7th out of 13 books
—
7 voters
Oz: The Marvelous Land of Oz (Marvel's Oz Comics series #2)
by
Eric Shanower (Goodreads Author),
Skottie Young , L. Frank Baum
The epic continues! Fresh off their landmark THE WONDERFUL WORLD OF OZ, superstars ERIC SHANOWER (Age of Bronze) and SKOTTIE YOUNG (X-MEN) return with L. Frank Baum's MARVELOUS LAND OF OZ. Join new characters Tip and Jack Pumpkinhead as they're whisked to Oz, and meet foes and friends! You've NEVER seen L. Frank Baum's masterpiece like this before... COLLECTING: The Marvel...more
Hardcover, 200 pages
Published
September 29th 2010
by Marvel
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,308)
First cab off the rank this year is Eric Shanower and Skottie Young’s adaption of L. Frank Baum’s The Marvelous Land of Oz. Much like its predecessor The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (adapted by same), I was highly impressed by its loyalty to the original. Not only is its plot accurate, it has captured the spirit and youthful energy of Baum’s world superbly.
For those not familiar with the tale, The Marvelous Land of Oz tells the story of Tippetarius, known more commonly as “Tip”. Unlike Dorothy, Tip i...more
For those not familiar with the tale, The Marvelous Land of Oz tells the story of Tippetarius, known more commonly as “Tip”. Unlike Dorothy, Tip i...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I enjoyed this volume even more. With the exception of the Scarecrow and the Tin Man, we have an entirely new roster of characters including Tip, Jack Pumpkinhead, Sawhorse, Woggle-Bug, the flying Gump, Mombi, and General Jinjur.
The text of the original book is one half of the inspiration behind the fantastic film, "Return to Oz" which I have seen at least 10 times if not more and LOVE!!!
Apparently the book is somewhat controversial because of the way some people read the character of General Ji...more
The text of the original book is one half of the inspiration behind the fantastic film, "Return to Oz" which I have seen at least 10 times if not more and LOVE!!!
Apparently the book is somewhat controversial because of the way some people read the character of General Ji...more
Not as enjoyable as the first volume. Of course, that's not Shanower and Young's fault, the issue lies in the source material, which isn't as much fun as the classic "Wonderful Wizard." This time around, there's no Dorothy, Toto, Lion, Wicked Witch, or Wizard. Instead we get Tip, Mombi, Jack Pumpkinhead, Sawhorse, H.M. Woggle-Bug, T.E., and General Jinjur, who can't quite compare. Skottie Young's artwork is inspired once again, with slight touches of Bill Watterson and Berkeley Breathed. The fir...more
the main draw of the marvel oz series is skottie young. he's why you pick up individual issues. why you buy the bound hardback volumes. he's why this oz series is selling and winning awards. which is why i can give this 4 stars here. while the writing in volume 1 felt new and concise, the similar tone in this second volume, instead of feeling quick and to-the-point, feels less like it's geared to a younger audience and more like a reader's digest. the wit feels like it's leaving in favor of simp...more
Reason for Reading: Next in the series.
Another absolutely fabulous rendition of an OZ book by Shanower and Young. This is actually only as far as I've read of the original novels and I am inspired to start reading them now so that I can have read the book before continuing on with the next graphic novel. I own a gorgeous collection of the Baum books. This story only brings back a few old friends from our first encounter with Oz namely Scarecrow and Tinman and briefly for the last chapter Glinda....more
Another absolutely fabulous rendition of an OZ book by Shanower and Young. This is actually only as far as I've read of the original novels and I am inspired to start reading them now so that I can have read the book before continuing on with the next graphic novel. I own a gorgeous collection of the Baum books. This story only brings back a few old friends from our first encounter with Oz namely Scarecrow and Tinman and briefly for the last chapter Glinda....more
After finishing Eric Shanower and Skottie Young's graphic novel adaptation of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz last year, I was hoping they'd adapt other L. Frank Baum novels. We're all most familiar with the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Cowardly Lion of course, but there are other bizarre Oz friends and enemies that would shine with the right treatment.
The next book in the series is out in a trade paperback that collects all eight issues of the ongoing comic: The Marvelous Land of Oz. The 200 page book i...more
The next book in the series is out in a trade paperback that collects all eight issues of the ongoing comic: The Marvelous Land of Oz. The 200 page book i...more
As a child I read all fourteen of L. Frank Baum's Oz books. My hours spent with those books are some of my happiest childhood memories. Part of the delight I took in reading those books were in the wonderful illustrations by W.W. Denslow in the first volume and John R. Neil in the rest of the series.
These new graphic novel editions from Marvel comics are wonderfully adapted by Eric Shanower. He's managed to retain much of Baum's original dialogue and he's done a great job of capturing the flavo...more
These new graphic novel editions from Marvel comics are wonderfully adapted by Eric Shanower. He's managed to retain much of Baum's original dialogue and he's done a great job of capturing the flavo...more
A few months ago, I read the first Oz adaptation by this creative team (Shanower writing and Young drawing), and I was underwhelmed. I loved Young's beautiful and otherworldly figures, but the dialogue was awkward and the story was strangely formulaic. The art outweighed the words, though, so I asked for a copy of this next collection as a gift. It is phenomenal and well worth a read. Once again, the main selling point is the art, as Young is skilled both at capturing wild action scenes and at u...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Have you ever wondered what goes down in Oz when Dorothy makes her three quick skips back to Kansas?
