Forbidden Falls (Virgin River, #9)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Forbidden Falls (Virgin River #9)

4.2 of 5 stars 4.20  ·  rating details  ·  4,955 ratings  ·  278 reviews
Virgin River is abuzz with the news that a stranger bought the town's abandoned church on eBay. The buyer, a young widowed reverend, is a little like the building itself: in need of some loving care.

Noah Kincaid arrives ready to roll up his sleeves and revitalize his new purchase, but he's going to need some help. An ad in the local paper brings an improbable candidate his...more
Kindle Edition, 379 pages
Published December 29th 2009 by Mira (first published December 15th 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Auntee
Dec 28, 2009 Auntee rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Fans of the series; those who enjoy a hot contemporary
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
♡Karlyn P♡
One of the best in the series yet. And surprisingly, this one could be read as a stand-alone as there were no story arc's playing out in this book. Best yet, we get plenty of time with Noah and Ellie. I think they got 80% of the book. I also have to give this book credit for one of my favorite marriage proposals. Lets just say funny and touching!

Forbidden Falls is a wonderful romantic story of a young single paster in a new town who finds love with a woman from the other side of the tracks (so...more
Shawna
5 stars – Contemporary Romance

Sitting down with a Virgin River novel is like eating your mom’s or grandma’s home cooking.....just pure comfort food for the soul!

I’m a huge fan of this series, but I’ll be honest and admit that I wasn’t too keen on a story with a minister for a romantic hero. I was worried that Carr might lean too heavily on the religious element...ala Catherine Anderson, which isn’t really my preference when reading romance books. Well, I’m happy to say that Carr blew me away yet...more
Kathrynn
Fantastic! Wasn't sure how the author was going to mix a widowed pastor and an exotic dancer--with two kids--with this series, but she did it. In typical Virgin River style, previous characters popped in and out or were mentioned and briefly updated. Even the puppies from the anthology "That Holiday Feeling" that included Virgin River, #8, "Under the Christmas Tree" had a nice--surprising--update. :-)

Forbidden Falls starts about 7 months after the previous story, in July and only lasts to Octobe...more
Isis FG
Rating: 4.5 / 5

I liked this book a lot, but I'm not quite sure I 5-star-LOVED IT, LOVED IT, LOVED IT like a few of my GR friends. It was definitely an enjoyable book, though, and a great addition to the Virgin River series.

SERIES NOTE:
This book is the 9th story in the Virgin River series. This book could *probably* be read as a standalone without much trouble. The storyline is fairly independent in and of itself and what continuing storylines there are make sense without having read past books....more
Sherri needs a twin
*** spoiler alert ***


After having read the last three books in the Virgin River series and being highly disappointed (well Rick's book wasn't a total loss but still not up to par), I was ready and prepared to feel the same about this 1st book in the 3rd trilogy about Virgin River. I was actually pleasantly surprised and read it in one day.

This book could realistically be a standalone or read if you skipped the 2nd trilogy altogether, although a portion of the story would make alot more sense if...more
Ally72
My goodreads friends wrote very eloquent reviews of this book so I will just write a few thoughts I had about "Forbidden Falls." I wasn't sure I would like this storyline, but I should have known Robyn Carr would not disappoint me. I had to remind myself that these are just characters in a book and not real people! I loved Noah and Ellie and they have now tied for first place with my other favorite characters of Preacher and Paige (I love Mel and Jack too so I guess this will be a three way tie)...more
Pamela(AllHoney)
The ninth book in Robyn Carr's Virgin River series. It's been a while since I've visited Virgin River and it was a nice to return finally. Noah Kincaid has come to Virgin River to start a church. He bought the old abandoned church and is fixing it up. But he needs help and he decides to find an assistant. She comes in the form of exotic dancer, Ellie Baldwin. A tough beautiful woman who isn't afraid to get her hands dirty. Ellie needs a respectable job so she can regain custody of her children....more
Beanbag Love
Once again Robyn Carr makes me cry. And laugh. It's good.

A widowed pastor and a former stripper restore the old, abandoned church in Virgin River. There's more to it than that, of course, with child custody and self-esteem issues but it has a very sweet romance.

This one was kind of a change-up coming off of Paradise Valley (was that the last one?) which focused pretty strongly on three different romances. This entire story focused mostly on Noah and Ellie. We had a side story about Vanni and P...more
Dee
Two-haiku review:

New pastor needs help
Former stripper heart of gold
Wants to get kids back

Not as well written
Pastor screws his assistant
Many levels wrong

Originally read Nov. 2012
Re-read Dec. 2013
Julie (Mom2lnb)
Mar 06, 2013 Julie (Mom2lnb) rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Fans of Feel-Good, Small-Town Romance
Reviewed for THC Reviews
"4.5 stars" As always, it was a pleasure to be back in Virgin River, visiting with all my favorite characters in my favorite little town. Since Robyn Carr wrapped up most of the loose ends in the last book, Forbidden Falls was almost like starting over. All the main characters from past books were here in the background, but she brought some new characters to town and beefed up the roles of a couple of existing characters, while leaving more focus on the main hero and her...more
Edna Lyn
What a great book to start off the new year! It was nice that majority of the novel was focused on Noah and Ellie's lives. Book 4, I believe was the last time this happened. Most would call Noah and Ellie an odd couple just from hearing their occupations but they fit together perfectly. A great pace with their relationship as well. From the work relationship to genuine friends to something more. There was also a light banter going on between them throughout the book, a quote from Ellie to best d...more
Samantha
Forbidden Falls introduces Noah and Ellie. Noah is a preacher who buys an abandoned church on Ebay. Ready to start his ministries he heads to Virgin River and against his better judgement he hires Ellie, a single mother who is in desperate need of a job. An unlikely romance develops and there is alot of drama.

