326th out of 1,897 books
—
1,833 voters
Desire of the Everlasting Hills: The World Before & After Jesus (Hinges of History #3)
From the bestselling author of How the Irish Saved Civilization and The Gifts of the Jews, his most compelling historical narrative yet.
How did an obscure rabbi from a backwater of the Roman Empire come to be the central figure in Western Civilization? Did his influence in fact change the world? These are the questions Thomas Cahill addresses in his subtle and engaging inv...more
How did an obscure rabbi from a backwater of the Roman Empire come to be the central figure in Western Civilization? Did his influence in fact change the world? These are the questions Thomas Cahill addresses in his subtle and engaging inv...more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published
February 13th 2001
by Anchor
(first published 1997)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,804)
This is book #3 in the Hinges of History series. It's fairly interesting and thought-provoking at times. Cahill describes how the message of Christ changed civilization. He attributes to Christ (and to Christians) the gradual propagation of widespread principles of mercy, forgiveness, and second chances (opposed to the eye-for-an-eye system of retribution). He also attributes to Christianity the eventual spread of literacy and bringing an end to human sacrifice in some cultures. Cahill was a lit...more
This book started out so well! It got me all excited to see how he was going to develop the way Jesus changed the landscape of western civilization, and then as soon as he started getting into the text of the Bible, it's all this liberal theology. It was pretty depressing.
The first 65 pages are the real strength of the book. Cahill's prose is easy to read and engaging at the same time. You really get a sense that the world before Jesus was a brutal place where might makes right. It leaves you lo...more
The first 65 pages are the real strength of the book. Cahill's prose is easy to read and engaging at the same time. You really get a sense that the world before Jesus was a brutal place where might makes right. It leaves you lo...more
It's a pleasure to read Cahill's books. Firstly he writes on transitional histories, subjects about which he's both passionate and knowledgeable. Secondly he brings those eras to life with new (to me) information and brilliant texture for the settings and the subjects.
In Desire of the Everlasting Hills he brings the transitional event of Jesus of Nazareth to new light. In exploring the essential Jewishness of the place and of the people he shows that this man's teachings were a new doctrine and...more
In Desire of the Everlasting Hills he brings the transitional event of Jesus of Nazareth to new light. In exploring the essential Jewishness of the place and of the people he shows that this man's teachings were a new doctrine and...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jul 07, 2011
Joan
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Those who appreciate history and its influence on culture
This is, as one my friends says, ". . . my kind of book!" Cahill has the writing style to really enhance history and he has definitely done this in "Desire of the Everlasting Hills." It is a beautiful, lyrical discussion of the eras just before, during, and after the time Jesus walked the hills and countryside--including Jerusalem--of Israel.
Cahill starts with the era of Alexander the Great, his conquests and influence on the lands he conquers. To see the world being prepared--literally--for the...more
Cahill starts with the era of Alexander the Great, his conquests and influence on the lands he conquers. To see the world being prepared--literally--for the...more
May 31, 2009
Tifnie
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Tifnie by:
Shawnah
Shelves:
historical-non-fiction
I actually started taking notes while I was reading this book for 2 reasons. 1 - this wasn't my book and 2 - I wanted to remember some key points. There are so many points to cover - where do I start?
Desire of the Everlasting Hills isn't about The Fate of Human Societies like I originally thought, that book will appear later on my list, it's about Judism and Christianity. More importantly, it's about discrepancies among the disciples. What one disciple heard in a crowd of people, no one else hea...more
Desire of the Everlasting Hills isn't about The Fate of Human Societies like I originally thought, that book will appear later on my list, it's about Judism and Christianity. More importantly, it's about discrepancies among the disciples. What one disciple heard in a crowd of people, no one else hea...more
I'm definitely a Thomas Cahill fan. He describes Jesus Christ and his teachings into the historical setting just prior to his birth and following his death. Gave me a better understanding of the scriptures and the early days of the first believers. Details the research on the authors of the Gospels and the impact Paul had on interpreting Christ to the early followers of the "Jesus Movement". Made me want to study more carefully the teachings of Paul.
I need to remember: "...those of us who have '...more
I need to remember: "...those of us who have '...more
The third volume in Thomas Cahill's "Hinges of History" series, this book offers less thought-provoking material than his previous books. Cahill argues that Western morality is primarily Judeo-Christian in origin and that its influence is now felt all over the world. He also argues that the West has started to fall away from that morality and, he implies, needs to return to it. The bulk of the book deals with the portraits of Jesus presented in the four gospels, how they differ, and why. Those w...more
Wanders from the stated thesis of an inspection of what impact the existence of a itinerate Jewish preacher in the backwaters of the Roman Empire had on Western Civilization into a brief examination of how the Gospels came to be in there dogmatic form and the history of the early Church. Ends up being more about Cahill's theology of mercy and kindness than a clear-eyed examination of Jesus' affect on the world. But very good for what it is.
