Winter Rose (Winter Rose, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Winter Rose (Winter Rose #1)

3.84 of 5 stars 3.84  ·  rating details  ·  4,525 ratings  ·  221 reviews
Sorrow and trouble and bitterness will bound you and yours and the children of yours...

Some said the dying words of Nial Lynn, murdered by his own son, were a wicked curse. To others, it was a winter's tale spun by firelight on cold, dark nights. But when Corbet Lynn came to rebuild his family estate, memories of his grandfather's curse were rekindled by young and old - an...more
Mass Market Paperback, 262 pages
Published May 1st 1997 by Ace (first published July 1st 1996)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson LevineThe Goose Girl by Shannon HaleBeauty by Robin McKinleyThe Princess Bride by William GoldmanFairest by Gail Carson Levine
The Best Fairytales and Retellings
88th out of 1,472 books — 6,418 voters
The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. TolkienThe Hobbit, or There and Back Again by J.R.R. TolkienThe Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer BradleyDaughter of the Forest by Juliet MarillierThe Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis
The Best of Mythic Fiction
23rd out of 336 books — 488 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
3 stars solely for the quality of McKillip's writing - evocative, lyrical, full of beautiful imagery. Sort of a combination of Marillier's style, which is vivid, always filled with otherworldly and draws inspiration from folklore, and McKinley's - which is heavy on psychedelic "trips" her heroines have to go through to evolve and grow.

Winter Rose is an interesting enough Tam Lin re-imagining, too bad so much of the story is dedicated to the main character's running in the woods or in snow or hav...more
I sat down and read this grippingly passionate tale in the space of 4 hours. I was hooked from the first page and I realised around halfway through that my mouth was dry, I had a frown of concentration furrowing my brows and I had a crook in my neck from not moving for a long time... The sense of distance and mysteriousness in the writing style really added to the story (which was almost a mystery itself) as I found out more and more about what was going on as I read. I loved the way I had to ke...more
I love Patricia McKillip's writing. That bald statement doesn't do the depth of my feeling justice, but there it lies. She turns the simplest statement into poetry, creating exquisite images that shimmer before the mind's eye long after the book has been closed; she imbues the whole world with magic, drawing forth colors unimaginable from the stark black text on a white page.

It is possible that Winter Rose is her best book. Where normally her prose creates just the slightest distance, separating...more
Winter Rose is a Tam Lin retelling, and I think a particularly good one; also, it's a favorite of mine among McKillip's books. The first person narrator (a device I can't remember McKillip using in any of her other books I've read) gives the book a little more emotional immediacy than usual, and the writing is just as gorgeous and rich as always: the faeries and the faery world are particularly outstanding, with just the otherworldliness I was missing from Janet McNaughton's An Earthly Knight.
Peejay Who Once Was Minsma
This is a beautifully written, near-hallucinatory little novel, almost breathless in its telling of the story of a young man, Corbet Lynn, who returns to the ruins of his ancestral home, Lynn Hall, and starts to rebuild. There's a village rumor of a family curse, a dying man's words no one can quite remember the same way, as if the words and the memories shift with each retelling. One winter Corbet's grandfather was murdered by his son, Tearle—Corbet's father—who then disappeared without a trace...more
Winter Rose is written in a very lyrical style, but on reflection, not much really seems to happen. I quite enjoyed the style, but in the end, I can't really think of much substance to it. It was a bit Goblin Market-esque, I suppose, with the two sisters, and one pining away, and the other doing all she could to make things better... And of course, there was the story of Tam Lin. But I got a bit confused with who was related to who and how -- at one point I thought Corbet's father was also Rois'...more
I started reading this book a number of years ago and never finished. After having read it completely, I understand why I put it down the first time. While Winter Rose is a wonderful novel with great storytelling, you have to be ready to be pulled into the Winter Rose experience when you pick it up. The descriptions are beautiful, but they take over. Sometimes I felt like I was trapped in a haze of impressions rather than a novel, which is the perfect way to experience this book--but not if you'...more
Admittedly I started buying McKillip's books because of their covers, and was lucky enough to find an author that I liked. What I admire about the covers, aside from being lovely, is that they're done by an artist who has obviously read the books. Don't you hate it when you judge a book by it's cover, get it, and even if you LIKE the book come to realize that said cover was done by someone who never bothered to read more then a summary of the contents they're decorating?

I think the worst offende...more
Rois and Laurel are two very different sisters. The story follows Rois, the wild girl who feels at home outdoors. Both girls become fascinated with a man named Corbet. Rois becomes tangled in enchantments and mystery as she seeks to rescue the man she and her sister both love.
Michael Miley
Don't read much fantasy, but my girlfriend recommended this. A lovely slightly gothic tale, a love story, it moves between two worlds, a kind of deathly underworld and the light of day, between a tragic hero and a nature woman who doesn't know her own boundaries.
Brandy Painter
Full review posted here.

