Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Definitely Maybe” as Want to Read:
Definitely Maybe
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Definitely Maybe

3.99 of 5 stars 3.99  ·  rating details  ·  749 ratings  ·  68 reviews
Someone or something threatens the lives of leading scientists who are on the verge of major breakthroughs a bizarre and terrifying tale of the supernatural - or is it?
[Taken from the back cover]
Hardcover, 143 pages
Published 1978 by MacMillan Publishing Co. (first published 1974)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Definitely Maybe, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Definitely Maybe

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,514)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Zack Zildjan
Man vs Man? Man vs Nature? Man vs the Universe? Man vs Aliens?...I suppose it doesn't matter.

A mysterious book about a series of mysterious happenings intent on stifling all forms of progress and knowledge. Clearly a very personal work of art, having had to deal with the oppressive Soviet censors for most of their career, it's no wonder this book seems so chillingly real, in spite of it's more fantastical (sometimes hilariously so) elements.

While limitations can have a cripplingly negative effec
Easy to read, hard to follow.
While I really enjoyed the book, I confess that I spent most of the time wondering whether I truly understood what was happening, and whether or not any of it was real.
An astrophysicist trying to finish work on his theory is repeatedly thwarted by: unexplained alcohol, a random woman in a short skirt, strange men, and the potential visitation of (for want of a better word) aliens.

"I can't say that I didn't understand his theory, but I can't say that I fully grasped i
Ekaterina Kiseki
One of my favorite books. I have no idea why but best memories of my life are connected with abnormal heat, that's one of the reasons I loved the atmosphere of the book. The technique the authors used here makes a book captivating. Messy diary pages describing messy lives of the characters.
I can draw a parallel between the idea of the story and things that are happening in the world right now. Several decades ago people eagerly wanted to explore outer space with the help of new technologies, now
World Literature Today
"Definitely Maybe offers a serious probe of ethical issues related to the responsibilities of scholars. But what makes it irresistibly engrossing are the richness of the characters, the weirdness and politically metaphorical resonance of their predicament, and the complexity of the philosophical issues each must ultimately confront." - Michael A. Morrison, University of Oklahoma

This book was reviewed in the September 2014 issue of World Literature Today. Read the full review by visiting our webs
Charles Dee Mitchell
This novel was written in the 1970's and the setting appears to be contemporary to that period. Leningrad is recording the hottest weather on record for the past two hundred years. In his sweltering apartment, the astrophysicist Dmitri Malianov is doing important work, Nobel Prize important work. He has sent his wife and the bobchik to the coast for some privacy. Privacy will allude him.

A bag of gorceries, filled with unimaginable delicacies, arrives. A lovely young woman, a friend of Malianov;s
Gerhardt Himmelmann
Definitely Maybe is short, but very dense: not an easy read at all. This is a piece of fiction in which idea is central: not character, or story. It tells the story of four Soviet scientists, each working in separate disciplines, who are being distracted from their work by a series of bizarre events. They quickly decide that the distractions are quite deliberate: an attempt to keep them from their work.

Probably the most divisive thing about this book is (view spoiler)
I rarely read something and think to myself "I need to read everything they've ever written" but that's how I felt after reading Definitely Maybe by the Strugatskys.

The book is a funny and often frightening look at the powers of distraction and the lengths some will go to stop progress. The narrative moves at a very quick place and drops off at integral points only to pick up a bit later leaving the reader almost disoriented. It's as if you become a part of the chaos of the plot. I don't want t
weirdly, although this is science fiction, i did not pick it up in conjunction with my recent simultaneous meditations on formative science fiction and my duty to read it. which is actually not so weird, because it's a completely different animal from the classic american formative sci-fi that i've been thinking about. the strugatsky brothers get that what's creepiest is what's not just completely unknown but beyond your comprehension. i haven't read enough sci-fi to figure out if bradbury & ...more
This was definitely maybe okay. A minimalistic, Russian sort of book, which never leaves a multi-storey apartment house. The characters struck me as interesting and convincing. Lots of alcoholic indulgences, followed by hot tea and candy. Strange things happen, which are in some cases barely described.

The narrative fades in and out. It's supposedly a discontinuous manuscript. From where or by whom is unclear. The main character is faced with a dilemma: should he choose his family over his work
Doug Cummings
Fantastic chamber drama that's both frightening and funny; make sure you get the new 2014 English translation by Antonina Bouis.
Dmitri Malianov, a physicist on the verge of completing a brilliant new theorem (he may win a Nobel!), is interrupted by a knock on the door. It's a deliveryman from the deli with a case of vodka that's been paid for in advance by his wife. A few minutes later, another knock. It's a gorgeous young woman in a mini skirt bearing a letter from Malianov's wife, asking him to let her stay for a few days. An old friend (also a scientist) calls him in agitation, asking if anything unusual has happened ...more
Stanley Trice
Written in the mid 1970s, Definitely Maybe is an example of how Russian writers had to use subtle writing and their wit to defend their work against censorship by the Soviet Union government. In many ways, this subtle writing also strengthened the work by these Russian authors and brothers Arkady and Boris Strugatsky.

