Lilith
read book* *Different edition

Lilith

by
3.94 of 5 stars 3.94  ·  rating details  ·  2,328 ratings  ·  219 reviews
'Lilith is equal if not superior to the best of Poe' Wrote W.H Auden in his introduction to the 1954 reprint of George MacDonald's Lilith, first published in 1895.

It is the story of Mr Vane, an orphan and heir to a large house - a house in which he has a vision that leads him through a large old mirror into another world. In chronicling the five trips Mr Vane makes to this...more
Paperback, 252 pages
Published 1982 by Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., Michigan (first published 1895)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Mike (the Paladin)
I was torn between 4 ans 5 for this one(at first). I love it in many ways and give it 5 stars. Some will probably find it a little harder to read but that's more due to the time in which it is written and it's slightly dated style. I'm not sure that "relax" is the right word here but "relax" into the book and "experience it". This book is in my opinion amazing. I got it out of the library and still would like to find a copy available locally.

Great book.

UPDATE:

I have since bought the book. It ha...more
Don Incognito
A review proper will be forthcoming. In the meantime, here are my raw notes taken during reading.

[June 2012] So far, this fantasy story is self-consciously impressionistic--the narrator tends to give vague and mysterious descriptions of what he sees, and repeatedly apologizes to the reader for being unable to describe them more adequately due to their strangeness.

7/19/2012

I've never read a book quite like this. It's bizarre...

7/22/2012
...possibly the most bizarre book I've ever read as an adult.
...more
Meg Powers
This was an interesting book to read after David Lindsay's A Voyage to Arcturus. Both deal with fantastic travel (Lilith with inter-dimensional travel, Arcturus with inter-planetary travel) as a means of religious and spiritual discovery. Both drag you on a harrowing journey, where many questions go unanswered. Lilith, however, is blatantly Christian. It is fun to read a fantasy novel that illustrates the milestones of Christianity, particularly Creation and the Resurrection, using quirky versio...more
Mark Becher
As my brother accurately described it, it starts out as a sort of Christian acid trip/Alice in Wonderland type experience. For the first half of the book you have almost no idea what is actually going on, but it's worth sticking it through because later it all falls into place. The story takes it's premise from an old Jewish myth about a companion named Lilith whom God gave to Adam before Eve. She was an angelic being, not human, and couldn't reconcile herself to the vocation of bearing Adam's...more
Danielle
Mar 19, 2009 Danielle rated it 1 of 5 stars
Recommended to Danielle by: Tanya
I have an enormous respect for George MacDonald. His books such as At the Back of the North Wind, The Princess and Curdie, The Princess and the Goblin, The Day Boy and the Night Girl and even Alec Forbes and His Friend Annie were among my childhood favorites--they were magical and my first brushes with fantasy at 8-10 years old. He was an exceptionally gifted and inspired writer of the 1800's. I even respect his history as a clergyman who loved god but left off being a preacher because he believ...more
Amanda
Much, much preachier and more metaphysical than Phantastes, this MacDonald fantasy appealed less to me but still kept me reading so that I finished all 250 pages in one sitting. In this book, MacDonald's love affair with death gets even heavier and creepier. He also seems to be making a commentary on the danger of the "New Woman," who willfully abandoned the role of "Angel in the House" at the turn of the century. The moments wherein he becomes wrapped up in the world-building aspect of the fant...more
Juushika
Following a phantom, an average man is pulled into a strange world--one ephemeral and magical, where issues of salvation are not theoretical but are instead a literal battle and quest. Lilith is a direct allegory of Christian Universalist salvation, laid atop strange magics and stranger symbolism. Over landscapes effervescent and transcendent, shadowed and looming, the beginning of the book is more of a ramble than a journey; at his best MacDonald is deeply evocative, and while the book's intern...more
Smcleish
Originally published on my blog here in May 2002.

George MacDonald may have written pure fantasy, both for adults (Phantastes) and for children (The Princess and the Goblin), but he has been most admired for the allegory of Lilith. This picture of Christian salvation is the reason for his influence on C.S. Lewis in particular; as well as being part of the inspiration for the Narnia stories and the Ransome trilogy, it is why Lewis makes MacDonald his guide to heaven in The Great Divorce.

Lewis, of...more
Michele Brenton
Not my cup of tea at all :( It was interesting from the historical perspective in that I could see so many points at which it had obviously inspired other writers and that is why I gave it two stars instead of one. I have enjoyed the books that came after it by other fantasy authors. But nowadays when there is so much choice of accessible tightly written fantasy which also chimes with the social mores of current society I find it difficult to believe anyone would genuinely read this for pure enj...more
Christopher Bunn
I'm a fan of George MacDonald for his fantasies and for his children's books. His two older fantasies, Lilith and Phantases, are difficult to read and they're difficult to pigeon-hole. But why do we even want to pigeon-hole things in the first place? Oh, right. Marketing.

