The Replacements: All Over But the Shouting: An Oral History

by Jim Walsh
The Replacements: All Over But the Shouting: An Oral History  
published November 15th 2007 by Voyageur Press
binding Hardcover
isbn 076033062X   (isbn13: 9780760330623)
pages 240
description At the dawn of “Morning in America”--a period that would nurse the rise of suit-and-tie culture--there emerged a national network of anti-corpora...more
date added
05-11-07



Sign in to Goodreads to see your friends' reviews of The Replacements: All Over But the Shouting: An Oral History.







discuss this book

There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

groups with this book

Minnesota Bibliophage Continuum




friend reviews (0)

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.



lists with this book

This book is not in any lists. Go add it to a list.




other reviews (showing 1-20 of 190)



Mary
Mary rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
01/29/08

Read in December, 2007
It's incredibly tempting to allow this review to devolve into a shortlist of my favorite personal recollections about the Replacements. In fact, the only thing holding me back is the knowledge that everybody latches onto the same things about the Replacements, and has the same sorts of insights.

I know this for a fact because I wrote an essay about them in college, before all those Replacements essays and personal narratives were easily available on the internet. I wrote the thing in a freaki...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Keith
Keith rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
04/05/08

Read in March, 2008
For Christmas, my grampa used to get books about Minneapolis and St Paul, as it was back in the prohibition / gangster days. Back then, as the story goes, grampa paid his way through college by running booze, and as he reached his later days, he loved to read about the places he used to go, people he used to know. Holidays were always filled with stories about Kid Cann, the 1934 union riots and how gramps got sapped on the head by a cop with a nightstick.

This book is like those books we’...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Chattycathy7575
Chattycathy7575 rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
02/05/08

bookshelves: music
Read in February, 2008
recommended to Chattycathy7575 by: James, Jim McGuinn
recommends it for: Replacements fans, indie rock fans with even a remote sense of history, people amused by alcoholics
At 32, I'm more "unsatisfied" than ever. Somehow The Replacements never grabbed me when I was young and pissed off. Now that I'm older and still pissed off, I can't imagine I ever shrugged in the face of their greatness. Maybe it's because the first Replacements albums I owned were the then somewhat new, late 80s/early 90s, borderline "adult alternative" releases Don't Tell a Soul and All Shook Down, both not much more than death rattles of a once great band (an...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Christina
Christina rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
05/27/08

bookshelves: adultbooks, rock-books
Read in May, 2008
A hodge podge about the life and times of the Replacements. I am a huge fan and probably won't be as critical as I would otherwise. But it is a hodge podge, reading more like running into a bunch of replacements fans in a bar and everyone is talking at once, and you're getting snippets of stories. You sort of want to know more, but at the same time you know that there is no getting to the heart or the truth of story. Capturing the story of the Replacements is like trying to catch smoke. Wals...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Eric
Eric rated it: 1 of 5 stars1 of 5 stars1 of 5 stars1 of 5 stars1 of 5 stars
05/05/08

Read in May, 2008
There probably is a compelling narrative in the life and music of the Replacements, but unfortunately this book doesn't find it. The oral history format is always a gamble because one is depending on the cast of characters to carry the day. This worked well in Legs McNeil and Co.'s history of Punk, "Please Kill Me," mostly because the accounts came from such a compelling group of witnesses, and the story itself had an inbred dramatic arc. But in this book, there really aren't any insig...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Hamish
Hamish rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
05/23/08

Well, it's an oral history of one of my favorite bands who also happen to have a really interesting back-story and mystique, so it's already got that in its corner. It's kind of padded though, take out the preface and introduction and the epilogue and the pictures and all the sources at the back it's probably only about 150 pages. Plus it didn't seem like any of the band members (except Slim) were interviewed for the book, so all their quotes come from elsewhere which kind of detracts from the...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Carol
Carol rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
04/09/08

bookshelves: biographies
Read in April, 2008
I love The Replacements. Or, should I say, I loved them until they went corporate, slicked up their sound and booted Bob Stinson from the band. But I'm getting ahead of myself.

Back in the day I loved their chaotic don't-give-a-flip attitude, their rawness, their unpredictability. I'll never forget the excitement I felt when they came to play my college town. Would Bob Stinson be wearing a dress? Would they even be able to complete a song, much less a full set?

This book captured everythi...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

matt
matt rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
12/31/07

Has a copy to sell/swap — Read in December, 2007
recommends it for: who've work up a mean mean thirst after a hard day of nothing much at all
a lot of the reviews here compare this to "Please Kill Me" which makes sense since both are oral histories of rock bands within the (relative) same time period but "All Over but the Shouting" utilizes this writing style to its benefit (focusing on a narrow focus) instead of something as broad as Punk in the 70s.
All the major players are here (most of the times culled from earlier interviews however) and Walsh puts the puzzle pieces together just as nicely, if not better, t...more
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Patrick
Patrick rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
01/29/08

This one is for die-hard Replacements fans only. It has some pretty obscure facts that are of interest and gives one a feeling for the Minneapolis scene in the early 80's. The book really takes a depressing turn towards the end recounting the malaise and lack of direction after Bob was kicked out of the band.