It deepens your understanding of Cahill's viewpoint to r...more
It deepens your understanding of Cahill's viewpoint to r...more
I don't think I could possibly sing the praises of this book enough. It is an excellent discourse on just what is so special about Christ and about the faith, Christianity, named after him. Cahill is an intelligent, rational thinker and an articulate, nearly poetic, individual both at the same time. This is a very rare combination indeed, and one that leads Cahill in this book, as in the others I've read by him, to be able to work through problems logically, cogently explain the solution he's re...more
Cahill describes the world Jesus was born into examining the Roman empire and first century Palestine. The majority of the book is a comparison of the different Gospels. This includes the differing perspectives of the authors as well as how the particular Gospel reflects the intended audience and the time it was written. For example, Cahill argues the negative comments about Jews in the gospel of John reflect the conflict going on in the late first century as Christians were being evicted from t...more
Really more like 3.5 stars. This was a good book overall, definitely learned something. I really had a tough time with some of the historical research methods of identifying writing and style. It was good because it helped me think about my preconceived notions that were based on no knowledge, but I was disappointed by ideas like the assertion that certain books attributed to Paul within the text itself could not have been written by him simply because of the academic consensus was that the idea...more
You can see from the reverent language that Cahill uses that the subject of this book, Jesus and early Christianity, is of special importance to him. Even though this is just stop #3 in his seven-book Hinges of History series, his religious heritage brings out a tone of 'koinonia' that even his ancestral heritage (Ireland in book #1) cannot. It misses a star in the rating because although it is a gripping theological study, it still is a theological study, complete with a glass ceiling in entert...more
I liked this book, a lot. Some things I would, personally, look into more or word differently, but overall, I learned a lot and feel this is an amazing book (as so far I've enjoyed all Cahill's books in this series).
Examples of things you'll find:
1) A reference to Reynold Price's translation of Mary the Magdalene and Mary the mother of Joses on Easter Sunday:
Examples of things you'll find:
1) A reference to Reynold Price's translation of Mary the Magdalene and Mary the mother of Joses on Easter Sunday:
Entering the tomb they saw a young man sitting on the right dressed in a white robe and they were much stunned....more
But he said to them "Do
[T]his book is part of a series on cultural impact. And the great question about Jesus must always be: Did he make a difference? Is our world--in the century that began with the Turkish genocide against the Armenians, reached its nadir with the "scientific" holocaust of six million Jews (and five million others), not to speak of the slaughter by their own governments of Russians and Chinese in the scores of millions, and now comes to its end with genocides in central Africa and "ethnic cleansing...more
Cahill's history writing doesn't make the cut among scholars, probably for the same reason that reading him is so enjoyable: he is a good storyteller in a discipline sorely lacking them. Nevertheless, this book left me wanting. After an interesting but cursory glance at the world and value systems that preceded Jesus, Cahill approaches this mysterious figure through the lenses of the principle gospel authors. It's a good read for anyone wanting an introduction to the gospels, but Cahill's messag...more
Cahill's writing style is as accessible and engaging and his scholarship is vast. I especially like his use of small margin notes with additional thought, translation, history, commentary. Here is a sample of his language related to Jesus's baptism scene, which has led me to think of it as a compelling view for adoptive christology:
As he breaks the surface of the water, he sees the heavens torn open and God's Spirit "like a dove, descending..." Mark fails to tell us if anyone but Jesus saw and...more
As he breaks the surface of the water, he sees the heavens torn open and God's Spirit "like a dove, descending..." Mark fails to tell us if anyone but Jesus saw and...more
Oct 26, 2007
Michael Mills
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
those looking for an introduction to the Christian New Testament
I liked this book very much with regards to Cahill's wonderful summaries of most of the New Testament books. There are so many gems and one will consistenly say, "Ah ha! So that is what Paul was driving at in his letters to the Corinthians." Again, as in my review of Cahill's book on the ancient Israelites, those who hold a tight view of inerrancy might be troubled by some of Cahill's assertions (e.g., letters Paul might not have written, massaging of material in the Gospels to make rhetorical p...more
This book was a double treat for me. Not only am I a big Cahill fan, but it also tackles the topic I began with Jesus the Jew (see below). Delivering the same fantastic narrative he used in his two prior books, Cahill first gives us a wide shot of the Judea of the Intertestamental period, the different branches of Judaism that existed, and what each thought and preached. Into this mess he then places Jesus, seeking to locate him in history through analysis of the four gospels plus some historica...more
The title made me think that this book was a contemporary devotional or faith-help book and I almost left it on the shelf of free books at the hospital. It turned out to be thoughtful history by an amusing historian who has reminded me of why Jesus matters, his earthy beautiful Jewish context, and why I used to have a love affair with Paul. It is so wonderful to feel the gears of intellect and passion engaging with an author's subject. Thanks, Mr. Cahill.