Anyway, like I said, Lilith is not the easiest book to read. Perhaps it's partially due to the era MacDonald was writing in, but he certainly isn't pandering to the lowest denominator here. The story is a haunting tale of a man...more
Dylan Jay Smith
This is by far one of the darkest books I've ever read. Coming from a Christian minister, I would expect the book to be a bit preachy. I found, however, that the story is way more of a dark fairy tale set in a somewhat biblical world, with faint biblical themes. It's hard, of course, not to be a bit biblical, considering some of the main characters are Adam, Eve, and Lilith (the first wife of Adam). MacDonald writes this story in a way that truly makes them characters in a book, rather than bibl...more
Annette
Not my favorite of MacDonald's many excellent works, but worth reading if you're up for a bit of a challenge. Another "alternate world" story, it reminded me more of Alice in Wonderland or Through the Looking Glass (both about a generation older) than Narnia (roughly 50 years newer) - right down to the mode of access and a helpful/inscrutable rational animal guide. The Raven's world is highly dream-like with a plenitude of irrational or impossible occurrences in every chapter. However, unlike "W...more
C. Hollis Crossman
I give Lilith more than one star because it succeeds as a fairy tale; I give it no more than two because it fails on every other level.

It's not that MacDonald is a bad writer; he can make aesthetically pleasing sentences. It's just that his underlying premise is so unbiblical, and he doesn't stop pushing that premise in our faces throughout the entire novel.

Basically, this is MacDonald's most widely-read defense of universalism, that Hell isn't really a place of eternal torment but rather a hold...more
Φλεγύας
This is one of these books that I -personally- would classify as solid 5/5.
I only gave it a 4/5 for a single reason. MacDonald is not a typical writer. He was a priest, or, in the words of Wikipedia, a Christian minister.
Why's that of importance? Because, the folk and the shepherds may use the same language, but not in the same way.
The reader of this magnificent, allegoric, deeply religious fairytale will need to arm himself/herself with tones of good will to push onwards when the sentences beco...more
Karly Abreu
George MacDonald is one of the most severely underrated authors of all time. A contemporary to Lewis Caroll and major influence on C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien, this man’s imagination apparently knew no bounds and that is incredibly apparent in his masterpiece, Lilith. Narrated by a nameless everyman figure, it follows his adventures in a world he discovers after inheriting his father’s house and many unsettling circumstances there, leading him to a mirror which reveals another realm. Incredibl...more
John Caneday
MacDonald was a big influence on C.S. Lewis, as many know. Lewis acknowledges this in the preface to this edition. MacDonald was a universalist, which is quite apparent in reading Lilith. The entire premise of the book requires one to enter a world where universalism is presupposed. Universalism, at least the MacDonald version of it, believes that all people will eventually bow the knee to Christ in faith, repent, believe, and enter into the New Heavens and the New Earth. MacDonald even argues t...more
Veronica
'A long time we were together, I and the moon, walking side by side, she the dull shine, and I the live shadow.'


I didn't like Lilith the first time I read it, despite being a big fan of MacDonald (and the people he influenced, like CS Lewis & Tolkien), but over the years as I have read it and read it again it has become one of my favorite books. Do not make the mistake of trying to understand each nuance- that would be like trying to understand all the symbolism of a Salvador Dali painting....more
Elizabeth LaPrelle
I really really love George MacDonald--that is to say, I really really love his book, The Light Princess. I wanted to like Lilith a lot more than I did. It is so weird! And that's good. But...I don't know. I can be such a Whiny Wanda about this "allegory" business. Like, there's a Gulliver's Travels vibe here. I am not such a Gulliver fan. However, there are some excellent ambient MacDonald features: moonlight...ravens...old people who are completely awesome rulers of time/the universe...
Definit...more
cole
Lillith is a beautiful story that, as a good fairy tale should, draws the tragic and exultant in a heightening crescendo. The story is an enjoyable journey through an imaginative and enchanting allegory of love, forgiveness and redemption. The imagery is heavy enough that it is often hard to figure out just what everything represents or if someone or something represents anything at all. The narrator, Mr. Vane (one wonders if MacDonald was playing off the homophone with vain or not), can be hard...more
Jenna St Hilaire
In a beautiful introduction to the 2000 Eerdmans edition of this book, C.S. Lewis calls Lilith one of MacDonald’s great works, along with Phantastes, the Curdie books, The Golden Key, and The Wise Woman. “What he does best is fantasy,” Lewis says, “—fantasy that hovers between the allegorical and the mythopoeic. And this, in my opinion, he does better than any man.”

