51st out of 384 books
—
683 voters
Everything I Want to Do Is Illegal: War Stories from the Local Food Front
by
Joel Salatin
Drawing upon 40 years' experience as an ecological farmer and marketer, Joel Salatin explains with humor and passion why Americans do not have the freedom to choose the food they purchase and eat. From child labor regulations to food inspection, bureaucrats provide themselves sole discretion over what food is available in the local marketplace. Their system favors industri...more
Paperback, 338 pages
Published
September 17th 2007
by Polyface
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,439)
Joel, you are right but you are nuts and I need to take breaks when reading your book to get the righteous 'tone' out of my head. Since talking to you in person went so badly, my only wish is this: May your daughter become a feminist, recognize oppression everywhere, and bring that also to your dinner table. Yeah, sometimes it sucks to be a farmer, but you've got to figure out a system to help those whose lives suck even more. I only bring this up because you do, you white male, privileged enoug...more
Okay, ignore the racism, misogyny, xenophobia, etc, and this is a really good book. The ideas pertaining strictly to agriculture are wonderful. If I could rewrite it to get rid of the former list of issues, it would be my bible. As such, the notes I took will have to do.
This book offers fascinating insights into the processes involved in modern food creation, how this has changed, and why. It makes a very strong argument for the need to preserve (or bring back) local farms, pointing out the fallacy of the legislation that currently makes this so difficult. While I can't claim to agree with all of the author's view points (he talks about much more than just food and farming in the book), I fully agree with his philosophy that we should openly discuss our belie...more
Small-time farmer takes on big-city bureaucrats. This guy is a kook! Fascinating! It's in the spirit of the Humanure Handbook and Countryside Magazine with some Focus On The Family stuff thrown in. A little disturbing; wildly entertaining.
This is a book that would make Robert Heinlein rolled over in his grave, yet he would completely agree with it. It is a book to make me, the mildly rebellious anti-authority person I am, become a raving Libertarian. It also will make you think twice, if not three times, before you buy meat at the grocery store again.
The author of this book is a farmer in Virginia. He is trying to run a small farm and sell the products from his farm. Most of the things he wants to do, sell eggs, fresh chick...more
The author of this book is a farmer in Virginia. He is trying to run a small farm and sell the products from his farm. Most of the things he wants to do, sell eggs, fresh chick...more
A fantastic tirade on bureaucracy and its systematic attempt to eradicate small business. I completely feel for Joel Salatin.
My parents have had many similar experiences working with various cities, counties and state agencies on trying to build houses (they are general contractors). Of course, its Paul Allen who gets tax breaks and zoning variances, but if my parents want to build affordable housing, heaven forbid, lets pile on the fees! (Then people wonder why housing in the Seatt...more
My parents have had many similar experiences working with various cities, counties and state agencies on trying to build houses (they are general contractors). Of course, its Paul Allen who gets tax breaks and zoning variances, but if my parents want to build affordable housing, heaven forbid, lets pile on the fees! (Then people wonder why housing in the Seatt...more
An interesting read, and he makes some valid points about the difficulties of running a small farm in the current regulatory culture. He takes more personal satisfaction than perhaps appropriate at lambasting government employees who are enforcing the rules to the best of their ability (i.e. not turning a blind eye and letting him do whatever he wants) but still, he makes good points that it hardly seems fair that the rules are at times so vague that a change in personnel can mean the law is in...more
This is a great book for understanding the struggles that true believers of sustainable farming are up against. It is a detailed account of the bureaucratic red-tape family farmers need to navigate in order to make a living and do so in an environmentally sensitive, small business model, high quality product manner.
Salatin makes it easy to understand his point of view by walking the reader through several scenarios that he's experienced firsthand. Salatin's observations, whatever t...more
Salatin makes it easy to understand his point of view by walking the reader through several scenarios that he's experienced firsthand. Salatin's observations, whatever t...more
I'm sorry, Joel. I couldn't finish this. Heck, I could barely get into it.
