Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Thin Red Line” as Want to Read:
The Thin Red Line
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Thin Red Line (The World War II Trilogy #2)

by
3.96 of 5 stars 3.96  ·  rating details  ·  7,007 ratings  ·  159 reviews
They are the men of C-for-Charlie company—“Mad” 1st Sgt. Eddie Welsh, Pvt. 1st Class Don Doll, Pvt. John Bell, Capt. James Stein, Cpl. Fife, and dozens more just like them—infantrymen who are about to land, grim and white-faced, on an atoll in the Pacific called Guadalcanal. This is their story, a shatteringly realistic walk into hell and back.

In the days ahead, some wil
...more
Paperback, 544 pages
Published February 9th 1998 by Dial Press Trade Paperback (first published 1962)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
mark monday
A true masterpiece and one of my favorite novels. Although it has all the realistic, gritty detailing that any novel recounting World War 2 Guadalcanal should have, it is so much more. The reader will indeed learn which gun is which and which rank is which. They will understand what needs to happen to take a hill. They will know what a crowded ship full of men will smell like. They will come to understand the practical intricacies of making war. But, as anyone who viewed the recent version of th ...more
Ursula
I saw the 1998 movie version of this book in theaters when it came out. I remember that I was completely mesmerized and transported by it. It was a movie about war unlike any I'd ever seen before - it was mostly quiet and internal. Walking out of the theater, I found out I was pretty much alone in my enjoyment of it - people all around me said it was slow, boring, pointless. I mention this because I think the movie version prepared me for the book, which is probably just as divisive.

The story fl
...more
Drew
I had the same reaction to this as I did to From Here to Eternity, which is to say that the beginning was so irritating that it almost made me put it down, but I ended up glad that I didn't.

I haven't read too many other books that were written around this time, but the prose style in this seems lackluster. Yeah, there are some poetic bits, but there are also bits that seem really lazy. In the first handful of pages, for example, Jones uses the words 'unpleasant' and 'supercilious' to describe D
...more
Richard
This is one of the greatest books on how World War II was fought in the Pacific; it is also unparalleled in its exploration of the nature of war, especially on how it affects the psyches of those bound up in it. It's the second of Jones' trilogy on the Second World War. All of the venues of the three novels were derived from his experiences; Pre-war Schofield Barracks in Oahu, the 1942-43 battles of Mount Austen, the Galloping Horse, and the Sea Horse on Guadalcanal, and in military hospitals. T ...more
Paul Gaya Ochieng Simeon Juma
The thin red line...whet is it? It is the line that separates life from death, health from injury.
The Novel is an anti-war novel. The effects of war are clearly elaborated.
The reasons for war is actually left out. We see Welsh asking himself why they are fighting? He seems to be the only one with an answer to that question.

Fife also tries to answer that question, but his reasons are vague. Besides being sent by the government, he's in war for his own personal reasons. That is, to prove that he
...more
Geoffrey Benn
“The Thin Red Line,” by James Jones, is the fictional account of the trials endured by the men of Charlie Company during their first month on Guadalcanal in the early days of WWII. The book, first published in 1962, has come to be recognized as a classic war novel. I think that designation is well-deserved – the book is an incredible examination of the varying ways in which men react to the shock of combat. Jones follows at least a dozen recurring characters through a range of experiences – incl ...more
Emily
Let’s start with the names of the soldiers: Big Queen, Buck Sergeant Doll, Shorty Tall. Then move on to the soldiers’ names for their battle sites: The Giant Boiled Shrimp, The Sea Slug, Boola Boola. In vivid strokes like these, Jones brings intimacy, humor, and authenticity to his story of the U.S. invasion of Guadalcanal, told from the viewpoints of a handful of combat troops in C-for-Charlie Company. This book gives a reader so much to gnaw on: What is a soldier? What makes a good one? Can so ...more
Robynne
This is an incredible study of war and of men who have participated in battle. This book will not make you feel good; it is not designed for that. Jones, who served in the Guadalcanal campaign, says a lot in his dedication at the beginning of the novel: "This book is cheerfully dedicated to those greatest and most heroic of human endeavors, WAR and WARFARE; may they never cease to give us the pleasure, excitement and adrenal stimulation that we need, or provide us with the heroes, the presidents ...more
Steve Woods
This book is a tour de force! If you are looking for a controilled sequentiial narrative this is not it, but as someone who has seen combat the exploration of the function ofmen's minds in those circumstances is right on the knocker. Given my own experiences and conversations in the field and often afterwards the themes Jones outlines turn up time after time, often wryly in retrospect with a dash of embarrassed humour but there. The book has an essential American flavour, and much of the interna ...more
Jim Coughenour
My favorite World War II novel. I'm tempted to say "sentimental favorite," if that makes any sense applied to this hard-core tale of American soldiers in Guadalcanal. Jones is convincing on the banality, the raw fear, the horniness and insanity of combat – he refuses to romanticize any of it, just as he skips the easy polemics. A gritty, captivating tale.

