Annie's Ghosts: A Journey Into a Family Secret
by
Steve Luxenberg (Goodreads Author)
Beth Luxenberg was an only child; or so her son Steve believed until his mother, now fragile and almost an octogenarian, told a doctor that she had a disabled sister. Steve was puzzled: If his mother had a sibling, why had her existence been resolutely concealed for decades? His curiosity piqued, Luxenberg activated his journalistic skills to begin a probe into his family'...more
Kindle Edition
Published
(first published May 5th 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,806)
I stumbled upon an advance copy of Annie's Ghosts and picked it up thinking my mom might like to read it. Intrigued by some of the blurbs, somehow I started it and found myself carrying it around in search of free moments to read for the next several days--Mom would have to wait her turn. Obviously, family dynamics and hidden, secret things resonate with everyone. Although time does sweep back and forth, even within chapters, the author has done a great job crafting a narrative that even stands...more
Steve Luxenberg's mother had always identified herself as an only child. A few years before his mother died, Steve got a hint that the only child status might not be entirely accurate. Only after she died, and after some years of luck and research, did the story of Steve's Aunt Annie come out. Born in 1919, Annie had a severely deformed leg which was later amputated. She had serious learning challenges as well. At age 21, she was institutionalized with perhaps some mental health issues and she r...more
Luxenberg managed to put his family's story together with background about the times, places and situations they lived through. After his mother's death, Luxenberg is alerted to the possible existence of an aunt - his mother's sister. Luxenberg's mother - Beth - had always claimed to be an only child. Never had she mentioned a sister to any of her children. Through the help of researchers in libraries and historical museums, Luxenberg was able to prove the existence of the sister - Annie - and w...more
I read this book this month as part of my 12/12/12 TBR challenge: 12 books in 12 months that have languished for a year or more in my “TBR” (To Be Read) pile. The bullet on this one is that I’m glad the challenge made me finally read it, for a variety of reasons. It’s thought-provoking and educational (in a good way)...definitely worth a read if you’re interested in mid-20th century history, the history of medicine, or investigative journalistic techniques.
I was first drawn to “Annie’s Ghosts” w...more
I was first drawn to “Annie’s Ghosts” w...more
“Without really trying, I have become a collector of other families’ secrets.” –Steve Luxenberg.
Steve Luxenberg’s memoir reads like a mystery. In the Spring of 1995, Steve finds out that his mother, Beth, had a sister, Annie, who was mentally and physically disabled. This and other family secrets unfold in a number of shocking revelations and frustrating dead ends.
His story explores the history of mental institutions and how those patients had fewer rights than criminals. It explores the life of...more
Steve Luxenberg’s memoir reads like a mystery. In the Spring of 1995, Steve finds out that his mother, Beth, had a sister, Annie, who was mentally and physically disabled. This and other family secrets unfold in a number of shocking revelations and frustrating dead ends.
His story explores the history of mental institutions and how those patients had fewer rights than criminals. It explores the life of...more
Annie’s Ghosts: A Journey into a Family Secret by Steven Luxenberg (Hyperion, 416pp, ISBN 9781401322472) is not your everyday family memoir. This poignant, memorable book will live in your thoughts long after it’s been returned to your book shelf. Annie’s Ghosts is a striking combination of family secrets, mental health issues in the forties and the entanglements of love, past and present.
The most astounding thing about Annie’s Ghosts? It’s true. The book begins after Steve’s mother’s death with...more
The most astounding thing about Annie’s Ghosts? It’s true. The book begins after Steve’s mother’s death with...more
Shortly before his elderly mother's death, Steve Luxenberg learns his mother may have had a younger sister. Several months after the mother's death, Luxenberg learns that not only did his mother lie about being an only child, but she also hid the fact that her younger sister was committed at age 21 for her physical and mental disabilities.