This actually IS a good primer on the war in the countryside that's being waged between local producers and government. If you can get past the tone: Joel alternates between teacher, preachy and screechy.
Make no mistake: there IS a war being fought over food production and the deck is stacked in favour of large producers, feed lot cattle, battery cage chickens and massive hog operations. You'd think...more
This actually IS a good primer on the war in the countryside that's being waged between local producers and government. If you can get past the tone: Joel alternates between teacher, preachy and screechy.
Make no mistake: there IS a war being fought over food production and the deck is stacked in favour of large producers, feed lot cattle, battery cage chickens and massive hog operations. You'd think...more
This author is at the forefront of the food wars, and to sum up his book -- if I want to raise beef, butcher them at a table out back, and sell them to my neighbors who are perfectly aware of the entire process and the end product turns out cleaner than what you buy in the store, why should the government care? He makes many great points, but the overall feel of his attitude in the book is "I'm right, everyone else is wrong, and you're all idiots if you don't agree with me." In perso...more
I purchased this book directly from Polyface Farms after going on one of their free monthly tours of the farm and I swear I could almost hear Joel Salatin's voice as I read his book. His narrative was hilarious - full of contempt for government bureaucracy and stories of USDA/regulatory nonsense.
Joel takes some pretty aggressive positions for his quest for responsible, local farming, which I can understand, but not all of which I agree with. Still, it was a really insightful experience to unde...more
Joel takes some pretty aggressive positions for his quest for responsible, local farming, which I can understand, but not all of which I agree with. Still, it was a really insightful experience to unde...more
This thoroughly enjoyable book is at once humorous and infuriating. Humorous because of Joel’s genuine, down-to-earth writing style that just makes you chuckle throughout. Infuriating because of the jumble of insane bureaucracy he reveals.
Joel can be pretty far out with some of his political views, but that adds to the appeal of the book. Joel defines authentic — he lets it all hang out, doesn’t mince words, and states things plainly.
Whether you agree with him or not, he’...more
Joel can be pretty far out with some of his political views, but that adds to the appeal of the book. Joel defines authentic — he lets it all hang out, doesn’t mince words, and states things plainly.
Whether you agree with him or not, he’...more
Great book. Salatin is so funny and his stories about confronting and circumventing the anti-local food regulators are great. The local food movement is such an important movement in our country. This book chronicles the impact regulation has on small farms and local economies. In addition to pure libertarian arguments of free-choice and governmental non-interference, Salatin also shows practically how regulation is detrimental to the nation's local economies and overall public health. To S...more
Salatin is a "beyond organic" farmer, to use his own words. He writes about the struggles and triumphs of being an independent farmer in America, with some particulars relating to his state of Virginia. He shares his frustrations with bureaucracy and how the food system stifles the production of local, high quality, safe food. He writes on a myriad of topics related to a farmer, but it is very relatable by anyone who has aspirations to change the food system/culture in this country ...more
With a title like Everything I Want to Do is Illegal you might expect that Joel Salatin wants to do things that others might find morally questionable, or certainly well outside the norm. And while the latter, at least, might be true in a sense, that in and of itself is a sad commentary on our country, because all Salatin wants to do is to raise and sell to his customers what he believes (and many satisfied customers will agree) is the best animals and animal products in the world, and he wants ...more
Just finished this book; it's an excellent read-very well written. He does get a bit repetive on a few points, and refers to the bible a couple of times-but not in an over the top fashion. There are a couple of points that I don't particularly agree with, but the overall message I fully am on the same page with him and that is that over regulation is simply helping the big corporations of industrial and factory farming and pushing out the true local, small, sustainable farmer.
As an e...more
As an e...more
If you don't know who Joel Salatin is, he is the all-natural, very opinionated Virginia farmer that was interviewed in the documentary Food Inc. He is quite the libertarian and does not shy away from sharing his political views on nearly every topic under the sun, food related or not. The book could have used another round of editing - it repeats itself and there are grammar issues.
