Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Good Daughters” as Want to Read:
The Good Daughters
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Good Daughters

3.54  ·  Rating Details ·  7,696 Ratings  ·  1,170 Reviews

They were born on the same day, in the same small New Hampshire hospital—but Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson are different in nearly every way.

Ruth is an artist, a romantic with a rich, passionate, imaginative life—the fifth daughter born to a gentle, caring farmer and his stolid wife. Raised by a pair of capricious drifters, Dana is a scientist and realist whose faith i

Hardcover, 288 pages
Published August 24th 2010 by William Morrow (first published August 9th 2010)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Good Daughters, please sign up.

Recent Questions

This question contains spoilers… (view spoiler)

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Dec 29, 2010 Allison rated it did not like it
SPOILER ALERT. If you haven't read the book and you don't want spoiler, don't read this.

The more I thought about, the more I knew I had to change this to a one-star rating. Don't even bother with this book. Here's what really ticks me off about the book -- after getting 3/4 of the way through it, I find out the entire story is based on a stupid, flimsy premise. I figured out pretty early on that the two "birthday sisters" (which is what the one mother called them since they were born on the same
Aug 02, 2010 TK rated it it was amazing
I read this review in one big gulp over a long summer weekend this year. it's one of the best novels I have read in a good long while, and I recommend it to just about everyone except perhaps those among you who have hearts of stone, no sense of humor or are unduly boring and conservative in your values.

Maynard is a talented writer, and this novel is crafty and evocative. I appreciated the multiple meanings of the title, and that the earthy and everyday metaphors and similies Maynard uses, in pl
Deb (Readerbuzz) Nance
Look at the title. Look at the cover. Look at the author.

Be honest with yourself. You knew what you were getting when you decided to read this book.

Emotional conflict. Drama. Woman's point of view. Right?

If that's what you sought, you will rate this book high.

If you were expecting Tom Clancy, you aren't going to make it past chapter one. (Hint: Next time look for a submarine or a big gun on the front cover.)

But is it literary? I can hear you on the back row ask.

Oh dear. I'd rather you read th
Jun 29, 2010 Laura rated it really liked it
Usually I get annoyed when there's a plot twist that I can see coming a mile away (example? SPOILER ALERT: Darth Vader is Luke's father. oh, and Leia's his sister). For some reason, even though I figured out what the plot twist was in this book, it didn't bother me.

There are three daughters here: Ruth Plank, fifth daughter of Edwin and Connie; Dana Dickinson, daughter of Val and George; and a new strawberry hybrid (I'm not kidding). Ruth and Dana are "birthday sisters", born nine months after a
Michele Harrod
Feb 08, 2012 Michele Harrod rated it it was amazing
It is a long time since I read a book and had to go and find space alone, so I could allow the tears to freely pour down my face and drip onto my chest, as I experienced moments of intense love and loss - with characters that I had come to care for immensely, despite their frailties and failings. Most extraordinary, was knowing within 3 chapters exactly where the book was going, and being utterly astounded that the characters took 50 odd years to figure it all out? Yet, I loved them anyway. And ...more
Sep 09, 2010 Barbara rated it liked it

The rhythms of Nature and the seasons courses with natural cadence through this bittersweet novel by Joyce Maynard. It is the tale of two very dissimilar families. One is a farming family, existing in the routine of life created by their environment and the requirements of their work. The other is smaller, less organized, less traditional group, who lead a more erratic life, living from hand-to-mouth.

She has deftly described the life of two daughters of these families. The emotional experience
May 05, 2012 Bookreaderljh rated it it was amazing
I absolutely loved this book which is a little odd as at points it was a real downer and the topics it covered were less than upbeat. But the story of these two good daughters - growing up in the "wrong" family and yet in the end finding their own way. It starts slow as the two characters are children but it builds the foundation for all that is yet to come. And so it comes. So many of these stories could have made a whole book just to themselves but I never felt any story line was rushed (excep ...more
Apr 27, 2011 Elyse rated it liked it
I liked it!!! I like Joyce Maynard!
Maynard's premise in this book is an interesting one. Unfortunately, her efforts to be coy about that premise result only in heavy-handed foreshadowing that really leaves very little to the reader's imagination. Given how much she gives away, it seems that what was really important was not what the big secret was, but how the characters would react once they found out. That being the case, I wonder why Maynard chose to frustrate the reader by giving away almost the whole thing through less-than- ...more
Jun 30, 2010 Jackie rated it really liked it
I'll say flat out that I enjoyed this book more than "Labor Day", a book I liked quite a bit. It was easier for me to relate to the two main characters--maybe because they were women, maybe because they were farmers at points in their lives, maybe because they were searching for a place to belong and someone to be cherished by who would love them for
themselves. I definitely became attached to them and enjoyed watching their lives unfold (though they both face difficult times that moved me greatl
Ann Douglas
May 19, 2012 Ann Douglas rated it it was amazing
Warning: This novel is not suitable for reading in public, unless, of course, you don't mind having people stare at you, wondering why it is that a book has brought you to tears.

