6th out of 81 books
—
9 voters
The Unwritten, Vol. 2: Inside Man (The Unwritten #2)
by
Mike Carey (Goodreads Author),
Peter Gross , Yuko Shimizu
In this volume, Tom arrives at Donostia prison in Southern France and falls into the orbit of another story: The Song of Roland. Unfortunately for Tom, it's a story that ends with a massacre. .Tom discovers the true meaning of "out of the frying pan" after his escape from Donostia jail takes him to Stuttgart in 1940, a ghost city inhabited by the master liar of the Third R...more
Paperback, 168 pages
Published
August 17th 2010
by Vertigo
(first published December 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This installment started off as a 3, but picked up considerably by the middle, turning it into a 4 for me. The questions of the nature of narrative in our lives, the (un)truthfulness of stories and whether the veracity or lack thereof makes a difference (using the "Song of Roland" as a reference point), and the effect on the work itself when it's been 'tortured' into its opposite by those who twist it into something it isn't for their own purposes all elevate this story.
The last few pages conce...more
The last few pages conce...more
This started out a little slow to for me, partially because it has been probably a year since I'd read the first volume (and needed to re-familiarize myself with the characters and concepts), and partially because it just gets more interesting and effective as the story moves along.
With this series, Carey's developed the perfect way to balance commenting on the nature and power of "the story" while also weaving a powerful narrative himself. He's managing to have his cake and write about it too....more
With this series, Carey's developed the perfect way to balance commenting on the nature and power of "the story" while also weaving a powerful narrative himself. He's managing to have his cake and write about it too....more
Still good, still engrossing, still moving. The paucity of characters of color (unless they're criminals) and women in anything but occasional mother, vixen, or girl-sidekick roles is starting to really irritate me, though. It makes me look a little differently at the Kipling section from the end of the first collection; although it's clear that evil forces are at play in preserving and spreading British imperialism, I can't help but wonder if the portrayal of Kipling's pro-imperialist, racist i...more
I think I like the themes and ideas covered in this volume better than the actual plot of the story. And I will admit that I was confused reading it the first time through (although I can blame that on staying up way too late to finish reading it all in one go).
The last chapter was absolutely genius...and hilarious. It could definitely stand on its own, but I liked that just a few times it pulled in elements of the main story.
I love that you can read this just as a graphic novel, or you can read...more
The last chapter was absolutely genius...and hilarious. It could definitely stand on its own, but I liked that just a few times it pulled in elements of the main story.
I love that you can read this just as a graphic novel, or you can read...more
The internet is rife with rumors and accusations regarding Tom Taylor. Is he the rather boring son who lives in the shadow of his famous late father, living off of his memories? Or is he even Wilson Taylor’s son at all? Is Tom Taylor responsible for the slaughter at the Villa Diodati? Is he the incarnation of Tommy Taylor, boy wizard? And what about the stories of a flying cat—where do those fit in? The Inside Man wants to know.
While being taken by train to the prison Donostia at Maison d’Arrêt...more
While being taken by train to the prison Donostia at Maison d’Arrêt...more
This post/review is going to be chock full of spoilers, and is really written for those people who have already read the first two collections. For that reason, I want to sum up my overall view and suggestion of The Unwritten now, so if you’re the kind of reader who doesn’t like to know too much about a story, you can still get something out of this post:
If you didn’t like the first collection because you felt like it was more promise than substance, then read the second collection before you gi...more
If you didn’t like the first collection because you felt like it was more promise than substance, then read the second collection before you gi...more
I have been a lone voice crying in the comic book wilderness all my life, saying yes, yes, I love comic books, I love them so much it makes my head hurt and my bank account shrink, but this is not literature. We are not even close to opening up the can of worms that a really good writer, like Dostoyevsky, or Nin, or J. Crowley or PKD or Zola can. The feeling that you get from a really good book -- the feeling that they are taking off the tops of people's heads and showing you the gears and wires...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
If you haven’t started reading Unwritten yet, please do so at your soonest convenience. It’s a meta-fantasy in the mold of Fables, focusing on the role that stories play in our lives and culture. The protagonist, Tommy Taylor, is the adult son of an author who penned a series of children’s books similar in scope and fame to Harry Potter. Tommy’s father disappeared under mysterious circumstances and left his son a problematic legacy.