The authors hid their social criticism of the Soviet Union inside absurd situations, a freewheeling style of writing, and a plot with many twists and turns. The brothers wrote in a
Mike McDevitt
If you're finding the weather too hot, the wine too tempting, strangers offering themselves sexually, or trees appearing and disappearing- fear not! It's just the indifferent but powerful cosmos trying to stop you from thinking too hard. It will do this by any means necessary, so have a gun handy to off yourself if being a smarty-smart-pants becomes TOO unbearable.

It's not paranoia if the universe is really trying to kill you.
‘Definitely Maybe’ is another in a long line of ‘everyone is in on the joke but the protagonist’. It has the beginnings of a good story but lacks one element, why should I care about the characters? It is brief, the mystery interesting, and the reader is left at the end with several possible outcomes. The problem stems from the fact that there are multiple clueless protagonists and none of them are particularly heartwarming. A good example of what Definitely Maybe could have been was written by ...more
Something is keeping leading scientists from getting any work done, threatening the future of scientific progress.

Is it a meddling alien civilization, intent on keeping the human race from ascendancy?

Is it an unyielding law of conservation, preserving order in an uncaring universe?

Is it an Era of Stagnation in a poorly-planned socialist economy?

This is an enjoyable little book, intent more on the human reaction to the ongoing interference than on its actual cause. One can even glimpse the novel'
John Xero
An even four stars. Not a partial celestial body in sight.

I really enjoyed this. It begins in the realms of the ridiculous, edging into farcical, very much reminding me of G.K. Chesterton, and then it transitions into a kind of high-concept paranoia, à la Philip K. Dick.

There's a bit in the middle where it's making the crossover that gets a little bogged down in its own twists and turns, but that's my only complaint.

Definitely Maybe is an extremely pleasant diversion. It has a good blend of humo
Highly recommended. A wonderfully crafted novel that uses 1984-ish (in how overt it is) sci-fi to deliver a strong political message that's /somewhere in there/ but like the authors state in the afterword, cannot be pointed to directly. In that sense, I actually like in more than 1984. As an aside, one of the beauties of Soviet-era literature (published via regular, censored channels or samizdat) is that the constraints imposed upon the writers result in intricate coded messages that greatly ele ...more
Bradley Skaught
What an extraordinary book. At the most immediate level of discourse, its Soviet-era paranoia is razor sharp and fraught with delicious tension. But it operates on a number of levels, asking complicated moral questions with great humor and gritty suspense. The science-fiction touches are so lightly applied, it could almost be a straightforward portrayal of noir-ish intrigue, but the fantasy elements elevate everything with just the right amount of absurdity to bring a powerful weight to the char ...more
Matthew Snope
I am really digging the Strugatsky Bros. after first reading & loving Roadside Picnic. D.M. is a very strange and riveting novel, almost in the format of a play since it basically takes place in one room for most of its duration. I love the way the Bros. mix the human, all too human -- sweat, drunkenness, bodily functions, emotions, interpersonal psychology -- with very abstract and highbrow concepts about philosophy of science. I'm not sure I understood D.M. as clearly as Roadside Picnic, b ...more
A short but captivating tale of confusion on a cosmic scale, all taking place inside a few units of some undescribed soviet era apartment building. Vonnegut-esque with a Russian twist. This still feels very modern today here in America, possibly due to so much talk about government control and all of the paranoia that accompanies such talk. A novel from a time and place where there was actually that sort of government influence in everyday lives rings true in the cultural climate of America circ ...more
Μετά το αριστουργηματικό Πικνίκ δίπλα στο δρόμο, αυτό είναι το δεύτερο βιβλίο που διαβάζω από τους αδελφούς Στρουγκάτσκι, ελπίζοντας κάποια στιγμή να μεταφραστούν και άλλα έργα τους στα ελληνικά για να μην είναι το τελευταίο (εκτός και αν κάτσω να διαβάσω στα αγγλικά, χωρίς να έχω την ίδια ευχαρίστηση όμως). Πραγματικά οι τύποι είναι άπαικτοι.