Fortunately I read the book before I saw Terrence Malik's film – which is excellent, if a bit too austere and stylized. Malik leaves out the di
...more
John Nevola
James Jones is a talented writer with great insights and perspectives but I just could not connect with The Thin Red Line.
I loved From Here To Eternity but I found The Thin Red Line to be somewhat slow and laboring. Perhaps it was the use of fictional settings on a real island (Guadalcanal) that threw me off but I look for, and value, historical accuracy in historical novels. The War was long over when he published this book so national security could not have been the reason for the fictitious
...more
scott
This novel is awfully good. Clearly amongst the best war novels that I have read. I really didn't care for the movie when it came out, and after reading the book, understand why: The book is far more about the human rationalization of solidering and killing, than it is about actual events. Internal dialogs drive the narrative, and they are much more accurate than those of (at least from the feeble understanding of human behavior I use to conjecture) other war novelists. There's something masochi ...more
Chris
I imagine many people find this book in the same way I did; after seeing Terrence Malick's excellent 1998 movie of the same name. I'm so pleased I did because it has become an instant favourite.

Set during the bloody Guadalcanal campaign in 1943 the story follows the exploits of C-For-Charlie company of the US 25th Infantry Division right from their first arrival to their final evacuation after weeks of intense fighting against the Japanese forces occupying the island.

The book portrays the soldie
...more
Alexprado12
Its amazing how the mind of a human wants to know how things are like without even experiencing that certain topic. In this case the topic of war. If you haven't experienced war your self there is so many more visual, mental, physical aspects to war the average person can not describe without being there.
James jones, author of the novel, does a tremendous job on getting the reader to understand the visual effect of war, by just reading a book. For example, the reader can get an idea about worl
...more
Megan Openshaw
If I saw this in a bookshop, the likelihood is I'd walk straight past it without a second glance. I have little to no prior experience with 'war writing' (I'm not sure whether to count The Book Thief) - something like this isn't the kind of thing I'd normally read, but I'm so glad I did!

I won't go into too much detail about the plot (no spoilers!), but the basic premise of the novel is that it follows a group of US troops, 'C-for-Charlie Company', and depicts their experiences during the Guadalc
...more
Tsung Wei
A story of C-company and its role in the Guadalcanal campaign in WWII, involving a large cast of characters, many of whom had very brief roles and lifespans. Several themes run through the book which the author seems preoccupied with. The main focus is the horror of war. The author pulls no punches in describing the inhuman conditions and the unbelievable suffering experienced by the men of C-company. Many, many soldiers died or were horribly mangled. Yet the highlight was not the physical detai ...more
Kevin Summers
Sample quote: "A small group explored the little Japanese camp for booty and discovered there the first evidence any of them had seen of cannibalism. They had all heard rumors, but this was no rumor. A dead Japanese man, who apparently had died from artillery inflicted chest wounds, had been strung up from a branch by his heels and strips of flesh about two inches wide had been cut from his buttocks, lower back and thighs. ... The charred remains of the little campfire where they had cooked him ...more
António
A work of genius. The book has excellent character development, it has an impressive, and unvarnished, descriptive vividness, it's engrossing, and amidst a lot of melancholy it has the correct amount of black humour to balance it out.
Sarah
Jan 02, 2015 Sarah rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Give it a miss.
I just couldn't finish this. I got to about page 130. Then I realised I couldn't care less about the characters.

I started to read this because I lived on Guadalcanal as a child, so I was quite disappointed to learn the author had changed the names of hills/towns etc, to render them unrecognisable.

The chapters were overlong. There were so many characters I couldn't remember who was who especially as I was struggling to keep my mind on the book anyway.

There isn't much more I can say, really. Ther
...more
Harold
Really 3 1/2 stars. This is the second of James Jones's WWII trilogy. Jones has a dense, thick writing style that I sometimes find hard to stay with. There are a lot of characters that can mesh with one another and at times it's hard to remember who is who. That being said it is a memorable book and I'm glad I read it. It presents a realistic view of what warfare in the Pacific in WWII must have been like. There is a lot of time given to interpersonal relationships and the petty and personal rea ...more
Old_airman
Interesting take on men in battle. Very rough language. Not traditional hero tale.
Ola
I'm surprised that I did not like the book more. I can't even figure out why, but it's definitely not the best war book I've ever read, to say the least. At some points purely boring. I couldn't make myself like any of the characters. It didn't also help that almost all of them had 4- or 5-letter names, many of them even rhyming, and I couldn't figure out who is who. There's Bell, Dale, Blane, Darl, Doll, Culp, Culn, Cash, Bead, Band, Beck, Keck, Gray, Gaff, Carr, Witt, Task, Tall... and more. S ...more
Seamus Mcduff
Other reviewers have pointed out that J Jones was in the US infantry and was sent to Guadalcanal. It may be worth pointing out that by his own admission the author deserted the army twice, and was finally classified Section 8 (mentally disturbed) and discharged. Just saying.