Luxenberg's book details his painstaking research into this family secret. He meticulously reports on the findings of his hunt through medical and census recor...more
Luxenberg's book details his painstaking research into this family secret. He meticulously reports on the findings of his hunt through medical and census recor...more
“Though we share so many secrets
There are some we never tell”
The Stranger by Billy Joel
When journalist Steve Luxenberg discovers after his mother’s death that she was not an only child, bur rather had a physically and mentally disabled sister, Annie, he embarks on a journey to uncover the truth behind his mother’s secret. What he discovers is a societal and legal system that for decades sequestered the mentally ill and disabled into institutions – leaving behind few traces of the person institut...more
There are some we never tell”
The Stranger by Billy Joel
When journalist Steve Luxenberg discovers after his mother’s death that she was not an only child, bur rather had a physically and mentally disabled sister, Annie, he embarks on a journey to uncover the truth behind his mother’s secret. What he discovers is a societal and legal system that for decades sequestered the mentally ill and disabled into institutions – leaving behind few traces of the person institut...more
Annie eventually is diagnosed with schizophrenia - was she really schizophrenic or was this just a catchall diagnosis.
p. 94 Patient imagines that someone wants to do her bodily harm.
p. 96 Annie's fears and paranoia, her screaming and crying, were driving the family crazy.
What is the definition of schizophrenia vs. schizo-affective disorder? At one time was a catchall diagnosis.
possible intermarriage in the family between cousins - were Annie's parents first cousins from the Ukraine?
Radziwillow...more
p. 94 Patient imagines that someone wants to do her bodily harm.
p. 96 Annie's fears and paranoia, her screaming and crying, were driving the family crazy.
What is the definition of schizophrenia vs. schizo-affective disorder? At one time was a catchall diagnosis.
possible intermarriage in the family between cousins - were Annie's parents first cousins from the Ukraine?
Radziwillow...more
Jul 17, 2009
Nicole
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
i-read-more-than-bush-09
In Annie’s Ghosts, Steve Luxenberg (a Washington Post journalist) tells of discovering the secret his mother kept from him and his siblings—they had an aunt who had been institutionalized at age 21. As Luxenberg searches for answers about his aunt and why his mother elected to change her entire family history, he discovers just how difficult it is to obtain records from a time when mental illness was a secret shame for families. Even after he gets legal documents giving him the authority to act...more
Part mystery, part investigative journalism, and part family history, Annie’s Ghosts is about the discovery of family secret. Details of the secret unfolds like a mystery with writing that’s easy to read thanks to Steve Luxenberg’s investigative journalism background.
Steve discovers that his mother, who always made the point of telling everyone she was an only child, had a sister that almost no one knew about. Unfortunately, this secret is only unearthed on his mother’s deathbed. With only a few...more
Steve discovers that his mother, who always made the point of telling everyone she was an only child, had a sister that almost no one knew about. Unfortunately, this secret is only unearthed on his mother’s deathbed. With only a few...more
I've heard it said that secrets are rarely as secret as we might imagine them to be. Annie's Ghosts is the story of one family's secret--a woman who was both mentally handicapped and mentally ill.
The author, Steve Luxenberg, is a Harvard-educated Jewish (ethnically) journalist from Detroit. In 1995 his mother mentioned a disabled sister to someone who had always understood that she was an only child. This woman called the family for more information. Steve and his siblings decided that since hi...more
The author, Steve Luxenberg, is a Harvard-educated Jewish (ethnically) journalist from Detroit. In 1995 his mother mentioned a disabled sister to someone who had always understood that she was an only child. This woman called the family for more information. Steve and his siblings decided that since hi...more
It's amazing how many mystery stories revolve around family secrets. One of my favorites, Thomas H Cook, has built a career writing books that deal with the emotional toll of family secrets and family history. Writers as diverse as Harlen Coben and Edgar Allen Poe have used the hidden history of families to tell their sorrowful tales.
