216th out of 1,207 books
—
6,934 voters
Tortall and Other Lands: A Collection of Tales (Tortall)
by
Tamora Pierce (Goodreads Author)
Collected here for the first time are all of the tales from the land of Tortall, featuring both previously unknown characters as well as old friends. Filling some gaps of time and interest, these stories, some of which have been published before, will lead Tammy's fans, and new readers into one of the most intricately constructed worlds of modern fantasy.
The Dragon's Tale
D...more
The Dragon's Tale
D...more
Hardcover, 369 pages
Published
February 22nd 2011
by Random House
(first published February 7th 2011)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Mar 31, 2013
Sophie
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Tamora Pierce fans
If you're new to Tortall, this book contains huge spoilers for the Immortals series and the Trickster duology, so you probably want to read those first. Tortall veterans, though, should love this book. It continues the stories of some familiar characters and creatures, and introduces others for the first time. I'm going to review each story on its own.
Student of Ostriches: Tammy takes a character who was mentioned ONCE in Lioness Rampant and gives her a complete and awesome backstory. I won't sp...more
Student of Ostriches: Tammy takes a character who was mentioned ONCE in Lioness Rampant and gives her a complete and awesome backstory. I won't sp...more
Allison Freeman
APA Citation:
Pierce, T. (2011). Tortall and other lands: A collection of tales. New York: Random House.
Genre: Short Story
Format: Print
Selection Process:
Baker, D. F. (2012). Tortall and other lands: A collection of tales. Horn Book Magazine, 87(2), 122-123.
Review:
Many of the stories in this collection have been published in other works but Tamora Pierce includes eight previously published tales and three written specifically for this collection.
Kylaia is the narrator of the first...more
APA Citation:
Pierce, T. (2011). Tortall and other lands: A collection of tales. New York: Random House.
Genre: Short Story
Format: Print
Selection Process:
Baker, D. F. (2012). Tortall and other lands: A collection of tales. Horn Book Magazine, 87(2), 122-123.
Review:
Many of the stories in this collection have been published in other works but Tamora Pierce includes eight previously published tales and three written specifically for this collection.
Kylaia is the narrator of the first...more
So what's the protocol if you're reviewing a book, and you're married to the writer? Should I not review or rate at all since, well, I'm not about to give any of Tammy's book less than five stars, am I? I do live with her, after all - and I have to sleep
sometime
.... :o :o :o
EDITED TO ADD: Seriously, is it okay for me to review a book Tammy's written or not?
EDITED TO ADD: Seriously, is it okay for me to review a book Tammy's written or not?
I originally purchased a copy of this when it was first released, but never got around to reading it. Then yesterday I was poking around the stacks at the library for the first time in ages and it caught my eye, so I figured, hey, why not?
So today I sat down and I read it, and you know what? Pleasantly surprised.
I'm not usually a big fan of short stories, and while some of these don't quite qualify as "short" (one clocks in at about 75 pages), they were great little insights. We get to see the...more
So today I sat down and I read it, and you know what? Pleasantly surprised.
I'm not usually a big fan of short stories, and while some of these don't quite qualify as "short" (one clocks in at about 75 pages), they were great little insights. We get to see the...more
So obviously I am a huge Tamora Pierce fan. She is officially my most read author. I've been slowly working my way through her novels for over three years now. I've listened to all but one of them. (Cold Fire is not available on audio and I'll have to read Shatterglass for the same reason.) It took a bit more effort and interlibrary loan to get Tortall and Other Lands on audio, but it was well worth it.
Tortall and Other Lands is a fabulous collection of stories, and I wouldn't say that I'm a hug...more
Tortall and Other Lands is a fabulous collection of stories, and I wouldn't say that I'm a hug...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This is a nice collection of short stories; Pierce knows her trade and her audience.
