like to think...that I write stories...more
Robin Hobb and Megan Lindholm are one and the same person but they are very different writers. The Inheritance is a collection of short novels, novellas and stories, some of which are based in Hobb’s popular universe of the Six Duchies. Before each of the stories, Lindholm/Hobb gives a small snippet of history as to how she came to write the piece and I loved this insight into her working process. I have read all of the novels written so far by Robin Hobb and thoroughly enjoyed them but this was...more
I was very disappointed with this collection of short stories. There's only so many times I can take being told that all men are bastards. (Even the man who features in the story she wrote as a birthday present for her husband, and who is presumably meant to be a celebration of him, is a jerk.) I know she can write decent male characters: Fitz, Burrich, Chade, Verity, Wintrow, Brashen, and Paragon are all very well-drawn, and Kennit is a masterpiece. But here we have psychopaths, users, bullies,...more
Dividing this collection up into Hobb stories and Lindholm stories was definitely a good decision, since the two do have a completely different vibe and focus. I've enjoyed what I've previously read of the Megan Lindholm oeuvre (notably the Ki and Vandien quartet) but that too was fantasy, so it was interesting to sample some of her stories with modern-day settings. "A Touch of Lavender" was definitely my favourite of these in here - great voice and a haunting, original plot. I was less taken wi...more
As a devoted Robin Hobb fan I've only read her short stories and plan to read Lindholm's at a later date as I become more familiar with her work. (Obviously) I am aware that both Robin Hobb and Megan Lindholm are pseudonyms of the same author but, as the writing styles are so different, it's natural to pick one over the other.
There are only three 'short' stories written in the style of Hobb but they account for 50% of this collection as (in Hobb's usual tradition) they're fairly lengthy. They ar...more
There are only three 'short' stories written in the style of Hobb but they account for 50% of this collection as (in Hobb's usual tradition) they're fairly lengthy. They ar...more
I stumbled across this book in the catalog of the Vancouver Public Library recently, and decided to pick it up for a quick read. I have been a fan of Meghan Lindholm for around 20 years at this sitting, as I first started reading her many years ago, when I picked up the paperback of "The Wizard of the Pigeons". Since then I have made a point to read most of the work she has published, including the epic fantasy trilogies that she writes under her other pseudonym, Robin Hobb.
Reading through this...more
Reading through this...more
I've adored Robin Hobb since reading The Farseer trilogy in my early teens (a decade ago!), but never picked up a Megan Lindholm (Hobb's earlier pseudonym) book. Why? I'm not sure, but now I think I'm going to have to remedy this! Why? The Inheritance and Other Stories made me see that Megan is a force to be reckoned with.
Megan Lindholm's short stories are (whilst not too short) shorter than Robin Hobb's, but they have stayed in my mind since I finished this anthology a week or so ago. They're...more
Megan Lindholm's short stories are (whilst not too short) shorter than Robin Hobb's, but they have stayed in my mind since I finished this anthology a week or so ago. They're...more
When I first picked up this book, I thought I only thought of it for the stories by Robin Hobb, whose Liveship series I read and was interested in a little taste of that world again without getting into another series or full sized novel. I was less interested in Lindholm, certain that I had never read the author's work under that pen name. I was actually planning to skip the Lindholm section! I am glad that in the end I decided that I couldn't do that to a book. I can't half-read them unless th...more
This book pairs the short stories of Megan Lindholm and her pseudonym, Robin Hobb. As someone who has almost entirely read the Robin Hobb books, it was very instructive to see to two voices in comparison. I thought that all the stories were solid but I did not enjoy any individual one as much as the full novels I've read. As a collection, it isn't very cohesive (as you'd expect from one book with two different "authors" and no central theme, but it also lacked cohesion within the Megan Lindhom v...more
Jul 13, 2012
Kate
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Robin Hobb fans, cat lovers, people that like vaguely disturbing sci-fi
The fact that Robin Hobb and Megan Lindholm are the same person was hard to credit when I first found out that this was the case. Lindholm's books are spiky, disturbing and somewhat cold. Hobb's novels are more rounded, warmer and have characters that I want to meet and interact with. Hobb's writing is far more engaging.
