Symposium
by
Plato,
Benjamin Jowett
One of the most famous works from classical antiquity is Plato's "Symposium." The symposium of this work is more literally translated to mean a dinner-party. At this dinner-party several notable figures from classical antiquity, including Phaedrus, Pausanias, Eryximachus, Aristophanes, Agathon, and Socrates in turn give speeches in praise of the god of love. An i...more
Paperback, 96 pages
Published
January 1st 2006
by Digireads.com
(first published -380)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
8,962)
Non avendo avuto la fortuna di studiare filosofia alle superiori, nè di essermi interessata ad essa dopo, ignara totalmente del greco, mi son trovata davanti la sfida a leggere questo testo. Possedevo già 2 volumi con l'opera completa di Platone. Ovviamente mai letto nulla perchè, come al solito, compro per il piacere di comprare libri e spero un giorno di avere tempo di leggerli tutti.
Il testo che ho letto, però, mi è stato donato da una persona che riteneva avessi bisogno di lezioni d'am...more
Il testo che ho letto, però, mi è stato donato da una persona che riteneva avessi bisogno di lezioni d'am...more
Plato recounts a dinner party where all the guests drink wine until more-or-less drunk, and then proceed to participate in a "dinner-game" contest where each man present is required to give a speech in praise of love. The different speeches in praise of Eros belie Plato's philosophical agenda: to categorize love in its varied conceptions and manifestations, and to determine the form of love that is the most beautiful, noble, and worthy of pursuit. I was most moved by the recounting o...more
The Symposium was like a very filling snack - small, but potent. The Socratic method is always a treat when put into play, and I was fascinated by the way stories went into fourth- and fifth-hand accounts, rather a direct presentation - it added another dimension to the tale. I think anyone looking to read, and more, to understand the Symposium would need to know a little something about the history and society it's set in, as the topics the party-goers discuss, such as pederasty or the basen...more
As a philosophy-head, one usually falls into one of two ancient camps - Socrates or Aristotle, I am squarely in the Socrates camp. The Symposium may be the most widely read of Socrates works and deserves a look, it is an excellent entree into his style and form. He questions and questions and questions until the truth is drawn out. The topic of The Symposium is Love and what nobler of a topic is there? Many of the speakers focus on the base aspects of love or the virtues one should be speaki...more
I was required to read this for ENG150Y1Y, The Literary Tradition. That's right: a philosophical text in an English setting. I don't know why, either, since lectures haven't started yet.
So, the Symposium, the apparent start of the concept of 'Platonic love', even though it's never referred to, though I guess it's implied. The story's framed by a guy answering a question (again, apparently) and so telling the story of the time Socrates went to a party, didn't drink at all, and got eve...more
So, the Symposium, the apparent start of the concept of 'Platonic love', even though it's never referred to, though I guess it's implied. The story's framed by a guy answering a question (again, apparently) and so telling the story of the time Socrates went to a party, didn't drink at all, and got eve...more
I'm not a philosophy or ancient history student, I picked up Plato's "Symposium" to challenge myself and see if I could understand it. The "Symposium" is a gathering of Greek thinkers who sit around and give speeches about love.
Phaedrus talks about the greatness of love and how those who have it achieve great things. Pausanias talks of the merits of boy/man love where the boy pleasures the man while the man passes on his wisdom to the boy and that this is the bes...more
Phaedrus talks about the greatness of love and how those who have it achieve great things. Pausanias talks of the merits of boy/man love where the boy pleasures the man while the man passes on his wisdom to the boy and that this is the bes...more
There are many things that are admirable about this work that Plato may not have meant to touch upon, but then again maybe he did. Like the fact that it contains the ONLY passage from Classical Athens that recognizes the existence of homosexuality amongst females. There's more than one view in here that defies convention, and I can appreciate such diversity.
Anyway, most of the first half is just Plato setting things up for Socrates' turn in which he dissects his fellows' eulogies, so...more
Anyway, most of the first half is just Plato setting things up for Socrates' turn in which he dissects his fellows' eulogies, so...more
My most vivid impression from this book is Aristophanes' creation myth concerning humanity.