Six of the twelve tales occur in the Tortall world Pierce is so well known for. These give further voice to some of the side characters whose point of views haven't previously made it onto the page. The other stories are not placed in one of Pierce's standard worlds, and one isn't speculative fiction, though it's still a good read. "Huntress", a contemporary urban fantasy tale is something of a stand-out in the c...more
Six of the twelve tales occur in the Tortall world Pierce is so well known for. These give further voice to some of the side characters whose point of views haven't previously made it onto the page. The other stories are not placed in one of Pierce's standard worlds, and one isn't speculative fiction, though it's still a good read. "Huntress", a contemporary urban fantasy tale is something of a stand-out in the c...more
I always find collections of short stories difficult to review (unless Edgar Allen Poe or Anton Chekhov are the writers). In the case of Tortall and Other Lands I found that I really loved the quality of many of the stories and the plot lines that allowed them to conclude nicely. However there were around three stories that I found detracted on the whole from the overall book. It particularly did not help that those stories were right near the very end when a novel should be concluding strongly....more
Tamora Pierce has been entertaining teens for years, especially those who are female. Most of her books have avery strong feminine main character who struggles through the world of men to show that they are just as good as any male. Tortall and Other Lands : A Collection of Tales, doesn't focus on any particular character as it plays with many different characters in its many short stories. Many of the main characters are still female, but that is not the purpose of these stories, these stories...more
Okay, as some of you may know, I love Tamora Pierce to an almost frightening degree. Were I familiar with the ground she walked on, I would most likely worship it. She’s basically my spirit animal.
So I went into this new collection in a state of hyperventilating-glee, and... eh. I must prefer to experience her books in larger, more sweeping quantities, because the short stories didn’t do much for me.
In part, I blame the somewhat erratic nature of the collection. Some are short! Some are long!...more
So I went into this new collection in a state of hyperventilating-glee, and... eh. I must prefer to experience her books in larger, more sweeping quantities, because the short stories didn’t do much for me.
In part, I blame the somewhat erratic nature of the collection. Some are short! Some are long!...more
From my blog: (\__/)nymfaux
...
I just about inhaled the stories all at once—but with the short story format it’s easy to read a few stories, and then pick it up again later on if you need to.
Eleven stories are included, in all—And as for picking a favorite—I won’t even try.—Ok, I tried, but I totally can’t, so here are all the things I love:
I LOVE Kylaia, in Student of Ostriches, learning different fighting and defense techniques by watching how different animals interact, while she’s tending her...more
...
I just about inhaled the stories all at once—but with the short story format it’s easy to read a few stories, and then pick it up again later on if you need to.
Eleven stories are included, in all—And as for picking a favorite—I won’t even try.—Ok, I tried, but I totally can’t, so here are all the things I love:
I LOVE Kylaia, in Student of Ostriches, learning different fighting and defense techniques by watching how different animals interact, while she’s tending her...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Tortall and Other Lands: A Collection of Tales is a selection of ten short stories from Tamora Pierce. This young adult collection puts Pierce's ability to draw the reader into the lives of her characters on display perfectly. Pierce consistently writes compelling tales for children and young adults that make the readers really care about the characters and the bigger picture of the world that they live in. While eight of the stories in this book are fantasy, taking place in Tortall and surround...more
This book contains a variety of stories ranging from the fantasy world of Tortall to modern day America.
Student of Ostriches introduces you to Kylaia, a character briefly referenced in the Song of the Lioness quartet. This story was about strength, courage, and observation. I liked the Africa feel of it as well as the story.
Elder Brother was one of my favorites in this collection. After reading Wolfspeaker (Book 2 in the Immortals quartet), I really wanted to know what happened to the poor tree...more
Student of Ostriches introduces you to Kylaia, a character briefly referenced in the Song of the Lioness quartet. This story was about strength, courage, and observation. I liked the Africa feel of it as well as the story.
Elder Brother was one of my favorites in this collection. After reading Wolfspeaker (Book 2 in the Immortals quartet), I really wanted to know what happened to the poor tree...more
The stories were all good tales, but the collection itself was highly erratic in both length and depth. It went from short stories about characters we've never met to long stories about characters who we know (and hopefully love) already. For example, we get to meet the apple tree that Numair turned into a human, halfway around the world, in a short story about intolerance from all sides. On the other hand, we also get to spend quite a long time in Nawat's head as he deals with being the father...more
Half of these 11 stories take place in or near Tortall, the kingdom that fans of Pierce have come to know well, but four of them are non-Tortall fantasies and one of them is not a fantasy at all.
