A Perfect Day for Bananafish
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A Perfect Day for Bananafish

4.35 of 5 stars 4.35  ·  rating details  ·  3,811 ratings  ·  91 reviews
"A Perfect Day for Bananafish" is a short story by J. D. Salinger, originally published in the January 31, 1948 issue of The New Yorker. It was anthologized in 1949's 55 Short Stories from The New Yorker, as well as in Salinger's 1953 collection, Nine Stories.
Published (first published 1948)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Perfect Day for Bananafish, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Perfect Day for Bananafish

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Salida
Let's get one thing straight, Seymour Glass was not a sex offender. He never asked Sybil to look at 'his bananafish' as some ignorant reviewer posted.

This is a story about desperation, about a man who was exhausted of trying to fit into a society where he was not welcomed. In the beginning, with the conversation between Muriel and her mother, the reader can sense that Seymour might be mentally or emotionally unstable. Muriel is not like Seymour at all, she's superficial and centered around mate...more
Rowland Bismark
“A Perfect Day for Bananafish” appeared in the New Yorker in 1948 and was later republished as the opening story in the collection Nine Stories(1953). In “A Perfect Day for Bananafish,” Salinger introduces the Glass family, who would become recurring characters in his fiction. In the next ten years, Salinger published three other Glass family stories in the New Yorker: “Franny,” “Zooey,” and “Raise High the Roof-Beam, Carpenters.” These stories appear in Salinger’s other books, which include Fra...more
Knar   Avetisyan
"I see you're looking at my feet," he said to her when the car was in motion.
"I beg your pardon?" said the woman.
"I said I see you're looking at my feet."
"I beg your pardon. I happened to be looking at the floor," said the woman, and faced the doors of the car."


"A Perfect Day for Bananafish" contrasts the world of children, imaginative, curious, pure, and innocent with the world of adults materialistic, selfish, shallow. As you can see, the story glorifies children and to some degree condemns...more
Wendy
Mar 02, 2012 Wendy rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: EVERYONE
I remember the day I read this book. It was hot outside and I was at achool and out teacher made us read an excerpt. I've never really liked books that I was forced to read but this one reached out to me so when I got home I got on the computer, found a copy and read it.

It made me think, and that's what I love about literature.
The main is complex and the whole thing is so sad. I LOVE IT.

If you're debating reading this, trust me, you should.
Sarah Peters
Easily one of the greatest short stories I've ever read. When I can spend more time thinking about the text than actually reading it, I know I've found something special.
Cole Blouin
This short story is written in absolutely crystal-clear prose taking the idea of show, don't tell, to an extreme I've never encountered before. As such, with its abrupt ending (as many of the stories within Nine Stories), it leaves as many questions as it does answers. A second reading reveals a few more details; by the third I've started to get a full picture. Salinger is quite possibly my favorite author for this reason: it's easy to read the story and know what happened, but upon asking, "Why...more
Melissa Ingalls
I thought that it was deep. I love the unseen commentary in this short story. There are a lot of "banana fish" in our world - meaning that there are a lot of greedy people. When I had to read the first page of this short story, I thought that Muriel was a murdered by killing her husband - the rings that were in the bathroom, her left hand stretched away, & removing the stain out of her dress vs. some in my class saw her as some sort of a harlett that was paid for her services however, that w...more
Mohamed Sall
This was actually recommended to me by Gabriel, and he was right -- this was the best short story I've ever read. This story forces you to read from the historical lens. Salinger compares his experiences in WWII and his post-traumatic stress to Seymour Glass' post-traumatic stress after coming back from the war. This book has many different themes as well. The bananafish, for instance, symbolized Seymour's emotions being built up and then eventually going away when he committed suicide.
Ell (Egregore)
Dec 16, 2011 Ell (Egregore) rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Suicide fascinated people, J.D. Salinger fans
An Interesting short story, about a man who shoots himself after he tells a story about his so-called Bananafish to a young girl on a beach. Now, don't get me wrong, the girl DID NOT instigate the suicide if thats what you think.