What a great read. Two people who are total opposites have so much in common. I loved the way the author showed how the characters dealt with Ellie's situation. My heart went out to her. Sh...more
Brandy *Ahviel*
I love ELLIE.... she is such a fun loving character that you can't help but to feel uplifted by her. I love the fact that she just states what is really going on. There is no middle ground. She is who she is and will say what she thinks, feels and so on. It was so refreshing. And Noah...
oh can I swoon now... I love him as a man because him being a man first then finding that he wanted to help people by being a preacher I think made him that much more. He knew because he probably experienced som...more
Arlena
Title: Forbidden Falls
Author: Robyn Carr
Publisher: Mira Books
Series: Virgin River #9
Reviewed By: Arlena Dean
Rating: 5
Review:

"Forbidden Falls" by Robyn Carr was another good read of this author's 'Virgin River Series.' This series was of Noah and Ellie. This was a wonderful romantic story of a pastor from a new town who finds love on 'from the other side of the tracks.' There will also be a secondary story involving a past hero/heroine who will have a 'heart tugging change of events that will be...more
Laura
This is the 9th installment in the Virgin River series. I've read all of them and been a little disappointed in the last few (minus the Christmas stories) because they seemed to get too dark and tried to include too many stories in one book. I was actually a bit concerned about reading this one because it involves a minister and I know that all the VR books involve sex. I was concerned about how this would play out and I feel that it is the only real downfall of the book for me.

Noah Kincaid is...more
Quinn
4.5 stars

Forbidden Falls is one of my favourite stories in the Virgin River series so far. It was like coming home, an old friend, chicken soup and warm, fluffy socks in winter all rolled into one. When she's good, that's what Carr's writing brings me, and why I keep coming back for more.

That's not to say that this was in any way a boring, comfortable read - it wasn't. This book was surprising and challenging, fun and sexy. If you have any doubts that a pastor can make a sexy, compelling hero, t...more
BJ Rose
What a great couple - I loved both Ellie and Noah all the way through! Ellie is absolutely amazing - she has all sorts of reasons to complain about her rotten life and to expect others to give her a break, for heaven's sake, but she just keeps on working and coping and caring for her two kids. And Noah needed so badly to be a minister with his own congregation that he used his inheritance to buy, repair and refurbish the old church in Virgin River. How these two discovered friendship and love al...more
Michelle
Another awesome book! I just loved this story about Ellie and Virgin River Pastor, Nick Kincaid. Ellie was such a lovable person, with the most positive attitude, who had real bad luck when it came to men. Her kids were the most important thing to her and with the help of Nick and her new friends of Virgin River she was able to get her kids back from her ex-husband and learn the truth of his identity.

Vanni and Paul were faced with a huge challenge of their own. As soon as they decided to finall...more
Regina
This is one of my favorite in the series. The new characters are good additions to the Virgin River world and there is a decent inclusion of past favorites - -Mel, Jack, Preacher, Brie, Paul, Vannessa .... It is a sweet romance and a sweet life make-over story. There is a heartwrenching storyline about the loss of custody by a mother of her children but Carr presents it emotionally realistically.

There is a very believable and genuine storyline about the stress and hard work of motherhood. Carr...more
Brenda (b)
First of all, I want to say that I loved this book. Noah and Ellie were a terrific couple and I enjoyed learning about them and watching them find each other as they worked through the problems with Ellie's ex. However, the one thing that kept running through my mind as I read the book was the sense that the author had changed her story-telling style. What I've truly loved about the Virgin River series, and the Grace Valley books too for that matter, was the feeling I got of being part of the co...more
Rossy
Fantastic story. Great set of characters and what a joy to see some old ones again. This book has made it into my favorites and a bit surprised by it. Normally i can't relate with characters so involved in religion. Thankfully, Carr wrote religion scenes that were necessary due to the heroe's vocation that were fundamental to the story without overdoing it. I can't wait for the next book!
Season
I really enjoy this series. It has been a while since I read one of them, but as soon as I started this one, I was back to this lovely little town and all these really nice people that we have met previously. I thought Noah & Ellie were great characters and loved that Paul & Vanni were big parts in this book. Cannot wait to read the next book.
Kath
This is actually Virgin River #8, not #9 as described. A little shorter than the rest, but I love the storyline between Noah and Ellie and the who ex-husband. Who would have thought that a minister and a stripper would be together, but it actually worked. There was more to Ellie than met the eye.

