Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Earth Hums in B Flat” as Want to Read:
The Earth Hums in B Flat
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Earth Hums in B Flat

3.69 of 5 stars 3.69  ·  rating details  ·  1,513 ratings  ·  288 reviews
Young Gwenni Morgan has a gift. She can fly in her sleep. She’s also fond of strawberry whip, detective stories and asking difficult questions. When a neighbour mysteriously vanishes, she resolves to uncover the secret of his disappearance and return him to his children. She truthfully records what she sees and hears: but are her deductions correct? What is the real truth? ...more
Kindle Edition, 346 pages
Published (first published November 1st 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Earth Hums in B Flat, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Earth Hums in B Flat

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jo
“Whales, porpoises, mermaids and mermen, dead sailors, fishes, crabs, tiny shrimps; the sea is forever full of eyes that watch me. I never fly far beyond the shore. If my town were a map the bay would have Here be Monsters written on it in golden ink.”

It always feels a cop out when I write a review about a book such as ‘The Earth Hums in B- Flat’ because I’m going to go on and on about how much I enjoyed it and you’ll read with wide-eyes shining, practically quivering with excitement because y
...more
Emily
Really quite good, but somewhat painful reading. It reminds me in some ways of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time in that it's about an ultra-naive child who decides to turn detective and is oblivious to the consternation she leaves in her wake as she goes about her investigations. A case could be made for an Asperger's diagnosis for Gwenni (besides her inability to comprehend other people's reactions, there's her extreme sensitivity to tastes and smells -- one has to read rather ...more
Katy Noyes
4.5 stars

Reminded me of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime - a murder mystery with a protagonist whose world view differs from that of the reader.

Gwenni is 13. She's smart but also naive and very imaginative, believing she can fly. Her mother, clearly with her own issues, worried that people will think her daughter mad. When looking after a teacher's young children, she becomes involved in their family tragedy, and vows to solve the mystery for them.

As Gwenni digs (to her mother's
...more
Felice
I'm suspicious of adult novels told in the first person from a child's point of view. The child is never really a child. It's always a quirky little prophet machine. It's innocence a mask in place to reveal the hypocrisy of adults. This doesn't mean that there haven't been novels like this that I have enjoyed. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time and The Sweetnees at the Bottom of the Pie come to mind.

Another book to add to this list is The Earth Hums In B Flat by Mari Stranchan. G
...more
Karen
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Stefanie
I thought this was an interesting book. I picked it up in a charity shop because I liked the title and cover and thought it sounded interesting.

For me it fell a little short. We never learn the full story about Mam and Ifan Evans and why she still seemed to love him 14 or so years later even though he was abusive to his wife and possibly his children (they never did say what really happened to the twins).

I just felt the story was all a little too vague, with some things Gwenni investigated too m
...more
Carrie Fletcher
‘Gwenni Morgan is not like any other girl in her small Welsh town. Inquisitive, bookish and fill of spirit, she can fly in her sleep and loves playing detective. So when a neighbour mysteriously vanished and no one seems to be asking the right questions, Gwenni decided to conduct her own investigation.’
It was only by chance that I stumbled across this book and decided to buy it. I was supposed to be working and when i got there i got a call saying they’d moved the time we were meeting to and hou
...more
Patrick Neylan
It's set in Wales. Don't forget that. Well, you can't. In fact, the author spends most of the first 100 pages painting an initially charming but eventually tiresome picture of an authentic North Welsh town in the Catherine Cookson-style long-ago-when-life-was-harder-but-the-world-was-better picture-postcard past. For instance, things are never white, they're "as white as the winter snow on Llapgoch" - just in case at any point you forget that IT'S SET IN WALES.

When the story finally gets going,
...more
Rhi
superb, absolutely superb.
i didn't want it to end, and dragged out reading it because of that.

welsh literature is my most favorite of genres, and this did not disappoint. full of all the good stuff, madness, murder, family, welsh tradition, and one superb little female protagonist. what is it that makes me love welsh literature so much? perhaps the nostalgia of tea time at my mam and da's, with a spread of bread and butter and cakes gallore. perhaps the phrases that really are still used today a
...more
Nicola
This book definitely gets full marks for originality. I don't think I've ever read anything quite like it before. Both the writing style and plot were interesting and unique. I liked the setting a lot and also enjoyed all the interesting Welsh names. Gwenni was a likable enough character and she had an intriguing way of looking at things. The story moved a little too slowly for my liking though and I predicted the main plot twist from the start which was annoying. Most of the characters were pre ...more
Robyn
Didn't enjoy this at all, I feel tricked somehow by the synopsis! Really boring and a very weak storyline. Most of the book was spent describing old fashioned ways of living.
Philippa
4-4.5*