Though Unwritten is about authors, writing and the power of stor...more
Though Unwritten is about authors, writing and the power of stor...more
Tommy Taylor is a boy wizard and hero in a billion-dollar fantasy series.
Tom Taylor is the son of the author and has spent his life living in the shadow of his fantasy counterpart.
After a series of bizarre and deadly events, Tom realizes that there is more of a connection between him and Tommy than just their names.
By far one of the best written and freshest comic book series to come along in years. Think Y: The Last Man meets Sandman.
It did take me a bit to get used to Tom. At first he comes...more
Tom Taylor is the son of the author and has spent his life living in the shadow of his fantasy counterpart.
After a series of bizarre and deadly events, Tom realizes that there is more of a connection between him and Tommy than just their names.
By far one of the best written and freshest comic book series to come along in years. Think Y: The Last Man meets Sandman.
It did take me a bit to get used to Tom. At first he comes...more
So our magical boy has grown up into a self-righteous slacker, most recently framed for murder. Carey and Gross have largely dropped the social criticism angle of the story to focus more on the intrigue of just what the heck is going on. Tommy Taylor is at least a hybrid of fiction, if not entirely pulled from another world, and now finds himself pursued by a killer who is likely the same, serving some murky purpose that, at least it feels like, it will take several more volumes to puzzle out.
Th...more
Th...more
The second collection of The Unwritten takes a while to get rolling. The entire first arc, to be exact. You would think that having our intrepid hero accused of murder most foul and imprisoned would be a bit more exciting but, in the end, I spent most of these issues waiting for something to happen. All we are really given is a couple of breadcrumbs, a child with an unhealthy imagination and the feeling that something else should be going on.
The Inside Man arc concludes with a bang, though, and...more
The Inside Man arc concludes with a bang, though, and...more
The intro was really interesting and helpful but also made me think that maybe I'm not smart enough to really understand this series. But it sure made me want to try.
There was something really beautiful about Tom finding and helping Jud Süss find redemption from the canker Goebbels and the Nazis turned it into. It was a great example of the real power of stories.
The story at the end about Willowbank Wood was really twisted.
The cover and occasional full page artwork is really beautiful. The style...more
There was something really beautiful about Tom finding and helping Jud Süss find redemption from the canker Goebbels and the Nazis turned it into. It was a great example of the real power of stories.
The story at the end about Willowbank Wood was really twisted.
The cover and occasional full page artwork is really beautiful. The style...more
http://nwhyte.livejournal.com/1750581...
A collection of seven issues (I think), the first four taking Tom Taylor to a French prison where the governor reads Tommy Taylor books to his children and the Song of Roland makes an appearance, the next two taking Tom and his allies Savoy and Lizzie Hexen to Stuttgart in 1940 and a confrontation with Goebbels over the film of Jud Süss, and the last being a horrifying side story of a thug trapped in the form of a fluffy bunny rabbit in a children's book....more
A collection of seven issues (I think), the first four taking Tom Taylor to a French prison where the governor reads Tommy Taylor books to his children and the Song of Roland makes an appearance, the next two taking Tom and his allies Savoy and Lizzie Hexen to Stuttgart in 1940 and a confrontation with Goebbels over the film of Jud Süss, and the last being a horrifying side story of a thug trapped in the form of a fluffy bunny rabbit in a children's book....more
This graphic novel collect the issues 6-12.
Again the intertexuality is ever present and engaging and the limits between reality and fiction get blurred further in this volume. Tom Taylor is arrested as an alleged murderer and sent to prison. The prison happens to be on his “map of stories”: Roncevaux is the place where the massacre of the Song of Roland takes place and again fiction and reality began to overlap.
A second tragic story line follows the director of the prison and his family. His two...more
Again the intertexuality is ever present and engaging and the limits between reality and fiction get blurred further in this volume. Tom Taylor is arrested as an alleged murderer and sent to prison. The prison happens to be on his “map of stories”: Roncevaux is the place where the massacre of the Song of Roland takes place and again fiction and reality began to overlap.