Of course, real families have secrets too and Steve Luxenberg, of the Washington Post, found a doozy. Late in life, his mother, who had always made a great deal abo...more
Of course, real families have secrets too and Steve Luxenberg, of the Washington Post, found a doozy. Late in life, his mother, who had always made a great deal abo...more
Steve Luxenberg's sister phoned him one day and asked him if he knew that his mother Beth had a sister. But all of his life, he had been told by his mom that she was an only child, a statement that she would give to pretty much everyone upon meeting them. After her death in 1999, Steve's brother Jeff was going through her unopened mail and discovered a flyer from Hebrew Memorial Park offering for a small fee to put flowers on the graves of his grandparents as well as on the grave of Annie Cohen....more
Annie's Ghosts is an ambitious part memoir, part investigative journalism effort by veteran reporter Steve Luxenberg, who discovers a family secret he can't leave alone. Unlike the usual tell-all, emotionally driven memoirs on the market, Luxenberg's background makes this an impeccably researched, thoroughly engaging account based in facts. Brief passages summarizing relevant personal memories give the story a personal feel that isn't found in the average history book, but the focus of the book...more
I'm wavering between two and three stars for this book. The author's family past is definitely fascinating--not just for what happens to his aunt, but because they live through enormous moments in world and American history (the turn-of-the-century wave of immigration to America, the early twentieth century prosperity of Detroit, the Jewish diaspora, the Depression, the Holocaust...). While a reader shares in Luxenberg's journey of discovery, the reader also shares in his frustrations, which in...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
ou know a story is well written when it continues to haunt you well after you've turned the last page. This is one of those stories.
This book was recommended by one of the speakers at the 2012 St. George Family History Expo. The topic of the class discussion was using Prison, Criminal and Asylum Records in family history research. When the discussion turned to asylums there was a great deal of historical information given about those types of facilities and this book was mentioned as being a wo...more
This book was recommended by one of the speakers at the 2012 St. George Family History Expo. The topic of the class discussion was using Prison, Criminal and Asylum Records in family history research. When the discussion turned to asylums there was a great deal of historical information given about those types of facilities and this book was mentioned as being a wo...more
Steve Luxenberg never really thought it odd that his mother made a point of telling nearly everyone she met that she was an only child, often during their first meeting. It was just a part of her identity, like her name, that she thought was important and wanted to share right away. However, in 1995, Luxenberg learned that his mother had a sister, and he had to ask why she insisted on telling this untruth to new and old acquaintances. This book tells the story of Luxenberg� s investigation into...more
Steve Luxenberg's family always knew their mother Beth had been an only child. So when she mentioned to a new doctor that she had had a disabled sister who had been sent away at age two, they figured it was an elderly thing. Then while sorting out her affairs after she died, they find a bill for cemetery maintenence for her parents--and her sister Annie.
When Steve began the search to find out more about Annie, no one in the family was prepared for the information and the additional family secret...more
When Steve began the search to find out more about Annie, no one in the family was prepared for the information and the additional family secret...more
I first heard about 'Annie's Ghost' from an NPR interview with the author, Steve Luxenberg several months ago. I was captivated by the story he told and his articulateness. I came across the book again while reading a review on an ancestry research board. Everyone seemed to find it a worthwhile read so as an avid fan of genealogy, I reserved it at the library and picked it up this week. The book does not disappoint. The author is an investigative journalist who was left with a family mystery whe...more
This book is about the unraveling of one family's secrets, diligently, and above all respectively. It covers about a century of history and touches extensively on mental illness and disorders, institutions, the depression, the Holocaust, the auto industry during the first half of the 1900's, the value of the written word and photographs, and the irreplaceable knowledge and memories of experiences past that dies with our parents and grandparents. The author travels throughout much of the US and o...more
This is a family history story written by an investigative journalist that reads like a mystery book. Reading someone else's family story written by a journalist could have been really boring but Steve Luxenberg keeps the story moving. After the author finds out that his mother was not the only child that she had always pretended to be, he sets out on a quest to find out who his mother's sister really was, where his grandparents had sent her and why his mother had always denied that she even exi...more
I attended a talk by the author at a genealogy conference in 2010 and bought the book then. He inscribed it "Every family has its stories." I I found the book to be a very satisfying read. The stories of his family and their secrets was fascinating, but what I enjoyed most were his efforts to understand what was behind them, both as a son and a reporter. He provides a combination of personal memories of the people involved, woven together with the events of history, spanning the twentieth centur...more
This is a story of a family with a hidden secret that a mother was hiding from her family about a sister that spent the most of her life in an institution. The sister, Annie, lived at home until she was 21 and then spent the rest of her life institutionalized. The mother's children found out about their hidden aunt not long before their mother died but did not ask her about her sister. After his mother's death then Steve the author tried to piece together the story and why his mother hid this fr...more
Dec 07, 2009
Janell
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Readers interested in history of mental health institutions, or a well researched book
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The author's mission to know more about his aunt purposely kept a secret for decades. It's a personal story that transcends into so many aspects relevant in everyday American life...mental health, patient's rights, sociology, economics, history and heritage.
