The Keep
by Jennifer Egan
|
|
Sign in to Goodreads to see your friends' reviews of The Keep.
discuss this book
friend reviews (0)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
other reviews (showing 1-20 of 1206)
Read in July, 2007
I picked this one up a month or so ago based on the NY Times Book Review writeup from forever ago, because was that review so positive that it glowed like a deep-sea anglerfish's esca? Oh, yes. But is that an apt metaphor? Also yes, because reading the book felt like being digested by an anglerfish (if you know what that feels like), plus guess what, and this is the most important take-away:
A book review in the NY Times Book Review is different from a book review in the NY Times...more
A book review in the NY Times Book Review is different from a book review in the NY Times...more
Like this review?
yes
(1 person liked it)
add a comment
bookshelves:
2008-book-list,
adult-2008
Read in February, 2008
Here's another one of my "write the review as I go" commentaries. ** SPOILERS **
1- I would NEVER have chosen this book on my own, which means someone recommended it to me, but I can't for the life of me remember who.
2- I don't like the protagonist. I didn't from the start, and 1/4 into the book he's only just starting to have some redeeming qualities, but even so I just can't warm up to him.
3- The swearing. Too much, I just don't like swearing in books, and I know many w...more
1- I would NEVER have chosen this book on my own, which means someone recommended it to me, but I can't for the life of me remember who.
2- I don't like the protagonist. I didn't from the start, and 1/4 into the book he's only just starting to have some redeeming qualities, but even so I just can't warm up to him.
3- The swearing. Too much, I just don't like swearing in books, and I know many w...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
general-fiction,
mystery-suspence
Read in November, 2007
**SPOILER FREE REVIEW**
Another so-so read, i was so excited for this book, especially after all the rave reviews of her first novel. Maybe i should have started with that one. This book is creatively written, Jennifer Egan knows how to draw the reader in immediately by raising their curiosity (and the dark horrible prank Danny pulled in his youth did that for me.)
Her best accomplishment is the narrator's voice and how it weaves the story in and out making you wonder just how he knows so ...more
Another so-so read, i was so excited for this book, especially after all the rave reviews of her first novel. Maybe i should have started with that one. This book is creatively written, Jennifer Egan knows how to draw the reader in immediately by raising their curiosity (and the dark horrible prank Danny pulled in his youth did that for me.)
Her best accomplishment is the narrator's voice and how it weaves the story in and out making you wonder just how he knows so ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in January, 2007
recommends it for:
Literary fiction lovers
Jennifer Egan's The Keep mixes love, ghost and Gothic stories into a fine literary thriller. While the book is a bit too self-referential to provide true scares or deep surprises, it manages to evoke dread and create suspense while spinning a story about the challenges of connecting with others.
The story begins in an unnamed Central European country where Howard invites his cousin Danny to come stay and work. Twenty years past, Danny was involved in a cruel prank on Howard, but now Howard is...more
The story begins in an unnamed Central European country where Howard invites his cousin Danny to come stay and work. Twenty years past, Danny was involved in a cruel prank on Howard, but now Howard is...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in March, 2008
My review of this book will sound like it deserves more stars than I've given it, because overall, I only found one flaw in this fine homage to ghost stories and their tellers. Unfortunately, it's a major one, though I'm sure some will read right past it without so much as a blip. Egan sets up two fascinating threads, that of two cousins coming together in adulthood to play out the effects a long-held secret between them, and the prisoner crafting their tale while taking a writing class from a...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
rejectbin
Read in September, 2006
i thought this was the most criminally over-hyped and misrepresented book of last year. clearly, Jennifer Egan has many well-placed friends (and fellow back scratchers) at the NY Times Book Section to fawningly and falsely fan the flames for this book. "The Keep" is two half-fleshed out novellas awkwardly crammed together. with a tacked-on third short story/chapter at the end.
i cannot believe that any accomplished and previously published author would look at this fragmentary and ...more
i cannot believe that any accomplished and previously published author would look at this fragmentary and ...more
Like this review?
yes
(2 people liked it)
add a comment
Read in April, 2007
The main plot of this book is the reunion of two estranged cousins at an ancient castle, but there is a lot of sub-plot/post-plot going on. The storyline follows the reunion of two cousins that long ago shared a horrific experience and have carried the guilt/fear from the experience into their adult lives. However, Howard is no longer the nerdy Dungeons and Dragons master of his youth, but a very wealthy (very tan) 30 something retiree. He has purchased an ancient European castle with the in...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
recommends it for:
goths, novel readers
I'm not sure what I think about The Keep, or better said, I'm not quite sure what to do with it yet. This is what I do know: I don't know a thing about crystal meth, and this is the second book I've read this year that touches on the topic--synchronicity.
I found the main character Danny completely unbelievable, all because Egan mentions fleetingly that he arrived at the castle in a goth getup. I wasn't sure the whole time whether the baroness was real or a ghost--and I'm still not sure. I d...more
I found the main character Danny completely unbelievable, all because Egan mentions fleetingly that he arrived at the castle in a goth getup. I wasn't sure the whole time whether the baroness was real or a ghost--and I'm still not sure. I d...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in September, 2007
A fun quick read, not half as tricky and Nabokovian as perhaps it would like to think (the solution to the puzzle isn't that much of a revelation, and the metafiction elements--always a hard trick to pull off if you're not the author of Pale Fire--can be a bit tiresome, and I didn't like the crazy German woman living in the tower) but I liked her articulation of modern inter-personal relations and the characterization of Danny as someone who is addicted to "being in contact" (through w...more
Like this review?
yes
3 comments
Another audio book that I listened to while entering data. Very strange, kind of an attempt on Gothic style but never really making it. I'm still pondering what I think of it. Basically 2 cousins come together in a run down castle years after experiencing a catastrophic event during their childhood. The book is the story of the tragic events that follow this reunion.