Having managed to read Phantastes without making sense of more than a quarter of it, I was not tempted to sympathize with Lewis goin...more
Jesse
I must admit, that at first I didn't think I was going to be able to finish this book. The prose seemed convoluted and obscure; I was often having to reread pages because I felt like I had missed something. However, I'm really glad I stuck with it because now I can honestly say that this is the best George MacDonald I've read.

"Lilith" is a dark biblical fantasy, but unlike anything I've come across. I would say that MacDonald's "Lilith" is to Genesis what America McGee was to "Alice and Wonderla...more
Jeslyn
This is the third novel I've read by George MacDonald, the first being The Princess and The Goblin, sort of a young-adult novel, which was wonderfully written. I then started searching out other titles and now have a little collection.

Frankly, I was a bit worried in the beginning - it started very reminiscent of Phantastes, and was loaded with exclamation points, which seemed odd...but don't be fooled: the story picks up in a hurry, and is an excellent read. MacDonald's imaginings of the world...more
Kerstin
I got this book for my 13th Birthday back then the German version of it. What can I say ? I couldn`t stop reading from the first sentence and didn`t count how many times I`ve read it again since... It got me into fantasy/gothic reading and still is my all time fav. This is one of those books one wants to take everywhere one goes. Somehow I lost that book due to moving once and it felt like a piece of myself was lost.
When I finally tried to buy it again here or get the english version - I had to...more
Kraig Horton
This was a very interesting read. At first MacDonald's style and prose read like it was going in circles, everything felt like it was all rhyme and puzzles. After looking beyond the way the story was written and diving into the characters, plot and symbolism, I found this novel to be quite amazing. The way the author took the idea of Adam and Eve and the symbols and concepts of Christianity and mixing it with a myth of Lilith supposedly adams first wife and then became the queen of hell. The boo...more
Ralph
The book is as difficult as people say it is, but I found it worth the effort. C. S. Lewis's introduction was a big help to me in getting into the book, and you can recognize in it many places that are reflected in Lewis' own writings. The evangelism of Lilith was perhaps the most remarkable and illuminating description I've ever read of the struggle of a person to come to faith.
Bridget West
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jenna
This is perhaps my favorite book of all time. It does not get enough good press. It is definitely MacDonald's magnum opus. I would recommend it to all fantasy-lovers and readers just looking for something refreshingly different. Like most of George MacDonald's work, Lilith does have strong religious undertones, but they are presented in a unique way that I don't believe will offend or even distract non-religious readers. The religious content is comparable to that in the works of CS Lewis. I pro...more
Becca
May 24, 2007 Becca added it
Shelves: fiction
He considered it his best book. I think "At the Back of the North Wind" is the best (although I've always liked Sir Gibbie and many others as well).

Dr. Neuhauser let me know about some publishers of unedited George MacDonald books.
Ron
The only thing more pathetic than this tale were the highlighting and marginal notes by someone who had no idea what MacDonald was about. Perhaps only read because all the great experts tell us to read it.
Adam Gilchrest
This story blew my mind. I believe that I was assuming that it would be rather straight forward but still full of symbolism. Im not sure why I assumed this. I was so bewildered and perplexed at one point early on, that I almost stopped reading it all together. I felt like I fell into Wonderland but it was deathly ill and out to murder Alice. Any way, I remember after the chapter entitled,"The White Leach" things began to make sense in my mind and then he goes and explains a lot of what happened...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
George MacDonald: Questions about Lilith 1 5 Jan 31, 2013 02:53am  
Lilith (Paperback)
Lilith (Kindle Edition)
Lilith (Paperback)
Lilith (Paperback)
Lilith: A Romance (Paperback)

2413
George MacDonald was a Scottish author, poet, and Christian minister.

Known particularly for his poignant fairy tales and fantasy novels, George MacDonald inspired many authors, such as W. H. Auden, J. R. R. Tolkien, C. S. Lewis, and Madeleine L'Engle. It was C.S. Lewis that wrote that he regarded MacDonald as his "master": "Picking up a copy of Phantastes one day at a train-station bookstall, I be...more
More about George MacDonald...
The Princess and the Goblin The Princess and Curdie Phantastes At the Back of the North Wind The Light Princess

Share This Book

Your website

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“Whose work is it but your own to open your eyes? But indeed the business of the universe is to make such a fool out of you that you will know yourself for one, and begin to be wise.” 36 people liked it
“A man is as free as he chooses to make himself, never an atom freer.” 34 people liked it
More quotes…