51st out of 236 books
—
332 voters
The Unknown Masterpiece
Honoré De Balzac (1799-1850) is generally credited as the inventor of the modern realistic novel. In more than ninety novels, he set forth French society and life as he saw it. He created a cast of over two thousand individual and identifiable characters, some of whom reappear in different novels. He organized his works into his masterpiece, La Comedie Humaine,which was th...more
Paperback, 160 pages
Published
January 26th 2011
by NYRB Classics
(first published 1829)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
542)
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I love Balzac and was ready to love this book---which is actually comprised of two short stores: the Unknown Masterpiece and the almost unreadable Gambara.
The UM is pretty good, but much below the level of the other books and short stories by Balzac I've read. It's interesting in it's discussion of art, reality, perception, etc. Gambara tried to by another story about creativity, aesthetics, etc., but about music and composition---also about madness. It reminded me of the obnoxious cha...more
The UM is pretty good, but much below the level of the other books and short stories by Balzac I've read. It's interesting in it's discussion of art, reality, perception, etc. Gambara tried to by another story about creativity, aesthetics, etc., but about music and composition---also about madness. It reminded me of the obnoxious cha...more
Balzac, Honore de. THE UNKNOWN MASTERPIECE and GAMBARA. (this ed. 2001). ****. The first of these two novellas tells the story of three artists: Porbus, an up-and-coming artist in Paris, Poussin, a young artist on his way to an audience with Porbus, and Frenhofer, an older artist of some fame who is visiting Porbus at the same time. Both Porbus and Poussin are based on real artists of the early 17th century, though Balzac takes some artistic license with their real ages and personalities. ...more
The two stories collected together here ("The Unknown Masterpiece" and "Gambara") share remarkably similar themes and even plot details, to the point that the pairing seems at times more redundant than complimentary. Both stories tell of an artist (a painter in the first story; a composer in the second) struggling with a work that he believes to be a masterpiece but that others hold in considerably lower regard. One can read this two ways: that the artist is a misunderstood g...more
I wanted to read Balzac, and "The Unknown Masterpiece" has a special place of appreciation in art history. Cezanne loved it, Picasso loved it, every Frenchman with a brush and a beret seems to have been cast in its spell.
Balzac captures a lot of what painting is about. It's the story of an artist trying to create work that rivals the creation of life; he's trying to make a painting that has the power of a living thing. But even though this story, along with the one it's pa...more
Balzac captures a lot of what painting is about. It's the story of an artist trying to create work that rivals the creation of life; he's trying to make a painting that has the power of a living thing. But even though this story, along with the one it's pa...more
Short story Balzac wrote in the 1830s about Frenhofer, a (fictional, 17th-century) artist so fanatically obsessed with capturing his model perfectly on the canvas that he winds up producing only an unintelligible chaos of paint — with just a foot barely visible in the corner of the picture. Picasso drew illustrations for the story in the 1920s, and Cézanne reportedly said, with tears in his eyes, “Frenhofer, c’est moi.” In his introduction, Arthur Danto argues, not implausibly, that Frenhofer’s ...more
The shortish title story started with a really entertaining/enlightening crit re: hypermimetic painting, then seemed unclearly smeared before ending interestingly re: the reception of abstract painting in the 17th century, not to mention re: any sort of under- or unrecognized creation. The longer novella that pads the book tells a similiar story, this time about an ecstatic composer, sort of like Cecil Taylor 125 years before ears would open to such music. My first Balzac. Definitely worthwhile ...more
Be sure to read the introduction before starting the book, as it's helpful in understanding the three main characters. The book is a must for anyone interested in portrait painting. There's an interesting section in which an old painter says tp a younger one, "You fill in your outline with flesh tones mixed in advance on your palette, carefully keeping one side darker than the other, and because you glance now and then at a naked woman standing on a table, you think you're copying nature ...more
Op de achterflap van de Nederlandse vertaling, uitgegeven bij de Arbeiderspers, staat o.a. "Dit fameuze boek zouden onze schilders ten minste een keer per jaar moeten herlezen." (Paul Cezanne.)
Je kan het op een avondje uitlezen (amper 40 p) Dus waarom ook niet?
Ondanks dat het geschreven is in 1832, en zich afspeelt in 1612, blijft het hedendaagse kunstenaars (en critici) boeien.
Wat begint als een liefdesverhaal en eindigt als een esthetische beschouwing, is het verha...more
Je kan het op een avondje uitlezen (amper 40 p) Dus waarom ook niet?
Ondanks dat het geschreven is in 1832, en zich afspeelt in 1612, blijft het hedendaagse kunstenaars (en critici) boeien.