This is a story within a story within a story...with even another separate 'story' at the end. Typically I like this style if d...more
This is a story within a story within a story...with even another separate 'story' at the end. Typically I like this style if d...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
fiction,
read-in-2007
Read in September, 2007
A very peculiar book, about two cousins who re-unite at an old castle in Germany after not having seen each other since childhood. Along with this, it's the story of an inmate in prison for shooting someone in the head. At first, the transitions seemed a little jarring, as well as the narration, but I found it pretty easy to get the swing of.
A lot of readers seemed put off by the vague narration style, and how at times you don't really know what happened or if things were just a dream. I'm a...more
A lot of readers seemed put off by the vague narration style, and how at times you don't really know what happened or if things were just a dream. I'm a...more
Like this review?
yes
(1 person liked it)
add a comment
Read in March, 2007
I'm conflicted. I actually listened to this on audio CD, and I think that might have, at least in part, been the driving force behind actually finishing it... the narrator was excellent and nailed all of the characters. The book was well written, beautifully descriptive, etc. There were two parallel stories happening at once, which caused some initial confusion as far as story and character development. The end was mildly frustrating but still relatively unexpected, and the point at which th...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in December, 2007
I was struck by the great artistic control of a praticed and expert storyteller. I didn't particularly like the characters in the book, but that didn't stop me from really enjoying the story. (That was a surprise to me - that I could like the story without really connecting to the characters too much). It seemed to me that the story actually got better as I got deeper into the book. There was no saggy middle. New twists and turns were developed all the way through so that more and more light...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in January, 2007
recommends it for:
slumming medievalists
The Keep is one of those books that I listened to rather than read, so it's possible that awkwardly changing cds while driving may have negatively affected my impression. But I'm doing my best to be objective and I still cannot get over my feeling that Jennifer Egan is simply not writing well here. The elements of a great book all seem to be in place but her wacko plot manuevers bring you to dizzying heights only to let you down with another non-ending. Look at Me had ideas and pacing and cha...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in March, 2007
"The Keep" is literary neo-gothic novel that echoes some of the elaborate "frame tale" devices used in traditional gothic novels. It also takes advantage of postmodern "meta" fiction wink-winkyness. In my opinion, this book didn't follow out the implications of its elaborate and frankly wonderful set-up. It didn't get into why the characters who tell the story (and there are two layers of storytelling here) feel compelled to tell each other's story. This could have ...more
Like this review?
yes
(1 person liked it)
add a comment
Read in February, 2008
This books starts out as the story of two cousins who share a tragic childhood secret. Years later, Howard is rich and successful and renovating a castle in Eastern Europe. He invites the ne'er do well Danny out to help with the project. Several chapters later you learn that the Howard/Danny story is actually the creation of Ray, an inmate in a maxium-security prison. The chapters go back and forth between the two stories until eventually they intertwine. As Danny stays longer in the castle, he ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in February, 2008
Patrick sent this to me for my birthday (along with some lovely jewelry--in the words of En Vogue, "What a man, what a man, what a man, what a mighty good man"), and already I'm hooked. I'll report back soon!
***
The Keep manages to be juicy and readable, while also being quite bold in its storytelling and structure. Egan uses some good old fashioned gothic conventions to suck you into the story, and then reveals the narrator to be someone wholly unexpected. You continue to read...more
***
The Keep manages to be juicy and readable, while also being quite bold in its storytelling and structure. Egan uses some good old fashioned gothic conventions to suck you into the story, and then reveals the narrator to be someone wholly unexpected. You continue to read...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
2006booklist
Read in September, 2006
Okay, what a wacky book. I like wacky! But to me, this was random wackiness at the expense of the reader. Two cousins, Howie and Danny, meet as adults. There was an incident in their youth where Howie was abandoned in an old mine or something or other. He was found days later…physically fine, but mentally effected. Now Howie has bought a castle in Germany and has asked Danny to help him and his team restore the castle to its former glory. Danny, an email/internet junkie, hates the idea ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in April, 2008
This is bizarre and - I hate to say it - post-modern. It's really three stories crammed together, not all of which work. Reading this book was like watching the TV programme Lost, in that lots of narrative threads are started but never tied up, leaving me feeling dissatisfied at the end.
Unanswered questions are a great thing - they are what keep us reading - but they have to be answered at some point. Unfortunately, a lot of the questions in this novel are never answered, and it seems like ...more
Unanswered questions are a great thing - they are what keep us reading - but they have to be answered at some point. Unfortunately, a lot of the questions in this novel are never answered, and it seems like ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in September, 2006
recommends it for:
literary readers
There was something unusual about this book, which seemed to start as a tale of discord between cousins, an old secret come out to haunt them both. But the narrator wouldn't recede to the background. He kept interrupting and stopping, until his story burst out between the lines. A convict in a writing class falling for a teacher who has a story of her own. In someways, I was saddened by how the whole story tied together at the end, a feeling that resonated with my experience of reading Kevin Bro...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment

