synopsis from Wiki;
"His speech is an explanation of why people in love say they feel "whole" when they have found their love partner. It is, he says, because in primal times people had doubled bodies, with faces and limbs turned away from one another. As somewhat spherical creatures who wheeled around like clowns doing cartwheels (190a), these original people were v...more
synopsis from Wiki;
"His speech is an explanation of why people in love say they feel "whole" when they have found their love partner. It is, he says, because in primal times people had doubled bodies, with faces and limbs turned away from one another. As somewhat spherical creatures who wheeled around like clowns doing cartwheels (190a), these original people were v...more
The prominent place the Symposium holds in our canon comes as much as a result of its literary merit as its philosophical merit. While other works among Plato's middle-period dialogues, such as the Republic and thePhaedo, contain more philosophical meat, more closely examining the Theory of Forms and intensely cross-examining interlocutors, none can match the dramatic force of the Symposium. It is lively and entertaining, with sharp and witty characterization that gives us valuable insight into ...more
Dusty
rated it
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Dusty by:
Elizabeth Richmond-Garza
Shelves:
graduate-school,
read-in-2010
A curious coincidence: It's 2010, and the debate over Proposition 8, which disallows state recognition of same-sex unions, has invited court testimony on the "nature" of homosexuals -- as politically unimportant, as sexually deviant, as likely sexual predators. That's in California. Here in Texas, for my graduate course on critical theory, we've just read Plato's "Symposium", which Edith Hamilton (the translator of my edition) says is one of the man's two best dialogues. Its ...more
Starts out slow, with mostly irrelevant speeches on the nature of Love. The first half or so is remarkable just for the interesting description it gives of Ancient Greek homosexual practices. It gets much more interesting once Socrates takes the floor, immediately ripping the false rhetoric of the hypocritical sophists in favor of Truth. His theory of love is interesting but is not at all what we think of as romantic love. . . it is more like love of truth/beauty/god and culminates in a mysti...more
Erik Graff
rated it
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
everyone
Recommended to Erik by:
no one
Shelves:
philosophy
Although I read the Symposium for the first time long ago, I reread the thing a couple of years ago in the Jowett translation with a friend who was finishing up a Ph.D. in Classics at Loyola University Chicago. He had come over for dinner and we read the thing aloud to one another afterwards with both the translation and the Greek text at hand.
The Symposium is often the first of Plato's texts read by students and it is a good choice because readily accessible to the beginner. Furth...more
The Symposium is often the first of Plato's texts read by students and it is a good choice because readily accessible to the beginner. Furth...more
Okay - so, as far as I can see, this dialogue is about love. Well, of course it is - everyone knows this, and the theme is made explicit right from the outset. Various people at this party give encomia on how wonderful love is - but then Socrates delivers the killer punch: we've all misunderstood what love really is. He broadens the discussion right out, pointing out that love stands midway between the imperfect and the perfect, the unholy and the holy. It's the dynamic flux which leads us from ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This may be Plato's best dialogue. The discussion here in on "Love." There are different degrees of love depending on how far removed from "The Form" of love something is. The furthest removed from the form is "eros." A bit closer to the form is "phileo." The closest to the form would be "agape." But, what makes this dialogue especially well written is that there is discussion on love along with the attempt to demonstrate the three types of...more
One morning after sitting in on another students exhibition, I had about two hours to kill. So I walked into Barnes & Nobel and found myself in the philosophy section and picked up this book. I sat down an dbarley looked up fromit's pages. The ideas in this book were not only well fleshed out but very thought provoking. I am sure I will have to read it again and take notes becuase there were mnay ideas presented in the book that I strongly disagreed with. Also, I believe some research should be ...more
Plato's account of Socrates on love was more engaging than I expected. In the eponymous symposium several figures present a speech in praise of love and its qualities. Perhaps best-known is the famous speech of Aristophanes in which he humorously claims that humans once had two heads and four arms and legs before being split in two by the gods, and we now seek to rejoin with our primordial double.
But Socrates really steals the show with his magnificent recounting of love as an instr...more
But Socrates really steals the show with his magnificent recounting of love as an instr...more
I was completely enthralled by this beautiful piece of writing all through-out. All of the speeches pronounced in an attempt to define "Love" are interesting in their own ways, and added something relevant that made me reflect. I particularly enjoyed Aristophanes's myth which was both touching and humorous, mainly because it so references all types of love: male-male, female-female, and male-female, and perhaps I have a soft spot for this way of thinking.
I was excited to rea...more
I was excited to rea...more
This work is a real jewel. Entertaining, and full of all sorts of little tidbits about love and sex; the effects of intoxicants on philosophical discourse; the nature of man's relationship with law. There's a reason everyone in the modern world knows the names of Plato and Socrates- a must read.
