Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Forty Lashes Less One” as Want to Read:
Forty Lashes Less One
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Forty Lashes Less One

3.91  ·  Rating Details ·  570 Ratings  ·  43 Reviews
The hell called Yuma Prison can destroy the soul of any man. And it's worse for those whose damning crime is the color of their skin. The law says Chiricahua Apache Raymond San Carlos and black-as-night former soldier Harold Jackson are murderers, and they'll stay behind bars until they're dead and rotting. But even in the worst place on Earth, there's hope. And for two ha ...more
Mass Market Paperback, 272 pages
Published November 5th 2002 by HarperTorch (first published April 1972)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Forty Lashes Less One, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Forty Lashes Less One

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jim
Dec 23, 2014 Jim rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2fiction, western, 1paper
No one does gritty like Leonard. This is bleak, barren, & ugly - the perfect prison. He had me sweating & dry as a bone in Yuma prison's heat when it's cold & wet here. Excellently done, but brutal & depressing. It was a quick read, but I just didn't get to it with the holidays. I should have.
Sergio GRANDE films
I am not so erudite that can review a book without comparing it to other work.

But I can't compare this novel to other Elmore Leonard books -it's my first Leonard- and I can't compare it to other Westerns -it's my first one too.

I can only compare it to other other much-hyped novels from famous writers and I can only say, Not Bad.

I expected a little more in places and I didn't expect a few of the plot twists. I loved the ending, though.

Let's call it a 3 1/2 star which means: I'm glad I read it bu
...more
Don Massenzio
Forty Lashes Less One was a return to Leonard's western genre. Set in a desert prison, the story centers around the conflict-turned friendship between an African American and a Native American. This book is a bit more gritty than some of Leonard's books that I have read to date. The liberal use of the dreaded "N-word" throughout the book, although likely accurate to the culture of the time period, made me feel a bit uncomfortable as I read the book. The book has an interesting group of character ...more
Jim
Oct 18, 2016 Jim rated it liked it
Shelves: fiction
This was advertised as a Western, or at least I thought so, but it is really a prison story set in the West that delves into racism within the incarcerated and their handlers, with a somewhat convoluted story line, that for me was not really believable. Entertaining, yes, but not really credible. And it lacked the humor I usually enjoy in his work.
Wyckliffe Howland
Nov 30, 2016 Wyckliffe Howland rated it really liked it
Big fun Elmore Leonard style! Predictably cool dialogue but great, not predictable, conclusion. Interesting 1906 ambience, Yuma, Arizona.
Redemption!
Sue
Oct 18, 2016 Sue rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
The author thought that to write about this time frame is to give himself license to use derogatory, pejorative language to describe the only black man in the prison. blech Just kept getting worse, when Sambo, Zulu, coon and nigger kept coming up. Really detracted from the story.

Written in 1972--glad times are changing, but I don't have to read about it like this.
Molly
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Heath Lowrance
Sep 01, 2014 Heath Lowrance rated it it was amazing
Surprisingly funny Western that takes place mostly within the walls of Yuma prison in the early part of the 20th century. Harold is the only black inmate at the soon-to-be-closed Yuma, and Raymond is the only Indian, which makes them the targets of derision. Shelby, a prisoner with connections, makes their lives hell, until the new warden, Mr. Manly, takes a special interest in the pair and decides to elevate their confidence in the hopes he can bring them to Jesus. Harold and Raymond eventually ...more
joel
May 10, 2015 joel rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Not comfortable with ethnic nicknames.

This story is about prisoners assigned to the old Territorial Prison, Yuma, AZ. The conflicts arise as two new convicts arrive at the facility one Black Civil War vet, and the other is, of course, a Membre Apache mistaken for Mexican. The inside gang that runs the prison, for profit, attempt to egg these two to fight. In addition the prison has come under temporary supervision of an unlearned, prison wise, preacher...of sorts. He rode into Yuma on the same s
...more
Paul
Apr 24, 2014 Paul rated it it was ok
This is the worst of Elmore Leonard's books I've read, and the only one I couldn't recommend for anyone to read.

