Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Ursula, Under” as Want to Read:
Ursula, Under
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Ursula, Under

3.71  ·  Rating Details  ·  1,136 Ratings  ·  227 Reviews
Once in a while, a first-time novelist dares to write bravely and big. Ingrid Hill has done just that with her breathtaking first novel.
In Michigan's Upper Peninsula, a dangerous rescue effort draws the ears and eyes of the entire country. When a two-year-old girl falls down a mine shaft it is as if all hope for life on the planet is bound up in her rescue. Little Ursula
...more
Published (first published 2004)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Ursula, Under, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Ursula, Under

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,592)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Zinta
Jan 05, 2009 Zinta rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
If I have for some time now been reading books to illuminate the meaning of life, here was a break to turn that coin on its other side and ask of its value. To ponder meaning, after all, assumes life has value. And if it does, are all of our lives to be valued equally?

When 2 1/2-year-old Ursula falls into an old mine shaft in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, media and curiosity seekers swarm the scene, and not one alone asks about the mixed race child born of poor parents - is she worth saving?
...more
Diana Higgins
Jul 28, 2008 Diana Higgins rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: abandoned
I just could not read this book. I liked the beginning, even though the overwritten phrases continually distracted me from the story, but then when the story changed to that of the Chinese alchemist I almost gave up right then.

I did stick with it through that part. Let me just say that I LOVE the premise of this book, that each life is beautiful and valuable, that each one of us is only here because of the interesting and unique ancestors that came before us. It was just the writing! The Chinese
...more
Ami
Jul 04, 2007 Ami rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book is such a great, great read. I tried to convince everyone to pick it up for summer a couple years ago, but people kept not finishing it. I believe that the third chapter, set in ancient China, is the sticking point. Everyone thought the rest of the novel was going to be as dry and inexplicable as that one. But it's not, at all.
Kathy
Jul 21, 2007 Kathy rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: People who love stories that weave together
I was on the fence about giving this book a 4 or 5 star review. I'll give it a 5 star recommendation, because I think it is very worth the read and might likely be someone's favorite book of all time if they give it a try after seeing a nice high recommendation. I think most people would give it four or five stars.

It is the story of a two and a half year old who falls down a well. But, as the book says, what you see of an iceberg is only what is above the surface and the iceberg is formed by the
...more
Lauri
Oct 05, 2007 Lauri rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction_modern
I really liked the architecture of the book and the writing style was nice. I mean, the way that Ursula and her ancient ancestors' stories were woven together was unique and original. But, the author failed to get me to care enough about the characters to lose myself in the book. I just didn't really care about what happened to any of them, which is sad, because there were some interesting characters there.
Sheri
Jun 18, 2015 Sheri rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I haven't written a review on Goodreads in a long time, but this book warrants it. This is a behemoth of a book. . . okay, not really. It's 476 pages. But it's so very intricately woven with random threads going off this way and that, it takes a great deal of energy to stay focused while reading it. It doesn't move quickly and is definitely not plot-driven.

However, this is a beautiful novel, if a bit too wordy at times. I got bogged down in ancient China and nearly gave up. I'm glad I didn't.

The
...more
Wendy
Apr 12, 2015 Wendy rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
The overall theme of this book captured my nostalgic side. I loved the idea that all of us are only here because our ancestors somehow made it possible by their meeting of each other, and were then able to produce at least one child to carry on the family line, so from that perspective the book really made me appreciate the struggle of my own ancestors. I also enjoyed most of the characters from Ursula's bloodline, some of which had beautiful love stories attached which I'm a sucker for. I did o ...more
Marvin
Aug 07, 2009 Marvin rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: midwest
Hill, who lives in Iowa City, has been in several church school classes with me (including the one I taught) and contributed good insights. The book has some beautifully written passages & scenes that don't hold together all that well & is undermined by some overwiting, some repetition of themes, & a lot of (literally) incredible coincidences. The story centers around a little girl (& her family) who falls down an abandoned mine shaft in Michigan's Upper Peninsula. From beginning ...more
Christine
This was such a good idea. I love collections of short stories masquerading as novels! There is one contemporary story interspersed with historical stories, each one featuring different ancestors in Ursula's family tree. The premise is wonderful, and is handled really well too. I don't know what order it was written in (it unfolds more or less chronologically) but the writing actually seems to improve over the course of the book. Either that or her style - full of interruptions like this one - g ...more
Elisascalise
Jul 20, 2007 Elisascalise rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Disappointed. Had I not been encouraged to persist with this book, I admit I would have put it down after the first couple of pages. But then it grabbed me by the pulomonary and I have been disappointed every time I have had to put it down.

