220th out of 926 books
—
5,294 voters
The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye
by
A.S. Byatt
The magnificent title story of this collection of fairy tales for adults describes the strange and uncanny relationship between its extravagantly intelligent heroine--a world renowned scholar of the art of story-telling--and the marvelous being that lives in a mysterious bottle, found in a dusty shop in an Istanbul bazaar. As A.S. Byatt renders this relationship with a pow...more
Paperback, 274 pages
Published
October 27th 1998
by Vintage International
(first published 1994)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I fell in love with the work of A. S. Byatt after reading her story "The Story of the Eldest Princess". I love fairy tales, but I also am the eldest child in my family and always felt a little slighted because in most fairy tales the older children fail. Even after I learned why that was, it still got tiresome. It was refreshing to read a story that approached fairy tales from the viewpoint of an eldest child who knows she is caught in the tale and what that means. It's a wonderful story for any...more
I think I have a new author to add to my quiver of favorites. This is the second book by Byatt I have read, and both have been spectacular!
Byatt’s style is poetic, lyric and beautiful. The words process like an ancient tapestry telling an epic story. Byatt’s sentences are often long and contain many phrases, but rarely do they seem clumsy or hard to follow. Instead the phrases march out a beat that leads to a clear concise thought. There is an echo of haunting in the writing as well, a note of...more
Byatt’s style is poetic, lyric and beautiful. The words process like an ancient tapestry telling an epic story. Byatt’s sentences are often long and contain many phrases, but rarely do they seem clumsy or hard to follow. Instead the phrases march out a beat that leads to a clear concise thought. There is an echo of haunting in the writing as well, a note of...more
...Because sometimes, a completely modern fairytale, so-called, just won't do.
I still have sitting on my bedside table Possession, by Byatt. It is sitting there all forlorn, halfway-read with a growth which stagnated a couple of months back, when I found I just couldn't read another page at that moment. And still I haven't reached the next moment that will make me pick up the book and continue reading it.
Possession is one of those books that's like very dark, incredibly rich chocolate brownies....more
I still have sitting on my bedside table Possession, by Byatt. It is sitting there all forlorn, halfway-read with a growth which stagnated a couple of months back, when I found I just couldn't read another page at that moment. And still I haven't reached the next moment that will make me pick up the book and continue reading it.
Possession is one of those books that's like very dark, incredibly rich chocolate brownies....more
I've always loved Byatt's fairy tales, which often appear in her novels (see Possession and The Children's Book), so I was excited to find a whole book of them. And these are not only about fairly tales, they are all about the reasons we tell stories and what it means to be inside one. (Of course, that's what all Byatt's books are about on some level, but that's a theme too large for a small internet review.) There are five stories in this book, but it's more like four stories and one novella. I...more
This one got me emotionally, intellectually, and viscerally. Five enchanting fairytales for adults that successfully triggered the magical feelings of childhood while surviving the scrutiny of adult wisdom and modern sensibilities. Clever, very clever, as A.S. Byatt certainly is.
The jist of the djinn, the namesake story? A divorced, past-her-prime, upper middle-aged professor specializing in narratology finds herself in the possession of a genie trapped inside a beautiful “nightingale eye" glas...more
The jist of the djinn, the namesake story? A divorced, past-her-prime, upper middle-aged professor specializing in narratology finds herself in the possession of a genie trapped inside a beautiful “nightingale eye" glas...more
I'm torn in writing this review. I adored first four of the five fairy stories in A. S. Byatt's "The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye": limpid lambent language and the twisting satisfaction of fairy plotlines, so familiar, yet surprising. True almost all of the four had elements which I could critique, like loose ends and jumpy plots (like in Dragons' Breath), or sometimes characters apparently there just as foils (like the woodsman in "The Glass Coffin" or the little thing in Gode's Story), but t...more
I just encountered Byatt for the first time, and despite her jaundiced view of the Harry Potter books, I have to say she's really a great read. This book contains four retellings or reimaginings of traditional fairy tales and a more realistic novella about a middle-aged professor who encounters the titular djinn on a trip to Turkey. The literary snob in me really appreciates the fact that she's a master wordsmith who also treats fairy tales seriously, but what really won me over was "The Story o...more
Finding an immaculate copy of the first edition in a London used bookstore - reviewing slip hidden between the pages - I decided to indulge in reading more of Byatt's inventive and refreshing "fairy stories," tales with more than a nodding familiarity to conventions Propp would have argued for, but told with wonderful humour and sensitivity. My chance was amply rewarded: the stories in this little volume are a mix of short and long, serious and light-hearted. I particularly liked the closing tal...more
The collection is a little disjointed - the earlier stories are short and a little confused, though the expressions quite beautiful at times. It wasn't until the very end of the last (most substantial) story - Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye, that words and ideas came together. I think most of the earlier short stories are explained by A.S. Byatt's fascinations - "The Glass Coffin" with glass, suspension of time within glass; "The Story of the Eldest Princess"- of Fate and falling within the narr...more
Apr 25, 2009
Destiny
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
female-authors,
fiction
I liked the self-awareness of the stories in this volume--how the characters were familiar with fairy tales, and that informed their actions and decisions in some way. In particular, I enjoyed "The Glass Coffin," "The Story of the Eldest Princess," and the title story for this reason. The emphasis on the act of storytelling gave me a lot to ponder. Also, I love that the title story uses the frame narrative structure--stories being told within the story--but without the neccesity of The Arabian N...more
I read this for the Mythic Fiction book group here on Goodreads, but never got around to going and posting about it over there...