But despite all of that, I'm really glad I read this book. Joel explains how the U.S. food industr...more
But despite all of that, I'm really glad I read this book. Joel explains how the U.S. food industr...more
Joel Salatin is a small farmer who has found a niche providing a unique product--meat uninfected by the industrial food system. In this book he compiles a list of complaints on how the government works to undermine his efforts, and the efforts of like-minded small farmers.
The government's various agencies work in collusion with industrial farmers to push out the small, independent farmer and leave the American diet to industrialized food and all its undernourished animals, contamina...more
The government's various agencies work in collusion with industrial farmers to push out the small, independent farmer and leave the American diet to industrialized food and all its undernourished animals, contamina...more
This book is very informative about the current problems in the food production industry and the problems small farmers have fighting the government as they try to produce actually healthy food. Some of the content is down right disgusting and makes me want to never buy store food again. However, the author goes off on a LOT of tangents and after a while I got tired of it, he could have presented his story without all of the ranting. By the last few chapters I just started scanning. Overall I di...more
This book brings to light the bureaucratic struggles that the average farmer must endure to bring fresh and local food to their community. Unfortunately most regulations are put in place to try and force small producer out. Most people would consider their choice of food a personal decision. Everyone should really think about where they are spending their money and what kind of business practices you are enabling. (PS I do have very different views on some subjects that Salatin commented on t...more
It's nice to see that someone gets as annoyed as I do that our government spends an insane amount of time, effort and energy to solve problems that shouldn't even exist in the first place. Salatin does have some ideas I think are nutty tangents (like suggesting that we have an illegal alien problem due to abortion) but I'm sure he would insist that all his points are connected. No matter what your political persuasion or belief system, I guarantee he will offend you at some point in the book, bu...more
I think his time in the high school Debate Team paid off. Salatin is eloquent, intelligent, passionate and a little crazy. I like him a lot. He also sheds some light and raises some extremely insightful points on the world of farming, the term "Organic" and several other things related to farming such as government regulations, and psychological habits...I enjoyed learning more about sustainable farming, composting and such, but I also enjoyed his perceptive ability to understand the m...more
So, 2/3 of the way through this book I lost it to the library queue, and finally got it back.
Basically, Joel Salatin is a nut. I believe he would not necessarily argue with that. He's all over the place, hates Democrats, hates Repulicans, is a homeschooler and hates school systems, is a rabid Christian who thinks people have a responsibility to treat the Earth well (rather than use it up "because God gave it to us"),hates big business, hates environmentalists, hates illegal i...more
Basically, Joel Salatin is a nut. I believe he would not necessarily argue with that. He's all over the place, hates Democrats, hates Repulicans, is a homeschooler and hates school systems, is a rabid Christian who thinks people have a responsibility to treat the Earth well (rather than use it up "because God gave it to us"),hates big business, hates environmentalists, hates illegal i...more
When Joel Salatin came to our city for a speaking engagement we went and liked what he had to say. Hence, checking the book out from the library. I have read a lot about local food movements, slow food movements, CAFO's, etc. etc. and was excited to read this book from the perspective of the farmer.
I felt that Joel had some very good points and good stories, either his or people he knew, to illustrate the myopic visions that often cloud judgements regarding our food system. Wher...more
I felt that Joel had some very good points and good stories, either his or people he knew, to illustrate the myopic visions that often cloud judgements regarding our food system. Wher...more
The pope of sustainable, the crusader of local, responsible food.
I can't wait: hurry up, Amazon!
June '11: I agree that State and Federal rules stack the deck in favor of big agribusiness, feedlots, assembly-line slaughterhouses, battery chickens, huge fossil-fuel-fertilized subsidized Gmo corn and soy fields, and that it takes enormous determination nowadays to run sustainable, humane, natural farming enterprises.
His other views I find very objectionable. Example: birth ...more
I can't wait: hurry up, Amazon!