On the upside, there is much life-like detail and characterisation which gives the reader a feeling of the types of conditions, relationships, emotions, brutality, etc. the ordinary soldier was subject to in the US Army durin
...more
Coxy
The quote for this book on Goodreads sums it up really:

"When compared to the fact that he might very well be dead by this time tomorrow, whether he was courageous or not today was pointless, empty. When compared to the fact that he might be dead tomorrow, everything was pointless. Life was pointless. Whether he looked at a tree or not was pointless. It just didn't make any difference."

Whilst certainly recalling the fantastic film by Malick, there is a lot more to this book besides comparing it t
...more
Chris Chester
Somehow I was expecting more of this book after having watched the Terrence Malick film based on it.

I really enjoyed the setup, through the taking of the Big Dancing Elephant. The characters felt like genuine portrayals of the kind of men you would expect to find under fire, in WWII or maybe even today in Afghanistan. Their personalities spoke directly to the way they coped with fighting a war for the first time -- whether it was a 'fake it til you make it' strategy, ruthless glory hunting, or
...more
Alan Marchant
mission accomplished

James Jones draws the title of this book from the "thin red line between the sane and the mad." But the subtitle gives a clearer sense of the theme - "every man fights his own war."

On the surface, The Thin Red Line is strikingly similar to The Naked and the Dead. Each novel tell the stories of a group of inexperienced soldiers sent as cannonfodder to fight the Japanese on a lonely Pacific island.

But under the surface, the novels could not be more different. Norman Mailer's no
...more
Nathan
James Jones writes a gripping account of life as a WWII infantry man on the Pacific Front. One of the most impressive things about this book is how deftly and smoothly James switches between characters. My favorite thing about reading this book was that I read it so quickly. I think this definately went a long way to heighten the battle scenes. The detail and violence of which (particularly the battle for the Elephant) left me sharing a sense of exhaustion with the characters. I don't think the ...more
Chris
I first picked up this book more than 12 years ago, shortly after the movie came out. I put it down before delving too deeply into it, and never had an interest to return. Recently I picked it up again on a lark and decided to give it one more try. This time around I found it fascinating. Generally in media American soldiers are regarded as heroes. They defeated the German and Japanese soldiers and did so against great odds, facing their charge with great courage. Portrayals of Americans in WWII ...more
Chortle
Sep 20, 2011 Chortle rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: history buffs, LGBT, 60's, 70's
Longest book I've read.

Not one of my favorites because I'm not interested in tactics of which hill they decided to go on, didn't care about the hills. Wish more time had been spent on certain characters. There were too many characters and I wanted there to be more focus on a few. Liked the various responses to combat. But it seemed that there was too much of a list of all the types of things that would happen to people while in combat. Lots of where's my next drink, which was probably honest but
...more
manuti
Otro más, que cae.
Supongo que a todo el mundo le sonarán las películas De aquí a la eternidad y La delgada línea roja, pues además debería sonarnos también que el autor de la dos novelas en que se basan es el mismo, James Jones. Aún no he visto la película, pero sé que tiene fama de dura, pero la novela no es para menos. Creo que es la aproximación más real a lo que pasa por la cabeza de alguien cuando se encuentra en esas situaciones extremas de combate, y también las preguntas que uno se hace
...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Young Man's Guide
  • Essential Manners for Men: What to Do, When to Do It, and Why
  • Seek: Reports from the Edges of America and Beyond
  • The Book of Deeds of Arms and of Chivalry
  • The Crisis
  • The Frontier in American History
  • The Rough Riders
  • American Boys Handy Book
  • Boy Scout Handbook
  • The Young Lions
  • Parallel Lives
  • The Boys of Summer
  • Cross of Iron
  • The Dangerous Book for Boys
  • Theodore Roosevelt: A Strenuous Life
  • The Naked and the Dead
  • Self-Reliance
  • Das Boot
3999
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

James Ramon Jones was an American author known for his explorations of World War II and its aftermath.

His wartime experiences inspired some of his most famous works. He witnessed the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, which led to his first published novel, From Here to Eterni
...more
More about James Jones...

Other Books in the Series

The World War II Trilogy (3 books)
  • From Here to Eternity
  • Whistle
From Here to Eternity Whistle Some Came Running Go to the Widow-Maker The Merry Month of May

Share This Book

“If I never meet you
In this life
Let me feel the lack
A glance from your eyes
Then my life
Will be yours”
94 likes
“War don't ennoble men, it turns 'em into dogs. It poisons the soul.” 24 likes
More quotes…