A second tragic story line follows the director of the prison and his family. His two...more
In Tommy Taylor and the Bogus Identity Tom Taylor's life changes dramatically. He goes from being a coat-tails riding literary namesake to being a possible new messiah to child wizard loving children and internet geeks everywhere and suspected murderer. He might also be a fraud and there might have been some magic in his father's books after all.
Tom is extradited to France for trial and is placed in the Donostia prison. He must escape and figure out the powers that are available to him with the...more
Tom is extradited to France for trial and is placed in the Donostia prison. He must escape and figure out the powers that are available to him with the...more
Really enjoyed the second round of this graphic novel series.
Rather than focusing on the secret literary cabal, this one targeted the power of story and how it can change people's perceptions - using the propaganda of the Nazis as an example, including Goebbels' actual film "Jud Suss."
The plot is complex - Tom Taylor is slowly discovering who he is (most likely answer - a book character brought to actual life by an author who is now missing), as he spends time in jail for the series of murders h...more
Rather than focusing on the secret literary cabal, this one targeted the power of story and how it can change people's perceptions - using the propaganda of the Nazis as an example, including Goebbels' actual film "Jud Suss."
The plot is complex - Tom Taylor is slowly discovering who he is (most likely answer - a book character brought to actual life by an author who is now missing), as he spends time in jail for the series of murders h...more
Tom Taylor, found alone at the scene of a massacre at the Villa Diodati, is shipped off to prison in France. The prison warden's two children are intense fans of the Tommy Taylor books and the warden plots to off Tommy to spare them from seeing their fallen idol. Tom begins having visions straight out of "La Chanson de Roland," and with the help of his cellmate Savoy (a reporter) and Lizzie Hexam, they escape the prison using a magic doorknob straight out of the Tommy Taylor books. They end up i...more
With his miraculous escape from prison,, Tom Taylor has finally started to believe in his own magic. The doorknob that is a gateway between time and space is only the first part of the puzzle, along with the mysterioius map that he found in his father's study, and Tom must figure out what they can do to figure out who he really is. It looks like these objects are a way for Tom to visit the times in the past when the great books were written, but I'm not sure yet how these tie in to the whole sto...more
An excellent progression to the story. Though Carey & Gross could have made it feel like they were being economical by showing the story from a few different character POVs, including some of the same scenes two or three times, it works remarkably well to give you that sense of connectedness that makes things good. The prison escape sequence is awesome, and ultimately fucked up and kind of cool in the manifestation of the main villain (who even in a brief glimpse, is fucking scary). The "Jud...more
I mentioned in my review of the first volume of The Unwritten that it was too light on actual story; this volume corrects that by moving the story along nicely, while at the same time continuing to develop the themes implied by the premise.
Tom Taylor continues the journey he started in the first volume, encountering a variety of fictional characters who are starting to seep into the 'real' world. What's really interesting here, though, is the subtle argument for the divine nature of story - Fran...more
Tom Taylor continues the journey he started in the first volume, encountering a variety of fictional characters who are starting to seep into the 'real' world. What's really interesting here, though, is the subtle argument for the divine nature of story - Fran...more
This was nominated for the 2011 Hugo Award, and while it was pretty good, I didn't see it as award-worthy. The book starts a bit confusing and slow, and doesn't really pick up till the end, when you discover it's brilliant. I still think the underlying truths could be hinted at more effectively, ie I know we're to be kept in the dark as much as Tommy is, but if I'd been reading this via comic book instead of graphic novel format, I'd probably have lost interest.
Don't get me wrong, it's a brillia...more
Don't get me wrong, it's a brillia...more
Mike Carey, who is also a published novelist, is helping to keep the tradition of literary fantasy alive at Vertigo. Tom Taylor is supposed to be the basis for his father's best selling series of YA fantasy books about boy sorcerer Tommy Taylor (yes, I assume all Harry Potter allusions are intended). But this is much more than a Harry Potter pastiche. Tom has been framed for multiple murders, and this had lead to an examination of his role in the world's popular culture and unfavorable examinati...more
I enjoyed volume 2 of the Unwritten far more than volume 1, but you really need volume 1 to understand the story. Volume 2 gets right into the actual story without having to provide the annoying backstory that volume 1 required. The story itself is *so* good but this volume still spends too much time on world reaction to the Tommy Taylor story. In this day and age, I think you can assume that a celebrity story is getting discussed on the internet; devoting pages to showing excerpts from blogs, f...more
Volume 2 of The Unwritten picks up where Volume 1 left off. If you haven't read Volume 1, this review will be a bit of a spoiler. If you've read Tommy Taylor and the Bogus Identity, read on! I promise not to spoil anything for you. :)
(view spoiler)...more
(view spoiler)...more
I've actually read through issue 15, the most recent released to date, but this collection will cap at 12. I really like several things about the next issues, though, so I look forward to reviewing upcoming volumes. More stars!