The story itself is told from the perspective of 12 year old Gwenni, growing up in the 1950s in Wales. Gwenni is a kind and thoughtful girl, with a very active imagination, firmly believing that in her sleep she flies and hears the sound of the earth's hum. One day, when a member of the community goes missing she is determined to work out what has happened as she watches the people she love feel the shock waves of it. Gwenni's quest for answers will reveal some buried truths about the peo
...more
Mark
This book was a fascinating approach to childhood, eccentricity and the dangerous knock on effect of ill kept secrets. The narrator, a young girl called Gwenni, is attempting to pick her way through the ups and downs of that strange unknown hinterland of childhood moving into adolescence. Falling in and out of friendship, discovering boys but not particularly liking the discovery and over arching it all is her bizarre imagination and a whole host of phobias and worries. Her family life is, to sa ...more
Trudi
This book starts out slow with not a whole lot happening. It’s definitely one of those reads that sneaks up on you in an amazing way, and you are so grateful to have stuck with it by the time you reach the end. Strachan uses a lot of Welsh idioms and dialect which takes a bit of getting used to. The first half is on the lighter fluffier side as the characters that populate Gwenni’s young life and a small 1950s Welsh town are introduced.

Told in the first-person, Gwenni is a precocious and imagina
...more
Kelly
On the surface The earth hums is about the humdrum life in a small 1950's Welsh town as seen through our protagonist Gwenni Morgan. Gwenni is a somewhat lonely young girl who is a voracious reader of novels including detective tales. She also has a vivid imagination believing that she can fly at night and that toby jugs and the distemper in her house are watching her family. In spite of her imagination everything is black and white for Gwenni and she takes things very literally. When the husband ...more
Grace
'The Earth Hums In B Flat' center's around oddball twelve-year-old Gwennie as she tries to solve the mystery of her neighbors disappearance and discover her family history. Strachan creates a brilliant picture of a small Welsh community where everyone knows everyone's secrets but nobody ever speaks of them. Her character's are wonderfully described, I especially enjoyed the police Sargent who seemed to make everything groan under his weight. Gwennie's mother is suffering from some sort of bi-pol ...more
Nikki
(Final book for the readathon. Seventh book/eighth text. Finished the last third after the readathon ended.)

I don't know what I expected from this book. It's somewhat marketed as a mystery, I suppose, but that's a little misleading. The central character, Gwenni, isn't a precocious little child detective, a mini Sherlock Holmes. She's a slightly odd child, with a lot of imagination and a funny way of putting things, and about the complications in her life that begin with the disappearance of one
...more
Susan Roebuck
Another favourite read for 2014.
One of the secrets of a great book, in my opinion, is the "voice". In this case it's the voice of a 12, getting on for 13-year-old girl. Yet, this is no children or young adult book, it's firmly in the adult field as the plot unfolds through the innocent eyes of Gwenni - a loveable and gifted girl who observes her Welsh village life, its poverty and hardships as perfectly normal. Somehow the narrator reminded me of a young Dylan Thomas with simple yet beautiful pr
...more
Louise
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Karen
The main character, Gwenni, is a young girl living in Wales in the 1950's. Gwenni wants to be a detective when she grows up and gets herself in trouble often by asking too many questions. She can't help it. She has a curious mind. She 'has' to know about things. Oh, and Gwenni can fly . . .