As far as retellings of Tam Lin go, this one does an excellent job maintaining the story and characters. The meeting at the well with roses, the heroine’s heedless love of running through the woods in unladylike manner, the hero’s cold manipulative indifference, the curse, the unfeeling Faerie Queen, the heroine holding the hero through transformations to break the curse, it is all here. This story adds the twist of the sister equally fascinated by the hero. Corbet wants...more
Winter Rose by Patricia McKillip
5 Stars + Favorite
272 Pages

When Corbett Lynn returns to the home of his father and grandfather before him, intent on rebuilding Lynn Hall, he stirs up memories long since locked away. It is said that on the night his grandfather mysteriously died, some say murdered, and his father disappeared, Nial Lynn uttered a powerful curse to chase his descendents through time. Yet no one was there to see the old man die, so how could they know of this curse, or more correctl...more
Althea Ann
McKillip is one of my favorite authors: she has an unrivalled ability to take a seemingly simple story and invest it with a beauty of language and depth of meaning seen in few books. Her fairytales are for adults, as well as younger people (as such stories were originally meant to be); she stays true to the heart and soul of this most enduring and significant form of tale-telling.
This book is based on the legend of Tam Lin, with a bit of Andersen’s Snow Queen thrown into the mix –
Set in a timele...more
I've been hearing praise about McKillip's books for a while, so when I found out that she had written a "Tam Lin" retelling, I was excited to finally be introduced to her works.

By far my favorite aspect of Winter Rose is the language. Beautiful, nostalgic, and searching, it perfectly conveys the greater themes of the novel.

The hard winds sang their way into my dreams again that night. Long, white, insistent fingers of snow brushed against the window glass until I saw the storm out of memory, s...more
This is my third book by McKillip this week. I might have gotten a bit over enthusiastic when ordering at the library :) Sometimes I forget I need breaks between things to really even out my feels.

Let me say this, the woman can tell an intricate, complex story and she does so with such evocative, beautiful prose. I've enjoyed every book I've read so far.

So Winter Rose was the third book I finished of hers this week and it was by far the most hair-pulling out, frustrating, wonderful one so far....more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I've been thinking quite a bit about this book lately. I loved it when I first read it as a fourteen-year-old. (This was not long after I read Villette by Charlotte Bronte and Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier, two amazing novels that opened my eyes to the manifold benefits of giving a book a strong female first-person narrator.)

McKillip is not for everybody: her writing is highly stylized, intensely florid, and stubbornly pre-Raphaelite in its aesthetics. She uses phrases like "He rode a horse the c...more
When Corbet Lynn comes to reclaim the dilapidated Lynn Hall, the wild Rois--given to foraging barefoot in the woods--becomes obsessed with the secrets and curses of his past. Winter Rose is a Tam Lin retelling at its best: it harvests some aspects (from Tam Lin and other tales) and discards others while maintaining the emotional and symbolic essence of the source material; it then weaves an entire tale around that skeleton, creating a vivid setting and cast without losing the story's magic. Inde...more
Recommended by: Year's Best Fantasy And Horror (10th)

"Winter Rose" is the story of wild child Rois and her sensible sister Laurel and their obsession with the mysterious and cursed Corbett.

I tried to like this book, it took me three attempts to read the whole thing, but I did! I just found that I didn't really enjoy it and found it difficult to get into.

For me, the language was beautiful, in parts, but the pretty metaphors, similes and adjectives got in the way of the story and at time
REREAD #1: 8/10 (3 September 2006 - 5 September 2006)

This was a reread for me. I have McKillip's latest, Solstice Wood and since I knew that was about descendants of the characters in Winter Rose it seemed a good idea to reread that one first.