I was fortunate in that I lucked out and was able to read about three-quarters of this novel on a quiet Saturday when no one else was around. I was able to cry when I needed to -- which was often -- and I'm not the kind of person who cries easily while reading books. (Movies? That's an entirely different story.)

This is a
Katz Nancy from NJ
Jun 06, 2011 Katz Nancy from NJ rated it really liked it
I enjoyed this book although the premise of one family visiting another no matter how far they were wore thin. Still the chartacters were well described and I did enjoy most of them. For the most part I find Joyce Maynard's books poignant and well written. I especially loved The Usual Rules.
Sep 10, 2010 Jennifer rated it really liked it
From my book review blog Rundpinne.

"Heart breaking, beautiful, and life affirming, The Good Daughters by Joyce Maynard tells the story of Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson, known as the birthday sisters. On July 4, 1950 at the peak of strawberry season in Bellersville Hospital, Edwin and Connie Plank welcomed their 5th daughter into the world and two hours later, the Dickersons were greeting their second child and their first daughter. Maynard writes a beautiful, moving novel, and from the beginni
May 19, 2014 Elvan rated it liked it
An enjoyable story overall. Written from the POV of two women born on the same day in rural New Hampshire (birthday sisters) this is a saga of two families whose lives spin together and spin apart over a fifty year timespan.

We follow the lives of Ruth and Dana. Ruth, the fifth daughter and favourite of her fathers grows up feeling apart from her siblings and a cold and distant mother. She is infatuated with Dana's brother Ray. Her family live on a fruit and vegetable farm passed down through ge
Alice Meloy
Aug 12, 2012 Alice Meloy rated it did not like it
In alternating chapters, Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson tell their own stories about growing up in the 50s, 60s and 70s. Though they had little interest in each other, their families were connected in ways that it took them much longer to figure out than it takes the reader of this lackluster novel. The premise makes a worthwhile plot, up to a point, but because you know where it's going, you may find yourself skimming through the last half of the book, looking for the point when the family secre ...more
Michelle Catherine
Nov 26, 2010 Michelle Catherine rated it did not like it
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Roxenne Smith
Jun 28, 2016 Roxenne Smith rated it really liked it
Even though I agree with the one reviewer who thinks the plot is like a bad soap opera, I have to admit that sometimes I need that kind of story. The writing is magnificent, the plot is engaging, and the characters are people I really like. And not beside the point, I've found that real life is often very much like a bad soap opera. So what's the problem?

After years of dismissing Joyce Maynard as a fraud for having made me believe (through her "Domestic Affairs" column) that she had a blissful f
Bess Conner
Feb 25, 2016 Bess Conner rated it liked it
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jul 01, 2010 Diane rated it it was amazing
Shelves: a-favorite-read
The Good Daughters, by Joyce Maynard is a simple story on the surface. It is the story of two families, the Planks and the Dickersons. On July 4, 1950, baby girls were born to each family in a rural New Hampshire hospital. For the Planks, baby Ruth was a fifth daughter. For the Dickersons. baby Dana was an only daughter, with a little boy, Ray at home. The two families could not have been more different. The Planks, Edwin and Connie, were a hard working farming family with roots on the land and ...more
Hurricane season in New Hampshire brings about an unexpected aftermath in the year 1949. Nine months later, on July 4, 1950, two girls are born to two very different families living in this little community. The families feel a connection because of this event, although the two are very different and seemingly have nothing in common—except, of course, for the two "birthday sisters." The girls are Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson.

The Planks are a farming family. Edwin and Connie already have four da
Jul 09, 2011 Dawn rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: audiobooks
Based on the reviews I've seen, on this site and others, I am clearly in the minority in my opinion of this book. I'm not sure what others have seen that I'm missing, but I really just didn't like it. The story is told in alternating chapters from the point of view Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson, as they each tell their respective life story. Ruth and Dana are 'birthday sisters', having been born on the same day in the same hospital in rural New Hampshire. I found Dana to be a little more likable ...more
Jan 22, 2011 RNOCEAN rated it it was amazing
"Two families, the Planks and the Dickersons, are mysteriously entwined in this exquisite novel that centers on decades of life at a New Hampshire farm. Youngest daughters Ruth Plank and Dana Dickerson, born on the same day in the same hospital, take turns narrating the struggles they face as children. Ruth feels a coldness from her mother; Dana is unsettled by her kooky parents constantly uprooting her and her brother Ray. Regardless, the Planks pay a yearly visit to the Dickersons no matter wh ...more
Sep 07, 2011 Laura rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
There is a major twist in The Good Daughters that I had figured out very early in the novel. Although I knew the destination, I still greatly enjoyed the journey getting there. I thought the prose was beautiful and almost lyrical at times. I most of all relished seeing the journey of the two girls throughout their life from birth until approximately age sixty. I loved the story time frame with Ruth and Dana being born in 1950. Their experiences growing up were buffeted at times by historical eve ...more
Jo Anne B
Mar 19, 2012 Jo Anne B rated it it was ok
This was such a predictable story from the get go. It was painful how obvious it was. I actually kept thinking that I had already read this because of its predictability. Two girls born on the same day referred to as Birthday Sisters forced to be a part of each other's lives based on this fact. But of course there was more to it. Can you guess?