Damon
My senior year of high school, I got on a JD Salinger kick and read everything I could find. The Norwegian exchange student that was staying with us and I would sit out on the deck that spring, making ourselves Tom Collins's and reading Salinger. (at least I read Salinger. I don't remember what he read. Do you remember, Thor??)
HaNaDy
أحببت طريقة السرد والأسلوب كثيراً فهيا مختلفة نوعاً ما عن الترتيب المنطقى للأحداث ولكن السرد بمشاهد من هنا وهناك بشكل منظم أمتعنى
نهاية الرواية مرعبة فعلاً وغير متوقعة بالمرة

لكن لم أحب التفاصيل الجنسيه بها الكتاب مجانى يمكنكم تحميله
yengyeng
The road leading to suicide is filled with deepest darkest despair, with a couple of stuffed dogs strewn along the curb maybe, but the final act is performed in a moment of clarity. In sun-kissed primary colours.
Rochelle
I feel terrible that I read the last line first it ruined that element of surprise. I was surprised at how well developed the characters were in 10 short pages.
إسراء محمد علي
بتحكي عن معاناة لفنان تشكيلي وتربية من وهو صغير قصرت فية وبالنسبالي رواية رائعة في نهايتها غير متوقعة والدليل علي كدة ان خلصتها في ساعتين بس
Beth
I didn't get it.

I'll be the first to admit that. J.D. Salinger and I just never hit it off. I can feel the tempo of Salinger's writing, but it refuses to 'click' for me. I can understand why people would think that this speaks for an angsty, existentalist (sorry, butchered word there) culture. Perhaps it does. Perhaps I'm just not a membeer of that culture. I loved the rhythm and flow of Seymour and...the little girl's conversation. Except I've totally forgotten her name, which should tell you h...more
Dana West
Did anyone else see Seymour as a sex offender? He had Sybil look at his "bananafish" and then he shot himself...in front of his wife.

I could postulate that Seymour suffered PTSD from The War. I could make the stretch and say that Muriel was superficial.

I could say that Muriel's mother was trying to keep the conversation "light" while Muriel was asking for advice or help or something.

I could say that Sybil was a symbol of innocence, but then again, I would have to come back to the idea that Sey...more
Ayat Mahmoud
لغة ركيكة لأقصى درجة! مع أخطاء املائية شنيعة و متكررة باصرار غريب لا يتناسب مع وجود مصحح لغوي للعمل، ماذا صحح اذن؟!
ربما كان عدم الترابط بين مشاهد العمل مقصود باعتباره رسم لخيالات مريض نفسي بالكلمات، ولكن هذا التفكك مع ضعف اللغة سببا مزيجا مزعجا للغاية. فقط النهاية الصادمة و الغير متوقعة والتي لم تزد عن نصف صفحة مثلا هي ما جعل لهذا العمل اي قيمة على الاطلاق. كان من الممكن طرح الفكرة في صورة قصة قصيرة بدون اللجوء لكل المشاهد التي تصور مواقف يعبر فيها البطل عن فحولة ضئيلة غالبا مشكوك فيها لا هدف له...more
Angelica Castillo
It was a bright sunny day.

Seymour Glass came from a war and he is on a vacation along with his wife. Muriel Glass, his wife, is aware that he has been mentally unstable since the war yet she does not do anything about it. Her parents are worried about her but she refuses to go home because she hasn't been in a vacation in a long time. While Muriel is in the hotel, Seymour is outside talking with Sybil Carpenter, a little girl. He tells her a story about a Bananafish who tend to swim into holes a...more
Gonzalo Lira
What’s interesting about this story is the sharp, self-consciously calculated effect it’s trying to achieve.

If the definition of art is to give an effect on the reader without the reader being aware of it, then this story fails miserably. This story comes at you, the reader, relentlessly, relentlessly trying to set you up for an effect. As far a neophyte professional writer goes, “A Perfect Day for Bananafish” is exactly what you should not do.