This book feeds my penchant for misplaced nostalgia through a series of characters who are connected by blood and really nothing else. Each chapter is devoted to one person in the blood line of a little girl, who has fallen down an unused mining shaft. Each ch
...more
Meliza
Dec 09, 2008 Meliza rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
I don't think I'm going to make it through this one. It is a great premise, telling the stories of generations of inter-connected lives that lead to one particular family and a little girl who falls down a mine shaft. But in the execution, I found it difficult to keep caring about the main plot while being constantly led in other (more interesting) directions. Also the prose was quite painful at times, over-written to the point that I found myself skimming to get to the relevant sections.

And...a
...more
Elizabeth
Feb 23, 2015 Elizabeth rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: book-bingo-2015
Katherine wins, this was excellent. Though I have to say: it did not click for me until at least 1/4 of the way in, but after that, I was hooked. Just thinking about the thousands of stories that came before you were born is both overwhelming and exhilarating. This would make an excellent book club selection!
Laurel Deloria
Feb 01, 2016 Laurel Deloria rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: china
A great study in genelogy and that we are all related within 6 degrees of kinship.
One of the most widely praised and rapturously entertaining first novels in recent years begins with a little girl falling down an abandoned mineshaft in Michigan 19s Upper Peninsula. Her name is Ursula Wong, she 19s part Chinese, part Finnish, only two years old, and soon the dangerous effort to rescue her has an entire country glued to the TV. As it follows that effort, Ursula, Under re-creates the chain of ances
...more
Jennifer
I appreciated all her research and liked learning about quirkly little facts (who knew there was a lepers colony in Sweden? Not me). I made it a 3 primarily for the reseach/information in it. There were portions that were mind-numbing. Beth was right though--some of the comments and references were bizarre (the anal sphincter comment in particular) and out of place. It was like she learned a new word or heard a new song and just had to include it.
Heather
This book reminded me a bit of Away by Amy Bloom in its style of telling the story of a different character in each chapter while maintaining at least a slight connection with the central thread. It starts with a couple in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan losing their little girl, Ursula down an abandoned mine shaft. Then it tells each of their stories and those of their parents interspersed with stories of ancestors from various places and times before eventually looping back to the present.

I lo
...more
Vicki Webb
Mar 02, 2014 Vicki Webb rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I really recommend this book. A brief synopsis of the story: 2 year old Ursula Wong-part Chinese, part Finnish- falls down a disused mine shaft. Soon the entire country is focused on the dangerous effort to rescue her. As it follows that effort, the author takes us on a chain of ancestors, across 2000 years, whose lives culminate in the fragile miracle of the little girl underground. In telling their stories, we get a deep sense of not only how Ursula is linked to all these people, but also how ...more
Líam P
Oct 27, 2014 Líam P rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Boy, did I struggle with this, dragging myself through to 100 pages in the hope of the milestone (of sorts) would help me through to the other side. It barely registered.

"Ursula, Under" is a book high on concept, but very low on execution, the attempt to zoom through layers of family history undermined by a glib, throwaway, narrative style. Any sense of tension was lost with what I took to be smart-alec asides to camera (these historic characters don't know what's coming, tee hee!), taking the
...more
Barbara Skalberg
I probably would have enjoyed this more if the library hadn't shelved it under "non fiction." I spent the entire book annoyed that it was trying to pass itself off as a true story when there was no way it could be. If I had read the author's note on the title page where it clearly states the book was a work of fiction to start instead of after I was finished, I would have had a better attitude about it. *sigh* Interesting concept to give little vignettes about her family tree to make the reader ...more
Susan
May 30, 2015 Susan rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I struggled with this book as it is one of those which jumps back in time.

The story of Ursula who falls down an old mine shaft is the glue that holds the story together.

She s part Chines and part Finnish in ancestry. The story jumps back to her ancestors way back. I was not keen on the Silk route story or the Chinese Jesuit missionary story but once the time line moved forward I began to really become absorbed in the family history of this little girl.

This is not an easy read and the author mus
...more
Karen
Aug 06, 2014 Karen rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
This book opened with a tragic fall by a young girl into a mine shaft in northern Michigan. It then wove stories of her ancestors into a series of snapshots in time starting with her Chinese ancestors from 300 BC to her equally early ancestry from the area that is now Finland. The book also travelled through the centuries to the present day to form a more complete history of her heritage. These stories helped draw parallels of her past with the present situation but they also helped shape the co ...more
Mimi
Feb 01, 2016 Mimi rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-2016
I loved the very idea of this novel - the way that all of our stories and histories are connected. Hill followed these threads of connection back several generations while at the same time telling the current story of the girl who fell down an abandoned mine. I loved the way that she'd step outside the narrative to give an omniscient, future comment. However, there was something lacking the whole time - the writing was not up to the scope or the idea. Frustratingly, for those of us who are tryin ...more
Stephen Gallup
Oct 10, 2015 Stephen Gallup rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
One summer day in 2003, a little girl on an outing with her parents tumbles down an abandoned mine shaft in the backwoods of northern Michigan. Justin and Annie, who’d been only steps away, enter panic mode. The rest of the world gradually begins responding in the ways it always does when such things occur, mobilizing rescue workers and eager media people, and, far back on the periphery, emitting unsympathetic commentary about the expenditure of so much fuss over mere “halfbreed trailer trash.”