Strange to say, but though I have read both Beka Cooper books, all four of the Protector of the Small quartet, the Circle of Magic quartet, AND the Circle Opens quartet, I have never read either the Immortals or Song of the Lioness quartets. Weird, huh?
However, it does put me in a good position to tell...more
Strange to say, but though I have read both Beka Cooper books, all four of the Protector of the Small quartet, the Circle of Magic quartet, AND the Circle Opens quartet, I have never read either the Immortals or Song of the Lioness quartets. Weird, huh?
However, it does put me in a good position to tell...more
So, this collection was mixed for me.
The contemporary tales didn't work for me. I needed more from them, more characterization, more complexity.
I had a real hard time with the tales that were clearly a critique of veils; this issue is really complex and it is troubling to take it on so simplistically from a western point of view. I had a similar issue with "Time of Proving".
I enjoyed the story "The Dragon's Tale" very much, and loved the way it took me back to characters I have great affection f...more
The contemporary tales didn't work for me. I needed more from them, more characterization, more complexity.
I had a real hard time with the tales that were clearly a critique of veils; this issue is really complex and it is troubling to take it on so simplistically from a western point of view. I had a similar issue with "Time of Proving".
I enjoyed the story "The Dragon's Tale" very much, and loved the way it took me back to characters I have great affection f...more
This amazing collection of tales fills in the blanks on events which happened before or after several of Tamora's Tortall books, but it would also stand on it's own just as a collection of great Fantasy short stories. Although I enjoyed them all, my favorites are: Student of Ostriches, Elder Brother, The Dragon's Tale and Lost.
Although I've reread the entire Tortall series at least once a year since I discovered it 8 years ago, I also have a few favorites that I pick up at random when I want to...more
Although I've reread the entire Tortall series at least once a year since I discovered it 8 years ago, I also have a few favorites that I pick up at random when I want to...more
As soon as I saw the title, I knew I had to have it. I pre-ordered it months ago, and had forgotten about it until I got an email letting me know my book was here. Excitedly, I sat down to read it, swearing that it was just a short-term thing, because short-stories are not meant to be devoured in one sitting.
Except that's totally what happened.
I really liked most of them, a few were better than others.
It starts strong, with quite a few which are clearly set in Tortall or neighboring lands which...more
Except that's totally what happened.
I really liked most of them, a few were better than others.
It starts strong, with quite a few which are clearly set in Tortall or neighboring lands which...more
It’s been over twenty years since readers first learned of Tortall in Tamora Pierce’s first novel Alanna. In the fifteen books that followed, readers have met numerous characters and magical creatures from the land of Tortall. In the book, Tortall and Other Lands, several of Tamora Pierce’s short stories are collected and published for the first time in print.
Several of the stories have new characters that we have not met before. In the story “Nawat,” readers are reacquainted with Nawat and Aly...more
Several of the stories have new characters that we have not met before. In the story “Nawat,” readers are reacquainted with Nawat and Aly...more
Hola... I have been reading as much as possible! Tortall and Other Lands, a Collection of Tales is by Tamora Pierce. These eleven short stories concern a myriad of different topics, from continuations of her previous fantasy books to modern, more realistic stories. I will tell you about my two favorites and two least-favorites. Bad first. Nawat is the story of a half-man and half-crow being, who is shunned for his humanity. Huntress is the other one. It is about a girl whose family worships old...more
An interesting point -- Pierce's feminist POV really pops from the pages in these shorter stories. Most of all in a pair in which she is grappling with a fantasy-version of Islamic culture. But knowing her agenda hardly hurts the narrative, or her ulterior cause. I like the way her back-to-back protagonists played off each other. In fact, that was an aspect of this collection I was surprised to like. I *knew* I would enjoy stories like "Nawat," which explores the post-happily-ever-after for the...more
I'm a fan of Tamora Pierce's young adult fantasies, which I discovered as an adult after a friend who loved her books from childhood was horrified when I asked her Tamora who? She can fall into a preachy political correctness, which can be seen from time to time in these shorts, but she also writes among the strongest female protagonists in fantasy, yet alone Young Adult. She's the perfect counter to Stephenie Meyer's Twilight Saga with her active, kick-ass heroines and creates imaginative magic...more
I've read all of Pierce's "Tortallans" series ("Song of the Lioness", "The Immortals", "Protector of the Small", "Daughter of the Lioness", and "Beka Cooper"), and I have to say that this short story collection was probably one of her best additions to the series. I'm still pretty sad about what happened in the "Beka Cooper" books, especially because of the way Pierce had to go to tie that series in with the rest of her novels (and I have to wonder what would have happened if she'd written her b...more
Dec 24, 2012
Zabe Nokomis
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Everyone. EVERY ONE needs to read this series.