We didn't see as much from the other characters, other than mostly their interaction with Ellie and Noah, but there was an additional storyline with Vanni and Paul. Vanni happens to be my least favorite...more
Jacqueline
Jan 12, 2010 Jacqueline rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: romance readers who don't like racy books
I was happy to find that this book concentrated on the two major characters. I was uncertain whether to even try this book since the last one tried to cram in too many characters and story lines so that none were done justice. This one was much more focused. We did get to see some of the old characters where their stories were pertinent to the main characters here. I do like when new characters interact with previous characters but only if it directly affects the main characters. Once I've read...more
Kristiana S
Sebentaar, coba aku cerita lagi soal buku ini, ya..

Hmm, cerita inti di buku ini adalah tentang Noah dan Eli. Noah adalah seorang pendeta Presbiterian yg membeli sebuah gereja tua di Virgin River. Dan Eli adalah ibu muda dengan 2 anak yang berusaha mendapatkan pekerjaan yg baik untuk merebut kembali hak asuh atas anak-anaknya dari mantan suaminya, yang adalah ayah tiri dari anak-anak Eli. Jadi bukan ayah kandung, ya. Dan si Eli cuma nikah selama 3 bulan sama suaminya yang jahat ini.

Nah, Noah yang...more
Kaye
The opening is most intriguing: Noah Kincaide, a widowed Reverend is patiently waiting for a church but the presbytery just hasn't come up with anything. When Noah sees an abandoned church for sale on E-Bay of all places, he contacts the real estate agent to take a look at the church. After convincing the presbytery that he has inherited enough money to do all the renovations,they approve the purchase and he is on his way to starting a new life in the little town of Virgin River.

When Ellie Baldw...more
MountainKat
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Like the others in the series, it was sweet with likable characters. I was a little concerned how I was going to like a book with a minister as the hero, but the author managed to make it work for me. I have no issues with faith, but I don't like being preached to in my books.

I particularly liked the heroine, Ellie. She had had a hard life, but never blamed anyone for it. She always found a positive in every situation. Except for losing her children, that was the...more
Carrie
I had to put Forbidden Falls down yesterday after getting about 160 pages into it by gritting my teeth (I then skimmed the rest). I've enjoyed the previous Virgin River books, except maybe not so much Second Chance Pass. But even that book didn't make me mad! Forbidden Falls is...YUCK! Tired, overused plot with huge holes in it, characters who don't make sense, married couples who keep big secrets or make major life-changing decisions without consulting spouse, women who are supposedly super int...more
Darcy
I so very much love this series, and with each one I read it seems like it is my new favorite, but this one will rank high in the list due to the main character, Ellie. She is so feisty and sassy, but it is only when you hear her past that you really admire her and her ability to stay positive in spite of growing up in the school of hard knocks. The way she slings out sayings by her grandma, helping those around her without even meaning to is something we should all aspire to. Noah is perfect fo...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • That Holiday Feeling (Includes: Virgin River, #8)
  • Welcome To Serenity  (The Sweet Magnolias #4)
  • The Summer Hideaway (Lakeshore Chronicles, #7)
  • More Than Words, Volume 6 (Includes: Virgin River, #11.1)
  • Finding Perfect (Fool's Gold, #3)
  • Austin (McKettricks of Texas, #3)(McKettricks, #13)
  • Bright Eyes (Kendrick/Coulter/Harrigan, #5)
  • Heartache Falls (Eternity Springs, #3)
  • Sugar Creek (Destiny, #2)
107767
A RITA award-winning author of 25 novels, Robyn Carr has found a whole new following with her stories about the independent women and former marines of Virgin River."

RT's Career Achievement Best Author Award winner (2010) for Contemporary Romance.
More about Robyn Carr...
Virgin River (Virgin River, #1) Shelter Mountain (Virgin River, #2) Whispering Rock (Virgin River, #3) Temptation Ridge (Virgin River, #6) A Virgin River Christmas (Virgin River, #4)

Share This Book

“Shelby handed off her bouquet and faced Luke, taking both his hands in hers. And she
began: “Luke, I love you. I promise that each day I have you in my life, I will show you my love.”
Noah's eyes drifted to Ellie's and a smile played about his lips as the bride and groom
spoke.
“Shelby, I love you. In each day of our lives together, I will show my love. And where
there is injury, I will pardon without hesitation.”
“Where there is doubt, Luke, I will have faith in you.”
“In times of despair, you will be my hope.”
“In times of darkness, I will find my light in you.”
“When there is sadness, let me bring you joy.”
“Luke, I will not so much seek to be consoled as to console.”
“I will seek to understand, not just to be understood.”
“I will love, not just crave love.”
“I pledge you my heart, my life.”
“And I pledge mine to you.”
“I, Luke Riordan, take you, Shelby MacIntyre, to be wife, my best friend, my lover, my partner, the head of my family and other half of my heart. Forever.” He slid a ring on her finger.
Shelby slid a ring onto his finger. “I, Shelby MacIntyre, take you, Luke Riordan, to be my
husband, best friend, lover, partner, head of my family and other half of my heart. Forever.”
24 likes
“Don't make love to your problems-- they'll never give you back the satisfaction you give them.” 18 likes
More quotes…