This is classic McKillip. The writing is dense, lyrical and beautiful. The tale is told in a tangle of metaphor and illusion that drags the reader in. Winter Rose is build from the basis of a retelling of Tam Lin, but McKillip takes the tale new places and...more
Mary Catelli
Rois sees a man walk out to the woods. . . and being a rather wild thing herself, she gathers flowers and herbs and returns to learn of Corbet Lynn, who returned home to claim his grandfather's lands, which have fallen to wrack and ruin since the day so many years ago when his father killed his grandfather and ran off, cursed by that grandfather. Not that any two people can tell the same story of what the curse was, or any one person tell who was there to see that it was murder, or hear the curs...more
I couldn't bring myself to finish this. I tried my utmost to like it, and I've gotten to the point where I feel a kind of moral obligation to finish a book once I start it, but I just couldn't do it. I know P. McKillip's style is all 'dreamy' and 'lyrical' or whatever, good for her, but I don't enjoy that kind of writing - it seems pretentious and unrealistic to me. Plus, I found the plot fatally slow-moving and I disliked the heroine with such a strangely passionate hatred that I longed to impa...more
I couldn't put this book down. I was completely captivated in a way I can't explain. I would feel like I finally grasped everything when the page would turn and I wasn't sure anymore. Near the end I began to despair that the book wouldn't end happily. How could things become right again? The ending reminded me of Sunshine by Robin McKinley. The ending wasn't sad. It wasn't concretely happy though. It reaches the point before happily ever after where you aren't sure that happily ever after will h...more
About 70% of this book is made up of descriptive words like: green, leaves, roses, winter, wind, dreams, wood, eyes, heart, cold, ivy, shadow, light, etc. The remaining 30% is story. It's like a house that is made up of 70% rococo gold scrolls and 30% foundation, which is fine as long as you don't live on a fault line. The story is interesting enough though except is one of those things where at the end you're still kind of wondering what happened and there's no right answer. If you're okay with...more
William Leight
I probably read this years ago, but as McKillip's novels have a tendency to blend together in my mind due to her writing style, I can't be 100% sure. However, "Winter Rose" is undoubtedly one of her best, with McKillip's prose, which always pushes dreamy romanticism almost to the point of being overwrought, proving to be an excellent vehicle for a retelling (with lots added, to be sure) of the old story of "Tam Lin". McKillip often has difficulty with novels based around quests, overcomplicating...more
This book hurt to read for a bit. Let's face it, following Rois makes us sad because of her love. But she goes further and listens to what the wind tells her. The tale is full of relationships and all kinds of love - romantic, familiar, friendship - which helps Rois grow.

It's been a long time since I finished a book in a day due to my hectic schedule. This book I couldn't put down. Starting with Alphabet of Thorn, and now this novel has made me a McKillip fan.
As usual, brilliant. Rich and varied plot--makes you wonder--is this a love story? Love triangle? A story of loss? The answer is all of the above, plus a healthy dose of parallel worlds, love lost and found again, along with a murder mystery just to keep things from getting boring. Not as good as Od Magic, but still better than everyone else...
PAM let chaos rule much of her novel. The main character will get into a situation, then wake up, then wake up again, and the reader can't tell when Rois fell asleep. Besides, her idea of magic was too wild and rampant for my tastes, without any boundaries except ties to nature.
I liked the fairytale influence, vivid descriptions, and the smallish scope of the story, but the characters didn't seem to click with me or with each other. Some of the plot was also too dreamy and repetitive for my taste.
Overall, the book is quite lyrical. Reading it felt rather like viewing a beautiful work of art. It continued to build a beautiful world. Though wonderfully written, the plot doesn't hold much. It spends a lot of time lyrically focused on the protagonist's feeling of being a part of a separate world. The majority of the book is spent exploring the problem that is set up quickly, and only the very end is dedicated to doing anything to resolve the problem. Outside of the protagonist, none of the o...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
  • Thomas the Rhymer
  • White as Snow
  • Silver Birch, Blood Moon
  • Tam Lin
  • Fudoki
  • The Perilous Gard
  • The Nightingale
  • The Door in the Hedge
  • The Wood Wife
  • Snow White And Rose Red
  • Fire and Hemlock
  • Beauty
  • Jack of Kinrowan
  • Fitcher's Brides
  • The Porcelain Dove
  • Mockingbird
Patricia Anne McKillip is an American author of fantasy and science fiction novels, distinguished by lyrical, delicate prose and careful attention to detail and characterization. She is a past winner of the World Fantasy Award and Locus Award, and she lives in Oregon. Most of her recent novels have cover paintings by Kinuko Y. Craft. She is married to David Lunde, a poet.

According to Fantasy Book...more
More about Patricia A. McKillip...
Riddle-Master: The Complete Trilogy (Riddle-Master, #1-3) The Forgotten Beasts of Eld The Riddle-Master of Hed (Riddle-Master, #1) Heir of Sea and Fire (Riddle-Master, #2) Harpist in the Wind (Riddle-Master, #3)

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

“But you must stop playing among his ghosts -- it's stupid and dangerous and completely pointless. He's trying to lay them to rest here, not stir them up, and you seem eager to drag out all the sad old bones of his history and make them dance again. It's not nice, and it's not fair.” 12 likes
“even I could not guess what misgivings lay behind Perrin's clear eyes. Perhaps none; perhaps he trusted Laurel without question. Perhaps he was right. All I knew is what Laurel's hands said when she spoke Corbet's name. And how often she said it, until it seemed, like the falling of autumn leaves, or the long ribbons of migrating birds, one of the season's changes.” 0 likes
More quotes…