(BTW, this story is famous not for itself, but bec...more
Andrew Rogers
I don't normally add short stories on here, but it's J.D. Salinger. It's based on a recurring family name, the Glass family, that appears in many of his stories. The themes in the story can be viewed as disturbing or morbid, but PTSD is real and affects people in tragic ways, as seen here. Writer's note: If you're having trouble writing dialogue, read this story.
Jens
It is perfect. Simple, poignant, and not a word wasted.
Annie
WHAT. JUST. HAPPENED. IN. THIS. STORY. SOMEONE. TELL. ME. I DONT KNOW WHAT RATING TO GIVE THIS STORY I SERIOUSLY DON'T KNOW BECAUSE WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED.
Karla
Absolutely fantastic. Resonated with me for weeks, When I think of this piece of writing I always get chills.
Lupeng Jin
A friend recommended this short article to me. After reading, to be honest, I was totally confused by three parts of this story. Even though I can figure out that the man and the woman are a couple, I have no idea what their conversation with others means. Wikipedia is a very helpful website supplying with enough information to me and Goodreads, as a perfect stage for sharing different reviews of each readers helps me understand more further between the lines of the article. Right now, I can say...more
Coffin
what I learned from this story is it is sometimes a much better idea to stay on the beach.
Neyly
Short story that left me heading off to look up its meaning. As suspected I found much analysis of characters, meaning, etc. (Whether or not a short story should have pages upon pages upon pages of analysis devoted to it is another question entirely. As is the thought that it's because of who wrote it rather than the work itself.) No matter - it boils down to a soldier suffers from PTSD and (view spoiler). The story just gets yo...more
Mohammed Alamin
التصوير وتسلسل الحوار و الترجمةالبديعة من ناحية.

الشخصيات اللعينة , بصحتها العقلية المهملة , الطيبة البلهاء , ظاهر الشخصيات الظاهر و باطنها المعتّم , سيمور مثلاً , أو الرجل الضاحك , كيف كتب سالنجر الرجل الضاحك؟ أقصد أي فكرة جاءت في رأسه ؟ ما الحالة النفسية للرجل الضاحك. هل هذا "بمثابة أعظم ما يكون الأسى".


"عدت إلى البيت مرتعداً تصطك أسناني فلا أتمالكها , فارسلوني تواً إلى السرير".
Lona Hill
i liked it, did not expect the tone to shift at the end. Reminded me of Desiree's Baby by Kate Chopin with the unexpected ending. I had enjoyed Cather in the Rye so this was an interesting short story wirtten by the same author as A Perfect Day for Bananafish.
Sheila Martinez
If you would read this like some kind of a fact sheet, it would only be 'a man committed suicide, probably because of his post-war hallucinations and such' but if you read read it, there is more to the man who committed suicide. Too much that he couldn't take it anymore.
Ryan S. Bennett
A friend of mine suggested that I read this story, since it is one of her most favorite stories. I read it and I'm confused on what I just read and I'm thinking I need to reevaluate my friendship with said friend. Just kidding, but seriously, no idea what I just read.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Author Support Group: A Perfect Day for Bananafish 1 4 Apr 13, 2014 08:59PM  
  • Memento mori
  • Hills like White Elephants
  • Death in the Woods and Other Stories
  • Я, бабушка, Илико и Илларион
  • The Ice Palace
  • J.D. Salinger: A Life
  • بابا سارتر
  • Yesterday
  • The Thirtieth Year: Stories (Modern German Voices Series): Stories by Ingeborg Bachmann
  • The Knight in the Panther's Skin
  • Tlon, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius
  • კაცი, რომელსაც ლიტერატურა ძლიერ უყვარდა
  • The Afterlife and Other Stories
  • The Black Cat
  • Sombrero Fallout
  • Le sumo qui ne pouvait pas grossir
  • Bronze Horseman
  • نان سال‌های جوانی
819789
Jerome David Salinger was an American author, best known for his 1951 novel The Catcher in the Rye, as well as his reclusive nature. His last original published work was in 1965; he gave his last interview in 1980. Raised in Manhattan, Salinger began writing short stories while in secondary school, and published several stories in the early 1940s before serving in World War II. In 1948 he publishe...more
More about J.D. Salinger...
The Catcher in the Rye Franny and Zooey Nine Stories Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters & Seymour: An Introduction جنگل واژگون

Share This Book

“كم أنا شخصية عنيدة لا تعرف ماذا تريد ؟!!” 5 likes
“Ah, Sharon Lipschutz," said the young man. "How that name comes up. Mixing memory and desire.” 2 likes
More quotes…