First of all, I didn't care about any of the characters. I wasn't rooting any of them on. I didn't really get the climax, either. I mean, I understood two guys going after the others for revenge, but I don't understand why anything that happened after the final shooting confrontation happened. That's not totally true, I kind of cared about a Mexican woman, but she was only a secondary
...more
Carl R.
Aug 22, 2014 Carl R. rated it really liked it
Forty Lashes Less One is another Elmore oater. I said I was off these for a while, but when a buddy drops this on the front porch--well, why put the friendship in danger? I've read a number of novels set in Yuma prison, back in them days. All of them pretty grim, of course. I've read a good deal of Elmore, much of it pretty humorous. Forty Lashes has the distinction of being not only set in one of the grimmest settings in history, but probably the funniest Leonard novel I've ever read.

The black
...more
Jonathan Briggs
May 14, 2012 Jonathan Briggs rated it really liked it
I wish Elmore Leonard wrote more westerns. Absolutely nothing against his superb crime thrillers, but the western really brought out his inner Hemingway, terse and tough and worn to perfection like old saddle leather. “Forty Lashes” is a bit of a transition novel, taking place in the waning days of the Old West and published as Leonard was making the switch to urban action. It has more of the wiseass sense of humor that marks his later novels. Inside Yuma Prison, Harold Jackson and Raymond San C ...more
cat reads
As I was reading the book, I kept thinking, "What the hell is this?" I mean that in the best way. This is my first Leonard novel, and it's an interesting one after I've heard so much about this writer, mainly that his dialogue is top-notch.

I have to agree with the consensus that Leonard knows dialogue. Each character has their own distinct voice with exposition and character development expertly woven in.

The characters are shown with warts and all. Don't expect pretty. I enjoyed that, though.
...more
Justin Decloux
Dec 25, 2015 Justin Decloux rated it it was ok
I really wanted to like this one. I've had a rough time with the Elmore Leonard novels I've read, liking the mood and some characters, but finding them glacially paced. I started this one with a bit of trepidation, but the write up sounded so good "An Apache and the only black man behind the walls of Yuma prison hunt down five outlaws!". What's more kick butt then that!? And it is when it finally happens! The problem is that the prisoners hunting down outlaws plot only kicks in at page 214 and t ...more
Tim Prosser
Apr 12, 2012 Tim Prosser rated it really liked it

Having read every Elmore Leonard book about ten times (possibly more!) I thought I'd take a look at some of his early westerns. I'm glad I did. This book has all the elements of his Detroit, Miami, and Atlantic City novels. Its all here in glorious print: oblique machine gun dialogue, closely observed behavior, a smiling sunny cynicism, a melancholic outrage and courage. Absolutely brilliant, I'm going to tuck into Valdez is Coming next. I vaguely remember the film with Burt Lancaster playing th
...more
Cody Gardner
This is the first Elmore Leonard book that I have read and I must admit I was somewhat disappointed in it. However, I think it was more of the story and setting than anything else. Leonard is definitely a remarkable writer and I plan on reading more of his stuff. Wasn't too impressed with this story however. It takes too long to go anywhere. The last 20-30 pages are great though and I was impressed on how quickly he wrapped it all up without it seeming rushed. Even with my disappointment, I'm lo ...more
Doug
Oct 16, 2016 Doug rated it really liked it
Shelves: westerns
This is a prison novel, set in the early 20th century, in Yuma, Arizona. It contains some standards -- a prison yard boss, time in the hole, racial conflict, etc. An unwitting social service preacher takes over as temporary superintendent, and there is some humor around his earnest efforts to reform a couple of prisoners. The prison includes two women, which Leonard works to pulpy salacious effect. The novel (not really a surprise, of course) leads up toward a break... and I'll leave it at that. ...more
Bad-at-reading
May 29, 2014 Bad-at-reading rated it really liked it
Shelves: western, comedy, prison, race
As someone who usually finds Leonard's books too pointless to really get into, his unpretentious yet insightful take on racism in this one was welcome. It gets a little jokey at times but unlike most white genre fiction writers to tackle the subject it seems a product of real empathy. Also interesting is that, being mostly set in a prison, it doesn't really feel like a western. But you know that outside the walls is the Arizona desert of 1908, and then at the end you go there.
Brian
Feb 25, 2014 Brian rated it really liked it
When a somewhat pious, square warden runs into a guard crouching down and spying on the female prisoners taking a shower and has a hilarious back and forth about the guard's intentions, you have one of the most memorable scenes in any novel I've ever read.