B
...more
Amanda
Jan 13, 2010 Amanda rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
The concept - of ancestry, fate and random chance - is fascinating and kept me reading past the point where I would have given up with most books. I loved the vast diversity of the histories of the characters: the author impressed me with her ability to sketch out the lives of these ancestors and leave me sympathetic with all of their faults and feelings. Sometimes the progression became very formulaic - the phrase "this detail from the present is identical/comes from this detail in the past but ...more
Julie
May 24, 2010 Julie rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: own, fiction
This was a fantastic book! This multi-generational tale of the Wong family spans centuries, circling back to a present-day crisis. Two and a half year old Ursula Wong has fallen down an abandon mineshaft. As rescue efforts take place, the story flashes back to her ancestors. From a Chinese alchemist two thousand years ago on her father’s side to a Finnish immigrant at the beginning of the twentieth century on her mother’s side, the novel spans history and geography. The chapters alternate from t ...more
Beth Cato
Ursula,Under is an odd yet beautifully written book. It begins by introducing little Ursula, age two. Her mother, who was crippled in a hit-and-run accident as a young girl, wasn't supposed to be able to have children. Her father, of mixed Chinese descent, adores his little girl and vows to do a better job than his own father, who abandoned his family when he was a toddler. Then, on a visit to the Michigan Upper Peninsula, the unthinkable happens - Ursula, laughing and happy, runs across a field ...more
Jody
Apr 23, 2008 Jody rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Hill's enchanting debut novel spans more than 2,000 years and is brimming with an engaging cast of characters. Annie and Justin Wong, who live in Michigan's Upper Peninsula, are on a day trip exploring the area where Annie's Finnish great-grandfather died in a mine collapse in 1926. Suddenly their only child, Ursula, disappears down an abandoned shaft, setting off a monumental rescue attempt and accompanying media frenzy. The author leaves that predictable plot behind, focusing instead on the yo ...more
Girl with her Head in a Book
I read and loved Audrey Niffenegger's The Time Traveler's Wife (I will try and review that at some point) and since then Niffenegger seems to have carved herself a bit of a career as a commenter on the covers of other people's books and whenever she does so, I now automatically buy it as any one that she has ever recommended has always been absolutely fantastic. The best of them all though is Ursula, Under - I majorly fell in love with this book. I read in my first year at university while I was ...more
Diane
Dec 09, 2008 Diane rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
I never totally warmed up to this book. The story is about a young couple with a small child (supposedly age 2 but that is unrealistic - I would say more like 3 or 4)who live in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. On a picnic the child, Ursula, falls down an abandoned mine shaft. During the next approximately 24 hours we see the rescue effort (in more detail that I wanted at times), the parents (excellent portrayal of how parents deal with this tragedy), and also - for the majority of the book - th ...more
Rebecca
Dec 06, 2007 Rebecca rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I almost stopped reading this book in the first chapter because it was about a Chinese alchemist.... sometimes there are just situations and settings that honestly I could care less about spending time in, even via a book. Chinese alchemy is one of those things for me (along with the South...I am sure I have some more prejudices that I am not aware of yet to add to the list!)

The conceit of the book's structure is that chance encounters and connections exist throughout a little girl's genealogy i
...more
Nln
Dec 29, 2014 Nln rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I just re-read "Ursula, Under" and for me it did not hold up as well on a second reading. I remember loving the concept and being enthralled by the stories of Ursula's ancestors, but this time, as some others have noted, some of the stories just seemed very long. One of the things I did enjoy was the self-aware omniscient POV, that would sometimes provide side comments about minor characters. Splitting the difference between a 5 on first reading and a 3 on the second...
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 86 87 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Tom Bedlam
  • After Such Kindness
  • Beatitude
  • Four Feet, Two Sandals
  • The Lovers of Algeria: A Novel
  • Family Roundabout
  • The Sweetheart Season
  • Silver People: Voices from the Panama Canal
  • And She Was
  • White Ghost Girls
  • Grange House
  • Heart of Coal
  • MotherKind
  • Adultery
  • The Fingerprint (Miss Silver, #30)
  • Tatty
  • The Virgin Soldiers
  • Mouthing the Words

Share This Book