A collection of 5 stories - 4 very short, and one novella-length (the title story). The first 4 stories were excellent - but 4.5 stars for the first half of the book, and 2 stars for the second half (actually, it's a little more than half) averages out to 3.
The Glass Coffin -
A humble tailor granted magical gifts, a sleeping princess, an enchanted prince, an evil magic...more
A collection of 5 stories - 4 very short, and one novella-length (the title story). The first 4 stories were excellent - but 4.5 stars for the first half of the book, and 2 stars for the second half (actually, it's a little more than half) averages out to 3.
The Glass Coffin -
A humble tailor granted magical gifts, a sleeping princess, an enchanted prince, an evil magic...more
Aug 20, 2011
Anne
marked it as abandoned
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
short-stories,
fairy-tales
I've finished all stories but the titular one. I have to say that Byatt did a remarkable job at making the stories read like fairy tales, which isn't much of a compliment if you've ever read any fairy tales. They tend to be sparse on description and characterization.
"The Glass Coffin" was a comfortably predictable fairy tale, with a slightly different ending. The "happy ending" takes a different tone that the usual "hero marries the princess" endings in most fairy tales.
"Gode's Story" is one I d...more
"The Glass Coffin" was a comfortably predictable fairy tale, with a slightly different ending. The "happy ending" takes a different tone that the usual "hero marries the princess" endings in most fairy tales.
"Gode's Story" is one I d...more
Jun 30, 2009
Nwm
added it
"The Glass Coffin"
Short and uninteresting, the first short story of the collection made me immediately doubt the person who recommended Byatt.
"The Miller's Daughter"
-A sad story that I had difficulty getting into initially. I don't feel as though I understood the underlying message of the story nor any of its allusions well enough to appreciate the story, but it was a decent read.
"The Story of the Eldest Princess"
An interesting take on the princess fairytale, and certainly more engaging than "...more
Short and uninteresting, the first short story of the collection made me immediately doubt the person who recommended Byatt.
"The Miller's Daughter"
-A sad story that I had difficulty getting into initially. I don't feel as though I understood the underlying message of the story nor any of its allusions well enough to appreciate the story, but it was a decent read.
"The Story of the Eldest Princess"
An interesting take on the princess fairytale, and certainly more engaging than "...more
Another author introduced during my class exploring fairy tales. In this case, A. S. Byatt has modern original fairy tales (as opposed to Angela Carter's modern retelling/resetting of "classic" tales) for us to enjoy.
1. The Glass Coffin: Very similar to the idea of Sleeping Beauty. Nothing too outstanding.
2. Gode's Story: kinda weird story involving a dancer with wanderlust who asks a girl to wait for him, and this girl seems to pine and wither while waiting, and somehow there's a mysterious dan...more
1. The Glass Coffin: Very similar to the idea of Sleeping Beauty. Nothing too outstanding.
2. Gode's Story: kinda weird story involving a dancer with wanderlust who asks a girl to wait for him, and this girl seems to pine and wither while waiting, and somehow there's a mysterious dan...more
It’s a collection of 5 “fairy stories,” although that being said, this is the author who got the award of Number One Partypooper when she snubbed adults who like Harry Potter because it’s so simplistic and the motifs so obvious and the magic so un-numinous. Fair enough, but please. Antonia, we know you’re rivals with your author-sister, and you don’t need to do any literary name-dropping to impress us. But that’s what she does in the titular tale, as it is about a fifty-something stout English n...more
As always, Byatt's work is stunning. The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye is a small collection of five stories - more accurately, four short fairy tales and a fifth story that's more of a novella, and follows a scholar in her 50s.
I had already read The Glass Coffin and enjoyed it, but as far as the four short pieces, The Eldest Princess might be my favourite. Her descriptions, dialogue, and characters are beautiful as always. , but it's Byatt's language that is, as usual, the most fantastic. I'v...more
I had already read The Glass Coffin and enjoyed it, but as far as the four short pieces, The Eldest Princess might be my favourite. Her descriptions, dialogue, and characters are beautiful as always. , but it's Byatt's language that is, as usual, the most fantastic. I'v...more
I got this book and Possession out from the library at the same time. Possession, it turned out, was a huge wash for me.
This book, on the other hand. This book is great.
The highpoint of the book is the title story, which starts out a tad slow but develops beautifully. There are certainly deeper themes, but they're not overwrought; it's about someone's story, their journey, not about the themes itself. The language is elegant and rich, the story here is highly compelling, and I was sad when I fin...more
This book, on the other hand. This book is great.