This volume mostly deals with Tom's ordeal in prison after the events of the first book, and where he begins to go after it's destroyed. He still doesn't have a plan really, or any idea why terrible things are following him and how much to trust the new capabilities he's p...more
This volume mostly deals with Tom's ordeal in prison after the events of the first book, and where he begins to go after it's destroyed. He still doesn't have a plan really, or any idea why terrible things are following him and how much to trust the new capabilities he's p...more
I have the intuition that in "real life" a filmy gauze of story is all that stands between us and the overwhelming enormity that is Reality. I think Mike Carey intuits that as well, because a similar notion resides at the heart of this series. Does life imitate art, does art imitate life, or do art and life arise from something else? From stories? So there are lots of big ideas about the power of story in these comics, which is good. And there is lots of beautiful artwork, which is also good. Un...more
I think the best part about this series so far is that even with the ridiculousness and insanity, it's all very literary. It loves literature and references it, in the form of the aforementioned Pooh spoof and an extended riff on the Song of Roland and of course all of the Harry Potter/fantasy-in-general allusions. It is also way more than its premise; sure, there's adventure and potential wizardliness, but there's also a lot to think about in terms of the role of media, the effect of childhood...more
Dec 16, 2012
Mark
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommended to Mark by:
Sara Q Thompson
Shelves:
graphic-novels,
from-library
This certainly furthered the story but also took it in unexpected ways building up plenty of maneuvering room to keep the series going for a while. But this also left me less sure of my appreciating its future direction.
There is a fair bit of French and German in this volume and I did not appreciate that they left it all untranslated. They could use a different way of lettering or put the different languages in some symbol, like << ... >>, as in the Luba stories. And it wasn't even c...more
There is a fair bit of French and German in this volume and I did not appreciate that they left it all untranslated. They could use a different way of lettering or put the different languages in some symbol, like << ... >>, as in the Luba stories. And it wasn't even c...more
Spoilers for volume 1
Volume two picks up with Tom(my) Taylor being arrested for the murders at the Villa Diodati. This book introduces the Ron surrogate character (or so I assume) in Richie Savoy as well. More importantly, this volume begins explaining more about what magical fictional powers Tom has as he steps in a Jewish novel twisted by the Nazis (it's a long story).
Oh, and there's a seemingly out of place story about a Peter Rabbit style character knowing that he's been trapped in a fiction...more
Volume two picks up with Tom(my) Taylor being arrested for the murders at the Villa Diodati. This book introduces the Ron surrogate character (or so I assume) in Richie Savoy as well. More importantly, this volume begins explaining more about what magical fictional powers Tom has as he steps in a Jewish novel twisted by the Nazis (it's a long story).
Oh, and there's a seemingly out of place story about a Peter Rabbit style character knowing that he's been trapped in a fiction...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.
Mike Carey was born in Liverpool in 1959. He worked as a teacher for fifteen years, before starting to write comics. When he started to receive regular commissions from DC Comics, he gave up the day job.
Since then, he has worked for both DC and Marvel Comics, writing storyli...more
More about Mike Carey...
Mike Carey was born in Liverpool in 1959. He worked as a teacher for fifteen years, before starting to write comics. When he started to receive regular commissions from DC Comics, he gave up the day job.
Since then, he has worked for both DC and Marvel Comics, writing storyli...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“When a book is read an irrevocable thing happens — a murder, followed by an imposture. The story in the mind murders the story on the page, and takes its place.”
—
10 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





























Glad...more
Jun 24, 2011 04:41am
Jun 24, 2011 10:00am