I enjoyed  reading about the farming techniques in this book. These were actually the best parts or the book. Meanwhile, this seemed like a coming of age
Nov 10, 2010 Kdevoli rated it it was amazing
Ah, how I love Joyce Maynard. This was such a great story - about two babies born on the same day in a small town in New Hampshire - so called "birthday sisters' - and their lives from birth through about age 60. the chapters alternate the stories of the two girls. Usually in this type of book, the two girls would at least at some point in their young lives be close friends - but Maynard often puts a twist on her stories, and these girls never really cotton to each other. They are very different ...more
Aug 08, 2011 Rachel rated it it was ok
One thing this book isn't, is subtle. Within a few chapters, I figured out the big twist and figured the author did this on purpose, because she wanted the reader to understand why the choices were made. Nope. Further, she creates one character to be the champion of the good guy and turns out, even he is an ass.

Also, I just didn't get the sense that the author was that comfortable with her characters. I know writers talk a lot about, characters speaking to them and choosing their directions. Tha
Mar 26, 2012 Rick rated it really liked it
I've liked Joyce Maynard's writing ever since about 1972 when she (and I) were 18 and she had just written a short little book called Looking Back. That book was a memoir for people our age about growing up in what was probably the last good time to be a kid: 1960's and early 70's. Great book and still one of my favorites today.

The Good Daughters is a work of fiction set mostly in Hew Hampshire that spans from 1949 until the present time. The book tells the story of two families with not much a
Kasa Cotugno
Jul 21, 2010 Kasa Cotugno rated it really liked it
Shelves: arc
Joyce Maynard has a way with a story. Although the "secret" at the core of this luminescent novel is apparent from reading the liner notes, the how of that secret is not revealed until the end. Two girls are born in a rural hospital on July 4, 1950, a good date because it makes tracking their progress through the decades easy to calibrate. Ruth's farmer family has been rooted to the land for generations whereas Dana's is virtually nomadic, her self-absorbed parents moving her and her charismatic ...more
Poorna Rajaraman
Dec 10, 2012 Poorna Rajaraman rated it really liked it
If you have read my earlier reviews, you know that I love to read anything that involves a farmhouse :-). This book is around a farmhouse! So, it really inspires me, and it was very good book. I liked both the daughters and especially how the author talks about being lesbian and the issues that arise due to it. I am not sure if it was descriptive of all the problems a lesbian couple can have in those years..

Long back, when I attended some communication related training by an American lady, she w
Ruth Ferguson
Jun 11, 2012 Ruth Ferguson rated it really liked it
Undoubtly the best best book I read this year so far. It is the kind of book you want to savor, heartbreaking with enough of a ring of truth that you adds to your own uncomfort when you think about your own choices.

Two women born on the same day - seemingly the only thing they have in common - find their lives intersect throughout their lifetime. However, they are not particularly close. How can they be when each's mother always seems to be comparing their daughter to the other girl. When they t
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
How did this get published? 3 66 Apr 08, 2012 03:47PM  
  • Amigoland
  • Robin and Ruby
  • Stiltsville
  • Spitting Off Tall Buildings
  • The Great Lover
  • In the Shadow of the Cypress
  • The Nobodies Album
  • The Cheating Curve
  • The Gendarme
  • Terminal (Tweed & Co. #2)
  • Without Prejudice
  • Red Hook Road
  • The Life You've Imagined
  • Letter to My Daughter
  • To Catch a Cheat
  • Written in Time
  • The Winters in Bloom
  • The Hijack (Stratton, #2)
Joyce Maynard first came to national attention with the publication of her New York Times cover story “An Eighteen-Year-Old Looks Back on Life” in 1973, when she was a freshman at Yale. Since then, she has been a reporter and columnist for The New York Times, a syndicated newspaper columnist whose “Domestic Affairs” column appeared in more than fifty papers nationwide, a regular contributor to NPR ...more
More about Joyce Maynard...

Share This Book

“There is something about the act of studying an unclothed body, as an artist does, that allows a person to appreciate it as pure form, regardless of the kinds of traits traditionally regarded as imperfections. In a figure drawing class, an obese woman's folds of flesh take on a kind of beauty. You can look at a man's shrunken chest or legs or buttocks with tenderness. Age is not ugly, just poignant.” 5 likes
More quotes…