However, some of the sources quoted aren't very illuminating and offer a rather pedestrian commentary. It reads better if you pick your way through the interesting bits and sort out ...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Amy
Amy rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
01/04/08

Read in January, 2008
I really liked this book. The oral history format really fit well. If it was told in a traditional biography it'd sound like a bad Behind the Music. "Artistic differences, drug and alcohol abuse, firing a founding member and manager, the death of a legend." Growing up listening to the cities radio stations, of course I knew who the Replacements were and liked their music. I liked Westerberg's solo stuff and had one of his albums. By reading this book I learned a lot about the Minneapo...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Danimal
Danimal rated it: 2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars
03/29/08

Read in March, 2008
recommends it for: people from Minneapolis or that guy who was my roommate for 3 months in 1990.
Biographies live and die on access; oral histories even more so. And this oral history has almost zero access to the band's members, scoring interviews with only Slim Dunlap and that drummer guy who replaced Chris Mars (both seem like very nice guys).

So, instead we get rehashed clips from interviews and a lot of people saying how great the band was. You don't get much insight into the musicians (hey, Paul was a jerk and Tommy was, well, pretty young), and you don't get very many good stories...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Mark
Mark rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
01/01/08

bookshelves: music
Read in January, 2008
recommends it for: Music geeks
An entertaining and nostalgic read. I think it could have used more squalor and gossip -- something more along the lines of Please Kill Me or Motley Crue the Dirt -- but there's lots of cool trivia and factoids to be discovered. Also the quotes from old interviews and reviews are often priceless (Westerberg on KQRS in '81: "Where is it written? Where is it written that you have to pay y...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Warren
Warren rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
05/23/08

bookshelves: music
Needed more imput by Peter Jesperson and MUCH more imput from the actual members of the band. If you're gonna do an oral history, you have to concentrate on the main five or six people involved in a band's history, not just buddies who saw a few early shows or neighbors who went to school with a friend of the singer. The Replacements deserve a better bio than this, but then again, in true Replacements fashion, maybe they would get a kick out of a shitty recounting of their musical career.
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Tony
Tony rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
01/08/08

Read in December, 2007
recommends it for: flannel-wearing slackers who are "too smart" to be successful
Not really an oral history, more of a fan's scrapbook. It doesn't cover much of the Replacements' history in any depth, but it does convey, precisely and in great detail, the sensation of being on the upwards side of 40 and looking back on your 20s when finding a great band seemed like the most important thing on earth. If you're not a fan of the Replacements already, you'll think it's all a little pathetic. If you are a fan, you'll still think it's pathetic, but you won't care. Either way, ...more
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  1 comments

Jason
Jason rated it: 5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
05/21/08

Read in May, 2008
I really enjoyed this book. The book is less 'written' as it is a culmination of stories from people that were associated with the band, folks that were just around during the rise (and fall) of the Replacements, members of bands that were influenced by the band, family members, and the band members themselves. When I first picked it up I found this style of 'writing' a bit difficult to read. After a few pages, I was hooked on the story and the true emotions that were coming from the story telle...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Randomanthony
Randomanthony rated it: 3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars
12/28/07

bookshelves: music
Read in November, 2007
recommends it for: Replacements Fans
I don't know. The author is both a drooling fanboy and a thief of the exact same format of "Please Kill Me: An Oral History of Punk Rock." Still, the guy did his research and the Replacements inner circle seems to trust him. You can get past the flaws if you're a fan, but you'll like this book more because you liked the band than because you liked the book. I think you know what I mean.
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Caroline
Caroline rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
12/15/07

Read in December, 2007
recommends it for: 'Mats fans
The style was unusual - collecting pieces of current interviews and pieces of dated stuff from when things went down. After a chapter you get used to it, though, and it leads to some cute moments. Perhaps the pathos of the Bob Stinson story is better told that way - less maudlin, less tragic.

I think it probably succeeds in it's intention - it's worth reading for the 'Mats fans, but unlikely to recruit anyone.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Larst
Larst rated it: 2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars
01/31/08

recommends it for: the unsatisfied
It did get me to appreciate Sorry Ma, I forgot to Take Out The Trash...way more than ever.
I love the replacements and ate this up, but there was no real dirt, no real descriptions. The Oral History worked so well for Legs McNeil's Please Kill Me history of punk but a bunch of Minneapolis folks talking about their acquaintance with the band was pretty rote. I feel even worse for Bob Stinson now.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Brendon
Brendon rated it: 4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars
01/02/08

recommends it for: fans of the band
Just finished this and enjoyed it overall. The author uses quotes a lot from articles on the band throughout their history, so it should be credited as "...compiled by"...

The impression one is left with is that while he may have tremendous song writing ability, Westerberg is not the nicest human being on the planet -- which is typical of moody creative types.

For fans only.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Julie
Julie rated it: 5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
03/22/08

Read in January, 2008
This was a brilliantly-edited book about the Replacements that takes a lot of different snippets of first-hand accounts and somehow weaves them into a somewhat chronological story. Left in the words of those who were there, this book makes you remember where you were when you were listening to those albums, and more importantly what you felt when you first heard this band.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10



book data (includes all editions)

avg rating (all editions): 3.58 (120 ratings)
avg rating (this edition): 3.58 (119 ratings)
number of reviews: 49






other editions

The Replacements: All Over But the Shouting: An Oral History (Paperback)