Wat begint als een liefdesverhaal en eindigt als een esthetische beschouwing, is het verha...more
I'm not sure how I stumbled on this book. I think it was referenced in another book I was reading and I added it to my WISH LIST on Amazon.com. I finally ordered it and it arrived as a mere pamplet of only 40 pages or so. Of course Honore de Balzac is well-known as a literary genius and this book was known to inspire many gifted artists (Picasso, Cezanne, etc). I did take away some interesting insight as an artist myself. It's worth your reading time if you're creative in any way. This i...more
Picasso painted for twenty years at 7 rue des Grands Augustins in Paris - the very same address of the fictional artist, Frenhofer, in THE UNKNOWN MASTERPIECE. PIcasso revealed GUERNICA to the public 100 years after Balzac published his story. If that's not a recommendation to read it, then I don't know what is...
- The best piece of literature I've read so far in 2011!
- In 37 pages, Balzac so aptly describes the fundamental question of what constitutes as genuis?
- Who decides what is brilliant and what is a farce???
- "The Unknown Masterpiece" is a real thought-provoker!
- In 37 pages, Balzac so aptly describes the fundamental question of what constitutes as genuis?
- Who decides what is brilliant and what is a farce???
- "The Unknown Masterpiece" is a real thought-provoker!
A study of the result of pursuing the "absolute"..... absolute perfection.At times too technical
when writing about th art forms of painting and music....but still delivered the powerful message"We are victims of own superiority"
when writing about th art forms of painting and music....but still delivered the powerful message"We are victims of own superiority"
this book deepened my philosophy about art; the creation of it and the human response to it. it solidified my thoughts of painting as i see and painting as i feel. fabulous.
With this very short story, Balzac invented abstract art way before Kandinsky did. Madness and art, 2 of my favorite subjects together in a single book.
Kristin
is currently reading it
OK, I am an honest to goodness Balzac freak, I've read them all, but not these two little tales...more when I finish.
Monsieur de Balzac really has an excellent grasp of the inner battles of artists in both fields covered here, painting and musical composition.
Almost a precognitive criticism of the coming modern area in visual art.
Jacob
added it
And after this, watch La Belle Noiseuse.
I've never read Balzac before--my interested was piqued by James Wood's adoration of the novelist. This book is actually composed of two longish stories, both concerning art and the ways it can break an artist. ...They're both so-so. I'd like to read a full Balzac novel to get a better sense of the writer. And also a full-lenth biography, as apparently the man lived an extraordinary life. (Favored apocrypha include his death from a caffeine overdose and his pronouncement of wanting to become the...more
A must read for every art historian
Finished at 3 AM
see Stone Arabia
Balzac is such a bore.
"The unknown masterpiece" is a fantastic story that made me think about the whole "authenticity or illusion" dialogue. It seems to have influenced so many other atrtists as well.
Muy buen relato del hecho de pintar, muy actual.
These are two really great short stories. In the first, four characters are drawn together by their passion for art. One of them - the inspired genius (or the humiliated failure) is the center of the work and has served as inspiration for artists as varied as Cezanne, Henry James, and Picasso. It is a bit of a philisophical look on modern art. Gambara is simply tragic. How crazy must a artist be, anyway?
Katelyn
added it
An interesting story, but what Balzac really has going for him here is an 1830s art-historical take on figure painting that presupposes the move from the classicism of Titian (et. al.) to Manet in the 1860s, and perhaps even De Koonig in the 20th century. Not only does Balzac secure a position as an art critic through this tale, but sets the stage for later, longer works (specifically Zola) in the same vein.
Two short stories/novellas make up this book. The first, the title story is the shorter one, and I probably would have given the book three stars if it had ended there. The second Gambara made a big difference. The two stories combine into a much more interesting commentary on the nature of art, and being an artist. Gambara also struck me as a better, more developed, story.
The four star rating is entirely for The Unknown Masterpiece, which was a wonderfully crafted short story and is rightfully considered a classic. However I found the second story, Gambara, to be fairly tedious reading and I must confess I did not finish it.
i've not read much of Balzac before, but i might again because this was a good tale well told. (doesn't Camus tell a story that's very similar?)
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Honoré de Balzac was a nineteenth-century French novelist and playwright. His magnum opus was a sequence of almost 100 novels and plays collectively entitled La Comédie humaine, which presents a panorama of French life in the years after the fall of Napoléon Bonaparte in 1815.
Due to his keen observation of detail and unfiltered representation of society, Balzac is regarded as one of th...more
More about Honoré de Balzac...
Due to his keen observation of detail and unfiltered representation of society, Balzac is regarded as one of th...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Young man,' Porbus said, seeing Poussin stare open-mouthed at a picture, 'Don't look at the canvas too long, it will drive you to despair.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...


















