And you know what, this book of short stories just reinforced my feelings about the two authorial voices. The Lindholm stories were short, disturbing and quite uncomfortable, usi...more
And you know what, this book of short stories just reinforced my feelings about the two authorial voices. The Lindholm stories were short, disturbing and quite uncomfortable, usi...more
Nov 11, 2012
Bellish
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Hobb afficiandos only
Recommended to Bellish by:
Library shelves
Shelves:
short-stories
A mixed bag. I didn't care much for the Lindholm stories except the first, Lavender, which is a rather difficult-to-describe near-future story of the relationship between a poor human family and an exiled musical alien. The Hobb stories were nice little snippets of new characters in each area of her main world: the Rain Wilds, Bingtown and the Six Duchies. I had read Homecoming in the Legends II anthology many moons ago but enjoyed it again as background for The Rain Wilds Chronicles which I've...more
I love having the extra bits of story to fill in the history of the Rain Wilds, the Trader Culture and even some Buck culture about the Wit. I love Robin Hobbs' work.
What I discovered here is that while Robin Hobb is still one of my favorite authors, that her alternate ego Megan Lindholm is not. I LIKE Lindholm's short stories in this collection, but her contemporary fantasy has a dispassionate edge that doesn't reach me as deeply. Hobb also has a lot of characters which are more pragmatically r...more
What I discovered here is that while Robin Hobb is still one of my favorite authors, that her alternate ego Megan Lindholm is not. I LIKE Lindholm's short stories in this collection, but her contemporary fantasy has a dispassionate edge that doesn't reach me as deeply. Hobb also has a lot of characters which are more pragmatically r...more
I personally found this collection to be a mixed bag. After reading it, I realized that I much prefer Robin Hobb's tales to Megan Lindholm's stories. I like Hobb's ability to immerse us into a completely new world and introduce us to dynamic characters. All three of Hobb's stories allow room and circumstance for the growth of her characters, while most of Lindholm's characters felt as flat as the paper pages on which their stories tread. Lindholm's style seems to be very story driven while Hobb'...more
...This collection is not a complete overview of the short fiction Lindholm and Hobb have produced but it clearly showcases that variety of works the author is capable of. Overall I thought The Inheritance is a strong collection. There's only one piece I consider weak, which is about as good as most collections get. It's also a good introduction to the Megan Lindholm side of the author's writing. Although I love the Hobb stories, I think this pseudonym does limit her to the more traditional epic...more
Aug 24, 2011
Jacque
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Shelves:
adventure,
anthology,
cats,
fantasy,
female-heroine,
future-of-earth,
satire,
to-buy,
urban-fastasy
I am always amazed at the craft of developing short stories. This group was truely some of the best I've read. I've always been a huge fan on Robin Hobb and the way her characters grow and learn. I was thrilled to find two stories that take place in one of my favorite fantasy destinations. "Homecoming" was epic for it's size. I had not read anything by Megan Lindholm before, it was very different from Hobb. It dealt more with social issues and the human condition in an urban fantasy setting. I d...more
There should really be two ratings for each author. I came into this book expecting to like the Hobb stories more but surprisingly it was the Lindholm ones that most grabbed my attention. A Touch of Lavender was a nice blend of fantasy and sci fi with themes of love, family, and home. Cut was a great question and debate story. When are you in control of what you do to your own body? The Fifth Squashed Cat poses the question what does it feel like to be the unchosen one. Drum Machine asks if it's...more
I don't normally like books of short stories. I find them jarring, going from character to character, small plot to another completely different small plot. Not for this one! This may be becuase she prefaces each story with a little intro, which often include little glimpses into her life at the time of the writing. (Yay, bonus!)
I fell in love with Robin Hobb from the moment I picked up her books, and discovering Megan Lindholm has been just as rewarding. Though I know they are one and the same,...more
I fell in love with Robin Hobb from the moment I picked up her books, and discovering Megan Lindholm has been just as rewarding. Though I know they are one and the same,...more
This was really good. I do not generally enjoy short stories, but each story did a great job of quickly bringing the charicters to life, endearing me to them, starting some intrique or action and taking me for a quick ride. I havent read anything by Ms. Hobb for a while, and i do not remember reading Lindholm stuff. This will change. I now am going to reserve some books by them both right after I am done messing around here on goodreads. My favorite story was by Hobb, "Homecoming" a story of the...more
There have been a few fantasy writers over the years that have brought out successful short story collections – Stephen Donaldson and George RR. Martin spring to mind and I’d have to say, this collection from Robin Hobb (and Megan Lindholm – her other pseudonym) is amongst the best I’ve seen.