Στα του βιβλίου: Δεν είναι το κλασικό βιβλίο επιστημονικής φαντασίας με τα διαστημόπλοια, τα φουτουριστικά τοπία και τα διάφορα εξωγήινα όντα, είναι περισ
Sergey Homyuk
Итак, группа выдающихся советских ученых сидит на советской же кухне, пьет коньяк, чай и боится гомеостатического закона вселенной, который вот-вот должен обрушиться на их светлые головы. Извините, кажется, это было краткое, но весьма точное изложение сюжета произведения... Нет, конечно, тема персонализации вселенной и ее реакции в ответ на попытки проникнуть в суть ее основополагающих законов крайне интересна (взять, тот же шедевральный "Солярис" Станислава Лема)! Но в данном случае, все слишко ...more
It's a hot summer and strange things are happening in Leningrad. A handful of scientists are confronted with threats to stop their research. Every threat is individually targetted. The father is threatened with getting jailed and the loss of his wife and son, the womanizer is threatened by his joint former affairs, the egomaniac is threatened with the representation of a "super-civilization". People are disappearing without a trace. All scientists somehow are related to another seemingly superio ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
A brilliant critique of Soviet censorship through weird opposition. I would elaborate, but my ignorance of the novel’s plot added to the enjoyment and heightened the mysterious happenings taking place early on. My only critique is one the brothers had no control over. There are multiple themes and ideas that had to be approached in a very round about manner due to censorship, and while I don’t want authors to hit me over the head with obviousness it would have been nice if they could have been a ...more
I did not enjoy this book a great deal while I was reading it, but it's a very good book to have read. I have thought about the concepts and the characters a lot more after finishing it than the vast majority of books, even good sci-fi. A quick read, and in my opinion a slightly unbelievable premise, but one that fosters thought and that I think an excellent thing.
Lauren Huibregtse
The book was certainly interesting- especially when you consider it as a parody of writers under the censor's board in Russia. The book could have been better developed with either more humor or more tension. The female characters were also a weak point in this novel- falling into the categories of temptress, perfect wife or banshee (loud troublemaker). To it's credit it was unlike anything I had ever read- but I would not pick it as a favorite.
Ani Artinyan
Три неща, които ще помня:

1. Английският вариант на заглавието пасва по-добре, поне за мен (на бг - Милиард години до свършека на света, на руски е същото).
2. Емоцииите били непълнота на информацията. Не знам.
3. Рекоха ми, че този път ще ме отведе до океана на смъртта и аз насред пътя свърнах обратно. И оттогава пред мен извиват само криволичещи и глухи околни пътеки…
At 11 this was definitely not "reasonably" priced, as the publisher's website states is part of their aim with their Neversink Library series, but the imperial purple cover and the blurb made it impossible to resist. And it's a very fun, well-written novella based around a clever idea. I'd like to read a novel by the Strugatsky brothers. ...more
Un tanar academician care duce, aparent, o existenta banala, intr-un apartament la bloc, cu sotie, copil si un motan. Dar pe cale sa tulbure echilibrul universal intre cele doua tendinte: entropie si homeostaza. Si universul reactioneaza, incercand sa il impiedice de la a-si finalize lucrarea. Cartea asta are toate ingredinetele unei lecture deosebit de bune: subiect, actiune, idee, stil.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 50 51 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Madonna of the Sleeping Cars
  • Faithful Ruslan
  • Peace on Earth
  • Los que aman, odian
  • Il Presidente
  • Store of the Worlds: The Stories of Robert Sheckley
  • Холодные берега (Искатели неба, #1)
  • Темная сторона (Лабиринты Ехо, #4)
  • Gilgi, eine von uns
  • Autobiography of a Corpse
  • The Polyglots
  • Aelita
  • Alice: The Girl From Earth
  • The Eternal Philistine
  • Our Lady of the Nile
  • Ambiguous Adventure
  • That Smell and Notes from Prison
The brothers Arkady (Russian: Аркадий; August 28, 1925 – October 12, 1991) and Boris (Russian: Борис; April 14, 1933 – November 19, 2012) Strugatsky (Russian: Стругацкий; alternate spellings: Strugatskiy, Strugatski, Strugatskii) were Soviet-Russian science fiction authors who collaborated on their fiction.
More about Arkady Strugatsky...
Roadside Picnic Понедельник начинается в субботу Hard to Be a God Обитаемый остров Град обреченный

Share This Book

“...It's like trying to fit an octopus into a pair of tuxedo pants. And not a plain octopus at that, but an octopus that doesn't even exist.” 6 likes
“I was told that this road would take me to the ocean of death, and turned back halfway. Since then crooked, round-about, godforsaken paths stretch out before me.” 1 likes
More quotes…