Tamora Pierce will always have a fond place in my heart. She might not make it to Hollywood, and she might not knock elbows with the greats like JK and Miss Meyer but I promise you, she's every bit as good. She reminds us that there are just some stories that are too big for the big screen. She created a whole new world, successfully and managed to use it as inspiration for SEVERAL series I will reccommend as long as I believe in Literature, which as a writer, will be forever.
Garth Nix and Tamo...more
Garth Nix and Tamo...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Tortall and Other Lands: A Collection of Tales is just that.
Old friends and new; short stories that have appeared in other anthologies, as well as new stories appearing for the first time in print.
As the title of the collection implies, not all of the stories take place in Tortall, nor are all of the characters you will meet within these pages familiar ones for readers of her novels.
What is unusual in this collection is that unlike most anthologies, the stories come first. The authors comments...more
Old friends and new; short stories that have appeared in other anthologies, as well as new stories appearing for the first time in print.
As the title of the collection implies, not all of the stories take place in Tortall, nor are all of the characters you will meet within these pages familiar ones for readers of her novels.
What is unusual in this collection is that unlike most anthologies, the stories come first. The authors comments...more
The world and people continue beyond the book. Some of these simply take place in the world of Tortall in familiar places or with familiar circumstances like the Shang warriors. One takes place as a result of events in one of the novels, another was a future story about main characters. There are some modern stories which are quite a change from what we are used to. Some of them even overlap with each other. I’m going to try to do this one story by story…
“Student of Ostriches” This one I had alr...more
“Student of Ostriches” This one I had alr...more
Tortall and Other Lands is a collection of short stories by the wonderful and inspiring Tamora Pierce. It features stories with new characters and many with our favorite old characters. Most of the stories are set in the Tortall universe, a place all Pierce fans know very well, but there are also 5 stories not set in Tortall, they take place in a variety of other locations (some real and some fantasy).
Since there was such a fantastic mixture of stories I wrote a separate review for each one.
Stu...more
Since there was such a fantastic mixture of stories I wrote a separate review for each one.
Stu...more
Tamora Pierce's first short story collection highlights the Tortall stories for a logical reason. The books set in Tortall are arguably her best know books, and using Tortall in the title is an intelligent selling point. The most emotionally moving stories in this collection are the non-Tortall stories. While some may call Testing and Huntress simple tales, I not only thoroughly enjoyed them I would highly recommend these stories and the entire book to parents. Especially parents who have young...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The (Not-So) Aust...: Tortall - Land of the Lioness | 4 | 27 | Jan 11, 2013 02:01am |
Hey, folks! I just discovered that apparently I have given some very popular books single-star ratings--except I haven't. How do I know I haven't? Because I haven't read those books at all. So before you go getting all hacked off at me for trashing your favorites, know that I've written GoodReads to find out what's going on.
I return to my regularly scheduled profile:
Though I would love to join gro...more
More about Tamora Pierce...
I return to my regularly scheduled profile:
Though I would love to join gro...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Without reading, we are all without light in the dark, without fire in the cold.”
—
19 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






view all 9 comments