This book was another example of Elmore Leonard's mastery of crisp plotting, fine set piece action, brief but descriptive atmospheric details and sharp dialogue, even if the central story has a great deal of silliness to it.
Monte Dutton
Dec 22, 2013 Monte Dutton rated it liked it
I already miss Elmore Leonard, and going back to his westerns is evidence of the void left in my reading list by his passing. Everything Leonard wrote was good. This one's long on stock characters. It reminded me of the latter-day John Wayne movies. It's entertaining, like,say, "Chisum," but not a classic like, say, "Red River." The difference, likely in general, too, is that authors, unlike actors, get better with age.
Patrick
Dec 29, 2011 Patrick rated it really liked it
Shelves: westerns
There is an autumnal glow about this book, which in movie terms is more like "High Plains Drifter" than like "Silverado." Characters in this story are as hardboiled and believable as anything in Elmore Leonard's urban fiction, and a surprising tie-in to the travails of Paul the Apostle elevates this above the "horse opera" level well-trod by less ambitious writers in the western genre.
Luca
Dec 29, 2015 Luca rated it it was amazing
A turn of the century prison romp with Apache and black leads, Leonard's FORTY LASHES LESS ONE may very well be the book where the author comes fully into his own as the Hollywood fave I was introduced to him as.

High drama and grimy violence alternates with Coenesque humor that finds the laffs in human ignorance and racism.

Bonus: one of my favourite closing lines on any book I've read.
Diogenes
Aug 01, 2016 Diogenes rated it liked it
A tragi-comic prison adventure with a Western flavor, but a totally original plot and characters. A quick and engaging read involving two racially stereotyped men, a native American and an African American, a preacher who is the temporary warden and an assorted cast of both wily and stupid bad guys.
TJ Wilson
Jul 28, 2014 TJ Wilson rated it really liked it
Shelves: fiction, western
This is probably Elmore Leonard's most Spaghetti Western novel yet. It is a very odd idea or premise, but yet Leonard's confident style, his blunt writing, makes this story work. And, of course, the ending is very Leonardish, which I very much like. Leonard isn't scared of taking very odd and creative chances.
Nicholos
Mar 01, 2012 Nicholos rated it liked it
Not the most exciting book you'll pick off the shelf, but it is pretty good. Refreshingly concise with its style after reading several books that tended to bloviate and meander into maddening amounts of minutia.
David Saliba
Jul 08, 2012 David Saliba rated it really liked it
Shelves: western
If you like Leonard's crime fiction, you will like this book as well. While classified as a western, it is more about racial prejudice and hypocritical religious figures than cowboys. A enjoyable read.
David Williams
Mar 31, 2012 David Williams rated it it was amazing
This was an excellent book. It is a lot of fun. Best $3.99 I've spent in a long time. Thanks Amazon!
Bob
Jun 13, 2014 Bob rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Perfect

Good western in confined spaces. This book has the perfect balance of action and humor. Elmore was a very gifted author.
Rodger
Jan 17, 2016 Rodger rated it liked it
Shelves: western
Generally, I prefer Leonard's contemporary crime fiction to his westerns. This one is OK, but far from his greatest story.
John
Jul 27, 2014 John rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: western
An Elmore Leonard Western novel from 1972. Plot is well-contained, characters are well-defined and dialogue is terse and vintage-Leonard. Worth re-reading.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Destry Rides Again
  • The Dawn of Fury (Trail of the Gunfighter, #1)
  • Brimstone (Virgil Cole & Everett Hitch, #3)
  • Showdown At Yellow Butte
  • Gone to Texas
  • Matagorda
  • Dance on the Wind
  • The Buckskin Line (Texas Rangers, #1)
  • The Unforgiven
  • Return of the Mountain Man (Mountain Man, #2)
  • Apache Devil
12940
Elmore John Leonard lived in Dallas, Oklahoma City and Memphis before settling in Detroit in 1935. After serving in the navy, he studied English literature at the University of Detroit where he entered a short story competition. His earliest published novels in the 1950s were westerns, but Leonard went on to specialize in crime fiction and suspense thrillers, many of which have been adapted into m ...more
More about Elmore Leonard...

Share This Book