The stories themselves are a mixture, with Megan Lindholm’s collection being more eclectic and varied, whilst Robin Hobb’s are longer and more intricately woven and are written in the style we’ve come to ex...more
The stories themselves are a mixture, with Megan Lindholm’s collection being more eclectic and varied, whilst Robin Hobb’s are longer and more intricately woven and are written in the style we’ve come to ex...more
The Inheritance: And Other Stories[return]Robin Hobb[return]Harper Voyager (2011), Edition: Original, Paperback, 400 pages[return][return]The many voices of Megan/Robin/Lindholm/Hobb. A collection of short stories ranging from Bingtown and Rain Wild to a suburban Sears and more. There is a delightful cast of characters and creatures; from cats to 'coons, vampires and aliens. The tales stand well on their own, but some provide glimpses into worlds we're familiar with from her other books. Nice pa...more
Dec 23, 2012
evan
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fantasy,
science-fiction
As with a lot of other readers, this was my first time reading work by Hobb's other pseudonym Lindholm. It was fascinating to me to see how the same author had two very different, yet equally captivating, voices. I'll definitely be checking out other works by Lindholm in the future.
I don't usually like short stories, or rather, I find them frustrating to read because it takes me awhile to get into a new characters world, and by the tie I do, it is done. These stories were almost all worth the ef...more
I don't usually like short stories, or rather, I find them frustrating to read because it takes me awhile to get into a new characters world, and by the tie I do, it is done. These stories were almost all worth the ef...more
Jeg har tænkt over, hvorfor mon Robin Hobb (aka Megan Lindholm) er så populær. Og med denne samling af hendes kortere arbejder, er svaret tættere på. Det er fordi hun rent faktisk kan skrive. I samlingen The Inheritance er der korte introduktioner til, hvorfor hun har skrevet de enkelte stykker og det er både interessant og indsigtsfuldt. Det er ikke al hendes fantasy der er godt - de serier hvor hun bliver for episk i sin sprogbrug er kedelige - men hun har bestemt ramt guld flere gange i karri...more
Short story collections are often a bit hit and miss, and this one is no real exception to the rule, even though all the stories were written by the same person. Robin Hobb and Megan Lindholm may be two personas of the same woman, but they have distinctly different styles with Lindholm dealing in the urban fantasy and science fiction genres, and Hobb in fantasy only. Indeed, all of Hobb's stories are set in the Realm of the Elderlings universe, nice for a fan like me but potentially troublesome...more
As with everything else I've read by Robin Hobb/Megan Lindholm, I enjoyed reading this book but spent most of the time wanting to slit my own throat. She is a talented author and I will continue to look forward to her new books, but the constant misery does get wearing after a while.
It's interesting to see how far back the misery goes, actually. Some of the Lindholm stories are twenty years old, or more, and they're just as grim and depressing as the newer stories by Hobb. Well-crafted misery, b...more
It's interesting to see how far back the misery goes, actually. Some of the Lindholm stories are twenty years old, or more, and they're just as grim and depressing as the newer stories by Hobb. Well-crafted misery, b...more
Robin Hobb has been one of my favorite fantasy authors ever since I first stumbled upon the Farseer trilogy. As such, when I desired to once more get back on the reading fantasy bandwagon, I decided to use her as a stepping stone eventhough I had not found the Soldier-trilogy or The Dragon Keeper to match my earlier love affairs with her bibliography, in other words, I claimed a copy of this collection in hopes that it will resurrect my fantasy reading fervor, or at least rekindle it a little.
Al...more
Al...more
THE INHERITANCE & OTHER STORIES by Robin Hobb and her other pen name Megan Lindholm, is a compilation of old and new short works, several of which are set in previous worlds she's built. Whether new to or experienced with Hobb/Lindholm novels (I'm particularly in love with her two Farseer Trilogies), this collection of short stories is worth reading on their own merit. She doesn't fear to tread those difficult subjects that make us squirm or create people we can't help to love...or hate.
"A T...more
"A T...more
c2011. Devoured is the only way that I can describe how I read this book. Anthologies/short stories are not usually something I will voluntarily get hold of but I just have to read every word that Ms Hobb/Lindholm writes. Every story was brilliant in its own right and the author's notes at the start of each new story shone a new light onto the reading of the story. I absolutely adore the Six Duchies (Bingtown, Rain Wilds et al) world and inhabitants and these short stories just reminded me just...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
** I am shocked to find that some people think a 2 star 'I liked it' rating is a bad rating. What? I liked it. I LIKED it! That means I read the whole thing, to the last page, in spite of my life raining comets on me. It's a good book that survives the reading process with me. If a book is so-so, it ends up under the bed somewhere, or maybe under a stinky judo bag in the back of the van. So a 2 st...more
More about Robin Hobb...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“The only magic that's left in the world right now is the magic that we make ourselves, deliberately. You're not going to stumble over enchantment by chance. You have to be open to it, looking for it, and when you first think you might have glimpsed it, you have to will it into your life with every machination available to you.”
—
7 people liked it
“Cats talk to whomever they please.”
—
4 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





view 1 comment




