June '11: I agree that State and Federal rules stack the deck in favor of big agribusiness, feedlots, assembly-line slaughterhouses, battery chickens, huge fossil-fuel-fertilized subsidized Gmo corn and soy fields, and that it takes enormous determination nowadays to run sustainable, humane, natural farming enterprises.
His other views I find very objectionable. Example: birth ...more
As I get closer and closer to my goal of living on a farm, I'm trying to understand and read more about it all. I'm only on page 5 (thanks to a preface and an introduction) but with such good reviews from other Goodreaders I'm crossing my fingers this one won't let me down.
-Just finished this book and hmmmmm, it was interesting. Gives me new thinking on the farm life and just proves how the government is basically controlling everything we want to do in order to make a living and li...more
-Just finished this book and hmmmmm, it was interesting. Gives me new thinking on the farm life and just proves how the government is basically controlling everything we want to do in order to make a living and li...more
I enjoyed this book and liked the author's matter-of-factness and down-to-earth sense of humor. It’s a tirade about how our food system laws and regulations favor the industrial giants and tend to run small farmers out of business. All the while offering some very funny stories. It was thought provoking and blood boiling! Salatin has a very libertarian mindset for which I can relate but some might find a bit out there. He shows how a more intimate relationship between the consumer and the produc...more
2/09 - I can't do it anymore.
--
I just felt I should update this book, as it's taking me forever to get through. This is because I find myself only able to read about 30 pages at a time of Joel's ranting and incoherentness. Don't get me wrong, so far he tells some good stories and makes some good points - but damn does he need an editor!
It comes as no surprise to me that me published this book himself as no sane publisher would have let it go out in this form. The ...more
--
I just felt I should update this book, as it's taking me forever to get through. This is because I find myself only able to read about 30 pages at a time of Joel's ranting and incoherentness. Don't get me wrong, so far he tells some good stories and makes some good points - but damn does he need an editor!
It comes as no surprise to me that me published this book himself as no sane publisher would have let it go out in this form. The ...more
Joel Salatin is brilliant and funny, and a great storyteller.
This book is an incredible look at the difficulty of small clean food producers. His thesis is as anti-government as possible. Beurocrats, serving the interests of big agri-business, have made the life of the small farmer almost untenable. It is only through diligence and endless legal and political battling that a small producer can survive and in Joel's case thrive.
He loses direction a little when he strays int...more
This book is an incredible look at the difficulty of small clean food producers. His thesis is as anti-government as possible. Beurocrats, serving the interests of big agri-business, have made the life of the small farmer almost untenable. It is only through diligence and endless legal and political battling that a small producer can survive and in Joel's case thrive.
He loses direction a little when he strays int...more
i am surprised how much i liked this book. i don't know why i never got tired of his rants. maybe because i agreed with 90% of them. but usually books that are written in such a confrontational style end up making me annoyed at the author and finding ways to disagree with every point they make, no matter how much i really agree with it. i guess i was more impressed by the honesty of his style than i was annoyed by self-righteousness or one-sidedness. it didn't even annoy me too much when he...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Joel is a nationally renowned speaker on organic farming and "relationship marketing." He is on a mission to develop emotionally, economically and environmentally enhanced agricultural enterprises, and facilitate their duplication around the world. Part of that goal is to produce the best food in the world.
Joel espouses an agricultural paradigm shift that sees plants and anim...more
More about Joel Salatin...
Joel espouses an agricultural paradigm shift that sees plants and anim...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“When faith in our freedom gives way to fear of our freedom, silencing the minority view becomes the operative protocol.”
—
23 people liked it
“How much evil throughout history could have been avoided had people exercised their moral acuity with convictional courage and said to the powers that be, 'No, I will not. This is wrong, and I don't care if you fire me, shoot me, pass me over for promotion, or call my mother, I will not participate in this unsavory activity.' Wouldn't world history be rewritten if just a few people had actually acted like individual free agents rather than mindless lemmings?”
—
21 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 5 comments



