I loved the simplicity, scholarship and beauty of this book. Cahill is not a professional scholar and does not write like one. Rather, he tells the story of Jesus and the New Testament only as a gifted storyteller can; with passion and gusto for the facts that have shaped our world. There is something about this book that bridges the gap between cold scholarship and opinion laden polemic that I just love. I have to read the rest of these books.
This is Book 3 of Cahill's Hinges of Civilization series, and I loved it as much as I loved the original two (How the Irish Saved Civilization, and The Gifts of the Jews). It paints an intimate picture of the historical Christ and his close friends, followers, and contemporaries. Cahill has a real gift for bringing ancient history to life. I was especially intrigued by his portrait of Paul. In case you didn't know, the Biblical writer to whom is attributed the injunction that women keep their mo...more
Why is it that texts which present themselves as overviews, summations, or syntheses find it so difficult to cite specific supporting evidence instead of alluding to it?
Mr. Cahill's book might be better subtitled "The New Testament in Context." He provides some background material on the age, and then readings of each of the portrayals of Jesus. This is no mean feat. However, it is not what the book claims to explicate, which is the specific impact of Jesus on the world and why he was such a piv...more
Mr. Cahill's book might be better subtitled "The New Testament in Context." He provides some background material on the age, and then readings of each of the portrayals of Jesus. This is no mean feat. However, it is not what the book claims to explicate, which is the specific impact of Jesus on the world and why he was such a piv...more
So this one would’ve been good, had I not been a Christian. I guess. There was a lot of liberal theology in here and a lot of trying to say that parts of the Bible were written later than they claim to be. This always bothers me since we actually have a lot of very early manuscripts.
Overall not worth it. I already knew everything except this one thing: before Jesus there was no rooting for the underdog. Those who were weak like women, children, slaves, the poor, and defeated nations, these were...more
Overall not worth it. I already knew everything except this one thing: before Jesus there was no rooting for the underdog. Those who were weak like women, children, slaves, the poor, and defeated nations, these were...more
I ate this book up. A mostly objective look at Jesus' life and how science, history, and geography meets up against the Gospels. Cahill sticks to the facts 95% of the time but occasionally he inserts an opinion/question on the science that makes you ponder our validity of certain "faith." Once again, Cahill takes a densely detailed topic and turns it into whipped butter for the soul.
Jul 27, 2012
Iosephus Bibliothecarius
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2011
This book is an interesting look at the cultures, people, languages, and events that shaped the world around Jesus. From the influence of Alexander the Great and the Greeks on the Jews to the personalities and writing styles of Jesus's early followers, many intriguing influences are discussed. While not comprehensive, Cahill's mostly-secular work is both engaging and accessible.
As in the other Hinges of History books, Cahill is wonderfully conversational in his writing while staying professional. His views on Christianity reveal a combination of liberal mainline beliefs as well as buying in to some of the Bart Ehrman/Jesus Seminar side of things. Overall, it's an enjoyable read, and for this pastor it was helpful and a bit refreshing to read something outside of the conservative/reformed circles I mostly spend time in.
Maybe I have OCD: all my life I've gravitated to series-style publishing, and devoured one edition after another just to finish the set. Thank goodness there are authors like Cahill to make the marathons worth the effort.
Desire was the first I read of the "Hinges of History", in addition to "Gifts of the Jews" and "Sailing the Wine-Dark Sea". I remember one of the jacket reviewers remarked on Cahill's ability to "strip the Victorian husk" from the Biblical subject at hand, and I still think the...more
Desire was the first I read of the "Hinges of History", in addition to "Gifts of the Jews" and "Sailing the Wine-Dark Sea". I remember one of the jacket reviewers remarked on Cahill's ability to "strip the Victorian husk" from the Biblical subject at hand, and I still think the...more
i had to write an essay about this book for my ancient history class when i was in college. the book is interisting. it is about christianity but it also discusses some points from other religions. i liked it the part of describing the story behind celebrating the hanukha by lighting the nine candles. generally this book talked about both chritianity and judism
Cahill's work is as much a bold historic narrative as it is a theological commentary. Using a scholarly yet approachable style, his pithy explanations of some of the more labyrinthine mysteries of the early Christian church help to bring this foundational period closer to us. It is also a joy to read, Cahill is a good writer and his prose is easy and illustrative.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Born in New York City to Irish-American parents and raised in Queens and the Bronx, Cahill was educated by Jesuits and studied ancient Greek and Latin. He continued his study of Greek and Latin literature, as well as medieval philosophy, scripture and theology, at Fordham University, where he completed a B.A. in classical literature and philosophy in 1964, and a pontifical degree in philosophy in...more
More about Thomas Cahill...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...





























What else is on your list?
Aug 19, 2010 10:51am