Annie Cohen was born with a deformity, too much for anybody to deal with in those days before WWII -- not fitting into that image of the atomic American family. She was hastily sent to live at Eloise mental hospital in Detroit Michigan, and f...more
Annie Cohen was born with a deformity, too much for anybody to deal with in those days before WWII -- not fitting into that image of the atomic American family. She was hastily sent to live at Eloise mental hospital in Detroit Michigan, and f...more
Washington Post journalist Steve Luxemburg discovers at the end of his mom’s life that she had had a sister he had never heard of. He is astonished! He and his siblings had always grown up being told that his mother had been an only child. After her death, he uses his journalistic background to ferret out the details of this sister and what happened. “Annie,” the aunt he never met, had been born with both mental and physical disabilities and, at age 21 (!), had been placed in an institution. Her...more
Mar 12, 2013
Cristina
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Cristina by:
Janeen
Shelves:
non-fiction
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This book started out slowly for me, trying to remember all the characters, but got easier as it went along. I like the way the author added the history of Detroit, like the riots and the famous Belle Isle. I hope people that are in charge or in authority would look at the problems of mental health and learn by their failures.
A lot of thought and hard work investigating this family secret went into this book. I still wonder why this secret was kept to his mother's dying day. We can speculate an...more
A lot of thought and hard work investigating this family secret went into this book. I still wonder why this secret was kept to his mother's dying day. We can speculate an...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Post #5 (new): A starred Kirkus review | 1 | 22 | 27. März, 14:49 Uhr | |
| Blog post #4 : The challenge of memory, part 2 | 1 | 15 | 11. März, 07:24 Uhr | |
| Blog post #3: The art of memoir | 1 | 9 | 04. März, 06:51 Uhr | |
| Post #2 to my GoodReads blog | 1 | 15 | 27. Februar, 07:19 Uhr | |
| From the author: My GoodReads blog | 1 | 21 | 24. Februar, 06:13 Uhr |
Steve Luxenberg is an author and an associate editor of The Washington Post. He has worked for more than 30 years as a reporter and editor. Two projects that he edited at The Post have won Pulitzer Prizes for his reporters. He grew up in Detroit, the primary setting for his nonfiction book, "Annie's Ghosts: A Journey Into a Family Secret" (Hyperion, hardcover, May 2009; paperback, May 2010).
The b...more
More about Steve Luxenberg...
The b...more
Share This Book
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Secrets, I've discovered, have a way of working free of their keepers.”
—
3 people liked it
“Without really trying, I have become a collector of other families' secrets. Whenever I tell someone about my detective work, the first question is invariably something like this: 'Can you tell me the secret?' Sure, I say. The next question often is: 'Want to hear my family's secret?”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…















01. Februar, 22:00 Uhr