The highpoint of the book is the title story, which starts out a tad slow but develops beautifully. There are certainly deeper themes, but they're not overwrought; it's about someone's story, their journey, not about the themes itself. The language is elegant and rich, the story here is highly compelling, and I was sad when I fin...more
Four short stories in the form of fairy tales and one longer one. I quite liked the longer one, the others seemed too much like exercises (I’m Going To Write a Story Shaped Like a Fairy Tale). They also shared with many “authentic” fairy tales the quality of being thin on character and rather vague as to point. Since not having a point appears to be something of a feature of modern literature as well, I guess that makes this stuff very up to date.
I read this as part of a reading challenge. The subtitle to this is “A Collection of Five Fairy Stories”. This is not something I would have chosen without the challenge since I prefer novels to short stories. However, the stories are not all the same length. The last one, from which the collection gets its title, is what I would consider to be more of a novella rather than a short story.
The first four stories were just o.k. for me. They were interesting, but I didn’t think they were particular...more
The first four stories were just o.k. for me. They were interesting, but I didn’t think they were particular...more
strong storytelling. but I was drawn to this book the more because it was written after byatt's visit to turkey for a literary conference (organized by my beloved Istanbul University). those conferences are always a stage for drama, tears and blood. people mate, break up, teachers fall in love with their students and vice versa.
A much more sincere and moving read than Possession. Clever without needing to rub it in your face. I really enjoyed the weaving in of tales and fables; happily-ever-after analyses; stasis, death and freud; floating redundant -- and most of all the depth of characterisation that I certainly did not find in Possession.
I wasn't at all sure if I liked this when I started, I read on, poised along the edge of yes and no. And fell to the side of yes, and then I got to the last story, a novella really, The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye. And rang like a bell. It's beautiful and deep and writing I shall return to over the years...
A lovely book. I'm finding myself drawn to fairy tales lately and this one bridges modernity beautifully. The title story is especially luscious and I kind of want to turn around and read it again.
For more about how this book speaks to femininity, check out my blog.
For more about how this book speaks to femininity, check out my blog.
I quite enjoyed this collection of four short stories and a novella. All five stories touched on gender and sexuality, which was unexpected but welcome. They were also all very self-aware, subverting fairy tale tropes left and right. Beautifully written, if occasionally a little rambling. (Granted, the author hangs a lampshade on this in the titular story ...)
Jan 30, 2011
Virania Munaf
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
People who love whimsical stories with reality in it :)
Shelves:
favourite
I read this in late junior high/early high school. It's a wonderful introduction (more like: MY wonderful introduction) to the exhilarating world of Magical Realism. I absolutely love the inherent poetic flair of A.S Byatt and the rich cultural link in each stories.
Definitely one of my favourites!
Definitely one of my favourites!
Well executed but lacking in magic, and the author seems a bit too fond of her own voice. I liked the idea of the stories better than the actuality.
The Glass Coffin — Plays a bit with traditional quest/adventure choices and a little less with mate selection in fairy tales.
Gode's Story — Lovelorn and dancing; a study in ill-timed waiting.
The Story of the Eldest Princess — I was on board with the unusual animal helpers until we got to the cockroach. Still the best of the bunch.
Dragon's Breath — Li...more
The Glass Coffin — Plays a bit with traditional quest/adventure choices and a little less with mate selection in fairy tales.
Gode's Story — Lovelorn and dancing; a study in ill-timed waiting.
The Story of the Eldest Princess — I was on board with the unusual animal helpers until we got to the cockroach. Still the best of the bunch.
Dragon's Breath — Li...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Endicott Mythic F...: * The Djinn in the Nightingale's Eye - discussion | 10 | 18 | Mar 09, 2013 09:39am |
A.S. Byatt (Antonia Susan Byatt) is internationally known for her novels and short stories. Her novels include the Booker Prize-winning Possession, The Biographer’s Tale and the quartet, The Virgin in the Garden, Still Life, Babel Tower and A Whistling Woman, and her highly acclaimed collections of short stories include Sugar and Other Stories, The Matisse Stories, The Djinn in the Nightingale’s E...more
More about A.S. Byatt...
Share This Book
4 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Once upon a time, when men and women hurtled through the air on metal wings, when they wore webbed feet and walked on the bottom of the sea, learning the speech of whales and the songs of the dolphins, when pearly-fleshed and jewelled apparitions of Texan herdsmen and houris shimmered in the dusk on Nicaraguan hillsides, when folk in Norway and Tasmania in dead of winter could dream of fresh strawberries, dates, guavas and passion fruits and find them spread next morning on their tables, there was a woman who was largely irrelevant, and therefore happy.”
—
6 people liked it
“All English stories get bogged down in whether or not the furniture is socially and aesthetically acceptable.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...


































updated May 09, 2007 08:31pm