Let's begin in the north country, where a young boy, Tip, is enslaved by old Mombi, a cretinous fossil who is not allowed to call herself a witch but nonetheless has witch-like powers and the foul, scheming comportment of one to boot. Tip hates old Mombi and at the top of this tale he's hoping to give her a fright. Constructing a wooden figure with a smiling jack-o-lantern head, Tip plants this sc...more
Let's begin in the north country, where a young boy, Tip, is enslaved by old Mombi, a cretinous fossil who is not allowed to call herself a witch but nonetheless has witch-like powers and the foul, scheming comportment of one to boot. Tip hates old Mombi and at the top of this tale he's hoping to give her a fright. Constructing a wooden figure with a smiling jack-o-lantern head, Tip plants this sc...more
Eric Shanower and Skottie Young's graphic novel is a retelling of L. Frank Baum's 2nd book about the Land of Oz written in 1904. Shanower does a wonderful job of taking the original novel and turning it into a comic, and Young's drawings give the characters new life. The book is the story of what happens after Dorothy and the Wizard leave Oz. So neither of them are in this story.
Baum used the first book's publishing success to turn it into a successful musical that made stars of the Tin Woodman...more
Baum used the first book's publishing success to turn it into a successful musical that made stars of the Tin Woodman...more
What a fun and faithful adaptation of the L. Frank Baum classic. Honestly, The Marvelous Land of Oz is one of my favorite Oz stories because it's just such a charming adventure, so it was great to relive that tale with such delightfully quirky illustrations. I know this is kind of arbitrary, but the pictures in this book so closely matched the pictures I had in my mind while reading the story. This was really just a fun way to relive a favorite story.
THis is an intermediate graphic novel I would consider appropriate for 3rd grade and up. Some of the content is a little dark and could be scary for younger readers. I think this would appeal to readers who enjoy fantasy and have interest in the Wizard of Oz but who maybe don't have the skill or are not ready to commit to reading the novels. I would suggest this to a class as a possible book report assignment or for enjoyment reading.
The second volume of the Eric Shanower / Skottie Young Oz series. The art is once again gorgeous, as per usual with Skottie Young. I really enjoyed this, because I'm not familiar with any of the Oz stuff after the original. Even that, I've only seen the movie, never read the books. That's what makes this series so enjoyable for me, discovering all the new stuff.
The second story of the land of Oz is the adventure of Tip, Jack the pumpkin-head, Scarecrow, Tin man and the Woggle Bug as they try to recapture the Emerald City from General Jinjur and her all female army who overtook the city with their knitting needles because they were sick of cleaning.
I'm sure Eric Shanower did a great job translating the original story to graphic novel format, since the first book/graphic novel the wonderful wizard of Oz were so similar. I just didn't like the characters...more
I'm sure Eric Shanower did a great job translating the original story to graphic novel format, since the first book/graphic novel the wonderful wizard of Oz were so similar. I just didn't like the characters...more
So I have no idea why this book took me over a month to read. Just like the first book in the series it's funny and filled with action and adventure. In this volume we follow Tip as he leaves his home with the witch Mombi and meets up with the Scarecrow and the Tin Man and helps Glinda the good witch reestablish the rightful ruler of the Emerald City when the Scarecrow is ousted by an arm of women. There is a very unexpected twist at the end and we get to meet some great new characters. The artw...more
Marvelous Land of Oz is one of my favorite of the Oz books, and it would be better if not for how very much General Jinjur's revolt is a product of its time. It's profoundly sexist to modern readers, and was hardly forward thinking at the time. Shanower reads it as Baum clumsily attempting to address suffrage issues, and there's something to be said for that. (Jinjur and her army are varying degrees of sexist stereotypes of what women in the army would be like, but Glinda's female army is unfail...more
Oh man this was so good! Such a faithful recreation of Baum's world in a new medium. I LOVED it. Especially the end. If you know what I'm saying.
Jack Pumpkinhead went from being my least favorite character in Oz to easily my favorite, also, so that is fun. :) Nick Chopper still kind of stinks.
Save me from myself, plz.
Jack Pumpkinhead went from being my least favorite character in Oz to easily my favorite, also, so that is fun. :) Nick Chopper still kind of stinks.
Save me from myself, plz.
This was cute, but a little hard to get into. The artwork is superb... I just have a feeling that L. Frank Baum's version of Oz is what was keeping me from totally loving this. Or maybe I just missed Dorothy. Either way, I enjoyed this enough to continue with the series, but not enough to rave about it.
Ozma of Oz started out as a girl, but was transformed into a boy to hide her from Glinda, the good witch. At the end of their adventures, Tip is transformed back into Ozma and resumes the throne of Oz.
This is another great collected work in hardback by Marvel. Just as with the first OZ graphic novel, the artwork and colors are rich and vibrant and suit the story well. This is definitely a volume that should be sitting on your shelf right beside The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Enjoy it over and over and share it with your children.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...





















![Amanda [Novel Addiction]](http://d.gr-assets.com/users/1296175918p2/4886503.jpg)













Sep 09, 2011 12:11pm