Symposium is Greek for “drinking party,” and it is in this setting of steady drinking and revelry where Socrates’ inquiry into the nature of love takes place among friends and acquaintances. The Symposium is my favorite of Plato’s dialogues and I especially enjoyed reading about the myth of love’s origins: how we humans were once one being—not sexless, but made of both sexes, and these creatures felt so powerful that they tried to scale the heights of heaven until incurring the wrath of Zeus, ru...more
"In fact, whenever I discuss philosophy or listen to others doing so, I enjoy it enormously, quite apart from thinking it's doing me good. But when I hear other kinds of discussion, especially the talk of rich businessmen like you, I get bored and feel sorry for you and your friends, because you think you're doing something important, when you're not." 173c
"I don't think you're a failure, I KNOW you are." 173d
"So not every type of loving and Love ...more
"I don't think you're a failure, I KNOW you are." 173d
"So not every type of loving and Love ...more
a remedial lesson of socrates slowly starts to come off as absolutist. this however, only in relation to the canceling of the socratic method and logical arguments with the encroachment of 'noble' virtues chosen from untenable dichotomist systems. disagreement mostly arise from the seemingly relativist approach socrates takes, yet never takes further. instead there is a limiting approach to phenomenon and knowledge for altogether the search for order and timelessness, or immortality generated th...more
ضیافت، مهمانی یا بزمِ میگساری (به یونانی: Συμπόσιο) یکی از مهمترین رسالههای افلاطون است. موضوع این رساله عشق است و این اثر مهمترین اثر افلاطون در زمینهٔ عشق میباشد. اثر دیگر افلاطون دربارهٔ عشق که با ضیافت هم در پیوند است فدروس میباشد. همچنین این رساله پیوندهایی هم با رسالهٔ فیدون دارد.این رساله از رسالههای سقراطی افلاطون میباشد که در آنها سقراط چهرهٔ اول رویداد میباشد. این رساله به گونهٔ روایتیاست که در بخشی از آن خواننده شاهد گفتگوی بازیگران آن با یکدیگر است. نام این داستان نیز اشاره به...more
Plato's depiction of Alcibiades arriving at Agathon's house is the most vivid and accurate representation of an obnoxious drunk crashing a party in the history of Western literature.
For example, consider Alcibiades's exchange with the boorish Eryximachus at 214B. Alcibiades, who is already "plastered" (212E), drinks an entire "cooling jar", which "holds more than two quarts of wine" (214A), orders it filled up again for Socrates, and then has the follow...more
For example, consider Alcibiades's exchange with the boorish Eryximachus at 214B. Alcibiades, who is already "plastered" (212E), drinks an entire "cooling jar", which "holds more than two quarts of wine" (214A), orders it filled up again for Socrates, and then has the follow...more
This is the source of Plato's theory of love, which has been watered down drastically over the centuries to the modern term of "platonic love". Plato's idea of love was almost the opposite of the what that modern term means. It was not about love between a man and a woman which is not sexual, but it was about a love between two men which is very much sexual (Greek word: eros), but where the sex is not acted on and so the love can rise to a higher, more spiritual level. Rather than d...more
A wine-bowl of fun! I think this would be a great book for a book club; like the best of Plato, it can inspire endless dialogue.
A brief, amusing, and insightful read. Plato's Symposium gives a more personal view into philosophy than we normally see - the title itself refers to a drinking party. It each interesting to hear each character's personal speech on Love (and its different aspects, both the human and the divine.) This additionally serves to give the reader a greater feel for the oral tradition of Ancient Greece. This took me about four hours (at a very leisurely pace) to read, and is definitely worth setting asid...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
i love the idea of forms, must re-read to remember why i was so moved by this
Excellent intro in this edition that sets the stage, provides historical background, and offers insight and analysis into the dialogue. Between that and my introduction to Plato with The Phaedrus in my Philosophy course, I was prepared to tackle The Symposium, and I rather enjoyed it. Love is always an intriguing topic, in my opinion, and the various opinions shared on it through the dialogue are fascinating. I felt there was an overall light tone to the dialogue, and I settled in feeling like I...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| به دنبال عشق گمشده | 1 | 22 | Mar 13, 2009 03:50am |
Birth c. 428–427 BC, Athens
Death c. 348–347 BC, Athens
Plato was a Classical Greek philosopher, mathematician, student of Socrates, writer of philosophical dialogues, and founder of the Academy in Athens, the first institution of higher learning in the Western world. Along with his mentor, Socrates, and his student, Aristotle, Plato helped to lay the foundations of Western phi...more
More about Plato...
Death c. 348–347 BC, Athens
Plato was a Classical Greek philosopher, mathematician, student of Socrates, writer of philosophical dialogues, and founder of the Academy in Athens, the first institution of higher learning in the Western world. Along with his mentor, Socrates, and his student, Aristotle, Plato helped to lay the foundations of Western phi...more
Share This Book
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Love is simply the name for the desire and pursuit of the whole.”
—
11 people liked it
“...when he looks at Beauty in the only way that Beauty can be seen - only then will it become possible for him to give birth not to images of virtue (because he's in touch with no images), but to true virtue [arete] (because he is in touch with true Beauty). The love of the gods belongs to anyone who has given to true virtue and nourished it, and if any human being could become immortal, it would be he.”
—
8 people liked it
More quotes…



view 2 comments














