This is a beautifully written book. The Welsh names took a bit of getting used to at first, but I found myself giving the characters names I could pronounce :) A touching story, but not overly sentimental, wit
...more
Pauline
I enjoyed parts of it but was quite depressing in other parts. Average read for me.
Surymae
...Menomale che non ci ho speso soldi. Menomale che non ho dato ascolto al mio istinto spendaccione che mi suggeriva di comprare "La musica segreta della terra" perché sembrava bello. Altrimenti avrei avuto un libro ben al di sotto delle aspettative che mi ero fatta. Un libro che é partito piuttosto male, per poi risollevarsi praticamente alla fine. E' partito piuttosto male per diversi motivi; prima di tutto per la voce narrante, Gwenni. Credo che, nel scegliere il punto di vista in prima perso ...more
Nicole
I stayed up until 2 am reading this book, but I still don't know how I feel about it. I mean, I liked it, and I read it in about two days but some parts made me feel weird. Gwenni reminded me a bit of Flavia de Luce, but not quite. I liked how she gave us all the information but because Gwenni was a child she couldn't quite figure it out, however that made all the twists and turns a bit predictable. All of my guesses were true. But the writing was lovely.
Val
The book is set in Harlech in the late 1950s and narrated by twelve-and-a-half year old Gwenni Morgan. Gwenni lives in her imagination and is closer to younger children than her sister and sometime friend, who are both a year older. Gwenni's father is happy for her to stay a little girl, her mother finds her constantly exasperating, her sister and friend find her babyish, the neighbours, fellow chapel-goers and other relatives find her either quaint or odd and the youngest child loves her.
I foun
...more
Sian
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Mum
kindle/audio

This is a strong first novel, I was mesmerized by it. I love Gwenni, I saw so much in her that was me as a young girl, trying to make her way with a huge imagination, a life that sometimes needed escaping from, a highly sensitive personality (OH! I so related with her feelings about Corned Beef! I have grown to like it, but as a kid? GAG!) and not quite understanding the subtleties of the world and the people around her. She is moving from her quite literal and black and white unders
...more
John Owen
There's an inexorable slowness about this book, which is really good. Set in a small 1950s Welsh town, it tells the story of Gwenni (the narrator) and her family, as events bring out secrets long hidden, dating back to the second world war and beyond. Gwenni is a fantasist, who dreams of flying, of being a detective, of many things. But she's still a young girl, in her early teens, so her life is constrained by her family, by school and by the local church. When a man goes missing, the husband o ...more
Urszula
I liked this book from the very first page. Normally I don't like books written in first person, but this one was different. Maybe because the story was told through the eyes of a teenage girl. A girl surrounded by untold secrets which led to lots of pain in her life.

Her mother, who should have loved her unconditionally would tell her time and time again how much she hates her, and wishes she was never born.

Her older sister, who took clues from her mother, showed no love for the sister, and when
...more
wanderaven
Quite an exceptional book - though rather more depressing than I'd anticipated.

Is it fair to take a book down a star because it hits a bit too close to home? I'm sure it isn't but since I'm the reviewer in this little world, I'll allow myself the indiscretion.
Pauline Lindeque
Beautifully written. I read this book twice in short succession as I loved all the small pretty ways of describing the world. An innocent little girl finds herself facing real world stuff and finds this confusing.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Is this a good book club book? 5 31 Sep 28, 2012 02:40AM  
  • Jasmine Skies
  • All Fall Down
  • Brown Skin Blue
  • The Coward's Tale: A Novel
  • Beswitched
  • Solace of the Road
  • Mistakes in the Background
  • Naked
  • Over
  • The Knot
  • Losing it
  • A Sky Full of Kindness
  • Resistance
  • Being Billy
  • Shipwrecked (Shipwrecked, #1)
  • The Girl With Glass Feet
  • Wann wird es endlich wieder so, wie es nie war
  • Agatha'nın Anahtarı (Başkomiser Nevzat #1)
2303385
Mari Strachan was born into a Welsh family in Harlech, on the north-west coast of Wales, and was brought up there with Welsh as her first language.

After graduating from Cardiff University she qualified as a chartered librarian, and worked in a variety of libraries, from academic through public and prison to school libraries, with occasional forays into other occupations.

In 2007 she acquired an MA
...more
More about Mari Strachan...
Blow on a Dead Man's Embers

Share This Book

“Up here, far away from everybody, the night is peaceful: there's no sound except the hum of the Earth. At school, when I sang the note to Mr Hughes Music he said it was B flat but he laughed when I said it was the note the Earth hummed. He said: You'll be hearing the music of the spheres next, Gwenni. But he doesn't know how the Earth's deep, never-ending note clothes me in rainbow colors, fills my head with all the books ever written, and feeds me with the smell of Mrs. Sergeant Jones's famous vanilla biscuits and the strawberry taste of Instant Whip and the cool slipperiness of glowing red jelly. I could stay up here for ever without the need for anything else in the whole world.” 5 likes
“Whales, porpoises, mermaids and mermen, dead sailors, fishes, crabs, tiny shrimps; the sea is forever full of eyes that watch me. I never fly far beyond the shore. If my town were a map the bay would have Here Be Monsters written on it in golden ink.” 1 likes
More quotes…